菩薩藏佛教學會
20
背景
翻譯
下載 ▾

X16n0318_楞嚴經宗通|X16n0318_楞嚴經宗通(續11)

"*The Surangama Sutra with Commentary: The Definitive Meaning of the Secret Cause of the Tathagata's Practice and Realization, and the Myriad Practices of All Bodhisattvas*, Volume 9",

"Ananda, all those in the world who cultivate the mind, without relying on dhyana (meditation) and lacking wisdom, but are able to uphold the body and abstain from sexual desire, whether walking or sitting."

] }


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

想念俱無。愛染不生。無留欲界。是人應念身為梵侶。如是一類。名梵眾天。欲習既除。離欲心現。于諸律儀。愛樂隨順。是人應時能行梵德。如是一類。名梵輔天。身心妙圓。威儀不缺。清凈禁戒。加以明悟。是人應時能統梵眾。為大梵王。如是一類。名大梵天。阿難。此三勝流。一切苦惱所不能逼。雖非正修真三摩地。清凈心中。諸漏不動。名為初禪。阿難。其次梵天。統攝梵人。圓滿梵行。澄心不動。寂湛生光。如是一類。名少光天。光光相然。照耀無盡。映十方界。遍成琉璃。如是一類。名無量光天。吸持圓光。成就教體。發化清凈。應用無盡。如是一類。名光音天。阿難。此三勝流。一切憂懸所不能逼。雖非正修真三摩地。清凈心中。粗漏已伏。名為二禪。阿難。如是天人。圓光成音。披音露妙。發成精行。通寂滅樂。如是一類。名少凈天。凈空現前。引發無際。身心輕安。成寂滅樂。如是一類。名無量凈天。世界身心。一切圓凈。凈德成就。勝托現前。歸寂滅樂。如是一類。名遍凈天。阿難。此三勝流。具大隨順。身心安隱。得無量樂。雖非正得真三摩地。安隱心中。歡喜畢具。名為三禪。阿難。複次天人不逼身心。苦因已盡。樂非常住。久必壞生。苦樂二心。俱時頓舍。粗重相滅。凈福性生。如是一類。名福生天。舍心圓融。勝解清凈。福無遮中。得妙隨順。窮未來際。如是一類。名福愛天。阿難。從是天中。有二歧路。若於先心無量凈光福德圓明。修證而住。如是一類。名廣果天。若於先心雙厭苦樂。精研舍心。相續不斷

```json
{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "『想念』和『俱無』都不存在,『愛染』(貪愛和執著)也不產生。不再留戀欲界(指色慾、食慾、睡眠慾等)。這樣的人,應當立即轉生為梵眾天(Brahmā-pāriṣadya)。這是第一類,稱為梵眾天。",
    "如果他們已經消除了對慾望的習氣,顯現出遠離慾望的心,並且喜愛和順從各種戒律,這樣的人,應當立即能夠修行梵德(brahmaguna)。這是第二類,稱為梵輔天(Brahmā-purohita)。",
    "如果他們身心微妙圓滿,威儀沒有缺失,在清凈的禁戒之上,又增加了明智的領悟,這樣的人,應當立即能夠統領梵眾,成為大梵王(Mahābrahmā)。這是第三類,稱為大梵天。",
    "阿難(Ānanda),這三種殊勝的眾生,一切苦惱都不能逼迫他們。雖然他們不是真正地修習『真三摩地』(true samādhi),但是在清凈的心中,各種煩惱不再動搖,這稱為初禪(first Dhyāna)。",
    "阿難,其次的梵天,統領和攝受梵人,圓滿地修行梵行(brahmacarya),澄凈內心而不動搖,寂靜而光明煥發。這樣的一類,稱為少光天(Parīttābha)。",
    "光明互相輝映,照耀無盡,映照十方世界,普遍成為琉璃般的光明。這樣的一類,稱為無量光天(Apramāṇābha)。",
    "吸取和保持圓滿的光明,成就教化的本體,煥發清凈的光明,應用無窮無盡。這樣的一類,稱為光音天(Ābhāsvara)。",
    "阿難,這三種殊勝的眾生,一切憂愁和牽掛都不能逼迫他們。雖然他們不是真正地修習『真三摩地』,但是在清凈的心中,粗重的煩惱已經被降伏,這稱為二禪(second Dhyāna)。",
    "阿難,這些天人,圓滿的光明化為妙音,從妙音中顯露出微妙的真理,煥發出精純的修行,通達寂滅的快樂。這樣的一類,稱為少凈天(Parīttaśubha)。",
    "清凈的虛空顯現在眼前,引發無邊的光明,身心輕安,成就寂滅的快樂。這樣的一類,稱為無量凈天(Apramāṇaśubha)。",
    "世界和身心,一切都圓滿清凈,清凈的功德成就,殊勝的依託顯現在眼前,迴歸寂滅的快樂。這樣的一類,稱為遍凈天(Śubhakṛtsna)。",
    "阿難,這三種殊勝的眾生,具有極大的隨順性,身心安穩,獲得無量的快樂。雖然他們不是真正地獲得『真三摩地』,但是在安穩的心中,歡喜完全具備,這稱為三禪(third Dhyāna)。",
    "阿難,再次,這些天人不再受到身心的逼迫,痛苦的根源已經斷盡,但是快樂不是永恒的,長久之後必定會壞滅和產生新的痛苦。痛苦和快樂兩種心念,同時頓然捨棄,粗重的現象消滅,清凈的福德自性產生。這樣的一類,稱為福生天(Puṇyaprasava)。",
    "捨棄的心圓融無礙,殊勝的理解清凈無染,在沒有遮蔽的福德中,獲得微妙的隨順,窮盡未來際。這樣的一類,稱為福愛天(Puṇyābha)。",
    "阿難,從這些天中,有兩條不同的道路。如果對於先前的無量清凈光明和福德的圓滿光明,進行修行和安住,這樣的一類,稱為廣果天(Bṛhatphala)。",
    "如果對於先前的厭惡痛苦和快樂的心,精細地研究捨棄的心,使之相續不斷。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "'Thinking' and '俱無' (俱無, both non-existent) are both non-existent, and '愛染' (ài rǎn, attachment and clinging) does not arise. There is no longer any attachment to the desire realm (referring to desires for form, food, sleep, etc.). Such a person should immediately be reborn as a Brahmā-pāriṣadya (梵眾天). This is the first category, called Brahmā-pāriṣadya.",
    "If they have eliminated the habits of desire, manifested a mind that is free from desire, and love and comply with various precepts, such a person should immediately be able to practice brahmaguna (梵德). This is the second category, called Brahmā-purohita (梵輔天).",
    "If their body and mind are subtly perfect, their demeanor is without fault, and on top of pure precepts, they have added wise understanding, such a person should immediately be able to lead the Brahmā-pāriṣadya and become Mahābrahmā (大梵王). This is the third category, called Mahābrahmā.",
    "Ānanda (阿難), these three kinds of superior beings cannot be compelled by any suffering. Although they are not truly practicing 'true samādhi' (真三摩地), in their pure minds, the various afflictions no longer stir. This is called the first Dhyāna (初禪).",
    "Ānanda, the next Brahmā-pāriṣadya, leads and gathers the Brahmā-pāriṣadya, perfectly practicing brahmacarya (梵行), clarifying the mind without wavering, serene and radiant with light. Such a category is called Parīttābha (少光天).",
    "Lights shine on each other, illuminating endlessly, reflecting the ten directions, universally becoming like lapis lazuli. Such a category is called Apramāṇābha (無量光天).",
    "Absorbing and maintaining perfect light, accomplishing the essence of teaching, emanating pure light, with endless applications. Such a category is called Ābhāsvara (光音天).",
    "Ānanda, these three kinds of superior beings cannot be compelled by any worries or concerns. Although they are not truly practicing 'true samādhi', in their pure minds, the gross afflictions have been subdued. This is called the second Dhyāna (二禪).",
    "Ānanda, these devas, perfect light transforms into wondrous sound, revealing subtle truths from the wondrous sound, emanating pure practice, penetrating the bliss of cessation. Such a category is called Parīttaśubha (少凈天).",
    "Pure emptiness appears before them, eliciting boundless light, body and mind are light and at ease, accomplishing the bliss of cessation. Such a category is called Apramāṇaśubha (無量凈天).",
    "The world and body and mind, all are perfectly pure, the merits of purity are accomplished, a superior reliance appears before them, returning to the bliss of cessation. Such a category is called Śubhakṛtsna (遍凈天).",
    "Ānanda, these three kinds of superior beings possess great compliance, their bodies and minds are peaceful and secure, obtaining immeasurable bliss. Although they have not truly attained 'true samādhi', in their peaceful minds, joy is fully present. This is called the third Dhyāna (三禪).",
    "Ānanda, again, these devas are no longer compelled by body and mind, the root of suffering has been exhausted, but happiness is not eternal, and after a long time, it will inevitably decay and give rise to new suffering. The two thoughts of suffering and happiness are simultaneously abandoned, gross phenomena disappear, and the pure nature of merit arises. Such a category is called Puṇyaprasava (福生天).",
    "The mind of abandonment is perfectly unobstructed, superior understanding is pure and undefiled, in unobstructed merit, subtle compliance is obtained, exhausting the future. Such a category is called Puṇyābha (福愛天).",
    "Ānanda, from these heavens, there are two different paths. If one cultivates and dwells upon the previous immeasurable pure light and the perfect light of merit, such a category is called Bṛhatphala (廣果天).",
    "If one diligently studies the mind of abandonment with regard to the previous mind that is averse to suffering and happiness, making it continuous."
  ]
}

。圓窮舍道。身心俱滅。心慮灰凝。經五百劫。是人既以生滅為因。不能發明不生滅性。初半劫滅。後半劫生。如是一類。名無想天。阿難。此四勝流。一切世間諸苦樂境。所不能動。雖非無為真不動地。有所得心。功用純熟。名為四禪。

  通曰。前六慾天。形雖出動。已離人仙二趣。心跡尚交。慾念未至全無。不可語于梵也。若修梵行者。但知持戒。修十善道。不知禪那。無有智慧。故於諸禁戒。唯淫難斷。茲力能斷淫。無留欲界。是為梵眾。心既離欲。戒為真戒。于諸律儀。愛樂隨順。是為梵輔。清凈禁戒。加以明悟。謂悟欲即是性。戒無所戒。是名大梵。戒定相應。得定其戒。已離欲界八苦。苦惱粗相。所不能逼。名離生喜樂地。總屬初禪。自此以上。無有言語。但以定心發光。光有勝劣。分其高下。少光其光尚劣。迭發多光。則光無量。猶未至成音也。至成就教體。令人觀光知修梵德。隨機受益。應用無盡。則圓光成音矣。此定生時。與喜俱發。名喜俱禪。微細憂懸。所不能逼。名定生喜樂地。總屬二禪。自此以上。離前喜動而生凈樂。是樂非境。乃出乎凈性。興寂滅為樂相似。始而曰通。其凈猶劣。既而曰成。則身心輕安。協乎妙性。猶未至於遍也。唯世界身心。一切圓凈。此勝托現前。托于勝境。非真寂滅現前也。但隨順凈性。歸寂滅樂。此定功德。與遍身樂俱發。名樂俱禪。雖離前喜動。而歡樂畢具。名離喜妙樂地。總屬三禪。喜動乃逼苦之因。離喜則苦因已盡。而得無量樂。是樂有為所致。樂久必壞。壞亦成苦。故

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本:圓滿而究竟地捨棄了世間的道路,身心都歸於寂滅。心中的思慮如同灰燼般凝固,經歷五百劫的時間。這種人因為以生滅作為修行的因,所以不能夠證悟不生不滅的本性。最初的半劫處於滅的狀態,後半劫又處於生的狀態。像這樣的一類眾生,就叫做無想天(沒有思想的禪定天)。",
    "阿難(佛陀的弟子),這四種殊勝的禪定境界,是世間一切的苦樂之境所不能動搖的。雖然它們並非真正的無為不動之地,但因為有所得之心,並且修行功夫已經非常純熟,所以被稱為四禪。",
    
    "總結來說,前面的六慾天,雖然形體已經脫離了動亂,也已經遠離了人道和仙道這兩種境界,但他們的心念和行為仍然相互交織,慾望和念頭還沒有完全斷絕,所以不能夠稱之為梵天。如果修行梵行的人,只知道持戒,修習十善道,卻不知道修習禪定,沒有智慧,那麼對於各種禁戒,就只有淫慾難以斷除。如果能夠斷除淫慾,不再停留在欲界,這就是梵眾天。心既然已經遠離了慾望,戒律才是真正的戒律,對於各種律儀,都喜愛並且隨順,這就是梵輔天。在清凈的禁戒之上,再加上明悟,也就是領悟到慾望本身就是自性,戒律也就沒有什麼可戒的,這就是大梵天。戒律和禪定相互相應,通過禪定來堅定戒律,已經遠離了欲界的八種苦,粗重的苦惱之相,不能夠逼迫他們,這叫做離生喜樂地,總的來說屬於初禪。從這裡往上,就沒有了言語,只是以禪定的力量發出光明,光明有強有弱,以此來區分高下。少光天的光明還比較弱,迭發多光天則光明無量,但還沒有達到形成聲音的程度。直到成就教體,能夠讓人通過觀察光明來了解修習梵德,根據不同的根器而受益,應用無窮無盡,那麼圓滿的光明就能夠形成聲音了。這種禪定產生的時候,與喜悅一同生髮,叫做喜俱禪。微細的憂愁和懸念,不能夠逼迫他們,叫做定生喜樂地,總的來說屬於二禪。從這裡往上,脫離了之前的喜悅的動盪,而產生清凈的快樂。這種快樂不是來自於外在的境界,而是來自於清凈的自性,與寂滅的快樂相似。開始的時候叫做少凈天,他們的清凈還比較弱,後來叫做遍凈天,那麼身心輕安,與妙性相合,但還沒有達到普遍的程度。只有世界和身心,一切都圓滿清凈,這種殊勝的境界才能夠顯現出來,是依託于殊勝的境界,而不是真正的寂滅顯現。只是隨順清凈的自性,歸於寂滅的快樂。這種禪定的功德,與遍身快樂一同生髮,叫做樂俱禪。雖然脫離了之前的喜悅的動盪,但歡樂完全具備,叫做離喜妙樂地,總的來說屬於三禪。喜悅的動盪是逼迫產生痛苦的原因,脫離了喜悅,痛苦的原因就消失了,從而得到無量的快樂。但這種快樂是有為法所導致的,快樂長久了必定會壞滅,壞滅也會變成痛苦,所以",
    ""
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version: Perfectly and ultimately abandoning the worldly path, both body and mind return to stillness. The thoughts in the mind are solidified like ashes, experiencing five hundred kalpas (an extremely long period of time). Such a person, because they take birth and death as the cause of their practice, is unable to realize the unborn and undying nature. The first half of the kalpa is in a state of extinction, and the second half is in a state of birth. Beings of this kind are called the Heaven of Non-Thinking (a dhyana heaven without thought).",
    "Ananda (Buddha's disciple), these four superior states of samadhi (meditative absorption) cannot be moved by all the realms of suffering and joy in the world. Although they are not the true unconditioned and immovable ground, because they have a mind of attainment and their practice is very pure and skilled, they are called the Four Dhyanas (Four levels of meditative absorption).",
    
    "In summary, the previous Six Desire Heavens, although their forms have escaped from turmoil and they have distanced themselves from the realms of humans and immortals, their thoughts and actions are still intertwined, and their desires and thoughts have not been completely eradicated, so they cannot be called Brahma Heavens. If those who practice Brahma conduct only know how to uphold precepts and cultivate the ten wholesome deeds, but do not know how to cultivate dhyana and lack wisdom, then among all the prohibitions, only lust is difficult to eradicate. If one can eradicate lust and no longer remain in the Desire Realm, this is the Brahma Assembly Heaven. Since the mind has already distanced itself from desires, the precepts are true precepts, and one loves and follows all the rules of conduct, this is the Brahma Retinue Heaven. On top of pure prohibitions, add clear understanding, which is to realize that desire itself is one's nature, and there is nothing to be prohibited, this is the Great Brahma Heaven. Precepts and samadhi correspond to each other, and one uses samadhi to strengthen the precepts, having already distanced themselves from the eight sufferings of the Desire Realm. The coarse forms of suffering and affliction cannot compel them, this is called the Land of Joy and Bliss Born from Detachment, which generally belongs to the First Dhyana. From here upwards, there is no speech, but only the power of samadhi emits light. The light has strengths and weaknesses, which are used to distinguish the levels. The light of the Heaven of Limited Light is still relatively weak, while the Heaven of Radiating Light emits immeasurable light, but it has not yet reached the point of forming sound. Until one achieves the teaching body, being able to allow people to understand the practice of Brahma virtue by observing the light, benefiting according to different capacities, and applying it endlessly, then the perfect light can form sound. When this samadhi arises, it arises together with joy, called the Dhyana Accompanied by Joy. Subtle worries and anxieties cannot compel them, called the Land of Joy and Bliss Born from Samadhi, which generally belongs to the Second Dhyana. From here upwards, one detaches from the previous agitation of joy and generates pure bliss. This bliss does not come from external realms, but from the pure nature, similar to taking stillness and extinction as bliss. Initially, it is called the Heaven of Limited Purity, their purity is still relatively weak, later it is called the Heaven of Universal Purity, then the body and mind are light and at ease, in harmony with the wonderful nature, but it has not yet reached the point of universality. Only when the world and the body and mind are all perfectly pure, can this superior state manifest, relying on the superior realm, not the true manifestation of stillness and extinction. One simply follows the pure nature and returns to the bliss of stillness and extinction. The merit of this samadhi arises together with the bliss pervading the body, called the Dhyana Accompanied by Bliss. Although one detaches from the previous agitation of joy, the joy is fully present, called the Land of Wonderful Bliss Born from Detachment from Joy, which generally belongs to the Third Dhyana. The agitation of joy is the cause of compelling suffering, and detaching from joy eliminates the cause of suffering, thereby obtaining immeasurable bliss. However, this bliss is caused by conditioned dharmas (phenomena), and lasting bliss will inevitably decay, and decay will also become suffering, so"
  ]
}

苦樂俱舍。則粗重相滅。舍念清凈。則凈福性生。凈德致福。三災不及。是名福生。苦樂二忘。舍無所舍。但愛樂隨順無遮福性。是名福愛。均名舍俱禪。從是有二歧路。若於先無量光無量凈福德圓明。不帶異執。無生滅心。則直趨廣果。謂凈福廣大所感果也。若先心雙厭苦樂。專研舍心。先舍粗心。入于微心。復舍微心。入微微心。從微微心。相續無間。以至心想一切皆舍。心慮灰凝。此妄想相也。是名無想定。乃從迂僻生無想天。是人不了妄性體空。即妄即真。厭此生滅。求不生滅。以至身心俱滅。非真不生滅性也。如來冰魚耳。初生此天。未全無想。經半劫始無。及報將習。後半劫有想而心相見。故曰初半劫滅。後半劫生。中間四百九十九劫。一向無想。乃定力所持。一切苦樂所不能動。總為四禪。在初禪二禪。曰非正修真三摩地。在三禪。曰非正得真三摩地。至四禪。則曰非無為真不動地。初禪修戒。二禪修定。從清凈梵行中修。雖不至為鬼神邪定。然非從真三摩地發心。此有為無為所由辨也。三禪有所得矣。得之而樂矣。有得有樂。即非真三摩地。此有得無得所由分也。至四禪有所得心幾於舍盡。可以謂之無為矣。然由功用純熟所致。非真不動地也。若真不動地。眾苦所不到。到且不能。而孰其動之。今以世間諸苦樂境所不能動。便以為三摩地。是三摩地可修而至也。可修而至者。非真三摩地也。故真三摩地。非具般若智慧。莫能知之。今四禪修心。不假禪那。無有智慧。于真三摩地。有所不知也。真凈和尚示眾云。是日已過。

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "'苦'和'樂'的感受都放下,粗重的念頭就會消滅。捨棄雜念,保持清凈,那麼清凈的福德本性就會產生。清凈的德行帶來福報,水災、火災、風災這'三災'都無法侵襲,這叫做'福生'。'苦'和'樂'兩種感受都忘卻,捨棄到無可捨棄的地步,只是喜愛並隨順那沒有遮蔽的福德本性,這叫做'福愛'。'福生'和'福愛'都可稱為'舍俱禪'。從這裡開始,就有兩條不同的道路。如果對於先前無量光明、無量清凈的福德圓滿明瞭,不帶有任何其他的執著,沒有生滅之心,那麼就能直接趨向'廣果天'(色界第四禪天),也就是清凈的福德廣大所感得的果報。如果先前內心同時厭惡'苦'和'樂',專門研究'舍'的心,先捨棄粗糙的心念,進入到細微的心念,再捨棄細微的心念,進入到更細微的心念,從這更細微的心念,相續不斷,以至於心中所想的一切都捨棄,心裡的思慮像灰燼一樣凝固,這就是虛妄的想像狀態。這叫做'無想定'(一種錯誤的禪定),乃是從迂迴偏僻的道路而生到'無想天'(色界第四禪天)。這種人不能明白虛妄的本性本來就是空,虛妄即是真實。他們厭惡這種生滅變化,追求不生不滅的狀態,以至於身心都滅亡,這不是真正的不生不滅的本性。就像如來所說的'冰魚'一樣,最初生到這個'無想天',還沒有完全進入無想的狀態,經過半劫(很長的時間單位)才進入無想狀態。等到果報將要結束的時候,後半劫又開始有想念,並且心識也顯現出來。所以說最初半劫滅,後半劫生,中間四百九十九劫,一直處於無想狀態,這是由禪定的力量所維持,一切的'苦'和'樂'都不能動搖他。總的來說,這就是'四禪'(色界天的四種禪定)。在初禪和二禪,佛經上說'不是真正修習真實的三摩地'(專注的狀態)。在三禪,佛經上說'不是真正得到真實的三摩地'。到了四禪,就說'不是無為的真實不動之地'。初禪修習戒律,二禪修習禪定,從清凈的梵行中修習,雖然不至於成為鬼神邪定的狀態,但不是從真正的三摩地發心。這就是有為和無為的區別所在。三禪已經有所得,並且因為得到而感到快樂。有所得,有快樂,就不是真正的三摩地。這就是有得和無得的區別所在。到了四禪,有所得的心幾乎完全捨棄,可以稱之為無爲了。然而這是由功用純熟所導致的,不是真正的不動之地。如果是真正的不動之地,各種痛苦都無法到達,即使到達也不能動搖它,又有誰能動搖它呢?現在用世間各種'苦'和'樂'的境界所不能動搖,就認為是三摩地,這種三摩地是可以修習而達到的。可以修習而達到的,就不是真正的三摩地。所以真正的三摩地,如果沒有般若智慧,就無法瞭解。現在'四禪'修習心念,不依靠禪那(禪定),沒有智慧,對於真正的三摩地,有所不知。真凈和尚開示大眾說:這一天已經過去了。",
    "English version",
    "The simultaneous cessation of both suffering and joy leads to the eradication of coarse phenomena. Abandoning thoughts and maintaining purity gives rise to the nature of pure merit. Pure virtue brings forth blessings, untouched by the 'Three Disasters' (water, fire, and wind), which is called 'Birth of Blessing'. Forgetting both suffering and joy, relinquishing all that can be relinquished, simply loving and complying with the unhindered nature of blessing is called 'Love of Blessing'. Both are equally named 'Simultaneous Abandonment Meditation'. From here, there are two divergent paths. If one is completely clear about the immeasurable light and immeasurable pure merit of the past, without any other attachments, and without a mind of arising and ceasing, then one directly heads towards the 'Broad Fruit Heaven' (the fourth dhyana of the Form Realm), which is the result of vast pure merit. If one simultaneously detests both suffering and joy, and focuses solely on studying the mind of abandonment, first abandoning the coarse mind and entering the subtle mind, then abandoning the subtle mind and entering the more subtle mind, and from this more subtle mind, continuously and uninterruptedly, to the point where all thoughts are abandoned, and the mind's deliberations become as solidified as ashes, this is a state of delusional imagination. This is called 'Non-Thinking Meditation' (a mistaken form of meditation), which leads to birth in the 'Non-Thinking Heaven' (the fourth dhyana of the Form Realm) through a roundabout and deviated path. Such a person does not understand that the nature of delusion is inherently empty, that delusion is truth. They detest this arising and ceasing, seeking a state of non-arising and non-ceasing, to the point where both body and mind are extinguished, which is not the true nature of non-arising and non-ceasing. Like the 'ice fish' mentioned by the Tathagata, one is initially born into this heaven and is not completely without thought. After half a kalpa (a very long unit of time), one enters a state of non-thought. When the retribution is about to end, in the latter half of the kalpa, thoughts arise again, and consciousness appears. Therefore, it is said that the first half of the kalpa is extinguished, and the latter half is born, with four hundred and ninety-nine kalpas in between, consistently in a state of non-thought, maintained by the power of meditation, unshaken by all suffering and joy. In general, these are the 'Four Dhyanas' (the four meditations of the Form Realm). In the first and second dhyanas, the sutras say 'it is not truly cultivating true samadhi' (a state of concentration). In the third dhyana, the sutras say 'it is not truly attaining true samadhi'. In the fourth dhyana, it is said 'it is not the unconditioned true immovable ground'. The first dhyana cultivates precepts, the second dhyana cultivates meditation, cultivated from pure Brahma conduct. Although it does not lead to the state of demonic or heretical meditation, it does not arise from the true samadhi. This is the distinction between conditioned and unconditioned. The third dhyana has something to be gained, and is happy because of it. Having something to gain and having happiness is not true samadhi. This is the distinction between having gain and not having gain. In the fourth dhyana, the mind of having something to gain is almost completely abandoned, and it can be called unconditioned. However, this is due to the perfection of effort, not the true immovable ground. If it were the true immovable ground, all suffering could not reach it, and even if it did, it could not shake it. Who could shake it? Now, using the inability to be shaken by the various worldly states of suffering and joy as samadhi, this samadhi can be cultivated and attained. What can be cultivated and attained is not true samadhi. Therefore, true samadhi cannot be known without prajna wisdom. Now, the 'Four Dhyanas' cultivate the mind, without relying on dhyana (meditation), without wisdom, and are ignorant of true samadhi. The Venerable Master Zhenjing instructed the assembly: This day has passed."
  ]
}

命亦隨滅。如少水魚。斯亦何樂。唯二乘禪定寂滅為樂。是為真樂。學般若菩薩法喜禪悅為樂。是為真樂。三世諸佛。慈悲喜捨四無量心為樂。是為真樂。石霜普會云。休去歇去。冷湫湫地去。是為二乘寂滅之樂。雲門云。一切智通無障礙。拈起扇子云。釋迦老子來也。是為法喜禪悅之樂。德山棒。臨濟喝。是三世諸佛慈悲喜捨之樂。除此三種樂外。不為樂也。且道歸宗一眾。在三種內三種外。良久云。今日莊主設饡飯。俵䞋錢。參退。僧堂內普請喫茶去。喝一喝。又鵝湖大義禪師。憲宗詔入內殿論義。有法師問欲界無禪。禪居色界。此土憑何而立。義曰。法師祗知欲界無禪。不知禪界無慾。曰如何是禪。義以手點空。法師無對。帝曰。法師講無窮經論。祗這一點。尚不奈何。故真三摩地。誠不易知。知之而三界俱超。何論四禪哉。

  阿難。此中復有五不還天。于地獄中。九品習氣。俱時滅盡。苦樂雙亡。下無卜居。故於舍心眾同分中。安立居處。阿難。苦樂兩滅。鬥心不交。如是一類。名無煩天。機括獨行。研交無地。如是一類。名無熱天。十方世界。妙見圓澄。更無塵像一切沉垢。如是一類。名善見天。精見現前。陶鑄無礙。如是一類。名善現天。究竟群幾。窮色性性。入無邊際。如是一類。名色究竟天。阿難。此不還天。彼諸四禪四位天王。獨有欽聞。不能知見。如今世間曠野深山聖道場地。皆阿羅漢所住持故。世間粗人所不能見。阿難。是十八天。獨行無交。未盡形累。自此已還。名為色界。

  通曰。五不還者。不復

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "生命也隨之消逝,就像淺水中的魚,還有什麼樂趣可言呢?只有二乘(聲聞乘和緣覺乘)的禪定寂滅才是真正的快樂。學習般若(Prajna,智慧)的菩薩,以法喜禪悅為樂,這才是真正的快樂。過去、現在、未來三世諸佛,以慈、悲、喜、舍四無量心為樂,這才是真正的快樂。石霜普會禪師說:『放下,歇息,冷冷清清地離去』,這是二乘寂滅之樂。雲門禪師說:『一切智慧通達無礙』,拿起扇子說:『釋迦老子(釋迦牟尼佛)來了!』這是法喜禪悅之樂。德山禪師的棒喝,臨濟禪師的喝聲,是三世諸佛慈悲喜捨之樂。除了這三種快樂之外,沒有其他的快樂了。那麼,歸宗禪師這一眾,是在三種之內還是三種之外呢?』停頓良久說:『今天莊主設齋飯,分發賞錢,參禪完畢,大家到僧堂里喝茶去。』然後大喝一聲。還有鵝湖大義禪師,唐憲宗(806-820)詔令他進入內殿論辯佛法。有法師問:『欲界沒有禪定,禪定在哪裡?此土(娑婆世界)憑什麼立足?』大義禪師說:『法師只知道欲界沒有禪定,不知道禪定的境界沒有慾望。』法師問:『什麼是禪?』大義禪師用手指點虛空,法師無言以對。憲宗說:『法師講解了無窮的經論,卻對這一點尚且無可奈何。』所以真正的三摩地(Samadhi,禪定),確實不容易瞭解。瞭解了它,就能超越三界,又何必談論四禪呢?",
    
    "阿難(Ananda,釋迦牟尼佛的十大弟子之一)。這其中又有五不還天(Pañca-anāgāmi-devā,色界天的第五層),在地獄(欲界)中的九品習氣,同時滅盡,苦樂雙亡,地獄不再有居所,所以在舍心眾同分中,安立居處。阿難,苦樂兩種感受都已滅盡,鬥爭之心不再產生,像這樣的一類天人,名為無煩天(Avṛha)。機智敏捷,獨來獨往,研究探討無處可施,像這樣的一類天人,名為無熱天(Atapa)。十方世界,精妙的見解圓滿澄澈,不再有塵埃污垢,像這樣的一類天人,名為善見天(Sudṛśa)。精純的見解顯現於前,造化運作毫無障礙,像這樣的一類天人,名為善現天(Sudarśana)。徹底窮盡各種細微的差別,窮盡色性的本性,進入無邊無際的境界,像這樣的一類天人,名為色究竟天(Akaniṣṭha)。阿難,這五不還天,只有四禪四位的天王能夠聽到他們的名聲,卻不能親眼見到他們。就像現在世間的曠野深山,聖道修行的場所,都是阿羅漢(Arhat,斷盡煩惱,證得解脫的聖者)所住持的地方,世俗之人無法見到。阿難,這十八天,獨來獨往,沒有交往,還沒有完全脫離形體的束縛,從這裡開始,稱為**。",
    
    "通曰:五不還天,不再..."
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Life also fades away, like a fish in shallow water. What joy is there in that? Only the meditative quiescence of the Two Vehicles (Śrāvakayāna and Pratyekabuddhayāna) is true joy. The Bodhisattva (enlightenment being) who studies Prajna (wisdom) takes joy in the Dharma and meditative bliss; this is true joy. The Buddhas of the past, present, and future take joy in the Four Immeasurable Minds of loving-kindness, compassion, joy, and equanimity; this is true joy. Zen Master Shishuang Puhui said, 'Let go, rest, depart in cold detachment.' This is the joy of the Two Vehicles' quiescence. Zen Master Yunmen said, 'All wisdom is unobstructed.' He picked up a fan and said, 'Old Shakya (Shakyamuni Buddha) is coming!' This is the joy of Dharma and meditative bliss. Deshan's staff and Linji's shout are the joy of the Three Buddhas' loving-kindness, compassion, joy, and equanimity. Apart from these three joys, there is no other joy. So, tell me, where does the assembly of Guizong belong—within or outside these three?' After a long pause, he said, 'Today the village head provides a vegetarian meal and distributes reward money. After the meditation session, everyone go to the monks' hall for tea.' Then he shouted loudly. Furthermore, Zen Master Dayi of Ehu was summoned by Emperor Xianzong of Tang (806-820) to debate the Dharma in the inner palace. A Dharma master asked, 'There is no meditation in the Desire Realm. Where does meditation reside? What does this land (Saha world) rely on?' Dayi said, 'The Dharma master only knows that there is no meditation in the Desire Realm, but does not know that there is no desire in the realm of meditation.' The Dharma master asked, 'What is meditation?' Dayi pointed to the empty space with his finger, and the Dharma master was speechless. Emperor Xianzong said, 'The Dharma master has lectured on endless scriptures, but is still helpless with this one point.' Therefore, true Samadhi (meditative concentration) is indeed not easy to understand. Understanding it allows one to transcend the Three Realms, so why even discuss the Four Dhyanas (meditative states)?",
    
    "Ananda (one of the ten principal disciples of Shakyamuni Buddha). Within this, there are also the Five Pure Abodes (Pañca-anāgāmi-devā, the fifth layer of the Form Realm), where the nine grades of habitual tendencies in the lower realm (Desire Realm) are extinguished simultaneously. Suffering and joy both cease, and there is no longer a dwelling in the lower realm. Therefore, they establish their abode in the shared sphere of equanimity. Ananda, both suffering and joy have ceased, and the mind of contention no longer arises. Such a class of beings is called Avṛha (No Affliction). Their faculties are sharp and they act independently, with no place to engage in debate. Such a class of beings is called Atapa (No Heat). The subtle view of the ten directions is perfectly clear, with no more dust or defilement. Such a class of beings is called Sudṛśa (Good View). Pure perception manifests before them, and creation operates without obstruction. Such a class of beings is called Sudarśana (Clear Vision). They thoroughly exhaust all subtle distinctions, exhaust the nature of form, and enter the boundless realm. Such a class of beings is called Akaniṣṭha (Ultimate Form). Ananda, these Five Pure Abodes, only the kings of the Fourth Dhyana heavens can hear of them, but cannot see them. It is like the remote wilderness and deep mountains in the world today, and the places where the holy path is practiced, which are all maintained by Arhats (liberated beings who have extinguished all afflictions), and cannot be seen by ordinary people. Ananda, these eighteen heavens are solitary and without interaction, and have not yet completely escaped the bonds of form. From here on, it is called **.",
    
    "Tong says: The Five Pure Abodes, no longer..."
  ]
}

于欲界受生。即斯陀含名為不來而實無不來者也。三果能斷九品習氣。種子與現行俱滅。于欲界無受生業。故曰下無卜居。此五天即四禪舍念清凈。更入微細立名耳。前于苦樂有舍有厭。則心與境鬥。不能無煩。盛熱則謂之煩。今苦樂兩滅。無與斗者。故名無煩。心雖不交。交地猶在。未為拔根也。今心機無對。能滅緣影。並生煩之熱而無之矣。故名無熱。此無煩無熱。但除外粗。未顯凈妙。今妙見圓澄。外不依塵象生。內不依沉垢生。照十方世界。如凈琉璃。是名善見。精見在我。能陶鑄妙色而無礙。十方世界。從我發化。是名善現。幾者動之微也。一微空故眾微空。眾微空故一微空。於此窮色性性。色性空。空性覺。覺則所謂色性性也。空生大覺中。如海一漚發。不獨究竟色性。而且究竟性之所自來。色于究竟盡矣。楞伽云。住色究竟天。離諸過失處。于彼成正覺。有味哉其言之也。所謂正覺者。不住於色。不住于空。唯色究竟天。前此之色既盡。后此之空未來。於此可證無上正等正覺也。彌勒曰。色界十八處。初禪三天。由䎡中上品熏修初靜慮故。二禪三天。由䎡中上品熏修第二靜慮故。三禪三天。由䎡中上品熏修第三靜慮故。四禪四天。由䎡中上品熏修第四靜慮故。復有諸聖住。心不共五凈居地。由䎡中上上極品熏修第四靜慮故。此不還天何為四禪以下不能知見。下天修有漏凡定。此天修無漏聖業。聖凡之隔。故不能見。云居膺結庵於三峰。經旬不赴堂。洞山問子近日何不赴齋。膺曰。每日自有天神送食。山曰。我將謂汝是個人。

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "于欲界受生,即是說證得斯陀含果位(梵文:Sakadāgāmin,含義:一來),名為『不來』,但實際上並非真的不來。三果阿那含(梵文:Anāgāmin,含義:不還)能斷除欲界九品思惑的習氣,種子和現行都滅盡,在欲界沒有受生的業力,所以說『下無卜居』(不再於欲界投生)。這五天(五凈居天)實際上就是四禪(梵文:Dhyāna)的舍念清凈,只是更深入微細而立的新名稱罷了。之前對於苦樂有舍有厭,那是心與外境相鬥,不能沒有煩惱。煩惱就像盛夏的酷熱。現在苦樂都已滅盡,沒有可以相鬥的對象,所以叫做『無煩』。心雖然不與外境交涉,但交涉的『地』還在,還未徹底拔除煩惱的根源。現在心機沒有對立,能滅除緣影,連同產生煩惱的熱源也一併消滅了,所以叫做『無熱』。這無煩天、無熱天,只是除去了外在的粗重煩惱,還未顯現清凈微妙。現在微妙的見解圓滿澄澈,外不依賴塵象而生,內不依賴沉溺的污垢而生,照耀十方世界,如同清凈的琉璃,這叫做『善見』。精妙的見解在於自身,能陶冶鑄造微妙的色相而沒有阻礙,十方世界,從我這裡發化,這叫做『善現』。『幾』是動的極微之處。一微空故眾微空,眾微空故一微空。於此窮盡色性,色性本空,空性是覺性。覺性就是所謂的色性之性。空性生於大覺之中,如同大海中生起一個水泡。不只是究竟了色性,而且究竟了覺性所從何來。色于究竟處窮盡了。《楞伽經》說:『住在色究竟天(梵文:Akaniṣṭha),遠離諸過失之處,在那裡成就正覺。』這話真有意味啊!所謂正覺,就是不住於色,不住于空,唯有色究竟天,前此之色已經窮盡,后此之空尚未到來,於此可以證得無上正等正覺。彌勒菩薩說:『十八處(十八界),初禪三天,由下品、中品、上品熏修初禪靜慮的緣故。二禪三天,由下品、中品、上品熏修第二禪靜慮的緣故。三禪三天,由下品、中品、上品熏修第三禪靜慮的緣故。四禪四天,由下品、中品、上品熏修第四禪靜慮的緣故。還有諸聖人住在心不共的五凈居地,由下品、中品、上品、上上品、極品熏修第四禪靜慮的緣故。』這不還天為什麼四禪以下的天不能知見?因為地獄天修的是有漏的凡夫禪定,這不還天修的是無漏的聖人事業,聖凡之間有隔閡,所以不能見。云居山的膺結庵在三峰,十幾天不去齋堂。洞山問:『你近日為何不去齋堂?』膺說:『每日自有天神送食。』洞山說:『我本以為你是個修行人。』"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Rebirth in the Desire Realm means attaining the state of Sakadāgāmin (meaning 'once-returner'), which is called 'non-return,' but in reality, it's not truly non-returning. The third fruit, Anāgāmin (meaning 'non-returner'), can sever the habitual energies of the nine grades of delusion in the Desire Realm. The seeds and manifestations are all extinguished, and there is no karma for rebirth in the Desire Realm. Therefore, it is said, 'There is no dwelling below' (no longer reborn in the Desire Realm). These five heavens (Five Pure Abodes) are actually the equanimity and mindfulness purity of the Four Dhyānas, just with more profound and subtle names. Previously, having equanimity and aversion towards suffering and pleasure meant the mind was fighting with external objects, unable to be without afflictions. Afflictions are like the intense heat of summer. Now, both suffering and pleasure are extinguished, with nothing to fight against, so it is called 'Avṛha' (No Affliction). Although the mind does not interact with external objects, the 'ground' of interaction is still there, and the root of afflictions has not been completely eradicated. Now, the mind's mechanism has no opposition, able to extinguish the shadows of conditions, and even eliminate the source of heat that produces afflictions, so it is called 'Atapa' (No Heat). These Avṛha and Atapa heavens only remove the external coarse afflictions and have not yet revealed pure subtlety. Now, subtle views are perfectly clear, not relying on dust-like appearances externally, nor relying on submerged defilements internally, illuminating the ten directions of the world like pure crystal. This is called 'Sudṛśa' (Good Appearance). The subtle view is within oneself, able to mold and cast wonderful forms without obstruction. The ten directions of the world emanate and transform from me. This is called 'Sudarśana' (Clear Vision). 'Ki' is the extremely subtle point of movement. One subtle emptiness means all subtle emptiness, and all subtle emptiness means one subtle emptiness. Here, exhaustively investigate the nature of form. The nature of form is empty, and the nature of emptiness is the nature of awareness. Awareness is the so-called nature of the nature of form. Emptiness arises within the Great Awakening, like a bubble arising in the ocean. It not only ultimately investigates the nature of form but also ultimately investigates where the nature of awareness comes from. Form is exhausted at the ultimate point. The *Laṅkāvatāra Sūtra* says: 'Dwelling in the Akaniṣṭha Heaven (Form's Highest Heaven), a place far from all faults, one attains perfect enlightenment there.' These words are truly meaningful! The so-called perfect enlightenment is not dwelling in form, not dwelling in emptiness, only in the Akaniṣṭha Heaven. The form before this is already exhausted, and the emptiness after this has not yet arrived. Here, one can attain Anuttarā-Samyak-Saṃbodhi (Unsurpassed Perfect Enlightenment). Maitreya Bodhisattva said: 'The eighteen dhātus (eighteen realms), the three heavens of the First Dhyāna, are due to the inferior, middle, and superior cultivation of the First Dhyāna concentration. The three heavens of the Second Dhyāna are due to the inferior, middle, and superior cultivation of the Second Dhyāna concentration. The three heavens of the Third Dhyāna are due to the inferior, middle, and superior cultivation of the Third Dhyāna concentration. The four heavens of the Fourth Dhyāna are due to the inferior, middle, and superior cultivation of the Fourth Dhyāna concentration. Furthermore, there are saints dwelling in the Five Pure Abodes, with minds not common, due to the inferior, middle, superior, supreme, and ultimate cultivation of the Fourth Dhyāna concentration.' Why can't the heavens below the Fourth Dhyāna know and see this Anāgāmin heaven? Because the lower heavens cultivate conditioned mundane samādhi, while this Anāgāmin heaven cultivates unconditioned noble deeds. There is a separation between the holy and the mundane, so they cannot see. Ying, who built a hermitage on the three peaks of Yunju Mountain, did not attend the dining hall for more than ten days. Dongshan asked, 'Why haven't you been attending the dining hall recently?' Ying replied, 'Every day, a deva sends me food.' Dongshan said, 'I thought you were a cultivator.'"
  ]
}

猶作這個見解在。汝晚間來。膺晚至。山召膺阇黎。膺應諾。山曰。不思善。不思惡。是甚麼。膺回庵。寂然宴坐。天神自此竟尋覓不見。如是三日乃絕。又神僧法本。嘗至襄州禪院。與一僧同過夏。本嘗言曰。貧道于相州西山中住持竹林寺。寺前有一石柱。他日有暇。必請相訪。其僧追念此言。因往彼尋覓。至山下村中寄宿。問其村僧曰。此去竹林寺近遠。僧乃遙指孤峰之側曰。彼處是也。古老相傳。昔聖賢所居之地。今但名存耳。僧疑之。詰朝往至竹叢中果有石柱。當法本臨別云。但扣其柱。即見其人。乃以小枝擊柱數聲。忽風雲四起。咫尺莫窺。俄然耳目豁開。樓臺對聳。身在三門之下逡巡。法本自內而出。見之甚喜。問南中舊事。乃引其僧度重門。升秘殿。參其尊宿。尊宿問其故。本曰。早年襄州同過夏。期此相訪。尊宿曰。可飯後請出。在此無座位。食畢。本送至三門相別。既而天地昏暗。莫知所進。此身宛在石柱之側。然則聖道場地。皆阿羅漢所住持故。非世人所可窺測。又何疑於五不還天哉。雖不可見。猶有色質。故總名色界。

  複次阿難。從是有頂色邊際中。其間復有二種歧路。若於舍心發明智慧。慧光圓通。便出塵界。成阿羅漢。入菩薩乘。如是一類。名為迴心大阿羅漢。若在舍心。舍厭成就。覺身為礙。銷礙入空。如是一類。名為空處。諸礙既銷。無礙無滅。其中唯留阿賴耶識。全于末那半分微細。如是一類。名為識處。空色既亡。識心都滅。十方寂然。迥無攸往。如是一類。名無所有處。識性不動。以滅窮研

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本:",
    "『還』執著于這種見解。你晚上來。膺晚上到了。山呼喚膺阇黎(梵語,意為導師)。膺答應了。山說:『不想善,不想惡,這是什麼?』膺回到庵中,寂然宴坐。天神從此竟然尋覓不見,如此過了三天就消失了。又有神僧法本,曾經到襄州禪院,與一位僧人一同度過夏天。法本曾經說:『貧道在相州西山中住持竹林寺,寺前有一石柱,他日有空,必定請你來拜訪。』那位僧人追憶起這句話,因此前往那裡尋覓。到達山下村中寄宿,問村裡的僧人說:『從這裡去竹林寺遠嗎?』僧人遙指孤峰旁邊說:『那裡就是了。』古老的傳說中,那是昔日聖賢所居住的地方,現在只剩下名字了。僧人懷疑。第二天早晨前往竹叢中,果然有石柱。當法本臨別時說:『只要敲擊石柱,就能見到我。』於是用小樹枝敲擊石柱數聲,忽然風雲四起,咫尺之內都看不清楚。突然耳目豁然開朗,樓臺相對聳立,身處三門之下徘徊。法本從裡面出來,見到他非常高興,詢問南中的舊事。於是引導那位僧人穿過重重門,登上秘殿,參拜他的尊宿(梵語,意為上座)。尊宿問他緣故,法本說:『早年在襄州一同度過夏天,約定來此拜訪。』尊宿說:『可以在飯後請他出去,這裡沒有座位。』吃完飯後,法本送到三門告別。不久天地昏暗,不知道該往哪裡走,此身仍然在石柱旁邊。如此說來,聖道的場地,都是阿羅漢(梵語,意為斷盡煩惱,證得解脫的聖者)所住持的,不是世人所能窺測的。又何必懷疑五不還天呢?雖然不可見,仍然有色質,所以總稱為**。",
    
    "再次,阿難(梵語,佛陀的十大弟子之一)。從有頂色邊際中,其間又有兩種歧路。如果從舍心(梵語,平等對待一切眾生的心)中發明智慧,智慧之光圓滿通達,便能超出塵世,成就阿羅漢,進入菩薩乘。像這樣的一類人,稱為迴心大阿羅漢。如果在舍心中,捨棄厭惡之心成就,覺得身體是障礙,消除障礙進入空性。像這樣的一類人,稱為空處。各種障礙既然消除,就沒有障礙也沒有消滅,其中只留下阿賴耶識(梵語,第八識,含藏一切種子)。完全是末那識(梵語,第七識,執著自我)一半的微細狀態。像這樣的一類人,稱為識處。空色既然消亡,識心都滅盡,十方寂然,沒有去處。像這樣的一類人,稱為無所有處。識性不動,用滅盡來窮盡研究。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version:",
    "They still hold onto this view. You come in the evening. Ying arrived late. Shan called to Ying Ajari (Sanskrit, meaning teacher). Ying responded. Shan said, 'Do not think of good, do not think of evil, what is this?' Ying returned to the hermitage, silently sitting in meditation. The heavenly being could no longer be found from then on, and disappeared after three days. Furthermore, the divine monk Faben once went to Xiangzhou Chan Monastery and spent the summer with a monk. Faben once said, 'This poor monk resides in Zhulin Temple in the Western Mountains of Xiangzhou. There is a stone pillar in front of the temple. If you have time in the future, I will certainly invite you to visit.' That monk recalled these words, and therefore went there to search. He arrived at a village at the foot of the mountain and lodged there, asking the monks in the village, 'Is it far from here to Zhulin Temple?' The monk pointed to the side of a solitary peak in the distance and said, 'That is it.' According to ancient legends, that is where the sages of the past resided, but now only the name remains. The monk was doubtful. The next morning, he went to the bamboo grove and indeed found a stone pillar. When Faben was about to depart, he said, 'Just knock on the pillar, and you will see me.' So he struck the pillar several times with a small branch, and suddenly wind and clouds arose from all directions, and he could not see even an inch ahead. Suddenly, his eyes and ears opened wide, and towers stood facing each other. He was pacing beneath the three gates. Faben came out from within, and was very happy to see him, asking about the old affairs of the South. So he led the monk through layers of gates, ascended to the secret hall, and paid respects to his Venerable Elder (Sanskrit, meaning senior monk). The Venerable Elder asked him the reason, and Faben said, 'We spent the summer together in Xiangzhou many years ago, and agreed to visit here.' The Venerable Elder said, 'You can invite him out after the meal, there are no seats here.' After the meal, Faben escorted him to the three gates to bid farewell. Soon after, the sky and earth became dark, and he did not know where to go. This body was still beside the stone pillar. Thus, the sacred grounds are all maintained by Arhats (Sanskrit, meaning one who has extinguished all afflictions and attained liberation), and cannot be spied upon by ordinary people. Why doubt the Five Pure Abodes? Although they cannot be seen, they still have form and substance, so they are generally called **.",
    
    "Furthermore, Ananda (Sanskrit, one of the Buddha's ten great disciples). From the summit of the realm of form, there are two divergent paths. If one develops wisdom from the mind of equanimity (Sanskrit, the mind that treats all beings equally), and the light of wisdom is perfectly clear and penetrating, then one can transcend the world of dust, become an Arhat, and enter the Bodhisattva path. Such a type of person is called a Great Arhat who has turned his mind. If, in the mind of equanimity, the accomplishment of abandoning aversion is achieved, and one feels the body is an obstacle, dissolving the obstacle and entering emptiness. Such a type of person is called the Realm of Emptiness. Since all obstacles have been eliminated, there is neither obstacle nor elimination, and only the Alaya consciousness (Sanskrit, the eighth consciousness, containing all seeds) remains within. It is entirely a subtle state of half of the Manas consciousness (Sanskrit, the seventh consciousness, clinging to self). Such a type of person is called the Realm of Consciousness. Since emptiness and form have vanished, the mind of consciousness is completely extinguished, the ten directions are silent, and there is nowhere to go. Such a type of person is called the Realm of Nothingness. The nature of consciousness is unmoving, and one exhaustively investigates with extinction."
  ]
}

。于無盡中。發宣儘性。如存不存。若盡非盡。如是一類。名為非想非非想處。此等窮空。不盡空理。從不還天。聖道窮者。如是一類。名不迴心鈍阿羅漢。若從無想諸外道天。窮空不歸。迷漏無聞。便入輪轉。阿難。是諸天上。各各天人。則是凡夫業果酬答。答盡入輪。彼之天王。即是菩薩。游三摩提。漸次增進。迴向聖倫所修行路。阿難。是四空天。身心滅盡。定性現前。無業果色。從此逮終。名無色界。此皆不了妙覺明心。積妄發生。妄有三界。中間妄隨七趣沉溺。補特伽羅。(此云數取趣)各從其類。

  通曰。四無色天。定性聲聞所居。若迴心者。回智向悲。濟生利物。不住小果。入菩薩乘。名大阿羅漢。其鈍根者。不能發明智慧。復由定心忻上厭下。厭色依空。入空無邊處。身礙既銷。不依於色矣。無礙之無亦滅。又空無所空矣。身根六識。俱已泯絕。唯留八識全分。七識半分耳。末那七識。原無定位。外緣色空。則依六識。名粗。內緣八識。但內執。無外緣。名細。此厭空依識。名識無邊處。進之識心全半都滅。非真能滅也。但以識心湛不搖處。迥無攸往。便以為本無所有。真性本來無一物。而此識心都滅。亦略相似。然此以生滅為因地心。生滅之心未滅。如急流水。望如恬靜。故不可語于真性無所有處也。識心既滅。識性不動。又復窮研。使不動者亦滅。夫不動周圓。本如來藏妙真如性。本自不生。本自無盡。強於無盡中發宣儘性。其所謂盡者。亦依識滅之而見其盡耳。而性何嘗盡也。故於識性不動。以為存。則非無

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "于無盡之中,發揚宣示窮盡之性,好像存在又好像不存在,若說窮盡卻又並非真的窮盡。像這樣的一類眾生,稱為非想非非想處天(既非有想,又非無想的禪定境界)。這些天人窮盡了空,卻沒有窮盡空的真理。從不還天(不再返回欲界的聖者所居之天)以聖道為究竟的人,像這樣的一類,稱為不迴心鈍根阿羅漢。如果從無想天的各種外道天界,窮盡了空而不迴歸正道,迷惑于有漏之法而沒有聽聞佛法,便會進入輪迴。阿難,這些天上,各個天界的天人,都是凡夫酬償業報的結果,業報酬償完畢就進入輪迴。那些天王,實際上是菩薩,在三摩提(禪定)中游歷,逐漸增進修行,迴向于聖賢所修行的道路。",
    "阿難,這四空天(無色界的四種禪定天:空無邊處天、識無邊處天、無所有處天、非想非非想處天),身心滅盡,定性現前,沒有業果之色。從這裡直到命終,稱為無想報。這些都是因為不瞭解妙覺明心,積累虛妄而產生的。因為虛妄,所以有三界。在三界之中,又隨著七趣(地獄、餓鬼、畜生、人、天、阿修羅、中陰身)沉溺。補特伽羅(此云數取趣,意為不斷經歷生死輪迴的眾生)各自隨其業力而流轉。",
    
    "總的來說,四無色天是定性聲聞(專注于禪定的修行者)所居住的地方。如果能回心轉意,將智慧轉向慈悲,救濟眾生,利益萬物,不執著于小乘的果位,進入菩薩乘,就稱為大阿羅漢。那些鈍根的人,不能開顯智慧,又因為定心而欣慕上界,厭惡地獄,厭離色界而依附於空界,進入空無邊處天。身形的障礙既然消除了,就不再依附於色界了。無礙的『無』也滅除了,又空無所空了。身根和六識,都已經泯滅斷絕,只留下第八識的全分,和第七識的一半分。末那識(第七識)原本就沒有固定的位置,對外緣於色空,就依附於六識,稱為粗。對內緣于第八識,只是內執,沒有外緣,稱為細。這厭惡空而依附於識,稱為識無邊處天。更進一步,識心全部或一半都滅除了,但並非真的能滅除。只是因為識心湛然不動,沒有去處,便以為本來什麼都沒有,真性本來就一無所有。而這識心都滅除了,也略微相似。然而這是以生滅為因地的妄心,生滅之心並沒有滅除,就像湍急的流水,看起來好像平靜一樣。所以不能用真性本無所有的道理來形容它。識心既然滅除了,識性就不動了,又進一步窮究研習,使不動的識性也滅除。這不動周圓的,本來就是如來藏妙真如性,本來就不生,本來就沒有窮盡。強在無盡之中發揚宣示窮盡之性,所謂窮盡,也是依附於識滅而見到的窮盡罷了。而真性又何嘗窮盡呢?所以在識性不動時,以為是存在,那就不是沒有了。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "In the midst of the infinite, they proclaim and exhaust their nature, seeming to exist yet not exist, seemingly exhausted yet not truly exhausted. Beings of this kind are called those in the Realm of Neither Perception Nor Non-Perception (a state of meditative absorption that is neither with nor without perception). These beings exhaust emptiness but do not exhaust the truth of emptiness. Those who, from the Heaven of No Return (a heaven inhabited by non-returners, those who will not be reborn in the desire realm), reach the ultimate of the holy path, are called Arhats with dull faculties who do not turn their minds towards the Bodhisattva path. If, from the various heretical heavens of the Realm of No Thought, they exhaust emptiness without returning to the right path, deluded by the defiled dharmas and without hearing the Buddha's teachings, they will enter the cycle of rebirth. Ananda, the beings in each of these heavens are ordinary people repaying the results of their karma, and when their karmic retribution is complete, they enter the cycle of rebirth. The kings of those heavens are actually Bodhisattvas, traveling in Samadhi (meditative absorption), gradually increasing their practice, and dedicating themselves to the path of cultivation followed by the sages.",
    "Ananda, in these Four Heavens of Emptiness (the four formless realms: the Realm of the Limitless Space, the Realm of Limitless Consciousness, the Realm of No-Thingness, and the Realm of Neither Perception Nor Non-Perception), body and mind are extinguished, the nature of samadhi manifests, and there is no color resulting from karmic retribution. From here until the end of their lives, they are called those with the reward of no thought. All of this arises from not understanding the wondrously enlightened and bright mind, and accumulating delusion. Because of delusion, there are the Three Realms. Within the Three Realms, they sink into the Seven Destinies (hell-beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras, intermediate beings, and devas). Pudgalas (those who undergo repeated rebirths) each flow according to their karma.",
    
    "In general, the Four Formless Heavens are where those who are fixed in their meditative nature reside. If they can turn their minds, turning wisdom towards compassion, saving beings, and benefiting all things, not clinging to the fruits of the Hinayana, and entering the Bodhisattva path, they are called Great Arhats. Those with dull faculties cannot develop wisdom, and because of their meditative mind, they admire the higher realms and detest the lower realms, detesting the Form Realm and relying on the Realm of Limitless Space, entering the Heaven of Limitless Space. Since the obstruction of the physical form is eliminated, they no longer rely on the Form Realm. The 'no' of no obstruction is also eliminated, and there is nothing to be emptied. The physical roots and the six consciousnesses have all been extinguished, leaving only the full portion of the eighth consciousness and half of the seventh consciousness. The Manas consciousness (seventh consciousness) originally has no fixed position; externally, it is conditioned by form and emptiness, and relies on the six consciousnesses, which is called coarse. Internally, it is conditioned by the eighth consciousness, and is only internal clinging, without external conditions, which is called subtle. This detesting emptiness and relying on consciousness is called the Heaven of Limitless Consciousness. Further, the mind of consciousness is completely or partially extinguished, but it is not truly extinguished. It is only because the mind of consciousness is still and unmoving, with nowhere to go, that they think there is originally nothing, and the true nature is originally without a single thing. And this mind of consciousness is all extinguished, which is also slightly similar. However, this is the deluded mind that takes arising and ceasing as its causal ground, and the mind of arising and ceasing has not been extinguished, like a rapid current that appears to be still. Therefore, it cannot be described by the principle that the true nature is originally without anything. Since the mind of consciousness is extinguished, the nature of consciousness does not move, and they further investigate and study, causing the unmoving nature of consciousness to also be extinguished. This unmoving and all-encompassing nature is originally the wondrously true and suchness nature of the Tathagatagarbha, which is originally unborn and originally without end. Forcibly proclaiming and exhausting the nature in the midst of the endless, the so-called exhaustion is only seen as exhausted by relying on the extinction of consciousness. But how can the true nature ever be exhausted? Therefore, when the nature of consciousness is unmoving, if it is thought to exist, then it is not non-existent."
  ]
}

想。而心慮灰凝。又似不存。則非想也。以為盡則非想。而細微流注不息。又似非盡。則非非想也。此非想非非想。半依不生不滅。半依生滅。正是識陰區宇。為識所覆。但于念想間揣摩。非真能見性者也。生此天者。八萬劫無想。劫滿則復有想。此等窮空。不盡真空妙理。不悟空生於大覺故也。雖從五不還天聖道而窮。不明真性性覺真空性空真覺之旨。不入菩薩乘。終名不迴心鈍阿羅漢。此根雖鈍。尚有迴心之期。豈若外道從無想天迷有為漏。自謂無漏。報盡便入輪轉哉。即四空天不免輪轉。而欲界色界。俱是業果酬答。答盡入輪。又何疑也。唯諸天王。乃是諸地菩薩分身應化。遊戲於三摩提之外。權示漸次。迴向聖倫。亦漸增漸進修行之路也。是四空天。身心滅盡。定性現前。雖無業果色。猶有定果色存。從此逮終。並定果色而無之。非了悟妙覺明心。超出三界。不足以語此。不能了此。不超三界。妄隨七趣。展轉沉溺。皆由積妄所致。欲界妄見欲。色界妄見凈。無色界妄見空。妄有三界。各耽其趣。補特伽羅。能取當來諸趣。即中有也。涅槃云。中有五陰。非肉眼所見。天眼所見。妄從其類。故逐輪轉。總之識神未化乃至於此。若能轉識成智。自無此累。昔地藏問修山主甚處來。修云。南方來。藏云。南方近日佛法如何。修云。商量浩浩地。藏云。爭如我這裡種田博飯吃。修云。爭奈三界何。藏云。你喚甚麼作三界。天童頌云。宗設般般盡強為。流傳口耳便支離。種田博飯家常事。不是飽參人不知。參飽明知無所求。子房終不貴封侯

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本:",
    "想。而心念思慮如同灰燼般凝固,又好像什麼都不存在,這就不是『非想』(既不是有想)。如果認為已經到了盡頭,那也不是『非想』,因為細微的念頭流動並沒有停止,又好像沒有完全窮盡,這就是『非非想』(不是沒有想)。這『非想非非想』,一半依靠不生不滅的真如自性,一半依靠生滅的妄想。這正是識陰所覆蓋的區域,被妄識所矇蔽。只是在念頭和想法之間揣測,不是真正能夠見到自性的人。生到這種天界的人,有八萬劫的時間處於無想狀態,劫數滿了之後又會重新產生念想。這些人窮盡了虛空,卻沒有窮盡真空妙理,不明白萬法皆由大覺真心所生。雖然從五不還天(Anāgāmi-deva,不再返回欲界的聖者所居之天)的聖道而達到這種境界,卻不明白真性本覺真空、性空真覺的宗旨,不進入菩薩乘,最終只能被稱為不迴心的愚鈍阿羅漢。這種根器雖然愚鈍,尚有回心轉意的機會,哪裡像那些外道,從無想天(Asaññasatta,無想有情天)墮落到有為的煩惱之中,自以為已經沒有煩惱,報盡之後便進入輪迴呢?即使是四空天(Arūpāyatana,無色界四天)也無法避免輪迴,而欲界(Kāmadhātu,眾生有情慾樂之界)**,都是業果的酬償,酬償完畢就進入輪迴,這還有什麼可懷疑的呢?只有諸天王,才是諸地菩薩(Bodhisattva,為救度眾生而發願成佛之人)分身應化,在三摩提(Samādhi,禪定)之外遊戲人間,權且示現漸修的次第,迴向于聖賢的行列,也是逐漸增長和進步的修行之路。這四空天,身心滅盡,定性現前,雖然沒有業果之色,但還有定果之色存在。從進入四空天到最終,連定果之色也消失了。如果不能了悟妙覺明心,超出三界(Trailokya,欲界、色界、無色界),就不足以談論這個境界。不能了悟這個道理,就不能超出三界,只能隨著七趣(Gati,六道輪迴加上阿修羅道)妄動,輾轉沉溺,這都是由積累的虛妄所導致的。欲界妄見欲,**妄見清凈,無**妄見空,虛妄地認為有三界,各自沉溺於自己的境界之中。補特伽羅(Pudgala,意為『人』或『補特伽羅』,一種流轉于輪迴中的實體),能夠攝取當來的諸趣,也就是中陰身(Antarābhava,死亡到投生之間的過渡狀態)。《涅槃經》說,中陰身具有五陰(Pañca-khandha,色、受、想、行、識),不是肉眼所能看見的,而是天眼所能看見的,妄念會追隨同類的眾生,所以會逐于輪迴。總之,識神沒有轉化,才會導致這樣的結果。如果能夠轉識成智(Jñāna,智慧),自然就沒有這樣的累贅了。從前地藏菩薩(Kṣitigarbha,地獄不空誓不成佛的菩薩)問修山主從哪裡來,修山主說:『從南方來。』地藏菩薩問:『南方近日佛法如何?』修山主說:『商量浩浩地。』地藏菩薩說:『爭如我這裡種田博飯吃。』修山主說:『爭奈三界何?』地藏菩薩問:『你喚甚麼作三界?』天童禪師作頌說:『宗門設施般般儘是勉強,流傳口耳之間便會支離破碎。種田吃飯是家常便飯的事,不是真正參透的人不會知道。參透了明瞭知道無所求,張良最終也不會看重封侯。』",
    "**原文有缺失,無法確定具體內容"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version:",
    "Thought. But the mind's considerations are like ashes, solidified, and it seems as if nothing exists. This is not 'neither thought nor non-thought' (Naiva-saṃjñā-nāsaṃjñāyatana, neither perception nor non-perception). If one thinks it's the end, it's not 'neither thought nor non-thought' because the subtle flow of thoughts hasn't stopped; it seems not fully exhausted. This is 'neither thought nor non-non-thought.' It partly relies on the unarisen and unceasing true nature, and partly on arising and ceasing delusions. This is precisely the realm covered by the ālaya-vijñāna (storehouse consciousness), obscured by delusional consciousness. It's merely speculating between thoughts and ideas, not truly seeing one's nature. Those born in this heaven experience eighty thousand kalpas (aeon) of non-thought. When the kalpa is over, thoughts arise again. These beings exhaust emptiness but don't exhaust the wonderful principle of true emptiness, not understanding that all dharmas arise from the Great Enlightenment. Although they reach this state through the holy path of the Anāgāmi-deva (non-returner heaven), they don't understand the true nature of inherent enlightenment, the true emptiness of nature, and the true awareness of emptiness. They don't enter the Bodhisattva (Bodhisattva, one who vows to save all beings and become a Buddha) path and are ultimately called dull Arhats (Arhat, one who has attained enlightenment) who don't turn their minds. Although their faculties are dull, there's still a chance for them to turn their minds, unlike those heretics who fall from the Asaññasatta (non-perceptual heaven) into conditioned afflictions, thinking they're free from afflictions. When their reward is exhausted, they enter the cycle of rebirth. Even the Arūpāyatana (four formless realms) can't avoid rebirth, and the Kāmadhātu (desire realm)** is all about repaying karmic debts. Once the debts are repaid, they enter the cycle again. What doubt is there? Only the kings of the heavens are manifestations of Bodhisattvas from various lands, playing outside of Samādhi (meditative absorption), expediently showing gradual stages, dedicating themselves to the assembly of sages, and gradually increasing and progressing on the path of cultivation. In these four formless heavens, body and mind are extinguished, and the nature of concentration manifests. Although there's no karmic color, there's still the color of the fruit of concentration. From entering these heavens until the end, even the color of the fruit of concentration disappears. If one doesn't realize the wonderful, enlightened, and clear mind and transcend the Trailokya (three realms: desire, form, and formless), it's not enough to talk about this state. Not understanding this principle, one can't transcend the three realms and follows the seven Gati (paths of rebirth, including the six realms and the Asura realm) in delusion, sinking and drowning, all caused by accumulated delusions. The desire realm falsely sees desire, ** falsely sees purity, and the formless realm falsely sees emptiness, falsely believing there are three realms, each indulging in its own realm. Pudgala (individual), can take on future realms, which is the Antarābhava (intermediate state between death and rebirth). The Nirvana Sutra says that the Antarābhava has the Pañca-khandha (five aggregates: form, feeling, perception, mental formations, and consciousness), not seen by the physical eye but seen by the heavenly eye. Delusions follow their own kind, so they pursue rebirth. In short, if the consciousness hasn't been transformed, this is the result. If one can transform consciousness into Jñāna (wisdom), there will naturally be no such burden. In the past, Kṣitigarbha (Bodhisattva who vows not to become a Buddha until hell is empty) asked Master Xiu from which mountain he came. Master Xiu said, 'From the South.' Kṣitigarbha asked, 'How is the Dharma in the South these days?' Master Xiu said, 'There's much discussion.' Kṣitigarbha said, 'How does it compare to me tilling the fields here to earn a living?' Master Xiu said, 'What about the three realms?' Kṣitigarbha asked, 'What do you call the three realms?' Chan Master Tiantong composed a verse: 'The establishment of the school is all forced, spreading through words and ears becomes fragmented. Tilling the fields and eating is an ordinary thing, those who haven't truly penetrated won't know. Those who have penetrated clearly know there's nothing to seek, Zhang Liang ultimately didn't value being ennobled.'",
    "**Original text is missing, unable to determine the specific content"
  ]
}

。忘機歸去同魚鳥。濯足滄浪煙水秋。又翠巖真示眾云。不見一法。是大過患。山河大地。日月星辰。色空明暗。不是一法。拈起拄杖云。凡夫見拄杖。喚作拄杖。聲聞人見拄杖。認得頑空。撥無拄杖。菩薩人見拄杖。幾曾掛著齒牙。饑來吃飯。困來打睡。寒來向火。熱則取涼。不見道一切智智清凈。恁么說話。笑破土地鼻孔。此正與種田博飯吃一般清味。是超出三界底樣子。

  複次阿難。是三界中。復有四種阿修羅類。若於鬼道。以護法力。乘通入空。此阿修羅。從卵而生。鬼趣所攝。若於天中降德貶墜。其所卜居。鄰于日月。此阿修羅。從胎而出。人趣所攝。有修羅王。執持世界。力洞無畏。能與梵王及天帝釋四天爭權。此阿修羅。因變化有。天趣所攝。阿難。別有一分下劣修羅。生大海心。沉水穴口。旦游虛空。暮歸水宿。此阿修羅。因濕氣有。畜生趣攝。

  通曰。阿修羅福力等天。而無天行。故云非天。十地經曰。阿修羅有五類。一極弱者。住人間山林。西方山大深窟。有非天之宮。二妙高山北。大海之下。二萬一千由旬。有羅睺之宮。手能掩日月者也。三又下二萬一千由旬。有勇健之宮。此嗔不飲酒者也。四又下二萬一千由旬。有華鬘之宮。此女極美而男惡者也。五又下二萬一千由旬。有毗摩質多羅之宮。此云凈心。能波海出聲。帝釋之姻家也。長阿含云。修羅一日一夜。三次受苦。苦具自來。入其宮中。是知此趣。一分善報。謂之人天。若論受苦。實在人趣之下。故正法念經。唯以鬼畜二種收之。此經以胎卵濕化

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本:",
    "『忘卻機心,歸隱山林,與魚鳥為伴。在滄浪之水濯足,感受煙波浩渺的秋意。』",
    "翠巖禪師又開示大眾說:『不見一法,這是最大的過患。山河大地,日月星辰,色空明暗,都不是一法。』",
    "他拈起拄杖說:『凡夫看見拄杖,就叫它拄杖。聲聞人看見拄杖,就只認得頑空,否定拄杖的存在。菩薩看見拄杖,又何曾執著于言語概念?餓了就吃飯,困了就睡覺,冷了就烤火,熱了就取涼。難道沒聽說過一切智智清凈的道理嗎?』",
    "這樣說話,笑破了土地神的鼻孔。這正是與種田吃飯一樣平淡的滋味,是超出三界的樣子。",
    
    "阿難,三界之中,又有四種阿修羅(Asura,意為非天)的種類。如果鬼道的眾生,憑藉護法的力量,通過神通進入空界,這種阿修羅是從卵而生的,屬於鬼道所管轄。",
    "如果天界的眾生,因為失去德行而被貶謫,他們所居住的地方,靠近日月,這種阿修羅是從胎而出的,屬於人道所管轄。",
    "有阿修羅王,執掌世界,力量強大,無所畏懼,能夠與梵王(Brahmā)以及天帝釋(Śakra,也稱帝釋天)和四天王爭奪權力,這種阿修羅是因變化而生的,屬於天道所管轄。",
    "阿難,還有一部分下劣的阿修羅,生存在大海深處,沉溺於水中嬉戲,早晨在空中游蕩,晚上回到水中棲息,這種阿修羅是因濕氣而生的,屬於畜生道所管轄。",
    
    "通曰:《十地經》說,阿修羅有五類。一極弱者,住人間山林,西方山大深窟,有非天之宮。二妙高山北,大海之下,二萬一千由旬,有羅睺(Rāhu)之宮,手能掩日月者也。三又下二萬一千由旬,有勇健之宮,此嗔不飲酒者也。四又下二萬一千由旬,有華鬘之宮,此女極美而男惡者也。五又下二萬一千由旬,有毗摩質多羅(Vemacitrin)之宮,此云凈心,能波海出聲,帝釋之姻家也。",
    "《長阿含經》云,修羅一日一夜,三次受苦,苦具自來,入其宮中。是知此趣,一分善報,謂之人天。若論受苦,實在人趣之下。故《正法念經》,唯以鬼畜二種收之。此經以胎卵濕化"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version:",
    "'Forgetting scheming thoughts, returning to the mountains and forests, becoming companions with fish and birds. Washing feet in the Canglang River, feeling the misty autumn scenery.'",
    "Zen Master Cuiyan further instructed the assembly, saying: 'Not seeing a single dharma is the greatest fault. Mountains, rivers, the great earth, the sun, moon, and stars, form and emptiness, light and darkness, none of these is a single dharma.'",
    "He raised his staff and said: 'Ordinary people see the staff and call it a staff. Śrāvakas (聲聞人, Hearers) see the staff and only recognize inert emptiness, denying the existence of the staff. Bodhisattvas see the staff, but have they ever clung to verbal concepts? When hungry, they eat; when sleepy, they sleep; when cold, they warm themselves by the fire; when hot, they seek coolness. Haven't you heard of the principle of the purity of all-knowing wisdom?'",
    "Speaking like this, he broke the earth deity's nose with laughter. This is precisely the same plain flavor as farming and eating, a state beyond the Three Realms.",
    
    "Furthermore, Ānanda, within the Three Realms, there are four kinds of Asuras (阿修羅, non-gods). If beings in the realm of ghosts, relying on the power of Dharma protection, enter the realm of emptiness through supernatural powers, these Asuras are born from eggs and are governed by the realm of ghosts.",
    "If beings in the realm of gods are demoted due to loss of virtue, their dwellings are near the sun and moon. These Asuras are born from wombs and are governed by the realm of humans.",
    "There are Asura kings who hold the world, possessing great power and fearlessness, capable of contending for power with Brahmā (梵王) and Śakra (天帝釋, also known as Indra) and the Four Heavenly Kings. These Asuras are born from transformation and are governed by the realm of gods.",
    "Ānanda, there is also a portion of inferior Asuras who live in the depths of the great ocean, indulging in water play, wandering in the sky in the morning, and returning to the water to rest in the evening. These Asuras are born from moisture and are governed by the realm of animals.",
    
    "Commentary: The *Ten Stages Sutra* says that there are five types of Asuras. The weakest live in the mountains and forests of the human realm, in large, deep caves in the western mountains, where there are palaces of non-gods. The second type lives north of Mount Sumeru, 21,000 yojanas below the great ocean, where there is the palace of Rāhu (羅睺), who can cover the sun and moon with his hand. The third type lives another 21,000 yojanas below, where there is the palace of the courageous and strong, who are angry and do not drink alcohol. The fourth type lives another 21,000 yojanas below, where there is the palace of garlands, where the women are extremely beautiful but the men are ugly. The fifth type lives another 21,000 yojanas below, where there is the palace of Vemacitrin (毗摩質多羅), which means 'pure mind,' who can make the ocean roar and is related to Śakra by marriage.",
    "The *Long Āgama Sutra* says that Asuras suffer three times a day and night, with the instruments of suffering coming of their own accord into their palaces. It is known that this realm has a portion of good rewards, which are called human and heavenly. In terms of suffering, it is actually below the human realm. Therefore, the *Sutra on the Establishment of Right Mindfulness* only includes them in the realms of ghosts and animals. This sutra uses birth from wombs, eggs, moisture, and transformation."
  ]
}

及天人鬼畜四種。曲盡修羅之情狀。大略與十地經符。青林虔禪師上堂。祖師門下。鳥道玄微。功窮皆轉。不窮難明。汝等諸人。直須離心意識參。出凡聖路學。方可保任。若不如是。非吾子息。僧問久負不逢時如何。曰古皇尺一寸。問請師答話。曰修羅掌于日月。又僧問佛海禪師。即心即佛時如何。曰頂分丫角。曰非心非佛時如何。曰耳墜金環。曰不是心。不是佛。不是物。又作么生。師曰。禿頂修羅舞柘枝。恁般說話。非出凡聖路學。離心意識參。固莫測其涯涘。

  阿難。如是地獄餓鬼畜生。人及神仙。天洎修羅。精研七趣。皆是昏沉諸有為相。妄想受生。妄想隨業。于妙圓明無作本心皆如空華。元無所著。但一虛妄。更無根緒。阿難。此等眾生。不識本心。受此輪迴。經無量劫。不得真凈。皆由隨順殺盜淫故。反此三種。又則出生無殺盜淫。有名鬼倫。無名天趣。有無相傾。起輪迴性。若得妙發三摩提者。則妙常寂。有無二無。無二亦滅。尚無不殺不偷不淫。云何更隨殺盜淫事。阿難。不斷三業。各各有私。因各各私。眾私同分。非無定處。自妄發生。生妄無因。無可尋究。汝勖修行。欲得菩提。要除三惑。不盡三惑。縱得神通。皆是世間有為功用。習氣不滅。落於魔道。雖欲除妄。倍加虛偽。如來說為可哀憐者。汝妄自造。非菩提咎。作是說者。名為正說。若他說者。即魔王說。

  通曰。前阿難問妙心遍圓。云何復有地獄餓鬼畜生修羅人天等道。為有定處。為復自然彼彼發業。各各私受。為複本來自有。為是眾生妄習

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "以及天、人、鬼、畜生四種生命形態,詳盡地描述了修羅(Asura,意為非天、阿修羅)的情狀,大體上與《十地經》(Daśabhūmika Sūtra)相符。青林虔禪師上堂說法:祖師門下的教法,如鳥道般玄妙精微,功夫到了極點都會轉變,不到極點難以明白。你們這些人,必須離開心意識去參悟,超出凡聖之路去學習,才可以保任(保持和承擔)。如果不是這樣,就不是我的子孫。有僧人問:『長久以來懷才不遇,時機不來,該怎麼辦?』禪師說:『古皇(古代聖皇)的尺度是一寸。』又問:『請老師回答。』禪師說:『修羅掌握著日月。』又有僧人問佛海禪師:『即心即佛(即心是佛)時如何?』禪師說:『頭頂分出丫角。』問:『非心非佛(非心非佛)時如何?』禪師說:『耳朵上墜著金環。』問:『不是心,不是佛,不是物,又該如何?』禪師說:『禿頂修羅跳柘枝舞。』像這樣說話,不是超出凡聖之路去學習,離開心意識去參悟,確實無法測度其邊際。",
    
    "阿難(Ānanda,佛陀十大弟子之一)。像這樣地獄、餓鬼、畜生、人以及神仙、天人乃至修羅,精細地研究這七種生命形態,都是昏沉的、有為的表象,由虛妄的念頭而受生,虛妄的念頭隨著業力而流轉。對於妙圓明、無作的本心來說,都像空中的花朵一樣,原本沒有依附之處,只是一種虛妄,更沒有根源頭緒。阿難,這些眾生,不認識本心,所以承受這樣的輪迴,經過無量劫,都不能得到真正的清凈,都是由於隨順殺、盜、淫的緣故。反過來,如果能夠遠離這三種行為,就會出生於沒有殺、盜、淫的地方,這些地方可以稱為鬼倫(鬼道眾生),沒有名稱的則屬於天趣(天道眾生)。有和無相互傾軋,產生了輪迴的本性。如果能夠得到妙發三摩提(Samādhi,意為正定)的人,就會達到妙常寂的狀態,有和無兩種對立都不存在,沒有了二元對立,二元對立的觀念也會消失。尚且沒有不殺、不偷、不淫,又怎麼會隨順殺、盜、淫的事情呢?阿難,不斷除殺、盜、淫這三種業,每個人都有各自的私慾,因為各自的私慾,眾人的私慾就有了共同的部分,並非沒有一定的處所,而是從虛妄中產生,產生虛妄沒有原因,無法尋究。你要努力修行,想要得到菩提(Bodhi,意為覺悟),就要去除貪、嗔、癡這三種迷惑。如果不能完全去除這三種迷惑,即使得到了神通,也都是世間有為的功用,習氣不能滅除,就會墮落到魔道。雖然想要去除虛妄,反而更加虛偽。如來說這是最可憐憫的。這是你虛妄地自己造作的,不是菩提的過錯。這樣說,才是正確的說法。如果別人說其他的,那就是魔王說的。",
    
    "通曰:前面阿難問妙心遍滿周圓,為什麼還會有地獄、餓鬼、畜生、修羅、人、天等道?這些道是有固定的處所,還是自然而然地各自發起業力,各自承受果報?是本來就有的,還是眾生的虛妄習氣所致?"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "as well as the four forms of existence: gods, humans, ghosts, and animals. It exhaustively describes the conditions of the Asuras (non-gods, titans), roughly corresponding to the Daśabhūmika Sūtra (Ten Stages Sutra). Chan Master Qinglin Qian gave a Dharma talk, saying: The teachings of the Patriarch's lineage are as mysterious and subtle as a bird's path; when the effort reaches its limit, it transforms; it is difficult to understand if it does not reach its limit. All of you must investigate by separating from the mind-consciousness, and learn by transcending the path of the mundane and the sacred, only then can you maintain and uphold it. If it is not so, you are not my descendants. A monk asked: 'What if one has been burdened for a long time and the time has not come?' The Master said: 'The ancient emperor's measure is one inch.' He asked again: 'Please, Master, answer.' The Master said: 'The Asura holds the sun and moon in his palm.' Another monk asked Chan Master Fohai: 'What is it like when 'mind is Buddha' (即心即佛)?' The Master said: 'The top of the head is split into forked horns.' He asked: 'What is it like when 'neither mind nor Buddha' (非心非佛)?' The Master said: 'Golden rings hang from the ears.' He asked: 'It is neither mind, nor Buddha, nor thing, then what is it?' The Master said: 'A bald-headed Asura dances the Zhe Zhi dance.' Such talk is not learning by transcending the path of the mundane and the sacred, nor is it investigating by separating from the mind-consciousness; indeed, its boundaries are unfathomable.",
    
    "Ānanda (one of the Buddha's ten great disciples), these hells, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, as well as gods, celestial beings, and even Asuras, meticulously studying these seven realms of existence, are all deluded, conditioned phenomena, born from illusory thoughts, with illusory thoughts following the flow of karma. In relation to the wondrously perfect, enlightened, uncreated original mind, they are all like flowers in the sky, originally without any attachment, merely an illusion, and without any root or origin. Ānanda, these beings do not recognize their original mind, and therefore endure this cycle of rebirth, through countless kalpas, unable to attain true purity, all because they follow killing, stealing, and sexual misconduct. Conversely, if one can refrain from these three actions, one will be born in places without killing, stealing, and sexual misconduct; these places can be called the realm of ghosts (鬼倫), and those without names belong to the realm of gods (天趣). Existence and non-existence encroach upon each other, giving rise to the nature of reincarnation. If one can attain the wondrous arising of Samādhi (concentration), one will reach the state of wondrous constant stillness, where the duality of existence and non-existence does not exist, and when duality is gone, the very notion of duality also disappears. There is not even non-killing, non-stealing, and non-sexual misconduct, so how could one follow the affairs of killing, stealing, and sexual misconduct? Ānanda, without ceasing the three karmas of killing, stealing, and sexual misconduct, each person has their own private desires; because of each person's private desires, the private desires of all have a common part, and it is not without a definite place, but arises from delusion, and the arising of delusion has no cause, and cannot be investigated. You must strive to cultivate, and if you want to attain Bodhi (enlightenment), you must remove the three poisons of greed, hatred, and delusion. If you cannot completely remove these three poisons, even if you attain supernatural powers, they are all worldly conditioned functions, and if habitual tendencies are not extinguished, you will fall into the demonic path. Although you want to remove delusion, you become even more false. The Tathagata (如來, Buddha) says that this is most pitiable. This is what you falsely create yourself, not the fault of Bodhi. To say this is the correct teaching. If others say otherwise, that is what the demon king says.",
    
    "Tong said: Earlier, Ānanda asked why, if the wondrous mind is all-pervading and complete, there are still realms of hell, hungry ghosts, animals, Asuras, humans, and gods? Are these realms in fixed locations, or do they naturally arise from each individual's karma, with each individually receiving the consequences? Are they originally existent, or are they due to the illusory habits of sentient beings?"
  ]
}

生起。故此總答七趣昏沉。皆有為相。于妙圓明無作本心。元無所有。如空中華。于太虛空有何干涉。非本來自有也。但由妄想受生。妄想隨業。所謂妄習生起者是也。既有妄習。即有妄果。彼彼發業。各各私受。則非無定處也。自妄發生。惑為妄因。妄為業因。非為自然也。生妄無因。無可尋究。本自常寂也。由殺盜淫三為根本。隨順殺盜淫業。是妄見有。有必淪墮四惡趣。而鬼倫其最下者也。不隨順三者而力反之。是妄見無。無必出生三善趣。而天趣其最上者也。善惡雖殊途。而有無相傾。故三界輪迴。無有休息。皆人為所致。非菩提咎。若得妙發三摩提者。識自本心。得其真凈。謂之曰妙。不離三界。頓超三界。彼于寂常正定之中。無有無二相可得。已除俗諦之妄。無二之無亦滅。復除涅槃之真。根本無明。銷镕淨盡。惑從何起。妄從何生。尚無于善。況隨於惡。此猶眼本無翳。而空華無自有也。三惑諸經多指見思惑。塵沙惑。無明惑。見思亦名通惑。三乘共斷故也。塵沙名別惑。菩薩所斷。無明乃業識之種子。唯大乘菩薩方斷此惑。不除捏目。雖欲除華。倍加虛偽。縱得神通。亦落魔道。魔道不除殺盜淫而修邪定者也。故欲得無上菩提者。應除三惑。盪滌習氣。三惑既無。安有三界。若不知此說者。謂菩提本空。安事除惑。即魔說也。有一俗士問西堂藏禪師云。有天堂地獄否。藏云有。云有佛法僧寶否。藏云有。更有多問。盡答言有。士云。和尚恁么道。莫錯否。藏云。汝曾見尊宿來耶。云某甲曾參徑山和尚來。藏云。徑山向汝作

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "生起。因此總的回答七趣(地獄、餓鬼、畜生、阿修羅、人、天、聲聞緣覺)的昏沉狀態,都是有為的現象。在妙圓明、無作本心的狀態下,原本什麼都沒有。就像空中的花朵,對於太虛空有什麼影響呢?它不是本來就有的。只是由於妄想才產生,妄想跟隨業力。這就是所謂的妄習生起。既然有妄習,就有妄果。各自發起業力,各自承受果報,所以並非沒有固定的去處。自己產生妄念,迷惑地認為妄念是原因,妄念又成為業力的原因,而不是自然而然的。產生妄念沒有原因,無可追尋,本來就是常寂的。由於殺、盜、淫這三者為根本,隨順殺、盜、淫的業力,是妄見為有。有,就必定會墮入四惡趣(地獄、餓鬼、畜生、阿修羅),而鬼道是其中最下等的。不隨順這三者,反而努力與之對抗,是妄見為無。無,就必定會出生於三善趣(天、人、阿修羅),而天道是其中最上等的。善惡雖然道路不同,但有和無相互傾軋,所以三界輪迴,沒有停止的時候。這都是人為造成的,不是菩提的過錯。如果能夠妙發三摩提(正定),認識自己的本心,得到它的真凈,這就叫做妙。不離開三界,卻能頓超三界。在這種寂常正定之中,沒有有和無這兩種對立的相可以得到。已經除去了俗諦(世俗的真理)的虛妄,無二的『無』也消滅了。再除去涅槃(寂滅)的『真』,根本的無明,消融乾淨。迷惑從哪裡產生?妄念從哪裡生起?尚且沒有善,更何況隨順惡?這就像眼睛本來沒有翳障,而空中的花朵不是自己產生的。三惑,諸經多指見思惑、塵沙惑、無明惑。見思惑也叫通惑,是聲聞、緣覺、菩薩三乘共同斷除的。塵沙惑名叫別惑,是菩薩所斷除的。無明是業識的種子,只有大乘菩薩才能斷除這種迷惑。不除去捏著眼睛的行為,即使想要除去空中的花朵,也會更加虛偽。縱然得到神通,也會落入魔道。魔道是指不除去殺、盜、淫而修習邪定的人。所以想要得到無上菩提,就應該除去三惑,盪滌習氣。三惑既然沒有了,哪裡還有三界?如果不知道這種說法,認為菩提本性是空的,哪裡需要除惑,這就是魔的說法。有一個俗人問西堂藏禪師說:『有天堂地獄嗎?』藏禪師說:『有。』又問:『有佛法僧三寶嗎?』藏禪師說:『有。』再問了很多問題,都回答說『有』。這人說:『和尚您這麼說,難道沒錯嗎?』藏禪師說:『你曾經見過其他尊宿嗎?』這人說:『我曾經參拜過徑山和尚。』藏禪師說:『徑山和尚怎麼對你說的?』",
    "English version",
    "Arising. Therefore, this comprehensively answers the dullness of the seven realms (hell, hungry ghosts, animals, asuras, humans, gods, and sravakas and pratyekabuddhas), all of which are conditioned phenomena. In the state of wondrously perfect enlightenment and the original mind of non-action, there is originally nothing. It is like a flower in the sky, what impact does it have on the great void? It is not originally existent. It only arises due to delusion, and delusion follows karma. This is what is meant by the arising of deluded habits. Since there are deluded habits, there are deluded consequences. Each initiates karma, and each individually receives the retribution, so it is not without a fixed destination. One's own delusion arises, mistakenly believing that delusion is the cause, and delusion becomes the cause of karma, not naturally. The arising of delusion has no cause, and cannot be traced back; it is originally eternally still. Because of the three roots of killing, stealing, and sexual misconduct, following the karma of killing, stealing, and sexual misconduct is a deluded view of existence. Existence inevitably leads to falling into the four evil realms (hell, hungry ghosts, animals, and asuras), with the ghost realm being the lowest. Not following these three, but instead striving to counteract them, is a deluded view of non-existence. Non-existence inevitably leads to birth in the three good realms (gods, humans, and asuras), with the god realm being the highest. Although good and evil have different paths, existence and non-existence encroach upon each other, so the cycle of the three realms never ceases. All of this is caused by human actions, not the fault of Bodhi (enlightenment). If one can wondrously awaken Samadhi (concentration), recognize one's own original mind, and attain its true purity, this is called wondrous. Without leaving the three realms, one can instantly transcend them. In this state of still, constant, and correct concentration, there is no duality of existence and non-existence to be found. Having removed the delusion of conventional truth, the 'non' of non-duality is also extinguished. Furthermore, removing the 'truth' of Nirvana (liberation), the fundamental ignorance is completely dissolved. Where does delusion arise from? Where does delusion originate? There is not even goodness, let alone following evil? This is like the eyes originally having no cataracts, and the flowers in the sky not arising on their own. The three delusions, in many sutras, refer to the delusions of views and emotions (見思惑, Jian Si Huo), the delusions like dust and sand (塵沙惑, Chen Sha Huo), and the delusions of ignorance (無明惑, Wu Ming Huo). The delusions of views and emotions are also called common delusions, because they are jointly severed by the three vehicles (聲聞乘, Sheng Wen Cheng, 緣覺乘, Yuan Jue Cheng, 菩薩乘, Pu Sa Cheng). The delusions like dust and sand are called separate delusions, which are severed by Bodhisattvas. Ignorance is the seed of karmic consciousness, and only Mahayana (大乘, Da Cheng) Bodhisattvas can sever this delusion. Without removing the act of pinching the eyes, even if one wants to remove the flowers in the sky, it will only become more false. Even if one attains supernatural powers, one will fall into the demonic path. The demonic path refers to those who cultivate deviant concentration without removing killing, stealing, and sexual misconduct. Therefore, if one wants to attain unsurpassed Bodhi, one should remove the three delusions and cleanse away habitual tendencies. Since the three delusions are gone, where are the three realms? If one does not understand this teaching, thinking that the nature of Bodhi is empty, and there is no need to remove delusions, this is the teaching of demons. A layman asked Zen Master Xitang Zang, 'Are there heavens and hells?' Zen Master Zang said, 'Yes.' He asked again, 'Are there the Three Jewels of Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha?' Zen Master Zang said, 'Yes.' He asked many more questions, and all were answered with 'Yes.' The layman said, 'Venerable Master, are you not mistaken in saying so?' Zen Master Zang said, 'Have you ever seen other venerable masters?' The layman said, 'I have visited Zen Master Jingshan.' Zen Master Zang said, 'What did Zen Master Jingshan say to you?'"
  ]
}

么生道。云他道一切總無。藏云。汝有妻否。云有。藏云。徑山和尚有妻否。云無。藏云。徑山和尚道無即得。此于尋常語中。指出頓超三界訊息。妙矣。又僧問洞山詮禪師。清凈行者。不上天堂。破戒比丘。不入地獄時如何。詮曰。度盡無遺影。還他越涅槃。丹霞頌云。相好巍巍大丈夫。一生無智恰如愚。從來佛祖猶難望。地獄天堂豈可拘。此可為妙發三摩提者證明。

  即時如來將罷法座。于師子床。攬七寶幾。回紫金山。再來憑倚。普告大眾。及阿難言。汝等有學緣覺聲聞。今日迴心趣大菩提無上妙覺。我今已說真修行法。汝猶未識修奢摩他(此云止)毗婆舍那(此云觀)微細魔事。魔境現前。汝不能識。洗心非正。落於邪見。或汝陰魔。或復天魔。或著鬼神。或遭魑魅。心中不明。認賊為子。又復于中得少為足。如第四禪無聞比丘。妄言證聖。天報已畢。衰相現前。謗阿羅漢身遭後有。墮阿鼻獄。汝應諦聽。吾今為汝子細分別。阿難起立。並其會中同有學者。歡喜頂禮。伏聽慈誨。佛告阿難。及諸大眾。汝等當知有漏世界十二類生。本覺妙明。覺圓心體。與十方佛。無二無別。由汝妄想。迷理為咎。癡愛發生。生髮遍迷。故有空性。化迷不息。有世界生。則此十方微塵國土非無漏者。皆是迷頑妄想安立。當知虛空生汝心內。猶如片云點太清里。況諸世界在虛空耶。汝等一人發真歸元。此十方空。皆悉銷殞。云何空中所有國土而不振裂。汝輩修禪。飾三摩地。十方菩薩及諸無漏大阿羅漢。心精通㳷。當處湛然。一切魔王。及與鬼

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "怎麼說呢?(僧人)說他認為一切都是空無。(藏禪師)問:(你)有妻子嗎?(僧人)說:有。(藏禪師)問:徑山和尚(指徑山宗杲禪師,1089-1163)有妻子嗎?(僧人)說:沒有。(藏禪師)說:徑山和尚說空無就對了。這在尋常的言語中,指出了頓悟超越三界的訊息,真是妙啊!又有僧人問洞山詮禪師(洞山良價,807-869):清凈的修行者,不上天堂;破戒的比丘,不入地獄,這是怎麼回事?洞山詮禪師說:度盡一切,不留痕跡,還他一個超越涅槃的境界。丹霞禪師(丹霞子淳,1064-1117)作頌說:相貌莊嚴,真是大丈夫,一生沒有智慧,恰如愚人。從來佛祖都難以期望,地獄天堂又怎能拘束他?這可以為那些妙發三摩提(Samadhi,意為正定)的人作證明。",
    
    "即時,如來將要離開法座,在師子座上,拿起七寶幾案,轉身面向紫金山,再次憑靠。普告大眾以及阿難(Ananda,佛陀十大弟子之一)說:你們這些有學的緣覺(Pratyekabuddha,又稱獨覺或辟支佛)、聲聞(Sravaka,聽聞佛陀教誨而得解脫者),今日迴心嚮往大菩提(Bodhi,覺悟)無上妙覺。我如今已經說了真正的修行方法,但你們還不認識修習奢摩他(Samatha,意為止),毗婆舍那(Vipassana,意為觀)的微細魔事。魔境現前,你們不能識別,洗滌內心的方法不正,就會落入邪見。或者遇到五陰魔(色、受、想、行、識五種構成人身心的要素所產生的魔障),或者遇到天魔(欲界第六天的魔王),或者著了鬼神,或者遭遇魑魅(古代傳說中的山林精怪),心中不明,認賊為子。又或者在修行中得到少許就自以為滿足,如同第四禪的無聞比丘,妄言自己證得了聖果,天報享盡,衰相顯現,誹謗阿羅漢(Arhat,斷盡煩惱,證得解脫的聖者),身遭後有,墮入阿鼻地獄(Avici,八大地獄中最苦之處)。你們應當仔細聽,我現在為你們詳細分別。阿難起身站立,並且會中所有一同學習的人,歡喜頂禮,恭敬地聽從佛陀的慈悲教誨。佛告訴阿難以及諸位大眾:你們應當知道,有漏世界(指眾生因有煩惱而流轉生死的世間)的十二類眾生,其本覺妙明(本自具有的覺悟光明),覺圓心體(圓滿覺悟的心性),與十方諸佛,沒有絲毫差別。由於你們的妄想,迷惑了真理,這是過錯的根源。由癡愛而生起種種煩惱,煩惱生起而普遍迷惑,所以才有了空性。化解迷惑的念頭不停止,世界才會產生。那麼這十方微塵國土,沒有哪個不是有漏的,都是由迷惑頑固的妄想所安立的。應當知道,虛空生在你們的心內,猶如一片雲彩點綴在清凈的天空中。何況諸多的世界存在於虛空之中呢?你們一個人發起真心,迴歸本源,這十方虛空,都會全部消殞。那麼虛空中所有的國土,怎麼會不震動破裂呢?你們修習禪定,裝飾三摩地(Samadhi,意為正定),十方菩薩以及諸位無漏的大阿羅漢,心精通徹,當下湛然不動。一切魔王以及鬼",
    "English version",
    "What is it? (The monk) said that he thought everything was empty. (Zen Master Zang) asked: Do you have a wife? (The monk) said: Yes. (Zen Master Zang) asked: Does Zen Master Jingshan (referring to Zen Master Zonggao of Jingshan, 1089-1163) have a wife? (The monk) said: No. (Zen Master Zang) said: Zen Master Jingshan is right to say emptiness. This, in ordinary language, points out the news of sudden enlightenment surpassing the three realms, which is wonderful! Another monk asked Zen Master Dongshan Quan (Dongshan Liangjie, 807-869): When a pure practitioner does not go to heaven and a precept-breaking Bhikkhu does not enter hell, what is it like? Quan said: Exhaust everything without leaving a trace, return him a realm beyond Nirvana. Zen Master Danxia (Danxia Zichun, 1064-1117) composed a verse saying: The appearance is dignified, truly a great man, without wisdom in his life, just like a fool. From the beginning, Buddhas and ancestors are difficult to expect, how can hell and heaven restrain him? This can be used as proof for those who wonderfully awaken Samadhi (Samadhi, meaning concentration).",
    
    "Immediately, the Tathagata was about to leave the Dharma seat. On the lion throne, he picked up the seven-treasure table, turned to face Mount Zijin, and leaned on it again. He universally announced to the assembly and Ananda (Ananda, one of the ten major disciples of the Buddha), saying: You who have learned as Pratyekabuddhas (Pratyekabuddha, also known as Solitary Buddha or Paccekabuddha), Sravakas (Sravaka, those who attain liberation by hearing the Buddha's teachings), today turn your hearts towards great Bodhi (Bodhi, enlightenment) and unsurpassed wonderful enlightenment. I have now spoken of the true practice method, but you still do not recognize the subtle demonic affairs of practicing Samatha (Samatha, meaning cessation), Vipassana (Vipassana, meaning insight). When demonic realms appear, you cannot recognize them. If the method of washing your heart is not correct, you will fall into wrong views. Or you may encounter the five skandha demons (the demonic obstacles arising from the five elements that constitute the human body and mind: form, feeling, perception, volition, and consciousness), or you may encounter heavenly demons (the demon king of the sixth heaven of the desire realm), or you may be possessed by ghosts and spirits, or you may encounter goblins (mountain spirits in ancient legends). If your mind is unclear, you will mistake a thief for your son. Or you may be content with obtaining a little in practice, like the unlearned Bhikkhu of the fourth Dhyana, falsely claiming to have attained sainthood. When the heavenly reward is exhausted and the signs of decline appear, he slanders Arhats (Arhat, a saint who has exhausted afflictions and attained liberation), suffers future existence, and falls into Avici Hell (Avici, the most painful of the eight great hells). You should listen carefully, I will now explain it to you in detail. Ananda stood up, and all those who were learning together in the assembly, joyfully prostrated and respectfully listened to the Buddha's compassionate teachings. The Buddha told Ananda and the assembly: You should know that the twelve categories of beings in the world of outflows (referring to the world where beings transmigrate due to afflictions), their original enlightened wonderful brightness, the perfectly enlightened mind-essence, is no different from the Buddhas of the ten directions. Because of your delusions, you are deluded about the truth, which is the root of the fault. From ignorance and love, all kinds of afflictions arise, and afflictions arise and universally delude, so there is emptiness. If the thought of resolving delusion does not stop, the world will be produced. Then none of the dust-mote lands in the ten directions are without outflows, all are established by deluded and stubborn delusions. You should know that the void is born within your mind, like a cloud adorning the pure sky. How much more so are the many worlds existing in the void? If one of you initiates a true mind and returns to the source, this void of the ten directions will all disappear. Then how can the lands in the void not shake and break apart? You practice meditation, adorning Samadhi (Samadhi, meaning concentration), the Bodhisattvas of the ten directions and the great Arhats without outflows, their mind-essence is thoroughly clear, and they are still and unmoving in the present moment. All the demon kings and ghosts"
  ]
}

神諸凡夫天。見其宮殿無故崩裂。大地振坼。水陸飛騰。無不驚懾。凡夫昏昧。不覺遷訛。彼等鹹得五種神通。唯除漏盡。戀此塵勞。如何令汝摧裂其處。是故鬼神及諸天魔魍魎妖精。於三昧時。僉來惱汝。然彼諸魔。雖有大怒。彼塵勞內。汝妙覺中。如風吹光。如刀斷水。了不相觸。汝如沸湯。彼如堅冰。暖氣漸鄰。不日銷殞。徒恃神力。但為其客。成就破亂。由汝心中五陰主人。主人若迷。客得其便。當處禪那。覺悟無惑。則彼魔事。無奈汝何。陰銷入明。則彼群邪。咸受幽氣。明能破暗。近自銷殞。如何敢留擾亂禪定。若不明悟。被陰所迷。則汝阿難。必為魔子。成就魔人。如摩登伽。殊為眇劣。彼唯咒汝。破佛律儀。八萬行中。祗毀一戒。心清凈故。尚未淪溺。此乃隳汝寶覺全身。如宰臣家。忽逢籍沒。宛轉零落。無可哀救。

  通曰。魔即魔羅。此云殺者。亦云奪者。能殺慧命奪善法故。大約五種。曰五陰魔。煩惱魔。生死魔。天魔。鬼魔。合之唯陰魔天魔而已。陰魔即生死煩惱依五陰而起者也。天魔因修邪定。好害正道者也。又無聞比丘。得少為足。謗佛。妄說阿羅漢不受後有。是邪見魔。即陰魔而天魔者也。以謗法故。即墮阿鼻獄。一人發真歸元。十方世界銷殞。一切魔王。諸凡夫天。見其宮殿崩裂。水陸驚懾。便來惱亂禪定。此天魔之為害也淺。彼恃神力。猶為客也。其主在我。故以妙覺而破塵勞。如以湯銷冰。而以明破幽也。主人若迷。客得其便。毀我律儀。隳我寶覺。如宰臣籍沒。而宛轉零落也。此陰魔之為害也

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "諸神、凡夫和天人,看見他們的宮殿無緣無故地崩裂,大地劇烈震動,水陸生物四處飛騰,無不驚恐害怕。凡夫愚昧無知,不覺察到這種變遷。他們雖然都獲得了五種神通(天眼通、天耳通、他心通、宿命通、神足通),唯獨沒有斷盡煩惱,仍然貪戀塵世的享樂。怎麼能讓他們摧毀你修行的處所呢?因此,鬼神以及各種天魔、魍魎妖精,在你入三昧(正定)的時候,都一起來惱亂你。然而,那些魔雖然非常憤怒,但在他們的塵勞境界中,你的妙覺(清凈覺悟的心)就像風吹過光明,像刀砍斷流水,根本無法相互觸及。你就像沸騰的開水,他們就像堅硬的冰塊,溫暖的氣息漸漸靠近,不用多久就會融化消散。他們只是依仗著神通的力量,但終究只是外來的客人,只能造成一些破壞和擾亂,這是因為你心中的五陰(色、受、想、行、識)才是主人。如果主人迷惑了,客人就有了可乘之機。當你在禪定中,覺悟而沒有迷惑,那麼那些魔事就奈何不了你。五陰消散,進入光明,那麼那些邪惡之徒,都會受到幽暗之氣的侵蝕。光明能夠破除黑暗,靠近光明自然就會消散。他們怎麼敢留下來擾亂你的禪定呢?如果不能明白覺悟,被五陰所迷惑,那麼你阿難,必定會成為魔的眷屬,成就魔人,就像摩登伽女(Matangi)那樣,但摩登伽女的情況還算輕微。她只是用咒語迷惑你,破壞佛的戒律,在八萬種修行方法中,僅僅毀壞了一條戒律。因為你的心還算清凈,所以還沒有徹底沉淪。而這(被五陰迷惑)卻是要摧毀你珍貴的覺悟之身,就像宰相的家,突然遭到抄家沒收,徹底衰敗零落,無法挽救。",
    
    "通(一位法師)說:『魔』就是魔羅(Mara),這裡的意思是『殺者』,也可以說是『奪者』,能夠殺死人的智慧生命,奪走人的善良功德。大概有五種魔:五陰魔、煩惱魔、生死魔、天魔、鬼魔。合起來說,只有陰魔和天魔而已。陰魔就是生死煩惱,依附五陰而生起的。天魔是因為修行邪定,喜歡危害正道的人。還有無聞比丘(無聞比丘),得到一點點就自以為滿足,誹謗佛法,妄說阿羅漢(Arhat)不受後有(不再有生死輪迴),這就是邪見魔,也就是陰魔和天魔的結合。因為誹謗佛法,就會墮入阿鼻地獄(Avici Hell)。一個人發起真正的修行,迴歸本源,十方世界都會震動,一切魔王,諸凡夫天,看見他們的宮殿崩裂,水陸生物驚恐害怕,便來惱亂禪定。這是天魔所造成的危害,還算輕微。他們依仗著神通的力量,終究只是外來的客人。主人在我自身,所以用妙覺來破除塵勞,就像用開水融化冰塊,用光明破除幽暗一樣。如果主人迷惑了,客人就有了可乘之機,毀壞我的戒律,摧毀我珍貴的覺悟,就像宰相的家被抄家沒收,徹底衰敗零落一樣。這是陰魔所造成的危害啊。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Gods, ordinary people, and heavenly beings, seeing their palaces collapsing for no reason, the earth shaking violently, and aquatic and terrestrial creatures flying everywhere, were all terrified. Ordinary people are ignorant and unaware of such changes. Although they have all attained the five supernatural powers (divine eye, divine ear, knowledge of others' minds, knowledge of past lives, and divine feet), they have not eradicated all afflictions and still crave worldly pleasures. How can you allow them to destroy your place of practice? Therefore, ghosts, spirits, various heavenly demons, goblins, and evil spirits all come to disturb you when you enter samadhi (right concentration). However, although those demons are very angry, in their realm of defilement, your wonderful awareness (pure and enlightened mind) is like wind blowing through light, like a knife cutting through flowing water, unable to touch each other at all. You are like boiling water, and they are like hard ice. The warm air gradually approaches, and they will melt and dissipate before long. They only rely on the power of their supernatural abilities, but they are ultimately just external guests, only able to cause some destruction and disturbance. This is because the five skandhas (form, feeling, perception, mental formations, and consciousness) in your mind are the true masters. If the master is deluded, the guests will have an opportunity to take advantage. When you are in meditation, awakened and without delusion, then those demonic affairs can do nothing to you. When the five skandhas dissipate and enter the light, then those evil beings will all be affected by the dark energy. Light can dispel darkness, and approaching the light will naturally dissipate. How dare they stay and disturb your meditation? If you cannot understand and awaken, and are deluded by the five skandhas, then you, Ananda, will surely become a member of the demons, becoming a demonic person, like Matangi (Matangi). However, Matangi's situation was relatively minor. She only used spells to bewilder you, breaking the Buddha's precepts, destroying only one precept out of the eighty thousand practices. Because your mind was still relatively pure, you have not completely fallen. But this (being deluded by the five skandhas) is to destroy your precious body of enlightenment, like the family of a prime minister suddenly being confiscated, completely declining and falling, with no hope of salvation.",
    
    "Tong (a Dharma master) said: 'Mara' means 'killer,' or 'robber,' capable of killing one's wisdom life and robbing one's good merits. There are roughly five types of demons: the demon of the five skandhas, the demon of afflictions, the demon of birth and death, the heavenly demon, and the ghost demon. Combining them, there are only the demon of the skandhas and the heavenly demon. The demon of the skandhas is the afflictions of birth and death, arising from the five skandhas. The heavenly demon is one who cultivates wrong concentration and likes to harm the right path. There is also the Unlearned Bhikshu (Unlearned Bhikshu), who is content with a little and slanders the Buddha's teachings, falsely claiming that Arhats (Arhat) do not receive future existence (no longer have the cycle of birth and death). This is the demon of wrong views, which is a combination of the demon of the skandhas and the heavenly demon. Because of slandering the Dharma, one will fall into Avici Hell (Avici Hell). When a person initiates true practice and returns to the source, the ten directions of the world will shake, and all the demon kings, ordinary heavenly beings, seeing their palaces collapsing and aquatic and terrestrial creatures terrified, will come to disturb meditation. This is the harm caused by the heavenly demon, which is relatively minor. They rely on the power of their supernatural abilities, but they are ultimately just external guests. The master is within myself, so I use wonderful awareness to break through the defilements, just as I use boiling water to melt ice, and use light to dispel darkness. If the master is deluded, the guests will have an opportunity to take advantage, destroying my precepts and destroying my precious enlightenment, just like the family of a prime minister being confiscated and completely declining and falling. This is the harm caused by the demon of the skandhas."
  ]
}

深。成就破亂。全歸主人。故修禪定。必須明悟。不為五陰所迷。乃第一義。陰者識情蓋覆。如浮雲然。明者當陽顯露。如太虛然。陰銷入明。即還本覺。故本覺妙明。與十方佛。無二無別。但由癡愛妄想。隨迷轉變。有世界生。有世界。即有色陰。戀此塵勞。即有受想行識陰。吾欲破陰而出。還吾覺圓心體。期于漏盡。彼有漏者。戀著不捨。恃其通力。故來相惱。若毀戒破律。與之和同。雖得五通。必為魔子。於此覺破。是謂寶覺。此覺即是成佛種子。仗此寶覺。入乎正定。以證法身。十方菩薩及諸無漏大阿羅漢。心精吻合。常處寂然。寂照含虛空。即虛空且無之矣。又況依空而立諸有漏國土哉。華嚴座主問長沙岑。虛空為是定有。為是定無。沙曰。言有亦得。言無亦得。虛空有時。但有假有。虛空無時。但無假無。曰如和尚所說有何教文。沙曰。大德豈不聞首楞嚴云。十方虛空生汝心內。猶如片云點太清里。豈不是虛空生時。但生假名。又云汝等一人發真歸元。十方虛空悉皆銷殞。是不是虛空滅時。但滅假名。所以老僧道。有是假有。無是假無。長沙洞徹本覺妙明。故觀虛空起滅。亦乃是幻。何況其餘。有朋彥上座。博學強記。來訪報恩明禪師。敵論宗乘。明曰。言多去道轉遠。今有事借問。祗如從上諸聖。及諸先德。還有不悟者也無。彥曰。若是諸聖先德。豈有不悟者哉。明曰。一人發真歸元。十方虛空悉皆銷殞。今天臺山嶷然。如何得銷殞去。彥不知所措。即此一大疑團。不能銷殞。奈何輕言破陰哉。

  阿難。當知汝坐道場

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "深。成就破亂。完全歸於主人。所以修習禪定,必須明瞭覺悟,不被五陰(色、受、想、行、識)所迷惑,這才是第一義諦。陰,指的是識情蓋覆,就像浮雲一樣。明,指的是當陽顯露,就像太虛空一樣。陰消散而入于光明,就回歸到本覺。所以本覺妙明,與十方諸佛,沒有絲毫差別。只是由於癡愛妄想,隨著迷惑而轉變,才有了世界的產生。有了世界,就有了色陰。貪戀這塵世的勞苦,就有了受、想、行、識陰。我想要破除五陰而出離,迴歸我覺悟圓滿的心體,期望達到漏盡。那些有漏的人,貪戀執著而不捨棄,仗恃他們的神通力,所以來惱亂。如果毀壞戒律,與之同流合污,即使得到五神通,也必定成為魔的眷屬。於此覺悟而破除迷惑,這叫做寶覺。這個覺悟就是成佛的種子。憑藉這個寶覺,進入正定,以證得法身。十方菩薩以及諸位無漏的大阿羅漢,心精吻合,常處於寂靜之中。寂靜之光包含虛空,即使虛空也尚且不存在了,又何況是依附於虛空而建立的各種有漏國土呢?",
    "華嚴座主問長沙岑:『虛空到底是定然存在,還是定然不存在?』長沙回答說:『說它存在也可以,說它不存在也可以。虛空存在的時候,只是假有;虛空不存在的時候,只是假無。』華嚴座主問:『像和尚您所說的,有什麼教典依據嗎?』長沙回答說:『大德難道沒有聽過《首楞嚴經》說:『十方虛空生於你心內,猶如一片云點綴在太清之中。』這豈不是虛空產生的時候,只是產生一個假名嗎?又說:『你們一人發起真性,迴歸本元,十方虛空全部都消殞。』這豈不是虛空滅亡的時候,只是滅亡一個假名嗎?』所以老僧我說,存在是假有,不存在是假無。』長沙洞徹本覺妙明,所以觀察虛空的生滅,也認為是虛幻的,何況是其他的呢?",
    "有朋彥上座,博學強記,來拜訪報恩明禪師,辯論宗乘。明禪師說:『言語多了離道就越遠。現在有件事想請教。請問從古至今的諸位聖人,以及各位先德,還有沒有不覺悟的呢?』朋彥回答說:『如果是諸位聖人先德,怎麼會有不覺悟的呢?』明禪師說:『一人發起真性,迴歸本元,十方虛空全部都消殞。今天臺山(地名)巍然聳立,怎麼能夠消殞呢?』朋彥不知所措。就是這一個大疑團,都不能消殞,又怎麼能輕易地說破除五陰呢?",
    "阿難(佛陀弟子名)。應當知道你坐的道場"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Profound. Accomplishing destruction and chaos, all returns to the master. Therefore, in cultivating Chan meditation, one must be clear and enlightened, not to be deluded by the five skandhas (form, feeling, perception, mental formations, and consciousness), for that is the ultimate truth. Skandhas refer to the covering of consciousness and emotions, like floating clouds. Clarity refers to the manifestation of the sun, like the great void. When the skandhas dissipate and enter into clarity, one returns to the original enlightenment. Therefore, the wonderful clarity of original enlightenment is no different from the Buddhas of the ten directions. It is only due to ignorant love and deluded thoughts, which transform with delusion, that worlds are produced. With the existence of worlds, there is the skandha of form. Attachment to the toils of this world leads to the skandhas of feeling, perception, mental formations, and consciousness. I wish to break through the skandhas and emerge, returning to my enlightened and complete mind-essence, hoping to achieve the exhaustion of outflows. Those with outflows cling to and are unwilling to abandon them, relying on their supernatural powers, so they come to disturb. If one violates precepts and breaks the rules, aligning with them, even if one attains the five supernatural powers, one will surely become a demon's disciple. To awaken and break through delusion here is called Precious Awakening. This awakening is the seed of becoming a Buddha. Relying on this Precious Awakening, one enters into right concentration to realize the Dharma body. The mind-essence of the Bodhisattvas of the ten directions and the great Arhats without outflows are in perfect harmony, constantly abiding in stillness. The light of stillness encompasses emptiness; even emptiness itself ceases to exist. How much more so the leaky lands that are established based on emptiness?",
    "The Huayan Abbot asked Changsha Cen: 'Is emptiness definitely existent, or is it definitely non-existent?' Changsha replied: 'Saying it exists is acceptable, and saying it doesn't exist is also acceptable. When emptiness exists, it is only a provisional existence; when emptiness doesn't exist, it is only a provisional non-existence.' The Huayan Abbot asked: 'According to what the Venerable has said, what scriptural basis is there?' Changsha replied: 'Has the Great Virtue not heard the Shurangama Sutra say: 'The emptiness of the ten directions arises within your mind, like a wisp of cloud adorning the vastness of the sky.' Isn't this the arising of emptiness merely the arising of a provisional name? It also says: 'When one of you awakens to the truth and returns to the origin, the emptiness of the ten directions will completely vanish.' Isn't this the annihilation of emptiness merely the annihilation of a provisional name?' Therefore, this old monk says that existence is provisional existence, and non-existence is provisional non-existence.' Changsha thoroughly understood the wonderful clarity of original enlightenment, so he viewed the arising and ceasing of emptiness as illusory; how much more so the rest?",
    "There was an Upasaka Peng Yan, learned and with a strong memory, who came to visit Chan Master Baoen Ming to debate the teachings. Chan Master Ming said: 'The more words, the further one strays from the Way. Now I have something to ask. May I ask if there are any among the sages and virtuous ones of the past who have not attained enlightenment?' Peng Yan replied: 'How could there be any among the sages and virtuous ones who have not attained enlightenment?' Chan Master Ming said: 'When one person awakens to the truth and returns to the origin, the emptiness of the ten directions will completely vanish. Today, Mount Tiantai (place name) stands tall and majestic; how can it vanish?' Peng Yan was at a loss. Even this great doubt cannot be dispelled; how can one lightly speak of breaking through the skandhas?",
    "Ananda (name of Buddha's disciple). You should know that the place where you sit"
  ]
}

。銷落諸念。其念若盡。則諸離念一切精明。動靜不移。憶忘如一。當住此處。入三摩地。如明目人。處大幽暗。精性妙凈。心未發光。此則名為色陰區宇。若目明朗。十方洞開。無復幽黯。名色陰盡。是人則能超越劫濁。觀其所由。堅固妄想以為其本。阿難。當在此中。精研妙明。四大不織。少選之間。身能出礙。此名精明流溢前境。斯但功力暫得如是。非為聖證。不作聖心。名善境界。若作聖解即受群邪。阿難。復以此心精研妙明。其身內徹。是人忽然于其身內。拾出蟯蛔。身相宛然。亦無傷毀。此名精明流溢形體。斯但精行。暫得如是。非為聖證。不作聖心。名善境界。若作聖解。即受群邪。又以此心內外精研。其時魂魄意志精神。除執受身。余皆涉入。互為賓主。忽于空中聞說法聲。或聞十方同敷密義。此名精魄遞相離合。成就善種。暫得如是非為聖證。不作聖心。名善境界。若作聖解。即受群邪。又以此心澄露皎徹。內光發明。十方遍作閻浮檀色。一切種類。化為如來。於時忽見毗盧遮那。(身土相稱)踞天光臺。千佛圍繞。百億國土。及與蓮華。俱時出現。此名心魂靈悟所染。心光研明。照諸世界。暫得如是。非為聖證。不作聖心。名善境界。若作聖解。即受群邪。又以此心精研妙明。觀察不停。抑按降伏。制止超越。於時忽然十方虛空。成七寶色。或百寶色。同時遍滿。不相留礙。青黃赤白。各各純現。此名抑按功力逾分。暫得如是。非為聖證。不作聖心。名善境界。若作聖解。即受群邪。又以此心研究澄徹。精光不亂。忽

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本:",
    "消除所有念頭。如果念頭完全消失,那麼所有脫離念頭的狀態都將變得精純明澈,動靜之間沒有分別,記憶和遺忘也如同一體。應當安住于這種狀態,進入三摩地(一種冥想境界)。就像眼睛明亮的人,身處極度黑暗之中,其精妙的本性依然清凈,只是心靈的光芒尚未顯現。這被稱為色陰(五陰之一,指物質現象)的區域。如果眼睛變得明亮,十方世界都洞然開啟,不再有黑暗,就叫做色陰消盡。這個人就能超越劫濁(末法時代的污濁)。觀察其根源,是由於堅固的虛妄念想所致。阿難,應當在此之中,精細研究這微妙的光明。四大(地、水、火、風)不再相互交織,短暫的時間內,身體能夠穿透障礙。這被稱為精明流溢到身體之外。這只是功夫暫時達到的狀態,並非聖人的證悟。不將其視為聖境,就稱為善境界。如果將其理解為聖境,就會受到各種邪魔的侵擾。阿難,再次用這顆心精細研究這微妙的光明,使身體內部通徹。這個人忽然從自己的身體內部,取出蟯蟲蛔蟲,身體的相貌依然完好,也沒有任何損傷。這被稱為精明流溢到形體之中。這只是精進修行暫時達到的狀態,並非聖人的證悟。不將其視為聖境,就稱為善境界。如果將其理解為聖境,就會受到各種邪魔的侵擾。又用這顆心內外精細研究,這時魂魄意志精神,除了執著受納身體之外,其餘的都互相涉入,互為賓主。忽然在空中聽到說法的聲音,或者聽到十方世界同時宣揚秘密的教義。這被稱為精魄互相分離聚合,成就善的種子。這只是暫時達到的狀態,並非聖人的證悟。不將其視為聖境,就稱為善境界。如果將其理解為聖境,就會受到各種邪魔的侵擾。又用這顆心澄澈明亮,內在的光芒顯發,十方世界都變成閻浮檀金色(一種金子的顏色),一切種類都化為如來。這時忽然看見毗盧遮那佛(報身佛,代表絕對真理的佛)端坐在天光臺上,千佛圍繞,百億國土,以及蓮花,同時出現。這被稱為心魂被靈悟所染,心光經過研究變得明亮,照耀各個世界。這只是暫時達到的狀態,並非聖人的證悟。不將其視為聖境,就稱為善境界。如果將其理解為聖境,就會受到各種邪魔的侵擾。又用這顆心精細研究這微妙的光明,觀察不停,抑制按壓降伏,制止超越。這時忽然十方虛空,變成七寶色,或者百寶色,同時遍滿,互不阻礙,青黃赤白,各自純粹地顯現。這被稱為抑制按壓的功夫超過了限度。這只是暫時達到的狀態,並非聖人的證悟。不將其視為聖境,就稱為善境界。如果將其理解為聖境,就會受到各種邪魔的侵擾。又用這顆心研究澄澈,精純的光芒不亂,忽然",
    "English version:",
    "Eliminating all thoughts. If thoughts are completely extinguished, then all states free from thoughts will become pure and clear, with no distinction between movement and stillness, and memory and forgetting will be as one. One should abide in this state and enter Samadhi (a state of meditation). It is like a person with bright eyes, being in extreme darkness, whose subtle nature is still pure, only the light of the mind has not yet manifested. This is called the realm of the Rupa Skandha (one of the five skandhas, referring to material phenomena). If the eyes become bright, and the ten directions are opened up, with no more darkness, it is called the exhaustion of the Rupa Skandha. This person can then transcend the turbidity of the Kalpa (the defilements of the Dharma-ending Age). Observing its origin, it is due to solidified false thoughts. Ananda, one should meticulously study this subtle light within this. The four elements (earth, water, fire, and wind) no longer interweave, and within a short time, the body can penetrate obstacles. This is called the outflow of pure awareness to the external environment. This is only a temporary state achieved through effort, not the enlightenment of a sage. Not regarding it as a sacred state is called a good state. If it is understood as a sacred state, one will be disturbed by various demons. Ananda, again use this mind to meticulously study this subtle light, making the body internally transparent. This person suddenly takes out pinworms and roundworms from within their body, and the appearance of the body is still intact, without any damage. This is called the outflow of pure awareness into the physical body. This is only a temporary state achieved through diligent practice, not the enlightenment of a sage. Not regarding it as a sacred state is called a good state. If it is understood as a sacred state, one will be disturbed by various demons. Again, using this mind to meticulously study internally and externally, at this time, the soul, spirit, will, and mind, except for clinging to the body, all interpenetrate each other, becoming both guest and host. Suddenly, one hears the sound of Dharma being spoken in the air, or hears the ten directions simultaneously proclaiming secret doctrines. This is called the separation and union of the soul and spirit, accomplishing good seeds. This is only a temporary state achieved, not the enlightenment of a sage. Not regarding it as a sacred state is called a good state. If it is understood as a sacred state, one will be disturbed by various demons. Again, using this mind to make it clear and bright, the inner light manifests, and the ten directions all become Jambudvipa gold (the color of a type of gold), and all kinds of beings transform into Tathagatas. At this time, one suddenly sees Vairocana Buddha (the Sambhogakaya Buddha, representing absolute truth) seated on the platform of heavenly light, surrounded by a thousand Buddhas, with hundreds of millions of lands and lotuses appearing simultaneously. This is called the mind and soul being tainted by spiritual awakening, and the light of the mind, after being studied, becomes bright, illuminating all worlds. This is only a temporary state achieved, not the enlightenment of a sage. Not regarding it as a sacred state is called a good state. If it is understood as a sacred state, one will be disturbed by various demons. Again, using this mind to meticulously study this subtle light, observing without ceasing, suppressing and subduing, restraining and transcending. At this time, suddenly the ten directions of space become seven-jeweled colors, or hundreds of jeweled colors, simultaneously filling everything, without obstructing each other, with blue, yellow, red, and white, each appearing purely. This is called the effort of suppression exceeding its limits. This is only a temporary state achieved, not the enlightenment of a sage. Not regarding it as a sacred state is called a good state. If it is understood as a sacred state, one will be disturbed by various demons. Again, using this mind to study and clarify, the pure light is not disordered, suddenly"
  ]
}

于夜半在暗室內。見種種物。不殊白晝。而暗室物亦不除滅。此名心細密澄其見。所視洞幽。暫得如是。非為聖證。不作聖心。名善境界。若作聖解。即受群邪。又以此心圓入虛融。四體忽然同於草木。火燒刀斫。曾無所覺。又則火光不能燒爇。縱割其肉。猶如削木。此名塵並。排四大性。一向入純。暫得如是。非為聖證。不作聖心。名善境界。若作聖解。即受群邪。又以此心成就清凈。凈心功極。忽見大地十方山河皆成佛國。具足七寶。光明遍滿。又見恒沙諸佛如來。遍滿空界。樓殿華麗。下見地獄。上觀天宮。得無障礙。此名欣厭凝想日深。想久化成。非為聖證。不作聖心。名善境界。若作聖解。即受群邪。又以此心研究深遠。忽于中夜。遙見遠方市井街巷親族眷屬。或聞其語。此名迫心。逼極飛出。故多隔見。非為聖證。不作聖心。名善境界。若作聖解。即受群邪。又以此心研究精極。見善知識形體變移。少選無端。種種遷改。此名邪心。含受魑魅。或遭天魔。入其心腹。無端說法。通達妙義。非為聖證。不作聖心。魔事銷歇。若作聖解。即受群邪。阿難。如是十種禪那現境。皆是色陰用心互動。故現斯事。眾生頑迷。不自忖量。逢此因緣。迷不自識。謂言登聖。大妄語成。墮無間獄。汝等當依如來滅后。于末法中。宣示斯義。無令天魔得其方便。保持覆護。成無上道。

  通曰。禪那即止觀法門。銷落諸念。以湛旋其虛妄滅生。止也。其念已盡。離念猶存。一切精明。觀也。止觀不二。必以動靜不移。憶忘如一。不昏不散者。

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "于夜半時分,在黑暗的房間里,看見各種各樣的東西,和白天所見沒有差別,而且黑暗房間里的東西也沒有消失。這叫做心細密而澄澈,使視覺變得敏銳,所看到的東西幽深細微。暫時得到這樣的境界,並不是證得聖果,不要認為自己證得了聖果。如果這樣認為,就會受到各種邪祟的侵擾。又用這種心,圓融地進入虛空,感覺四肢忽然和草木一樣,被火燒刀砍,都沒有任何感覺。甚至火焰不能燃燒,即使割開他的肉,也像削木頭一樣。這叫做塵境消融,排斥四大(地、水、火、風)的性質,完全進入純粹的狀態。暫時得到這樣的境界,並不是證得聖果,不要認為自己證得了聖果。如果這樣認為,就會受到各種邪祟的侵擾。又用這種心成就清凈,凈心的功夫達到極點,忽然看見大地十方山河都變成佛國,具備七寶(金、銀、琉璃、玻璃、硨磲、赤珠、瑪瑙),光明遍滿。又看見像恒河沙一樣多的諸佛如來,遍滿虛空,樓閣殿宇華麗無比,向下能看見地獄,向上能看見天宮,得到無所障礙的境界。這叫做欣慕和厭惡的念頭凝結想像,日漸加深,想像時間長了就變化而成。暫時得到這樣的境界,並不是證得聖果,不要認為自己證得了聖果。如果這樣認為,就會受到各種邪祟的侵擾。又用這種心研究深遠的事理,忽然在半夜裡,遙遠地看見遠方的市井街巷、親族眷屬,或者聽見他們說話。這叫做迫切的心逼到極點而飛出,所以常常能隔著遙遠的距離看見事物。暫時得到這樣的境界,並不是證得聖果,不要認為自己證得了聖果。如果這樣認為,就會受到各種邪祟的侵擾。又用這種心研究精微到極點,看見善知識(指有德行的師長或朋友)的形體變來變去,一會兒工夫,毫無緣由地,發生各種各樣的變化。這叫做邪惡的心,包含容受魑魅(古代傳說中的山神)的侵擾,或者遭遇天魔,進入他的心腹,毫無緣由地說法,通達微妙的義理。暫時得到這樣的境界,並不是證得聖果,不要認為自己證得了聖果。不作聖解,魔事就會消歇。如果這樣認為,就會受到各種邪祟的侵擾。阿難(釋迦牟尼佛的十大弟子之一),像這樣十種禪那(梵語dhyāna的音譯,意為禪定)中出現的境界,都是色陰(五陰之一,指物質現象)和用心互動作用,所以才出現這些事情。眾生愚頑迷惑,不自己衡量,遇到這些因緣,迷惑而不能自己認識,說自己已經登上了聖位,這就成了大妄語,會墮入無間地獄。你們應當依如來(佛的稱號)滅度之後,在末法時代,宣揚這些道理,不要讓天魔得到方便,保持覆護,成就無上道。",
    
    "通曰:禪那(梵語dhyāna的音譯,意為禪定)就是止觀法門,消除各種念頭,用清澈的心來旋轉虛妄的生滅。『止』,就是念頭已經窮盡,離開念頭的狀態仍然存在,一切精明。『觀』,就是止觀不二,必須做到動靜不移,記憶和遺忘如一,不昏沉也不散亂。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "In the middle of the night, in a dark room, one sees various objects, no different from what is seen during the day, and the objects in the dark room do not disappear. This is called the mind being subtle and clear, making the vision sharp, and what is seen is profound and subtle. Temporarily attaining such a state is not the attainment of sainthood; do not think that you have attained sainthood. If you think so, you will be disturbed by various evil influences. Furthermore, using this mind to enter the void in a complete and harmonious way, one feels that the four limbs suddenly become like grass and trees, and being burned by fire or cut by knives, there is no feeling at all. Even fire cannot burn, and even if the flesh is cut, it is like carving wood. This is called the dissolution of dust, rejecting the nature of the four elements (earth, water, fire, and wind), and completely entering a state of purity. Temporarily attaining such a state is not the attainment of sainthood; do not think that you have attained sainthood. If you think so, you will be disturbed by various evil influences. Furthermore, using this mind to achieve purity, and the effort of purifying the mind reaches its peak, one suddenly sees that the earth, the ten directions, the mountains, and the rivers all become Buddha lands, possessing the seven treasures (gold, silver, lapis lazuli, crystal, mother-of-pearl, red pearl, and agate) in abundance, and filled with light. One also sees Buddhas and Tathagatas (title of a Buddha) as numerous as the sands of the Ganges River, filling the void, with magnificent pavilions and palaces. Looking down, one can see hell; looking up, one can see the heavenly palaces, attaining a state of unobstructedness. This is called the thoughts of admiration and aversion congealing and deepening day by day, and transforming after a long time of imagination. Temporarily attaining such a state is not the attainment of sainthood; do not think that you have attained sainthood. If you think so, you will be disturbed by various evil influences. Furthermore, using this mind to study profound principles, one suddenly sees distant marketplaces, streets, relatives, and family members in the middle of the night, or hears them speaking. This is called the urgent mind being forced to the extreme and flying out, so one can often see things from a great distance. Temporarily attaining such a state is not the attainment of sainthood; do not think that you have attained sainthood. If you think so, you will be disturbed by various evil influences. Furthermore, using this mind to study with extreme precision, one sees the form of a virtuous teacher (referring to a virtuous mentor or friend) changing, and in a short time, for no reason, undergoing various transformations. This is called an evil mind, containing and accepting the disturbance of chīmèi (mountain spirits in ancient legends), or encountering a heavenly demon, entering his heart and abdomen, speaking Dharma for no reason, and understanding subtle meanings. Temporarily attaining such a state is not the attainment of sainthood; do not think that you have attained sainthood. If you do not think you have attained sainthood, the demonic affairs will cease. If you think so, you will be disturbed by various evil influences. Ānanda (one of the ten major disciples of Śākyamuni Buddha), these ten kinds of states appearing in dhyāna (Sanskrit word, meaning meditation) are all due to the interaction of the rūpa-skandha (one of the five skandhas, referring to material phenomena) and the use of the mind, so these things appear. Sentient beings are foolish and confused, not measuring themselves, and when encountering these causes and conditions, they are confused and cannot recognize themselves, saying that they have ascended to the holy position. This becomes a great lie and will fall into the Avīci hell. You should, after the Tathagata (title of a Buddha) passes away, propagate these principles in the Dharma-ending Age, so that the heavenly demons do not get the opportunity, maintain protection, and achieve the unsurpassed path.",
    
    "Commentary: Dhyāna (Sanskrit word, meaning meditation) is the method of śamatha-vipassanā (calm abiding and insight meditation), eliminating various thoughts, and using the clear mind to rotate the illusory arising and ceasing. 'Śamatha' (calm abiding) is when thoughts have been exhausted, and the state of being free from thoughts still exists, all being clear and bright. 'Vipassanā' (insight meditation) is when śamatha-vipassanā (calm abiding and insight meditation) are not two, it must be done with immobility in movement and stillness, memory and forgetting being as one, neither dull nor scattered."
  ]
}

為正念。從此而入。乃得真三摩提。若靜有而動無。憶存而忘亡。此屬凝想光景。非為正定。初入止觀。色陰未破。如明目人。處大幽暗。未能發光。為色所局。是名色陰區宇。色陰既破。如目明朗。十方洞開。觀力圓照。不為前境所礙。如是則能超越劫濁。由色與見交織。故成劫濁。今見不為色法所迷。故能超也。是色陰胡為乎來哉。由堅固妄想以為其本。本于父母與己三者妄想交結而成。成此堅固四大色身。堅相為地。潤濕為水。暖觸為火。動搖為風。由此四纏而成六根。六湛圓明。蔽覆真性。故謂之陰也。今入禪那。精研妙明。離於前塵。身境俱空。四大不織。性與色離。始則精明流溢。身能出礙。外忘其境也。既而其身內徹。拾出蟯蛔。內忘其身也。既而精魄遞相離合。內身外身。互為賓主。能于空中聞說法要。則幾遺其形也。既而內光發明。見佛境界。靈悟所染。暫得如是。而不可為常也。若唸佛三昧。見凈土境。心境相應。名為正相。不在此例。既而抑按逾分。見多寶色。抑極則光生。亦十想觀所成也。既而密澄其見。睹暗中物。前所見者幻境。此所見者實境。非養盛心細者不能。既而四體虛融。同於草木。火燒刀斫。曾無所覺。非純覺遺身者不能。既而觀照之極。成就清凈。忽見十方佛土。天堂地獄。皆無障礙。幾於得天眼通矣。既而抑按之極。不但見暗室中物。而遠方市井。亦莫不見。不但聞空中法聲。而親族眷屬之語。亦莫不聞。幾於得天耳通矣。至研究精極。內外涉入。互為賓主。精神魂慮。忽忘所歸。由是魔得其便

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "以正念為入手處,由此進入,才能獲得真正的三摩提(Samadhi,正定)。如果只是靜止時有覺知,而行動時則無;記得時有,遺忘時則無,這屬於凝想的光景,並非真正的正定。初入止觀(Śamatha-Vipassanā,奢摩他-毗婆舍那),色陰(Rūpa-skandha)尚未破除,就像明眼人身處極度黑暗之中,無法發出光明,被色法所侷限,這稱為色陰的區域。色陰破除之後,就像眼睛明亮,十方洞開,觀照的力量圓滿照耀,不被眼前的境界所障礙,這樣就能超越劫濁(Kalpa-kaṣāya)。因為色法與見解相互交織,所以形成劫濁。現在見解不被色法所迷惑,所以能夠超越。這色陰究竟從何而來呢?由堅固的妄想作為它的根本。根本在於父母與自己三者的妄想交結而成,形成這堅固的四大色身。堅硬的相為地大,潤濕的相為水大,溫暖的觸感為火大,動搖的相為風大。由此四大纏繞而成六根(Ṣaḍindriya)。六根的湛然圓明,遮蔽了真正的自性,所以稱為陰。現在進入禪那(Dhyāna,禪定),精細研究微妙光明,遠離眼前的塵境,身與境界都空寂,四大不再交織,自性與色法分離。開始時,精明流溢,身體能夠穿透障礙,向外忘記了境界。之後,身體內部通徹,能夠取出體內的蟯蟲蛔蟲,向內忘記了自身。再之後,精魄互相分離聚合,內身與外身,互相成為賓客與主人,能夠在空中聽到說法要義,幾乎遺忘了自己的形體。再之後,內在的光明發明,見到佛的境界,靈悟被沾染,暫時得到這樣,但不可作為常態。如果唸佛三昧(Buddha-samādhi),見到凈土的境界,心與境界相應,這稱為正相,不在此例。再之後,如果抑制按捺過度,會見到多寶色。抑制到極點則光明產生,也是十想觀所造成的。再之後,如果秘密澄澈自己的見解,會看到黑暗中的物體。之前所見的是幻境,現在所見的是實境,不是養盛心細的人不能做到。再之後,如果四肢百骸虛空融合,如同草木,被火燒刀砍,都毫無感覺,不是純粹覺悟而遺忘身體的人不能做到。再之後,如果觀照到極點,成就清凈,忽然見到十方佛土,天堂地獄,都沒有障礙,幾乎得到天眼通了。再之後,如果抑制按捺到極點,不但能看到暗室中的物體,而且遠方市井的情景,也無所不見。不但能聽到空中的法聲,而且親族眷屬的言語,也無所不聞,幾乎得到天耳通了。等到研究精細到極點,內外相互涉入,互相成為賓客與主人,精神魂魄思慮,忽然忘記了歸宿,因此魔就得到了機會。",
    "English version",
    "Take mindfulness as the entry point, and through this, one can attain true Samadhi (正定). If there is awareness only when still but not when moving, or only when remembering but not when forgetting, this belongs to the realm of concentrated thought, not true Samadhi. When first entering Śamatha-Vipassanā (止觀), the Rūpa-skandha (色陰) has not yet been broken. It is like a person with clear eyes in great darkness, unable to emit light, confined by form. This is called the domain of the Rūpa-skandha. Once the Rūpa-skandha is broken, it is like the eyes becoming clear, with the ten directions opening up. The power of contemplation shines completely, unhindered by the present environment. In this way, one can transcend the Kalpa-kaṣāya (劫濁). Because form and perception are intertwined, Kalpa-kaṣāya is formed. Now, perception is not deluded by form, so one can transcend it. Where does this Rūpa-skandha come from? It originates from firm delusion. It is rooted in the delusion of the three – parents, and oneself – intertwined, forming this solid body of the four great elements. The solid aspect is the earth element, the moist aspect is the water element, the warm sensation is the fire element, and the moving aspect is the wind element. From these four elements arise the six sense organs (Ṣaḍindriya). The clear and complete nature of the six sense organs obscures the true self, hence it is called a skandha. Now, entering Dhyāna (禪那), meticulously studying the subtle light, one separates from the dust of the present environment. Both body and environment become empty, the four elements no longer intertwine, and the nature separates from form. Initially, subtle light overflows, and the body can pass through obstacles, forgetting the external environment. Later, the body becomes internally clear, able to extract worms from within, forgetting the internal self. Further, the essence and spirit separate and combine, with the inner and outer bodies becoming guests and hosts to each other. One can hear the essence of the Dharma in the air, almost forgetting one's own form. Further, inner light arises, and one sees the realm of the Buddha, with spiritual understanding being influenced, temporarily attaining this state, but it should not be taken as permanent. If one practices Buddha-samādhi (唸佛三昧) and sees the Pure Land realm, with the mind and environment corresponding, this is called a correct sign and is not included in this example. Further, if one suppresses and restrains excessively, one will see multi-colored lights. Extreme suppression will generate light, which is also formed by the ten thoughts. Further, if one secretly clarifies one's perception, one will see objects in the dark. What was seen before was an illusion, what is seen now is reality, which cannot be achieved by those who do not cultivate a refined mind. Further, if the four limbs become empty and integrated, like grass and trees, one will feel nothing when burned by fire or cut by a knife, which cannot be achieved by those who do not purely awaken and forget the body. Further, if contemplation reaches its peak and achieves purity, one will suddenly see the Buddha lands of the ten directions, and the heavens and hells, without any obstacles, almost attaining the divine eye. Further, if one suppresses and restrains to the extreme, one will not only see objects in a dark room, but also the scenes of distant markets, seeing everything. One will not only hear the Dharma sounds in the air, but also the words of relatives and family members, hearing everything, almost attaining the divine ear. When the study becomes extremely refined, with inner and outer intermingling, becoming guests and hosts to each other, the spirit, soul, thoughts, and worries will suddenly forget where to return, and thus demons will find an opportunity."
  ]
}

。入其心腹。乃令形體變移。種種遷改。無端說法。通達妙義。彼豈不以為能破色陰。不復為色法所拘攣乎。而不知為魔之所著也。此十者。皆由精研妙明。用禪那心。與堅固妄想交戰。色未能即空。空未能即色。互為勝負不得渾融。此色陰之魔。所得乘間而入也。眾生頑迷。不自忖量平日之見地。與佛何似。平日之功行。與佛何似。偶見此境。便為聖證。非聖謂聖。非證謂證。內迷於陰魔。而外感於天魔。大妄語成。墮無間獄。良可哀憫。故世尊欲宣示末法中。保護眾生。成無上道也。若功力既到。能破色陰。雖現如上事。不作聖心解者。宗門中亦多有之。如鵝湖智孚禪師。一日不赴堂。侍者來請赴堂。孚曰。我今日在莊吃油糍飽。者曰。和尚不曾出入。孚曰。你但去問取莊主。者方出門。忽見莊主來謝和尚到莊吃油糍。此非身能出礙者乎。瑞巖禪師。一日有媼來作禮。巖曰。汝速歸救取數千物命。媼回舍。見兒婦拾田螺歸。遂放之。又祖照禪師。于定中所見數十里內之事。而人未嘗有知之者。后以莊僧聞過故出揚于外。照慮惑眾。即入圓寂。此皆能之而不以為聖證者也。

  阿難。彼善男子修三摩提。奢摩他中。色陰盡者。見諸佛心。如明鏡中顯現其像。若有所得。而未能用。猶如魘人。手足宛然。見聞不惑。心觸客邪。而不能動。此則名為受陰區宇。若魘咎歇。其心離身返觀其面。去住自由。無復留礙。名受陰盡。是人則能超越見濁。觀其所由。虛明妄想以為其本。阿難。彼善男子。當在此中。得大光耀。其心發明內抑過分。忽

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本:",
    "侵入他的心腹。於是使他的形體改變移動,種種變化,無緣無故地說法,通達微妙的義理。那人難道不認為自己能破除色陰(五蘊之一,指物質現象),不再被色法所拘束了嗎?卻不知道是被魔所附著了。這十種情況,都是由於精研妙明,用禪那之心,與堅固的妄想交戰,色未能立即是空,空未能立即是色,互相爭勝負,不能夠完全融合。這是色陰之魔,得以乘機侵入的緣故。眾生愚昧迷惑,不自己衡量平日的見解,與佛相比如何?平日的功行,與佛相比如何?偶然見到這種境界,便認為是證得了聖果,不是聖人卻自稱為聖人,沒有證得卻說自己證得了。內心迷惑于陰魔,而外在又感應到天魔,犯下大妄語,墮入無間地獄。實在令人哀憐。所以世尊想要宣示末法時代中,保護眾生,成就無上菩提之道啊。如果功力已經達到,能夠破除色陰,即使出現如上所述的事情,也不作證聖之想,禪宗中也有很多人是這樣的。例如鵝湖智孚禪師,有一天沒有去參加佛堂的活動,侍者來請他去佛堂,智孚禪師說:『我今天在莊上吃油糍吃飽了。』侍者說:『和尚您不曾出入啊。』智孚禪師說:『你只管去問莊主。』侍者剛出門,忽然看見莊主來感謝和尚到莊上吃油糍。這不是身能出入無礙嗎?瑞巖禪師,有一天有一位老婦人來作禮,瑞巖禪師說:『你趕快回去救取數千物命。』老婦人回到家,看見兒媳婦撿田螺回來,就放了它們。還有祖照禪師,在禪定中所見數十里內的事情,而人們從來沒有知道的。後來因為莊上的僧人說了他的過失,所以他才在外人面前說出此事。祖照禪師擔心迷惑大眾,就入滅了。這些都是能夠做到卻不認為是證得聖果的人。",
    
    "阿難(佛陀弟子名)。那些善男子修習三摩提(禪定),在奢摩他(止觀中的止)中,色陰(五蘊之一,指物質現象)消盡的人,見到諸佛的心,就像在明鏡中顯現出影像。如果有所得,卻不能運用,就像被魘住的人,手腳完好,見聞不迷惑,心觸及客邪,卻不能動彈。這就叫做受陰(五蘊之一,指感受)的區域。如果魘住的現象消失,他的心離開身體,反觀自己的面容,來去自由,沒有阻礙,就叫做受陰消盡。這個人就能超越見濁(五濁之一,指錯誤的見解)。觀察它的根源,是虛妄光明的妄想作為它的根本。阿難(佛陀弟子名)。那些善男子,應當在此之中,得到大光明,他的心發明,內心抑制太過分,忽然"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version:",
    "Invading his heart and mind, it then causes his form to change and shift, undergoing various transformations. He speaks without cause, mastering subtle meanings. Does he not then believe that he can break through the skandha of form (one of the five aggregates, referring to material phenomena) and no longer be constrained by form? Yet, he does not know that he is possessed by a demon. These ten situations all arise from deeply studying the wonderful brightness, using the mind of dhyana (meditation) to battle with solidified delusion. Form cannot immediately be emptiness, and emptiness cannot immediately be form; they contend for victory and defeat, unable to completely merge. This is how the demon of the skandha of form finds an opportunity to enter. Sentient beings are stubborn and deluded, not measuring their daily views against those of the Buddha, nor their daily practice against that of the Buddha. Upon encountering such a state, they immediately believe they have attained sainthood, claiming to be saints when they are not, and claiming to have attained enlightenment when they have not. Internally, they are deluded by the yin demons, and externally, they are influenced by the heavenly demons, committing great lies and falling into the Avici Hell. It is truly lamentable. Therefore, the World Honored One wishes to proclaim, in the Dharma-ending Age, how to protect sentient beings and attain the Unsurpassed Path. If one's skill has reached the point where one can break through the skandha of form, even if the above-mentioned events occur, one does not interpret them as signs of sainthood. There are many such examples in the Zen school. For example, Zen Master Zifu of Ehu did not attend the hall one day. The attendant came to invite him to the hall, and Zifu said, 'Today I ate my fill of fried rice cakes at the village.' The attendant said, 'Venerable Master, you have not been out.' Zifu said, 'Just go and ask the village head.' As the attendant was leaving, he suddenly saw the village head come to thank the Venerable Master for coming to the village to eat fried rice cakes. Is this not the body being able to move without obstruction? Zen Master Ruiyan, one day an old woman came to pay respects. Ruiyan said, 'Quickly return and save several thousand lives.' The old woman returned home and saw her daughter-in-law bringing back snails she had gathered from the fields, so she released them. Also, Zen Master Zuzhao, in meditation, saw events within a radius of several tens of miles, which people had never known. Later, because a monk from the monastery spoke of his faults, he revealed this matter to outsiders. Zuzhao, fearing that he would confuse the masses, immediately entered parinirvana (final passing away). These are all people who were able to do such things but did not consider them to be signs of sainthood.",
    
    "Ananda (name of Buddha's disciple), those good men who cultivate samadhi (meditative concentration), and whose skandha of form (one of the five aggregates, referring to material phenomena) is exhausted in shamatha (calm abiding), see the minds of all Buddhas, just as images appear in a clear mirror. If they have attained something but cannot use it, it is like a person who is paralyzed by a nightmare, whose hands and feet are intact, whose seeing and hearing are not confused, but whose mind is touched by external influences and cannot move. This is called the realm of the skandha of feeling (one of the five aggregates, referring to sensations). If the paralysis of the nightmare ceases, his mind leaves the body and reflects upon his own face, coming and going freely, without obstruction, this is called the exhaustion of the skandha of feeling. This person can then transcend the turbidity of views (one of the five turbidities, referring to wrong views). Observing its origin, it is the illusory brightness of delusion that is its root. Ananda (name of Buddha's disciple), those good men should, within this, attain great light, their minds illuminated, but if their internal suppression is excessive, suddenly"
  ]
}

于其處發無窮悲。如是乃至觀見蚊虻。猶如赤子。心生憐愍。不覺流淚。此名功用抑摧過越。悟則無咎。非為聖證。覺了不迷。久自銷歇。若作聖解。則有悲魔入其心腑。見人則悲。啼泣無限。失於正受。當從淪墜。阿難。又彼定中諸善男子。見色陰銷。受陰明白。勝相現前。感激過分。忽于其中生無限勇。其心猛利。志齊諸佛。謂三僧祇。一念能越。此名功用陵率過越。悟則無咎。非為聖證。覺了不迷。久自銷歇。若作聖解。則有狂魔入其心腑。見人則夸。我慢無比。其心乃至上不見佛。下不見人。失於正受。當從淪墜。又彼定中諸善男子。見色陰銷。受陰明白。前無新證。歸失故居。智力衰微。入中隳地。迥無所見。心中忽然生大枯渴。於一切時。沉憶不散。將此以為勤精進相。此名修心無慧自失。悟則無咎。非為聖證。若作聖解。則有憶魔入其心腑。旦夕撮心懸在一處。失於正受。當從淪墜。又彼定中諸善男子。見色陰銷。受陰明白。慧力過定。失於猛利。以諸勝性。懷於心中。自心已疑是盧舍那。(此云凈滿)得少為足。此名用心忘失恒審。溺於知見。悟則無咎。非為聖證。若作聖解。則有下劣易知足魔入其心腑。見人自言我得無上第一義諦。失於正受。當從淪墜。又彼定中諸善男子。見色陰銷。受陰明白。新證未獲。故心已亡。歷覽二際。自生艱險。於心忽然生無盡憂。如坐鐵床。如飲毒藥。心不欲活。常求於人令害其命早取解脫。此名修行失於方便。悟則無咎。非為聖證。若作聖解。則有一分常憂愁魔入其心腑。手執刀劍。自

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "對於他們所處的地方,生起無盡的悲傷。像這樣乃至看到蚊子、小蟲,都像對待自己的孩子一樣,心中生起憐憫,不知不覺流下眼淚。這叫做功用太過,壓抑太過。如果覺悟了,就沒有過失,但這不是聖證。覺察明白,不迷惑,時間久了自然消歇。如果當作聖證,就會有悲魔進入他的心腑,見到人就悲傷,哭泣不止,失去正受,將會墮落。阿難,還有那些禪定中的善男子,見到色陰消散,受陰明顯,殊勝的景象出現在眼前,感動太過分,忽然在其中生起無限的勇氣,他的心猛烈,志向與諸佛相同,認為三大阿僧祇劫,一念就能超越。這叫做功用太過,凌越太過。如果覺悟了,就沒有過失,但這不是聖證。覺察明白,不迷惑,時間久了自然消歇。如果當作聖證,就會有狂魔進入他的心腑,見到人就誇耀,我慢無比,他的心乃至向上看不見佛,向下看不見人,失去正受,將會墮落。還有那些禪定中的善男子,見到色陰消散,受陰明白,新的證悟沒有得到,舊的居所也失去了,智力衰微,進入中間的頹廢之地,什麼也看不見,心中忽然生起巨大的枯竭感,在一切時候,沉溺於回憶而不散去,把這當作勤奮精進的相。這叫做修心沒有智慧,自己迷失。如果覺悟了,就沒有過失,但這不是聖證。如果當作聖證,就會有憶魔進入他的心腑,早晚都揪著心,懸在一處,失去正受,將會墮落。還有那些禪定中的善男子,見到色陰消散,受陰明白,慧力超過定力,失去猛利,把各種殊勝的性質,懷在心中,自己的心已經懷疑自己是盧舍那(此云凈滿)。得到少許就滿足。這叫做用心忘記了恒常審察,沉溺於知見。如果覺悟了,就沒有過失,但這不是聖證。如果當作聖證,就會有下劣易知足魔進入他的心腑,見到人就說自己得到了無上第一義諦。失去正受,將會墮落。還有那些禪定中的善男子,見到色陰消散,受陰明白,新的證悟沒有獲得,舊的心已經亡失,經歷觀察過去未來,自己生出艱難險阻,心中忽然生起無盡的憂愁,像坐在鐵床上,像飲用毒藥,心裡不想活,常常請求別人殺害他的性命,早點得到解脫。這叫做修行失去了方便。如果覺悟了,就沒有過失,但這不是聖證。如果當作聖證,就會有一分常常憂愁的魔進入他的心腑,手執刀劍,自己",
    "English version",
    "From that place, they develop boundless sorrow. So much so that when they see mosquitoes and gnats, they regard them as their own children, and compassion arises in their hearts, and tears flow unconsciously. This is called 'using effort to suppress and overstep.' If they awaken to it, there is no fault, but it is not a sage's attainment. If they realize and are not confused, it will naturally subside over time. If they consider it a sage's attainment, then a sorrow demon will enter their heart, and they will be sorrowful upon seeing people, weeping endlessly, losing proper samadhi, and will fall. Ananda, furthermore, those good men in samadhi, seeing the skandha of form dissolve and the skandha of feeling become clear, with superior signs appearing before them, are excessively moved. Suddenly, boundless courage arises within them. Their minds are fierce, their aspirations equal to those of all Buddhas, and they think they can transcend three asamkhya kalpas in a single thought. This is called 'using effort to surpass and overstep.' If they awaken to it, there is no fault, but it is not a sage's attainment. If they realize and are not confused, it will naturally subside over time. If they consider it a sage's attainment, then a madness demon will enter their heart, and they will boast upon seeing people, with unparalleled arrogance. Their minds will reach a point where they do not see the Buddhas above, nor the people below, losing proper samadhi, and will fall. Furthermore, those good men in samadhi, seeing the skandha of form dissolve and the skandha of feeling become clear, without new attainment and losing their old abode, their wisdom weakens, and they enter a middle, ruined ground, seeing nothing at all. Suddenly, a great dryness and thirst arise in their hearts, and they constantly dwell on memories without letting go, taking this as a sign of diligent effort. This is called 'cultivating the mind without wisdom, losing oneself.' If they awaken to it, there is no fault, but it is not a sage's attainment. If they consider it a sage's attainment, then a memory demon will enter their heart, and they will constantly clutch their heart, suspending it in one place, losing proper samadhi, and will fall. Furthermore, those good men in samadhi, seeing the skandha of form dissolve and the skandha of feeling become clear, their wisdom power exceeds their samadhi power, losing fierceness. They cherish the various superior qualities in their hearts, and their own minds already suspect that they are Vairocana (meaning 'pure and complete'). They are content with little attainment. This is called 'using the mind, forgetting constant examination, and drowning in knowledge and views.' If they awaken to it, there is no fault, but it is not a sage's attainment. If they consider it a sage's attainment, then an inferior, easily satisfied demon will enter their heart, and they will say to people that they have attained the unsurpassed, ultimate truth. Losing proper samadhi, they will fall. Furthermore, those good men in samadhi, seeing the skandha of form dissolve and the skandha of feeling become clear, without gaining new attainment and their old mind already lost, experiencing and observing the two realms (past and future), they themselves create difficulties and dangers. Suddenly, endless sorrow arises in their hearts, like sitting on an iron bed, like drinking poison. Their hearts do not want to live, and they constantly ask people to kill them, to quickly attain liberation. This is called 'cultivating practice, losing skillful means.' If they awaken to it, there is no fault, but it is not a sage's attainment. If they consider it a sage's attainment, then a portion of a constantly sorrowful demon will enter their heart, holding knives and swords, and"
  ]
}

割其肉。欣其舍壽。或常憂愁。走入山林。不耐見人。失於正受。當從淪墜。又彼定中諸善男子。見色陰銷。受陰明白。處清凈中。心安隱后。忽然自有無限喜生。心中歡悅。不能自止。此名輕安無慧自禁。悟則無咎。非為聖證。若作聖解。則有一分好喜樂魔入其心腑。見人則笑。于衢路旁。自歌自舞。自謂已得無礙解脫。失於正受。當從淪墜。又彼定中諸善男子。見色陰銷。受陰明白。自謂已足。忽有無端大我慢起。如是乃至慢與過慢。及慢過慢。或增上慢。或卑劣慢。一時俱發。心中尚輕十方如來。何況下位聲聞緣覺。此名見勝無慧自救。悟則無咎。非為聖證。若作聖解。則有一分大我慢魔。入其心腑。不禮塔廟。摧毀經像。謂檀越言。此是金銅。或是土木。經是樹葉。或是㲲華。肉身真常。不自恭敬。卻崇土木。實為顛倒。其深信者。從其毀碎。埋棄地中。疑誤眾生。入無間獄。失於正受。當從淪墜。又彼定中諸善男子。見色陰銷。受陰明白。于精明中。圓悟精理。得大隨順。其心忽生無量輕安。已言成聖。得大自在。此名因慧獲諸輕清。悟則無咎。非為聖證。若作聖解。則有一分好輕清魔。入其心腑。自謂滿足。更不求進。此等多作無聞比丘。疑誤眾生。墮阿鼻獄。失於正受。當從淪墜。又彼定中諸善男子。見色陰銷。受陰明白。于明悟中。得虛明性。其中忽然歸向永滅。撥無因果。一向入空。空心現前。乃至心生長斷滅解。悟則無咎。非為聖證。若作聖解。則有空魔入其心腑。乃謗持戒名為小乘。菩薩悟空。有何持犯。其人常于

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本\n\n割他的肉。喜歡捨棄壽命。或者常常憂愁,走入山林,不能忍受見人。失去正確的禪定,應當由此而墮落。還有那些禪定中的善男子,見到色陰消散,受陰顯現明白,處於清凈之中,內心安穩后,忽然自然生起無限的喜悅,心中歡喜,不能停止。這叫做輕安而沒有智慧來約束自己。如果覺悟了就沒有過失,不是聖證。如果當作聖證,就有一分喜歡喜樂的魔進入他的心腑。見到人就笑,在道路旁邊,自己唱歌跳舞,自認為已經得到無礙解脫。失去正確的禪定,應當由此而墮落。還有那些禪定中的善男子,見到色陰消散,受陰顯現明白,自認為已經足夠,忽然生起無端的巨大我慢。像這樣乃至慢、過慢,以及慢過慢,或者增上慢,或者卑劣慢,一時都一起發作。心中還輕視十方如來(佛),更何況下位的聲聞、緣覺。這叫做見到殊勝而沒有智慧來救自己。如果覺悟了就沒有過失,不是聖證。如果當作聖證,就有一分巨大我慢的魔進入他的心腑。不禮拜佛塔寺廟,摧毀佛經佛像,對施主說:『這是金銅,或是土木。經是樹葉,或是毛織品。肉身才是真常,不自己恭敬,卻崇拜土木,實在是顛倒。』那些深信的人,聽從他的毀壞,埋藏丟棄在地下,疑惑誤導眾生,進入無間地獄。失去正確的禪定,應當由此而墮落。還有那些禪定中的善男子,見到色陰消散,受陰顯現明白,在精明之中,圓滿領悟精妙的道理,得到大的隨順,他的心中忽然生起無量的輕安,就說自己已經成聖,得到大的自在。這叫做因為智慧獲得各種輕清。如果覺悟了就沒有過失,不是聖證。如果當作聖證,就有一分喜歡輕清的魔進入他的心腑。自認為滿足,不再求進步。這些人大多成為沒有聞法的比丘,疑惑誤導眾生,墮入阿鼻地獄。失去正確的禪定,應當由此而墮落。還有那些禪定中的善男子,見到色陰消散,受陰顯現明白,在明悟之中,得到虛明的性質,其中忽然歸向永遠的滅亡,否定因果,一味地進入空,空的心現前,乃至心中生出斷滅的見解。如果覺悟了就沒有過失,不是聖證。如果當作聖證,就有空魔進入他的心腑,於是誹謗持戒是小乘,菩薩領悟空性,有什麼持戒和犯戒?這個人常常在",
    "English version\n\nCutting his flesh. Delighting in relinquishing life. Or constantly worrying, entering the mountains and forests, unable to bear seeing people. Losing proper samadhi, he should fall from this. Furthermore, those virtuous men in samadhi, seeing the skandha of form dissolve and the skandha of feeling become clear, residing in purity, after their minds are at peace, suddenly and naturally give rise to boundless joy, their hearts delighted, unable to stop. This is called light ease without wisdom to restrain oneself. If one awakens, there is no fault; it is not a sage's attainment. If one considers it a sage's attainment, then a portion of a delight-in-joy demon enters his heart. Upon seeing people, he laughs. By the roadside, he sings and dances by himself, claiming to have attained unobstructed liberation. Losing proper samadhi, he should fall from this. Furthermore, those virtuous men in samadhi, seeing the skandha of form dissolve and the skandha of feeling become clear, thinking they have attained enough, suddenly a groundless great arrogance arises. Like this, even to arrogance, excessive arrogance, and arrogance beyond arrogance, or increased arrogance, or inferior arrogance, all arise at once. In their hearts, they even belittle the Tathagatas (Buddhas) of the ten directions, let alone the lower-ranking Shravakas (Voice-Hearers) and Pratyekabuddhas (Solitary Buddhas). This is called seeing superiority without wisdom to save oneself. If one awakens, there is no fault; it is not a sage's attainment. If one considers it a sage's attainment, then a portion of a great arrogance demon enters his heart. He does not bow to stupas and temples, destroys sutras and images, and says to donors: 'This is gold and copper, or earth and wood. Sutras are tree leaves, or woolen fabrics. The physical body is truly constant. Not respecting oneself, yet revering earth and wood, is truly inverted.' Those who deeply believe him follow his destruction, burying and discarding them in the ground, causing doubt and misleading sentient beings, entering the Avici Hell. Losing proper samadhi, he should fall from this. Furthermore, those virtuous men in samadhi, seeing the skandha of form dissolve and the skandha of feeling become clear, within the essence of brightness, fully realizing the subtle principles, attaining great compliance, their hearts suddenly give rise to immeasurable light ease, and they declare themselves to have become sages, attaining great freedom. This is called obtaining various light purities due to wisdom. If one awakens, there is no fault; it is not a sage's attainment. If one considers it a sage's attainment, then a portion of a delight-in-light-purity demon enters his heart. He considers himself satisfied and no longer seeks to advance. Many of these become unlearned Bhikshus (monks), causing doubt and misleading sentient beings, falling into the Avici Hell. Losing proper samadhi, he should fall from this. Furthermore, those virtuous men in samadhi, seeing the skandha of form dissolve and the skandha of feeling become clear, within the brightness of awakening, attaining the nature of emptiness and brightness, within which they suddenly turn towards eternal annihilation, denying cause and effect, single-mindedly entering emptiness, the mind of emptiness appearing before them, even to the point of giving rise to a view of annihilation. If one awakens, there is no fault; it is not a sage's attainment. If one considers it a sage's attainment, then an emptiness demon enters his heart, and he slanders upholding precepts as Hinayana (Small Vehicle). Bodhisattvas realize emptiness; what is there to uphold or violate? This person often"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "Cutting his flesh. Delighting in relinquishing life. Or constantly worrying, entering the mountains and forests, unable to bear seeing people. Losing proper samadhi, he should fall from this. Furthermore, those virtuous men in samadhi, seeing the skandha of form (rupa-skandha) dissolve and the skandha of feeling (vedana-skandha) become clear, residing in purity, after their minds are at peace, suddenly and naturally give rise to boundless joy, their hearts delighted, unable to stop. This is called light ease without wisdom to restrain oneself. If one awakens, there is no fault; it is not a sage's attainment. If one considers it a sage's attainment, then a portion of a delight-in-joy demon enters his heart. Upon seeing people, he laughs. By the roadside, he sings and dances by himself, claiming to have attained unobstructed liberation. Losing proper samadhi, he should fall from this. Furthermore, those virtuous men in samadhi, seeing the skandha of form dissolve and the skandha of feeling become clear, thinking they have attained enough, suddenly a groundless great arrogance arises. Like this, even to arrogance (mana), excessive arrogance (ati-mana), and arrogance beyond arrogance (mana-ati-mana), or increased arrogance (adhimana), or inferior arrogance (avamana), all arise at once. In their hearts, they even belittle the Tathagatas (Buddhas) of the ten directions, let alone the lower-ranking Shravakas (Voice-Hearers) and Pratyekabuddhas (Solitary Buddhas). This is called seeing superiority without wisdom to save oneself. If one awakens, there is no fault; it is not a sage's attainment. If one considers it a sage's attainment, then a portion of a great arrogance demon enters his heart. He does not bow to stupas and temples, destroys sutras and images, and says to donors: 'This is gold and copper, or earth and wood. Sutras are tree leaves, or woolen fabrics. The physical body is truly constant. Not respecting oneself, yet revering earth and wood, is truly inverted.' Those who deeply believe him follow his destruction, burying and discarding them in the ground, causing doubt and misleading sentient beings, entering the Avici Hell. Losing proper samadhi, he should fall from this. Furthermore, those virtuous men in samadhi, seeing the skandha of form dissolve and the skandha of feeling become clear, within the essence of brightness, fully realizing the subtle principles, attaining great compliance, their hearts suddenly give rise to immeasurable light ease, and they declare themselves to have become sages, attaining great freedom. This is called obtaining various light purities due to wisdom. If one awakens, there is no fault; it is not a sage's attainment. If one considers it a sage's attainment, then a portion of a delight-in-light-purity demon enters his heart. He considers himself satisfied and no longer seeks to advance. Many of these become unlearned Bhikshus (monks), causing doubt and misleading sentient beings, falling into the Avici Hell. Losing proper samadhi, he should fall from this. Furthermore, those virtuous men in samadhi, seeing the skandha of form dissolve and the skandha of feeling become clear, within the brightness of awakening, attaining the nature of emptiness and brightness, within which they suddenly turn towards eternal annihilation, denying cause and effect, single-mindedly entering emptiness, the mind of emptiness appearing before them, even to the point of giving rise to a view of annihilation. If one awakens, there is no fault; it is not a sage's attainment. If one considers it a sage's attainment, then an emptiness demon enters his heart, and he slanders upholding precepts as Hinayana (Small Vehicle). Bodhisattvas realize emptiness; what is there to uphold or violate? This person often"
  ]
}

信心檀越。飲酒啖肉。廣行淫穢。因魔力故。攝其前人。不生疑謗。鬼心久入。或食屎尿。與酒肉等。一種俱空。破佛律儀。誤入人罪。失於正受。當從淪墜。又彼定中諸善男子。見色陰銷。受陰明白。味其虛明。深入心骨。其心忽有無限愛生。愛極發狂。便為貪慾。此名定境安順入心。無慧自持。誤入諸欲。悟則無咎。非為聖證。若作聖解。則有欲魔入其心腑。一向說欲為菩提道。化諸白衣。平等行欲。其行淫者。名持法子。神鬼力故。于末世中。攝其凡愚。其數至百。如是乃至一百二百。或五六百。多滿千萬。魔心生厭。離其身體。威德既無。陷於王難。疑誤眾生。入無間獄。失於正受。當從淪墜阿難。如是十種禪那現境。皆是受陰用心互動。故現斯事。眾生頑迷。不自忖量。逢此因緣。迷不自識。謂言登聖。大妄語成。墮無間獄。汝等亦當將如來語。於我滅后。傳示末法。遍令眾生開悟斯義。無令天魔得其方便。保持覆護。成無上道。

  通曰。色陰未銷。則心著於色。見諸異境。魔猶未入於心也。色陰滅而受陰存。受陰蓋指前五識虛能受明能領納。如明鏡中顯現其像。虛明體段。應是佛心。而何以為妄想耶。但生一執著。欲證為實得。便是受陰所覆。而不得謂之正受矣。故受陰未破。則不離五根。如心觸客邪。為魘所縛。雖有虛明而不得用。受陰既破。則明不依根。如魘咎既歇。其心去住自由。而能返觀其面。虛明得用。即超見濁。見大攬受諸境。交織而成濁。今者虛明無復留礙。是先拔其見矣。見根既拔。孰有為見所受者而

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "信心檀越(施主)。飲酒吃肉,廣泛進行淫穢行為,因為有魔力的緣故,迷惑先前的人,使他們不產生懷疑和誹謗。鬼的心長期進入(他們心中),(這些人)或者吃屎尿,把(這些東西)與酒肉等同,一切都變得空虛。破壞佛教的戒律和儀式,錯誤地使人犯罪,失去正確的禪定,應當由此而墮落。此外,那些禪定中的善男子,見到色陰消退,受陰變得明白,品味那虛幻的光明,深入心骨。他們的心中忽然產生無限的愛,愛到極點就發狂,於是就變成了貪慾。這叫做禪定境界的安順進入內心,沒有智慧來把持自己,錯誤地進入各種慾望。如果醒悟了就沒有罪過,(但)這不是聖證。如果當作聖證,那麼就會有欲魔進入他們的心腑,一直說慾望就是菩提道,教化那些在家信徒,平等地進行性行為。那些進行淫亂的人,(被)稱為『持法之子』。因為神鬼的力量,在末世之中,迷惑那些凡夫愚人,人數達到一百,像這樣乃至一百、二百,或者五六百,多到滿一千萬。魔的心生厭倦,離開他們的身體。威德既然沒有了,就會陷入官司牢獄之災,迷惑誤導眾生,進入無間地獄,失去正確的禪定,應當由此而墮落。阿難,像這樣十種禪那(禪定)中出現的境界,都是受陰和用心互動作用的結果,所以顯現這些事情。眾生頑固而迷惑,不自我衡量,遇到這種因緣,迷惑而不認識自己,說自己已經登上了聖位,犯下大妄語,墮入無間地獄。你們也應當將如來的話,在我滅度之後,傳示給末法時代,普遍地讓眾生開悟這個道理,不要讓天魔得到可乘之機,保持和守護(正法),成就無上的道。",
    
    "通曰:色陰沒有消退,那麼心就執著於色,見到各種奇異的境界,魔還沒有進入心中。色陰滅了而受陰存在,受陰大概是指前五識虛幻而能夠接受光明,能夠領納(境界)。就像明鏡中顯現其影像,虛幻光明的體段,應該是佛心,為什麼會成為妄想呢?只是產生一種執著,想要證實為真實的獲得,這就是被受陰所覆蓋,而不能稱之為正確的禪定了。所以受陰沒有破除,那麼就不離開五根,就像心接觸了邪惡的客人,被魘所束縛,雖然有虛幻的光明卻不能使用。受陰既然破除了,那麼光明就不依賴於五根,就像魘的災禍已經停止,他的心去留自由,而能夠反觀自己的面容,虛幻的光明得以使用,就超越了見濁。見大攬受各種境界,交織而成濁,現在虛幻的光明不再有阻礙,這是先拔除了他的見。見根既然拔除了,誰還有被見所接受的呢?"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Faithful *Dānpati* (benefactors), drinking alcohol and eating meat, widely engaging in lewd acts, due to the power of demons, they delude those who came before, preventing them from generating doubts and slanders. The demon's heart enters (their minds) for a long time, (these people) may even eat excrement and urine, equating (these things) with alcohol and meat, everything becomes empty. They break the Buddhist precepts and rituals, wrongly causing people to commit sins, losing the correct *samādhi* (meditative absorption), they should fall from this. Furthermore, those good men in *samādhi*, seeing the *rūpa-skandha* (form aggregate) diminish and the *vedanā-skandha* (feeling aggregate) become clear, savor that illusory brightness, deeply penetrating their hearts and bones. Suddenly, infinite love arises in their hearts, and when love reaches its extreme, they go mad, and thus become greed. This is called the peaceful entry of the *samādhi* state into the heart, without wisdom to restrain oneself, mistakenly entering various desires. If they awaken, there is no fault, (but) this is not a saintly attainment. If they regard it as saintly attainment, then a desire demon will enter their hearts, constantly saying that desire is the *bodhi* path, transforming those laypeople, equally engaging in sexual acts. Those who engage in promiscuity are called 'sons of the Dharma'. Because of the power of gods and demons, in the *mādhya-kāla* (latter days), they delude those ordinary and foolish people, the number reaching one hundred, like this, even one hundred, two hundred, or five or six hundred, up to ten million. The demon's heart becomes weary and leaves their bodies. Since their power and virtue are gone, they will fall into the disaster of lawsuits and imprisonment, deluding and misleading sentient beings, entering the *Avīci* (uninterrupted) hell, losing the correct *samādhi*, they should fall from this. Ānanda, these ten kinds of *dhyāna* (meditation) states that appear are all the result of the interaction between the *vedanā-skandha* and the use of the mind, so these things appear. Sentient beings are stubborn and deluded, not measuring themselves, encountering this kind of cause and condition, they are deluded and do not recognize themselves, saying that they have ascended to the saintly position, committing a great lie, falling into the *Avīci* hell. You should also take the words of the *Tathāgata* (Thus Come One), after my *parinirvana* (final passing), transmit them to the *mādhya-kāla*, universally letting sentient beings awaken to this principle, not allowing the heavenly demons to obtain an opportunity, maintaining and protecting (the Dharma), accomplishing the unsurpassed path.",
    
    "Tong said: If the *rūpa-skandha* has not diminished, then the mind is attached to form, seeing various strange states, the demon has not yet entered the heart. If the *rūpa-skandha* is extinguished and the *vedanā-skandha* exists, the *vedanā-skandha* probably refers to the first five consciousnesses, which are illusory and able to receive light, able to receive (states). Just like images appear in a clear mirror, the illusory bright substance should be the Buddha-heart, why would it become delusion? It is just that a kind of attachment arises, wanting to prove it as a real attainment, this is being covered by the *vedanā-skandha*, and cannot be called the correct *samādhi*. Therefore, if the *vedanā-skandha* is not broken, then it does not leave the five roots, just like the heart touches an evil guest, being bound by a nightmare, although there is illusory brightness, it cannot be used. Since the *vedanā-skandha* has been broken, then the brightness does not rely on the five roots, just like the disaster of the nightmare has stopped, his heart is free to go and stay, and is able to reflect on his own face, the illusory brightness can be used, and he transcends the turbidity of seeing. Seeing greatly embraces various states, intertwined to form turbidity, now the illusory brightness no longer has obstacles, this is first pulling out his seeing. Since the root of seeing has been pulled out, who is there to be received by seeing?"
  ]
}

為之濁乎。色陰未銷。心未發光。色陰既盡。得大光耀。即是虛明妄想。有正悟者。視此虛明亦屬境耳。唯精研妙明。內抑過分。則忘我之極。視物皆我。故視蚊虻如赤子而悲心生。虛明現前。感激過分。故謂諸佛可齊而勇心生。定強智微。則新故之間。杳無所依。故沉憶不散。心懸一處。而自以為精進。慧力過定。則自疑是佛。易生止足。故溺於知見。自謂已得光明遍照。不但諸佛可齊已也。進退失據。自生艱險。謂吾有大患。為有此身。常求害命。早取解脫。不但沉憶不散已也。處清凈中。心安穩后。無復艱險之憂。則有無限喜生。喜得無礙解脫。而歌舞失度。由無慧以自禁也。喜極自足。則大我慢生。慢有七種。所謂慢。過慢。慢過慢。增上慢。下劣慢。我慢。邪慢。慢不敬也。過慢。謂已過彼而慢之。慢過慢。兼二慢。既不敬。又作意凌之也。增上。謂己增上故。卑劣慢。慢尊勝者故。我慢。計蘊有我。以我慢故。邪慢。慢正故。以于定中緣持正法。故不言邪慢。增上未得謂得。卑劣以劣自矜。所以慢尊勝也。若有慧力。圓悟精理。色銷明圓。得大輕安。輕安在七覺支中。其體屬定。定若兼慧。正道可通。但以此自足。更不求進。坐在輕清窟中。故為無聞比丘也。若舍念清凈。一向入空。生斷滅解。撥無因果。乃謗持戒為小乘果。菩薩悟空。則無持犯。因而破毀律儀。雖彼自以為超脫。而不知為魔所使也。受陰虛明。不貪其味。則愛慾不生。唯愛極發狂。誤入諸欲。則煩惱與欲。二境俱發。天臺云。生來欲色。抑制可停。今所發者

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "會因此變得渾濁嗎?如果色陰(rupa-skandha,五蘊之一,指物質現象)尚未消散,心就無法發出光明。一旦色陰完全消散,就能獲得巨大的光明照耀,但這實際上是虛幻的光明妄想。真正覺悟的人會認為這種虛幻的光明也只是一種境界而已。如果只是專注于精研微妙的明性,過度地壓抑自己,就會達到忘我的極端狀態,以至於看任何事物都覺得是自己,所以看到蚊子、牛虻就像看到自己的孩子一樣而生起悲憫之心。虛幻的光明顯現時,如果過度地激動,就會認為自己可以與諸佛平起平坐,從而生起勇猛之心。如果禪定很強而智慧不足,那麼在新境界和舊境界之間,就會茫然不知所措,因此沉溺於回憶而無法擺脫,心思懸掛在一個地方,還自以為是在精進。如果智慧超過禪定,就會懷疑自己是不是佛,容易產生滿足感,因此沉溺於自己的知見,自認為已經獲得了光明遍照的能力,不僅僅是與諸佛平起平坐而已。這樣進退失據,自然會產生危險,認為自己最大的禍患就是擁有這個身體,常常想要自殺,早點獲得解脫,這不僅僅是沉溺於回憶而無法擺脫而已。如果身處清凈的環境中,內心安定之後,沒有了危險的憂慮,就會產生無限的喜悅,喜悅自己獲得了無礙的解脫,從而歌舞失態,這是因為沒有智慧來約束自己。喜悅到了極點就會產生極大的我慢,我慢有七種,分別是:慢(mana,傲慢),過慢(atimana,過度的傲慢),慢過慢(manamana,比過慢更甚的傲慢),增上慢(adhimana,未證言證的傲慢),下劣慢(unamana,以不如自己的人為傲慢的對象),我慢(asmimana,執著於我的傲慢),邪慢(micchamana,錯誤的傲慢)。慢是不恭敬。過慢是認為自己已經超過了別人而傲慢。慢過慢是兼具了慢和過慢兩種。既不恭敬,又故意凌辱別人。增上慢是認為自己已經增上了。卑劣慢是以不如自己的人為傲慢的對象。我慢是認為五蘊中有我,因此產生傲慢。邪慢是對正法的傲慢。因為在禪定中緣持正法,所以這裡不談邪慢。增上慢是沒有證得卻說自己證得了,卑劣慢是以自己的低下為傲慢,所以才會輕視尊勝者。如果具有智慧,圓滿地領悟了精深的道理,色陰消散,光明圓滿,就能獲得極大的輕安(prasrabdhi,身心輕快安適)。輕安在七覺支(sapta bojjhanga,七種覺悟的要素)中,它的本體屬於禪定。禪定如果兼具智慧,就能通往正道。但如果因此就感到滿足,不再尋求進步,只是坐在輕清的窟穴中,那就是無聞比丘(aranyakabhiksu,住在寂靜處的比丘)了。如果捨棄正念清凈,一味地進入空性,產生斷滅的見解,否定因果,就會誹謗持戒是小乘的果報。菩薩(bodhisattva,立志成佛的修行者)證悟空性,就沒有持戒和犯戒的分別,因此破壞戒律。雖然他們自認為已經超脫,卻不知道是被魔所利用了。如果受陰(vedana-skandha,五蘊之一,指感受)顯現虛明,不貪戀其中的滋味,那麼愛慾就不會產生。如果愛慾過度地爆發,誤入各種慾望之中,那麼煩惱和慾望兩種境界都會同時發生。天臺宗(Tiantai,中國佛教宗派)說,天生的慾望和色慾,可以通過抑制來停止,現在所發生的..."
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Will it become turbid because of this? If the rupa-skandha (form aggregate, one of the five skandhas, referring to material phenomena) has not yet dissipated, the mind cannot emit light. Once the rupa-skandha has completely dissipated, one can obtain great radiant illumination, but this is actually illusory bright delusion. Those who are truly enlightened will consider this illusory brightness to be just a state. If one only focuses on diligently studying the subtle brightness, excessively suppressing oneself, one will reach the extreme state of selflessness, to the extent that one sees everything as oneself, so seeing mosquitoes and gadflies is like seeing one's own children, and compassion arises. When illusory brightness appears, if one is excessively excited, one will think that one can be on par with all Buddhas, thus generating a courageous mind. If samadhi (concentration) is strong but wisdom is insufficient, then between the new and old states, one will be at a loss, so one indulges in memories and cannot get rid of them, the mind hangs in one place, and one thinks that one is being diligent. If wisdom exceeds samadhi, one will suspect that one is a Buddha, easily generating a sense of satisfaction, thus indulging in one's own views, thinking that one has obtained the ability of radiant illumination, not just being on par with all Buddhas. Advancing and retreating without a basis, danger will naturally arise, thinking that one's greatest trouble is having this body, often wanting to commit suicide, to obtain liberation early, this is not just indulging in memories and not being able to get rid of them. If one is in a pure environment, after the mind is stable, without the worry of danger, infinite joy will arise, rejoicing that one has obtained unobstructed liberation, thus singing and dancing out of control, this is because one does not have wisdom to restrain oneself. When joy reaches its extreme, great arrogance will arise, there are seven types of arrogance, namely: mana (arrogance), atimana (excessive arrogance), manamana (arrogance beyond excessive arrogance), adhimana (presumption of attainment), unamana (contempt for inferiors), asmimana (self-conceit), micchamana (wrong arrogance). Mana is disrespect. Atimana is being arrogant because one thinks one has surpassed others. Manamana combines mana and atimana. It is both disrespectful and deliberately insulting to others. Adhimana is thinking that one has increased. Unamana is being arrogant with those who are inferior to oneself. Asmimana is thinking that the five skandhas have a self, thus generating arrogance. Micchamana is arrogance towards the Dharma. Because one relies on the Dharma in samadhi, wrong arrogance is not mentioned here. Adhimana is saying that one has attained what one has not attained, unamana is being arrogant with one's own inferiority, so one despises the venerable. If one has wisdom, fully understands the profound principles, the rupa-skandha dissipates, the light is complete, one can obtain great prasrabdhi (ease and tranquility of body and mind). Prasrabdhi is in the sapta bojjhanga (seven factors of enlightenment), its essence belongs to samadhi. If samadhi is combined with wisdom, one can reach the right path. But if one is satisfied with this, and no longer seeks progress, just sitting in the light and pure cave, then one is an aranyakabhiksu (a bhikkhu living in a secluded place). If one abandons right mindfulness and purity, and enters emptiness in one direction, generating the view of annihilation, denying cause and effect, one will slander that holding precepts is the fruit of the Hinayana. Bodhisattvas (beings who aspire to Buddhahood) realize emptiness, there is no distinction between holding and breaking precepts, thus destroying the precepts. Although they think they have transcended, they do not know that they are being used by demons. If the vedana-skandha (feeling aggregate, one of the five skandhas, referring to feelings) manifests brightness, and one does not crave its taste, then desire will not arise. If desire excessively erupts, mistakenly entering various desires, then both the realms of afflictions and desires will occur simultaneously. The Tiantai school (a Chinese Buddhist school) says that innate desires and lust can be stopped by suppression, what is happening now..."
  ]
}

。其惑熾盛。若見外境。心狂眼暗。如睡師子。觸之哮吼。若不識者。則能牽人作大重罪。一念之愛。流毒至此。由挾持定境。其發最猛利。而其害最大也。如是十種。皆由得虛明性。用禪那心。與虛明妄想。交為勝負。故各有所著。若悲狂憶慢憂愁行淫。明是著魔。大般若經曰。魔能入一切眾生心。令歸依魔黨。如膠如漆。斷手截臂。不以為難。魔力所攝固如此至安穩輕安空心現前自信是佛。何為失於正受。蓋正受者未嘗不虛。未嘗不明。終不作虛明解。法華經曰。深著虛妄法。堅受不可舍。乃謗持戒等。故但存佛見於胸中。即是魔也。降魔藏見北宗秀。秀問汝名降魔。此無山精木怪。汝翻作魔耶。曰有佛有魔。秀曰。汝若是魔。必住不思議境界。曰。是佛亦空。何境界之有。又祇林和尚。每叱文殊普賢為精魅。手持木劍。自謂降魔。才見僧來參。便說魔來也。魔來也。以劍亂揮。歸方丈。如是十年。後置劍無言。僧問十二年前。為甚麼降魔。曰賊不打貧兒家。曰十二年後。為甚麼不降魔。曰賊不打貧兒家。故始以降降魔。既以不降降魔。若二降魔者。真不作聖心解者也。唯不作聖心解。故非魔作。臨濟至初祖塔。院主云。先禮佛先禮祖。濟云。佛祖俱不禮。院主云。佛祖與你有甚冤家。濟拂袖便出。茲非不禮塔廟者乎。丹霞于慧林寺。遇天大寒。取木佛燒火向。院主訶云。何得燒我木佛。霞以杖子撥灰曰。吾燒取捨利。主云。木佛何有舍利。霞雲。既無舍利。更取兩尊燒。主自後鬚眉墮落。投子拈曰。不會為客。煩勞主人。頌曰。古巖

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本:",
    "他們的迷惑熾盛。如果見到外境,心神狂亂,眼睛昏暗,就像沉睡的獅子,觸碰它就會怒吼。如果不認識到這一點,就會被牽引著做出極大的罪惡。一念的愛慾,流毒竟然到了這種地步,這是因為挾持著禪定的境界,所以它的發作才最猛烈,而它的危害也最大。像這樣的十種情況,都是因為得到了虛明的自性,卻用禪那的心,與虛明的妄想,互相爭鬥勝負,所以各自有所執著。如果出現悲傷、狂亂、憶念、傲慢、憂愁、行淫等情況,明顯是著魔了。《大般若經》說,魔能進入一切眾生的心中,使他們歸依魔的黨羽,像膠和漆一樣牢固,即使斷手截臂,也不覺得困難。魔力攝持的穩固程度竟然如此,以至於把安穩、輕安、空心現前、自信是佛,當作是真正的解脫。為什麼會失去正受呢?因為真正的正受,未嘗不是虛空的,未嘗不是光明的,但始終不會把虛空和光明當作一種解釋。 《法華經》說,深深地執著于虛妄的法,堅決地接受而不可捨棄,甚至誹謗持戒等行為。所以,如果只是把佛的見解存放在心中,那就是魔了。降魔藏去拜見北宗慧能的弟子神秀。神秀問:『你的名字叫降魔,這裡沒有山精木怪,你降的是什麼魔呢?』降魔藏說:『有佛就有魔。』神秀說:『你如果是魔,必定住在不可思議的境界中。』降魔藏說:『佛也是空的,哪裡有什麼境界呢?』又有祇林和尚,經常呵斥文殊菩薩和普賢菩薩是精魅,手持木劍,自稱降魔。才見到僧人來參拜,就說:『魔來了!魔來了!』用劍亂揮,然後回到方丈。像這樣過了十年,後來放下劍,不再說話。僧人問:『十二年前,你為什麼要降魔?』祇林和尚說:『賊不打貧兒家。』僧人問:『十二年後,你為什麼不降魔了?』祇林和尚說:『賊不打貧兒家。』所以,開始用降魔來降魔,後來用不降魔來降魔。像這樣兩種降魔的方式,都是真正不作聖心解的人。正因為不作聖心解,所以不是魔所能作為的。臨濟禪師到初祖塔(菩提達摩塔)時,院主問:『先禮佛還是先禮祖?』臨濟禪師說:『佛祖都不禮。』院主問:『佛祖與你有什麼冤仇?』臨濟禪師拂袖便走。這難道是不禮塔廟嗎?丹霞禪師在慧林寺,遇到天寒冷,就取木佛燒火取暖。院主呵斥說:『怎麼能燒我的木佛?』丹霞禪師用杖子撥開灰燼說:『我燒取捨利。』院主說:『木佛哪裡有舍利?』丹霞禪師說:『既然沒有舍利,再取兩尊燒。』院主自此以後鬚眉脫落。投子禪師拈起這件事說:『不會做客人,煩勞了主人。』並作頌說:古巖……"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version:",
    "Their delusion is intense. If they see external objects, their minds become deranged and their eyes darkened, like a sleeping lion that roars when touched. If they do not recognize this, they will be led to commit great sins. The poison of a single thought of love can reach such a degree because it is supported by the state of Samadhi, so its outbreak is most violent, and its harm is greatest. These ten conditions all arise because they have obtained the nature of illusory clarity but use the mind of Dhyana to contend with illusory thoughts of clarity, so they each have their attachments. If there is sadness, madness, remembrance, arrogance, worry, or sexual indulgence, it is clearly demonic possession. The *Mahaprajnaparamita Sutra* says that demons can enter the minds of all beings, causing them to rely on the demonic party, as firmly as glue or lacquer, so that they would not find it difficult to cut off their hands or arms. The power of the demons holds them so securely that they regard stability, ease, emptiness, and self-confidence as Buddhahood. Why do they lose the correct reception (Skt. *samyag-dṛṣṭi*)? Because the correct reception is never not empty, never not clear, but it never interprets emptiness and clarity as an explanation. The *Lotus Sutra* says that they are deeply attached to false dharmas, firmly accepting them and unwilling to abandon them, even to the point of slandering those who uphold the precepts. Therefore, if one merely keeps the view of the Buddha in one's mind, that is a demon. Jiangmo Zang (降魔藏, meaning 'Demon-Subduing Treasure') went to see Shenxiu (神秀, 606-706), a disciple of the Northern School of Chan. Shenxiu asked, 'Your name is Jiangmo, but there are no mountain spirits or tree demons here. What demons are you subduing?' Jiangmo Zang said, 'Where there is Buddha, there is demon.' Shenxiu said, 'If you are a demon, you must dwell in an inconceivable realm.' Jiangmo Zang said, 'Buddha is also empty, so what realm is there?' Furthermore, the Abbot of Qilin Monastery often scolded Manjushri Bodhisattva and Samantabhadra Bodhisattva as goblins, holding a wooden sword and claiming to subdue demons. As soon as he saw a monk coming to visit, he would say, 'The demon is here! The demon is here!' He would wave the sword wildly and then return to his abbot's quarters. He did this for ten years, and then he put down the sword and stopped speaking. A monk asked, 'Twelve years ago, why were you subduing demons?' The Abbot of Qilin Monastery said, 'Thieves don't rob poor people's houses.' The monk asked, 'Twelve years later, why aren't you subduing demons?' The Abbot of Qilin Monastery said, 'Thieves don't rob poor people's houses.' Therefore, he began by subduing demons with subduing demons, and later he subdued demons with not subduing demons. These two ways of subduing demons are truly those who do not interpret with a saintly mind. Precisely because they do not interpret with a saintly mind, they are not made by demons. When Linji (臨濟, died 866) arrived at the stupa of the First Patriarch (Bodhidharma), the abbot of the monastery asked, 'Do you bow to the Buddha first or to the Patriarch first?' Linji said, 'I bow to neither Buddha nor Patriarch.' The abbot asked, 'What grievance do you have with the Buddha and the Patriarch?' Linji flicked his sleeves and left. Is this not bowing to stupas and temples? When Danxia (丹霞, 739-824) was at Huilin Monastery, he encountered extremely cold weather, so he took a wooden Buddha and burned it for warmth. The abbot scolded him, 'How can you burn my wooden Buddha?' Danxia stirred the ashes with his staff and said, 'I am burning it to extract relics.' The abbot said, 'How can there be relics in a wooden Buddha?' Danxia said, 'Since there are no relics, I will take two more to burn.' From then on, the abbot's eyebrows and beard fell out. Touzi (投子, died 915) picked up on this incident and said, 'Not knowing how to be a guest, he troubled the host.' He composed a verse saying: Ancient Cliff..."
  ]
}

苔閉冷侵扉。飛者驚危走者迷。夜深寒爇汀州火。失曉漁翁輒自疑。茲非摧毀經像者乎。正為兩院主有佛祖魔。有經像魔。橫于胸次。臨濟丹霞。用出格手段拔之。竟不覺悟。大人境界。非庸眾所知。信哉。

  阿難。彼善男子。修三摩提。受陰盡者。雖未漏盡。心離其形。如鳥出籠。已能成就。從是凡身。上歷菩薩六十聖位。得意生身。隨往無礙。譬如有人。熟寐寱言。是人雖則無別所知。其言已成音韻倫次。令不寐者。咸悟其語。此則名為想陰區宇。若動念盡。浮想銷除。于覺明心。如去塵垢。一倫生死。首尾圓照。名想陰盡。是人則能超煩惱濁。觀其所由。融通妄想以為其本。阿難。彼善男子受陰虛妙。不遭邪慮。圓定發明。三摩地中。心愛圓明。銳其精思。貪求善巧。爾時天魔候得其便。飛精附人。口說經法。其人不覺是其魔著。自言謂得無上涅槃。來彼求巧善男子處。敷座說法。其形斯須或作比丘。令彼人見。或為帝釋。或為婦女。或比丘尼。或寢暗室。身有光明。是人愚迷。惑為菩薩。信其教化搖盪其心。破佛律儀。潛行貪慾。口中好言災祥變異。或言如來某處出世。或言劫火。或說刀兵。恐怖於人。令其家資無故耗散。此名怪鬼年老成魔。惱亂是人。厭足心生。去彼人體。弟子與師。俱陷王難。汝當先覺。不入輪迴。迷惑不知。墮無間獄。阿難。又善男子受陰虛妙。不遭邪慮。圓定發明。三摩地中。心愛遊蕩。飛其精思。貪求經歷。爾時天魔候得其便。飛精附人。口說經法。其人亦不覺知魔著。亦言自得無上涅槃。來彼

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "苔蘚封閉,寒冷侵襲著簡陋的門戶。飛行的鳥驚慌,行走的人迷失方向。夜深了,在汀州點燃篝火取暖,天亮時漁翁反而自己感到疑惑。這難道不是那些摧毀佛經佛像的人嗎?正是因為兩院的主持心中有佛祖的魔障,有經像的魔障,橫亙在胸中。臨濟禪師和丹霞禪師用超越常規的手段來拔除這些魔障,但他們竟然不覺悟。大人的境界,不是平庸之輩所能理解的。真是這樣啊。",
    
    "阿難(佛陀十大弟子之一)。那些修行三摩提(佛教的定)的善男子,如果受陰(五蘊之一)已經消盡,即使還沒有完全斷除煩惱,心也能脫離形體,就像鳥兒飛出籠子一樣,已經能夠成就。從此凡身開始,向上經歷菩薩的六十個聖位,獲得意生身(隨心所欲化生的身體),隨心所欲地前往任何地方,沒有任何阻礙。就像有人熟睡時說夢話一樣,這個人雖然沒有什麼特別的意識,但他說的話已經形成音韻和條理,讓沒有睡著的人都能聽懂他的話。這叫做想陰(五蘊之一)的區域。如果動念完全停止,浮動的想法都消失了,在覺悟明凈的心中,就像去除了塵垢一樣,能夠從頭到尾圓滿地照見一生的生死輪迴,這叫做想陰消盡。這個人就能超越煩惱的污濁。觀察他煩惱的根源,原來是融通了虛妄的念頭作為根本。",
    
    "阿難(佛陀十大弟子之一)。那些善男子,如果受陰(五蘊之一)虛空而微妙,沒有遭遇邪惡的思慮,圓滿的禪定得以顯發,在三摩提(佛教的定)中,內心喜愛圓滿光明,銳利地思考,貪求巧妙的法門。這時,天魔(佛教中的魔)就伺機而動,將精氣附著在人身上,通過他的口說經法。那個人自己卻沒有察覺是被魔附身,還自稱得到了無上的涅槃(佛教的最高境界)。來到那些追求巧妙法門的善男子那裡,鋪設座位,宣講佛法。他的形體一會兒變成比丘(出家男眾),讓那些人看到;一會兒變成帝釋(佛教護法神),一會兒變成婦女,一會兒變成比丘尼(出家女眾),或者在黑暗的房間里,身上發出光明。這些人愚昧迷惑,把他當作菩薩,相信他的教化,動搖自己的心,破壞佛教的戒律,暗中進行貪慾的行為,口中喜歡說災禍祥瑞和變異的事情,或者說如來(佛陀的稱號)在某個地方出世,或者說劫火(世界末日的火災),或者說刀兵(戰爭),用這些來恐嚇人們,使他們的家產無緣無故地耗散。這叫做怪鬼年老成魔,惱亂這些人。等到他厭倦滿足了,就離開那個人的身體。他的弟子和老師,都會一起陷入牢獄之災。你應該先覺悟,才不會進入輪迴。迷惑不知,就會墮入無間地獄。",
    
    "阿難(佛陀十大弟子之一)。還有那些善男子,如果受陰(五蘊之一)虛空而微妙,沒有遭遇邪惡的思慮,圓滿的禪定得以顯發,在三摩提(佛教的定)中,內心喜愛遊蕩,放飛自己的精思,貪求經歷各種境界。這時,天魔(佛教中的魔)就伺機而動,將精氣附著在人身上,通過他的口說經法。那個人自己也沒有察覺是被魔附身,也說自己得到了無上的涅槃(佛教的最高境界)。來到那些"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Moss closes the cold, invading the humble door. Flying creatures are startled and those walking lose their way. Deep in the night, a fire is lit in Tingzhou for warmth, but at dawn, the fisherman doubts himself. Are these not the ones who destroy Buddhist scriptures and images? It is precisely because the abbots of the two monasteries have the demons of the Buddha and the demons of scriptures and images, lying across their chests. Linji and Danxia used unconventional means to remove these demons, but they still did not awaken. The realm of great beings is not understood by ordinary people. Truly so.",
    
    "Ananda (one of the ten principal disciples of the Buddha). Those good men who cultivate Samadhi (Buddhist meditation), if the Skandha of Sensation (one of the five aggregates) is exhausted, even if they have not completely eradicated defilements, their minds can leave their bodies, like a bird escaping its cage, and they are able to achieve. From this ordinary body, they ascend through the sixty holy positions of Bodhisattvas, attain the 'Ideational Body' (a body created at will), and go anywhere without hindrance. It is like someone talking in their sleep; although they have no particular awareness, their words form sounds and order, allowing those who are awake to understand them. This is called the realm of the Skandha of Conception. If wandering thoughts cease completely, and floating ideas are eliminated, in the awakened and clear mind, it is like removing dust and dirt, and one can completely illuminate the cycle of birth and death from beginning to end. This is called the exhaustion of the Skandha of Conception. This person can then transcend the turbidity of afflictions. Observing the source of their afflictions, it is found that they are rooted in the fusion of false thoughts.",
    
    "Ananda (one of the ten principal disciples of the Buddha). Those good men, if the Skandha of Sensation is empty and subtle, and they do not encounter evil thoughts, and perfect concentration is manifested, in Samadhi, their minds love perfect brightness, they sharpen their thoughts, and greedily seek skillful methods. At this time, the heavenly demons (demons in Buddhism) seize the opportunity, attach their essence to a person, and speak scriptures through their mouth. That person does not realize that they are possessed by a demon, and claims to have attained unsurpassed Nirvana (the highest state in Buddhism). They come to those good men who seek skillful methods, set up a seat, and preach the Dharma. Their form sometimes transforms into a Bhikkhu (Buddhist monk), for those people to see; sometimes into Indra (Buddhist protector deity), sometimes into a woman, sometimes into a Bhikkhuni (Buddhist nun), or in a dark room, their body emits light. These people are foolish and deluded, taking them for a Bodhisattva, believing their teachings, shaking their own minds, breaking Buddhist precepts, secretly engaging in greed and desire, and liking to speak of calamities, auspicious signs, and strange occurrences, or saying that the Tathagata (title of the Buddha) has appeared in a certain place, or speaking of the fire of the kalpa (world-ending fire), or speaking of weapons and war, frightening people, causing their family wealth to be dissipated for no reason. This is called a strange ghost becoming a demon in old age, disturbing these people. When they are tired and satisfied, they leave that person's body. Their disciples and teachers will both fall into imprisonment. You should awaken first, so that you do not enter the cycle of rebirth. Being deluded and ignorant, you will fall into the Avici hell (the hell of incessant suffering).",
    
    "Ananda (one of the ten principal disciples of the Buddha). Furthermore, those good men, if the Skandha of Sensation is empty and subtle, and they do not encounter evil thoughts, and perfect concentration is manifested, in Samadhi, their minds love to wander, they let their thoughts fly, and greedily seek to experience various realms. At this time, the heavenly demons (demons in Buddhism) seize the opportunity, attach their essence to a person, and speak scriptures through their mouth. That person also does not realize that they are possessed by a demon, and also says that they have attained unsurpassed Nirvana (the highest state in Buddhism). They come to those"
  ]
}

求游善男子處。敷座說法。自形無變。其聽法者。忽自見身坐寶蓮華。全體化成紫金光聚。一眾聽人。各各如是。得未曾有。是人愚迷。惑為菩薩。淫逸其心。破佛律儀。潛行貪慾。口中好言諸佛應世。某處某人。當是某佛化身來此。某人即是某菩薩等。來化人間。其人見故。心生傾渴。邪見密興。種智銷滅。此名魃鬼。年老成魔。惱亂是人。厭足心生。去彼人體。弟子與師。俱陷王難。汝當先覺。不入輪迴。迷惑不知。墮無間獄。又善男子受陰虛妙。不遭邪慮。圓定發明。三摩地中。心愛綿㳷。澄其精思。貪求契合。爾時天魔候得其便。飛精附人。口說經法。其人實不覺知魔著。亦言自得無上涅槃。來彼求合善男子處。敷座說法。其形及彼聽法之人。外無遷變。令其聽者。未聞法前。心自開悟。唸唸移易。或得宿命。或得他心。或見地獄。或知人間好惡諸事。或口說偈。或自誦經。各各歡娛。得未曾有。是人愚迷。惑為菩薩。綿愛其心。破佛律儀。潛行貪慾。口中好言佛有大小。某佛先佛。某佛后佛。其中亦有真佛假佛。男佛女佛。菩薩亦然。其人見故。洗滌本心。易入邪悟。此名魅鬼。年老成魔。惱亂是人。厭足心生。去彼人體。弟子與師。俱陷王難。汝當先覺。不入輪迴。迷惑不知。墮無間獄。又善男子受陰虛妙。不遭邪魔。圓定發明。三摩地中。心愛根本。窮覽物化。性之終始。精爽其心。貪求辨析。爾時天魔候得其便。飛精附人。口說經法。其人先不覺知魔著。亦言自得無上涅槃。來彼求元善男子處。敷座說法。身有威神。摧伏

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本:",
    "又有一種情況,(如果)有人去親近那些修行有成的善男子,(魔)會佔據他們的座位,宣講佛法。表面上,(這些善男子)自身沒有任何變化。但聽法的人,會忽然覺得自己坐在寶蓮花上,整個身體都化成了紫金色的光芒。所有聽法的人,都各自如此,覺得得到了前所未有的體驗。這種人如果愚昧迷惑,就會誤以為自己成了菩薩,放縱淫慾之心,破壞佛教的戒律,暗地裡行貪婪之事。他們口中喜歡說諸佛應世,說某處某人,應當是某佛的化身來到這裡,某人就是某菩薩等等,來教化人間。其他人因為聽信這些話,心中產生傾慕渴求,邪見暗中滋生,本有的智慧消滅殆盡。這叫做魃鬼,年老之後成了魔,來惱亂這個人。等到厭倦滿足之後,就離開這個人的身體。結果弟子和師父,都會一起陷入牢獄之災。你應當事先覺察,不要陷入輪迴。如果迷惑不知,就會墮入無間地獄。",
    "又有一種情況,(如果)善男子在受陰的虛妙境界中,沒有遇到邪惡的念頭,圓滿的禪定得以開發顯明,在三摩地(Samadhi,禪定)中,心中貪愛綿密的觸感,沉溺於精細的思慮,貪求與(魔)的契合。這時,天魔就會伺機而動,飛出精氣附著在人身上,通過他的口宣說經法。這個人實際上並不知道自己被魔附體,還自稱已經證得了無上涅槃。他們會來到那些尋求結合的善男子處,佔據座位宣講佛法。表面上,他們的形體以及聽法的人,都沒有任何變化。但(魔)會讓聽法的人,在聽法之前,內心就自己開悟,念頭不斷變化,或者得到宿命通,或者得到他心通,或者見到地獄,或者知道人間的好壞諸事,或者口中說出偈語,或者自己誦讀經文,各自歡喜,覺得得到了前所未有的體驗。這種人如果愚昧迷惑,就會誤以為自己成了菩薩,貪戀綿密的觸感,破壞佛教的戒律,暗地裡行貪婪之事。他們口中喜歡說佛有大小,說某佛是先佛,某佛是后佛,其中也有真佛假佛,男佛女佛,菩薩也是如此。其他人因為聽信這些話,洗滌了原本的心,容易陷入邪悟。這叫做魅鬼,年老之後成了魔,來惱亂這個人。等到厭倦滿足之後,就離開這個人的身體。結果弟子和師父,都會一起陷入牢獄之災。你應當事先覺察,不要陷入輪迴。如果迷惑不知,就會墮入無間地獄。",
    "又有一種情況,(如果)善男子在受陰的虛妙境界中,沒有遇到邪魔,圓滿的禪定得以開發顯明,在三摩地(Samadhi,禪定)中,心中貪愛探究事物的根本,窮盡觀察萬物的變化,以及事物本性的始終,精研分析自己的心念,貪求辨別分析。這時,天魔就會伺機而動,飛出精氣附著在人身上,通過他的口宣說經法。這個人一開始並不知道自己被魔附體,還自稱已經證得了無上涅槃。他們會來到那些尋求本源的善男子處,佔據座位宣講佛法,身上散發著威嚴神力,摧伏(他人)。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version:",
    "Furthermore, there is a situation where (if) someone approaches those virtuous men who have attained some level of cultivation, (the demon) will occupy their seats and preach the Dharma. On the surface, (these virtuous men) themselves undergo no change. However, those who listen to the Dharma will suddenly feel as if they are sitting on a jeweled lotus flower, their entire bodies transformed into a mass of purple-gold light. Each of the listeners experiences this, feeling they have gained something unprecedented. If such a person is ignorant and deluded, they will mistakenly believe they have become a Bodhisattva, indulging in lustful desires, violating the Buddhist precepts, and secretly engaging in greed. They will often speak of Buddhas appearing in the world, saying that someone in a certain place must be an incarnation of a certain Buddha who has come here, or that someone is a certain Bodhisattva, etc., come to teach humanity. Others, hearing these words, develop admiration and craving in their hearts, and heretical views secretly arise, extinguishing their inherent wisdom. This is called a 'Ba' ghost, who becomes a demon in old age, disturbing this person. When they are tired and satisfied, they leave the person's body. As a result, both the disciple and the teacher will fall into imprisonment. You should be aware beforehand and not fall into the cycle of rebirth. If you are confused and unaware, you will fall into the Avici Hell (uninterrupted hell).",
    "Furthermore, there is a situation where (if) a virtuous man, in the subtle and wondrous state of the feeling aggregate, does not encounter evil thoughts, and perfect Samadhi (Samadhi, meditative absorption) is developed and manifested, in Samadhi (Samadhi, meditative absorption), the mind loves subtle and continuous sensations, indulging in refined thoughts, and craving union (with the demon). At this time, the heavenly demon will seize the opportunity, emit its essence and attach itself to a person, speaking the Dharma through their mouth. This person is actually unaware that they are possessed by a demon and even claims to have attained unsurpassed Nirvana. They will come to those virtuous men who seek union, occupy the seat and preach the Dharma. On the surface, their form and the form of those who listen to the Dharma undergo no change. However, (the demon) will cause those who listen to the Dharma to awaken on their own before hearing the Dharma, with their thoughts constantly changing, or gaining knowledge of past lives, or gaining telepathy, or seeing hell, or knowing the good and bad things of the human world, or speaking verses, or reciting scriptures themselves, each rejoicing and feeling they have gained something unprecedented. If such a person is ignorant and deluded, they will mistakenly believe they have become a Bodhisattva, craving subtle sensations, violating the Buddhist precepts, and secretly engaging in greed. They will often say that Buddhas are of different sizes, that a certain Buddha is an earlier Buddha, a certain Buddha is a later Buddha, and that there are true and false Buddhas, male and female Buddhas, and the same is true of Bodhisattvas. Others, hearing these words, cleanse their original minds and easily fall into heretical enlightenment. This is called a 'Mei' ghost, who becomes a demon in old age, disturbing this person. When they are tired and satisfied, they leave the person's body. As a result, both the disciple and the teacher will fall into imprisonment. You should be aware beforehand and not fall into the cycle of rebirth. If you are confused and unaware, you will fall into the Avici Hell (uninterrupted hell).",
    "Furthermore, there is a situation where (if) a virtuous man, in the subtle and wondrous state of the feeling aggregate, does not encounter evil demons, and perfect Samadhi (Samadhi, meditative absorption) is developed and manifested, in Samadhi (Samadhi, meditative absorption), the mind loves to investigate the root of things, exhaustively observing the transformations of all things, and the beginning and end of the nature of things, refining and analyzing their own thoughts, and craving to distinguish and analyze. At this time, the heavenly demon will seize the opportunity, emit its essence and attach itself to a person, speaking the Dharma through their mouth. This person is initially unaware that they are possessed by a demon and even claims to have attained unsurpassed Nirvana. They will come to those virtuous men who seek the origin, occupy the seat and preach the Dharma, radiating a majestic and divine power, subduing (others)."
  ]
}

求者。令其座下。雖未聞法。自然心伏。是諸人等。將佛涅槃菩提法身。即是現前我肉身上。父父子子。遞代相生。即是法身常住不絕。都指現在即為佛國。無別凈居及金色相。其人信受。亡失先心。身命歸依。得未曾有。是等愚迷。惑為菩薩。推究其心。破佛律儀。潛行貪慾。口中好言眼耳鼻舌。皆為凈土。男女二根。即是菩提涅槃真處。彼無知者。信是穢言。此名蠱毒魘勝惡鬼。年老成魔。惱亂是人。厭足心生去彼人體。弟子與師。俱陷王難。汝當先覺。不入輪迴。迷惑不知。墮無間獄。又善男子受陰虛妙。不遭邪慮。圓定發明。三摩地中。心愛懸應。周流精研。貪求冥感。爾時天魔候得其便。飛精附人。口說經法。其人元不覺知魔著。亦言自得無上涅槃。來彼求應善男子處。敷座說法。能令聽眾。暫見其身。如百千歲。心生愛染。不能捨離。身為奴僕。四事供養。不覺疲勞。各各令其座下人心。知是先師本善知識。別生法愛。黏如膠漆。得未曾有。是人愚迷。惑為菩薩。親近其心。破佛律儀。潛行貪慾。口中好言我於前世于某生中。先度某人。當時是我妻妾兄弟。今來相度。與汝相隨歸某世界。供養某佛。或言別有大光明天。佛于中住。一切如來所休居地。彼無知者。信是虛誑。遺失本心。此名癘鬼。年老成魔。惱亂是人。厭足心生去彼人體。弟子與師。俱陷王難。汝當先覺。不入輪迴。迷惑不知。墮無間獄。又善男子受陰虛妙。不遭邪慮。圓定發明三摩地中。心愛深入。克己辛勤。樂處陰寂。貪求靜謐。爾時天魔候得其便。飛精附

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本:",
    "(如果有人)尋求(這種人),即使沒有聽聞佛法,也會自然而然地被其折服。這些人把佛的涅槃、菩提、法身,就說是現在我這肉身上。父親兒子,一代一代地相生,就說是法身常住不絕。都指著現在(的地方)就是佛國,沒有另外的凈居(天)以及金色的佛像。那些人信受了這些話,喪失了原有的正念。把身命都歸依於他,覺得得到了前所未有的東西。這些愚昧迷惑的人,被迷惑認為是菩薩。推究他的內心,(就會發現他)破壞佛的戒律,暗地裡行貪慾之事,口中卻喜歡說眼、耳、鼻、舌都是凈土。男女的二根,就是菩提涅槃的真正之處。那些無知的人,相信這些污穢的言語。這叫做中了蠱毒,被魘魅鎮壓,惡鬼附身。年老之後成了魔,惱亂這些人。滿足了厭惡之心后就離開那人的身體。弟子和師父,都會一起陷入牢獄之災。你應該先覺悟,不進入輪迴。迷惑不知,就會墮入無間地獄。",
    "又,善男子,如果受陰(五陰之一,指感受)空虛玄妙,沒有遇到邪惡的思慮,在圓滿的禪定中發明(智慧),在三摩地(Samadhi,禪定)中,心中喜愛懸空的感應,到處探求精研,貪求這種冥冥中的感應。這時天魔就找到了機會,飛出精氣附在人身上,口中說著經法。那人原本不知道自己被魔附身,也說自己得到了無上涅槃。來到那些尋求感應的善男子處,鋪設座位說法,能讓聽眾暫時看到他的身體,好像百千歲一樣(長壽)。心中產生愛戀染著,不能捨離,身為奴僕,用四事(飲食、衣服、臥具、醫藥)供養,也不覺得疲勞。各自讓座下的人心,知道他是先前的老師、本來的善知識,另外產生對佛法的愛戀,粘著得像膠漆一樣,覺得得到了前所未有的東西。這人愚昧迷惑,被迷惑認為是菩薩。親近他的內心,(就會發現他)破壞佛的戒律,暗地裡行貪慾之事,口中卻喜歡說我於前世,在某一生中,先度了某人,當時是我的妻妾兄弟,現在來度你,與你相隨回到某個世界,供養某佛。或者說另外有大光明天,佛在其中居住,是一切如來所休息的地方。那些無知的人,相信這些虛假的謊言,遺失了本來的真心。這叫做中了癘鬼,年老之後成了魔,惱亂這些人。滿足了厭惡之心后就離開那人的身體。弟子和師父,都會一起陷入牢獄之災。你應該先覺悟,不進入輪迴。迷惑不知,就會墮入無間地獄。",
    "又,善男子,如果受陰空虛玄妙,沒有遇到邪惡的思慮,在圓滿的禪定中發明(智慧),在三摩地(Samadhi,禪定)中,心中喜愛深入(禪定),克制自己,辛勤修行,喜歡處在陰暗寂靜的地方,貪求靜謐。這時天魔就找到了機會,飛出精氣附在(人身上)。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version:",
    "If someone seeks (such a person), even without hearing the Dharma, they will naturally be subdued by him. These people say that the Nirvana, Bodhi, and Dharmakaya of the Buddha are just on this physical body of mine now. Fathers and sons, being born generation after generation, they say is the Dharmakaya constantly abiding and never ceasing. They all point to the present (place) as the Buddha-land, without any other Pure Abode (heaven) or golden Buddha images. Those people believe and accept these words, losing their original right mindfulness. They entrust their lives to him, feeling that they have obtained something unprecedented. These ignorant and deluded people are misled into thinking he is a Bodhisattva. Investigating his heart, (one will find that) he violates the Buddha's precepts, secretly engages in lustful desires, but likes to say that the eyes, ears, nose, and tongue are all Pure Lands. The two roots of male and female are the true places of Bodhi and Nirvana. Those ignorant people believe these filthy words. This is called being poisoned by Gu, being suppressed by witchcraft, and being possessed by evil spirits. After becoming old, he becomes a demon, disturbing these people. After satisfying his loathing, he leaves that person's body. The disciple and the master will both fall into the disaster of imprisonment. You should awaken first, not enter into reincarnation. Being deluded and ignorant, you will fall into the Avici Hell (uninterrupted hell).",
    "Furthermore, good man, if the feeling aggregate (one of the five aggregates, referring to sensation) is empty and profound, and one does not encounter evil thoughts, and develops (wisdom) in perfect Samadhi (禪定), in Samadhi, the mind loves suspended responses, exploring and researching everywhere, greedily seeking this mysterious feeling. At this time, the heavenly demon finds an opportunity, flies out his essence and attaches to a person, speaking scriptures from his mouth. That person originally does not know that he is possessed by a demon, and also says that he has attained unsurpassed Nirvana. He comes to those good men who seek responses, sets up a seat and speaks the Dharma, able to make the audience temporarily see his body as if it were hundreds of thousands of years old (long-lived). Love and attachment arise in their hearts, unable to leave him, serving as slaves, offering the four requisites (food, clothing, bedding, and medicine), without feeling tired. He makes each person under his seat know that he is their former teacher, their original good knowing advisor, and they develop a separate love for the Dharma, sticking like glue, feeling that they have obtained something unprecedented. This person is ignorant and deluded, misled into thinking he is a Bodhisattva. Approaching his heart, (one will find that) he violates the Buddha's precepts, secretly engages in lustful desires, but likes to say that in a previous life, in a certain life, I first saved someone, who was my wife, concubine, or brother at that time, and now I come to save you, to follow me back to a certain world, to make offerings to a certain Buddha. Or he says that there is another Great Light Heaven, where the Buddha dwells, a place where all Tathagatas rest. Those ignorant people believe these false lies, losing their original true mind. This is called being poisoned by a plague demon, becoming a demon after old age, disturbing these people. After satisfying his loathing, he leaves that person's body. The disciple and the master will both fall into the disaster of imprisonment. You should awaken first, not enter into reincarnation. Being deluded and ignorant, you will fall into the Avici Hell (uninterrupted hell).",
    "Furthermore, good man, if the feeling aggregate is empty and profound, and one does not encounter evil thoughts, and develops (wisdom) in perfect Samadhi, in Samadhi, the mind loves to delve deeply (into meditation), restraining oneself, practicing diligently, liking to be in dark and quiet places, greedily seeking tranquility. At this time, the heavenly demon finds an opportunity, flies out his essence and attaches to (a person)."
  ]
}

人。口說經法。其人本不覺知魔著。亦言自得無上涅槃。來彼求陰善男子處。敷座說法。令其聽人。各知本業。或於其處語一人言。汝今未死。已作畜生。敕使一人於後蹋尾。頓令其人起不能得。於是一眾傾心欽伏。有人起心。已知其肇。佛律儀外。重加精苦。誹謗比丘。罵詈徒眾。訐露人事。不避譏嫌。口中好言未然禍福。及至其時。毫髮無失。此大力鬼。年老成魔。惱亂是人。厭足心生去彼人體。弟子與師。俱陷王難。汝當先覺。不入輪迴。迷惑不知。墮無間獄。又善男子受陰虛妙。不遭邪慮。圓定發明三摩地中。心愛知見。勤苦研尋。貪求宿命。爾時天魔候得其便。飛精附人。口說經法。其人殊不覺知魔著。亦言自得無上涅槃。來彼求知善男子處。敷座說法。是人無端于說法處。得大寶珠。其魔或時化為畜生。口銜其珠。及雜珍寶。簡冊符牘。諸奇異物。先授彼人。后著其體。或誘聽人。藏於地下有明月珠。照耀其處。是諸聽者得未曾有。多食藥草。不䬸嘉饌。或時日䬸一麻一麥。其形肥充。魔力持故。誹謗比丘。罵詈徒眾。不避譏嫌。口中好言他方寶藏。十方聖賢潛匿之處。隨其後者。往往見有奇異之人。此名山林土地城隍川岳鬼神。年老成魔。或有宣淫。破佛戒律。與承事者。潛行五欲。或有精進。純食草木。無定行事。惱亂是人。厭足心生。去彼人體。弟子與師。多陷王難。汝當先覺。不入輪迴。迷惑不知。墮無間獄。又善男子受陰虛妙。不遭邪慮。圓定發明。三摩地中心愛神通。種種變化。研究化元。貪取神力。爾時天魔候

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本:",
    "還有一種情況,那人嘴裡說的是經法,但他自己根本沒有覺察到是被魔附體了,還說自己已經證得了無上涅槃(Nirvana)。他來到那些追求陰善的男子那裡,擺設座位,宣講佛法,讓聽眾各自知道自己前世的業報。或者在那個地方對一個人說:『你現在還沒死,就已經變成了畜生。』然後命令一個人在後面踩他的尾巴,那人立刻就站不起來了。於是,所有的人都傾心欽佩信服。有人開始動了念頭,知道了他這種做法的開端。他在佛教的戒律之外,又加上更加精進的苦行,誹謗比丘(Bhikkhu),謾罵僧眾,揭露別人的隱私,不避諱別人的譏諷和嫌疑。嘴裡喜歡說一些還沒有發生的禍福之事,等到事情發生的時候,一點都沒有差錯。這是大力鬼,年紀大了成了魔,來惱亂這個人,滿足了之後就離開這個人的身體。結果弟子和師父,都陷入了牢獄之災。你應該事先覺察到,不要進入輪迴(Samsara)之中,如果迷惑不知,就會墮入無間地獄(Avīci Hell)。",
    "還有,善男子在受陰虛妙的境界中,沒有遇到邪惡的思慮,在圓滿的禪定中發明了三摩地(Samadhi),心中喜愛知見,勤苦地研究探尋,貪求宿命(past lives)。這時,天魔就伺機而動,飛出精氣附在人的身上,嘴裡說的是經法,但這個人一點都沒有覺察到是被魔附體了,還說自己已經證得了無上涅槃(Nirvana)。他來到那些追求知見的善男子那裡,擺設座位,宣講佛法。這個人無緣無故地在說法的地方,得到了一顆大的寶珠。那個魔有時會變化成畜生,嘴裡銜著那顆寶珠,以及各種珍寶、簡冊符牘等奇異之物,先交給那個人,然後再附著在他的身體上。或者引誘聽眾,說地下藏有明月珠,照耀著那個地方。這些聽眾得到了前所未有的體驗。他們大多吃藥草,不吃精美的食物,有時一天只吃一麻一麥,但他們的形體卻很肥胖,這是魔力在支撐的緣故。他們誹謗比丘(Bhikkhu),謾罵僧眾,不避諱別人的譏諷和嫌疑。嘴裡喜歡說一些其他地方的寶藏,十方聖賢潛藏的地方。跟隨他的人,常常會見到一些奇異的人。這些人自稱是山林土地城隍川岳鬼神,年紀大了成了魔。或者有人宣揚淫慾,破壞佛教的戒律,與侍奉他的人,偷偷地進行五欲之事。或者有人精進修行,只吃草木,沒有固定的行爲規範。他們惱亂這個人,滿足了之後,就離開這個人的身體。結果弟子和師父,大多陷入了牢獄之災。你應該事先覺察到,不要進入輪迴(Samsara)之中,如果迷惑不知,就會墮入無間地獄(Avīci Hell)。",
    "還有,善男子在受陰虛妙的境界中,沒有遇到邪惡的思慮,在圓滿的禪定中發明了三摩地(Samadhi),心中喜愛神通,以及種種變化,研究變化的根源,貪取神通之力。這時,天魔就伺機而動。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version:",
    "Furthermore, there is a case where a person speaks of the Dharma, but he himself is completely unaware of being possessed by a demon, and even claims to have attained unsurpassed Nirvana. He comes to those good men seeking Yin virtue, sets up a seat, and preaches the Dharma, causing the listeners to know their past karma. Or in that place, he says to one person, 'You are not yet dead, but you have already become a beast.' Then he orders someone to step on his tail from behind, and that person immediately cannot get up. Thereupon, all the people wholeheartedly admire and believe him. Someone begins to have thoughts, knowing the beginning of his actions. Outside of the Buddhist precepts, he adds even more diligent ascetic practices, slandering Bhikkhus, scolding the Sangha, revealing the privacy of others, and not avoiding the ridicule and suspicion of others. He likes to speak of misfortunes and blessings that have not yet occurred, and when things happen, there is no mistake at all. This is a powerful ghost, who becomes a demon in old age, disturbing this person. When satisfied, he leaves this person's body. As a result, both the disciple and the teacher fall into the disaster of imprisonment. You should be aware beforehand, and not enter into Samsara. If you are confused and do not know, you will fall into Avīci Hell.",
    "Also, a good man, in the subtle realm of the feeling aggregate, does not encounter evil thoughts, and in perfect Samadhi, discovers the Samadhi. He loves knowledge and insight in his heart, diligently studies and explores, and greedily seeks past lives. At this time, the heavenly demon seizes the opportunity, flies out his essence and attaches to a person, speaking of the Dharma, but this person is not aware of being possessed by a demon, and even claims to have attained unsurpassed Nirvana. He comes to those good men seeking knowledge, sets up a seat, and preaches the Dharma. This person inexplicably obtains a large pearl in the place of preaching. The demon sometimes transforms into a beast, holding the pearl in its mouth, as well as various treasures, bamboo slips and talismans, and other strange objects, first giving them to that person, and then attaching to his body. Or he lures the listeners, saying that there is a bright moon pearl hidden underground, illuminating that place. These listeners have an unprecedented experience. They mostly eat medicinal herbs and do not eat fine food. Sometimes they only eat one sesame seed and one grain of wheat a day, but their bodies are very fat, which is due to the power of the demon. They slander Bhikkhus, scold the Sangha, and do not avoid the ridicule and suspicion of others. They like to speak of treasures in other places, and the places where sages and saints hide. Those who follow him often see strange people. These people claim to be mountain forest land city gods and river mountain ghosts and gods, who become demons in old age. Or some promote lust and destroy Buddhist precepts, secretly engaging in the five desires with those who serve him. Or some are diligent in practice, eating only grass and trees, without fixed rules of conduct. They disturb this person, and when satisfied, they leave this person's body. As a result, the disciples and teachers mostly fall into the disaster of imprisonment. You should be aware beforehand, and not enter into Samsara. If you are confused and do not know, you will fall into Avīci Hell.",
    "Also, a good man, in the subtle realm of the feeling aggregate, does not encounter evil thoughts, and in perfect Samadhi, discovers the Samadhi. He loves supernatural powers and various transformations in his heart, studies the origin of transformations, and greedily seeks the power of supernatural powers. At this time, the heavenly demon seizes the opportunity."
  ]
}

得其便。飛精附人。口說經法。其人誠不覺知魔著。亦言自得無上涅槃。來彼求通善男子處。敷座說法。是人或復手執火光。手撮其光。分于所聽四眾頭上。是諸聽人。頂上火光。皆長數尺。亦無熱性。曾不焚燒。或水上行。如履平地。或於空中。安坐不動。或入瓶內。或處囊中。越牖透垣。曾無障礙。唯于刀兵。不得自在。自言是佛。身著白衣。受比丘禮。誹謗禪律。罵詈徒眾。訐露人事。不避譏嫌。口中常說神通自在。或復令人傍見佛土。鬼力惑人。非有真實。讚歎行淫不毀粗行。將諸猥媟以為傳法。此名天地大力山精海精風精河精土精。一切草木積劫精魅。或復龍魅。或壽終仙。再活為魅。或仙期終。計年應死。其形不化。他怪所附年老成魔。惱亂是人。厭足心生。去彼人體。弟子與師多陷王難。汝當先覺。不入輪迴。迷惑不知。墮無間獄。又善男子受陰虛妙。不遭邪慮。圓定發明。三摩地中。心愛入滅。研究化性。貪求深空。爾時天魔候得其便。飛精附人。口說經法。其人終不覺知魔著。亦言自得無上涅槃。來彼求空善男子處。敷座說法。于大眾內。其形忽空。眾無所見。還從虛空突然而出。存沒自在。或現其身。洞如琉璃。或垂手足。作旃檀氣。或大小便。如厚石蜜。誹毀戒律。輕賤出家。口中常說無因無果。一死永滅。無復後身。及諸凡聖。雖得空寂。潛行貪慾。受其欲者。亦得空心。撥無因果。此名日月薄蝕精氣。金玉芝草。麟鳳龜鶴。經千萬年。不死為靈。出生國土年老成魔。惱亂是人。厭足心生。去彼人體。弟子與師。

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "得其便。妖魔的精氣依附於人,借人口中宣說經法。那人確實沒有察覺自己被邪魔附體,還說自己獲得了無上的涅槃(Nirvana,佛教術語,指解脫生死輪迴的境界)。(邪魔)來到那些尋求神通的善男子處,設定座位宣講佛法。這人有時手執火光,用手捏取火光,分給聽法的四眾弟子頭上。這些聽法的人,頭頂上的火光都長達數尺,卻沒有熱度,也不會焚燒。或者在水上行走,如同走在平地上。或者在空中,安穩地坐著不動。或者進入瓶子裡面,或者處在袋子裡面,穿過窗戶,穿透墻壁,都沒有任何障礙。唯獨對於刀槍兵器,不能夠自由自在。自稱是佛,身上穿著白色的俗家衣服,接受比丘(Bhikkhu,佛教出家男眾)的禮拜,誹謗禪定和戒律,謾罵僧眾,揭發別人的隱私,不迴避別人的譏諷和嫌疑。口中常常說自己神通自在,或者讓旁邊的人看見佛國凈土,這是鬼怪的力量迷惑人,不是真實的。讚歎行淫,不毀壞粗重的行為,把那些下流污穢的事情當作是傳法。這叫做天地間大力山精、海精、風精、河精、土精,一切草木經過漫長劫數的積累而成的精怪,或者又是龍的精魅,或者壽命終了的仙人,再次活過來變成精魅,或者仙人的壽命期限已到,推算年份應該死去,但是形體沒有變化,被其他的妖怪所附著,年老而成為魔,惱亂這個人。厭惡滿足的心生起,離開這個人的身體。弟子和師父大多會陷入牢獄之災。你們應當先覺悟,不進入輪迴,迷惑不知道,就會墮入無間地獄(Avīci,佛教術語,八大地獄中最苦之處)。",
    "又,善男子在受陰(Vedanā-skandha,佛教術語,五蘊之一,指感受)的虛妄和微妙之處,沒有遭遇邪惡的思慮,圓滿的禪定得以發明,在三摩地(Samādhi,佛教術語,指心專注一境的禪定狀態)中,內心喜愛進入寂滅,研究變化的本性,貪求深遠的空性。這時,天魔(Devaputra-māra,佛教術語,指障礙修行的魔)就得到了機會,妖魔的精氣依附於人,借人口中宣說經法。那人始終沒有察覺自己被邪魔附體,還說自己獲得了無上的涅槃(Nirvana,佛教術語,指解脫生死輪迴的境界)。(邪魔)來到那些尋求空性的善男子處,設定座位宣講佛法。在大眾之中,他的形體忽然消失不見,眾人什麼也看不見。然後又從虛空中突然出現,存在和消失都能夠自由自在。或者顯現他的身體,通透明亮如同琉璃。或者垂下手腳,散發出旃檀(Candana,一種香木)的香氣。或者大小便,如同濃厚的石蜜。誹謗戒律,輕視出家,口中常常說沒有因果,人死後就永遠滅亡,沒有來世,也沒有凡人和聖人。雖然得到了空寂,卻暗地裡行貪慾之事,接受他淫慾的人,也能夠得到空心,否定因果。這叫做日月薄蝕的精氣,金玉芝草,麒麟鳳凰龜鶴,經過千萬年不死而成為精靈,在國土出生,年老而成為魔,惱亂這個人。厭惡滿足的心生起,離開這個人的身體。弟子和師父。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Seizing the opportunity, the demon's essence attaches to a person, using their mouth to speak scriptures. That person is truly unaware of being possessed by a demon, and even claims to have attained unsurpassed Nirvana (Nirvana, a Buddhist term referring to the state of liberation from the cycle of birth and death). (The demon) comes to those virtuous men seeking supernatural powers, sets up a seat, and preaches the Dharma. This person sometimes holds a flame in their hand, plucks the light, and distributes it onto the heads of the fourfold assembly listening to the Dharma. The flames on the heads of these listeners are several feet long, but they have no heat and do not burn. Or they walk on water as if walking on flat ground. Or they sit motionless in the air. Or they enter bottles or stay inside bags, passing through windows and walls without any obstruction. Only against knives and weapons are they not free. They claim to be Buddhas, wear white lay clothes, and receive the prostrations of Bhikkhus (Bhikkhu, a Buddhist term referring to ordained male monks), slander meditation and precepts, scold the Sangha, expose the personal affairs of others, and do not avoid criticism or suspicion. They constantly speak of their supernatural powers and freedom, or cause those nearby to see Buddha lands, which are illusions created by demonic power, not reality. They praise sexual misconduct, do not condemn coarse behavior, and take lewd and obscene acts as the transmission of the Dharma. These are called the powerful mountain spirits, sea spirits, wind spirits, river spirits, and earth spirits of heaven and earth, the accumulated essences of all plants and trees over countless kalpas, or dragon spirits, or immortals who have died and been reborn as spirits, or immortals whose lifespan has ended and are supposed to die according to calculations, but whose forms have not changed, possessed by other monsters, becoming demons in old age, and tormenting this person. When the mind of aversion and satisfaction arises, they leave that person's body. Disciples and teachers often fall into imprisonment. You should be aware of this beforehand and not enter the cycle of rebirth. If you are confused and unaware, you will fall into the Avīci hell (Avīci, a Buddhist term referring to the most painful of the eight great hells).",
    "Furthermore, when virtuous men are in the subtle and illusory realm of the Vedanā-skandha (Vedanā-skandha, a Buddhist term referring to the skandha of feeling), without encountering evil thoughts, and perfect Samādhi (Samādhi, a Buddhist term referring to a state of meditative concentration) is developed, they love to enter extinction in Samādhi, study the nature of transformation, and greedily seek profound emptiness. At this time, the Devaputra-māra (Devaputra-māra, a Buddhist term referring to the demon who obstructs practice) seizes the opportunity, and the demon's essence attaches to a person, using their mouth to speak scriptures. That person is never aware of being possessed by a demon, and even claims to have attained unsurpassed Nirvana (Nirvana, a Buddhist term referring to the state of liberation from the cycle of birth and death). (The demon) comes to those virtuous men seeking emptiness, sets up a seat, and preaches the Dharma. In the assembly, their form suddenly disappears, and no one can see anything. Then they suddenly reappear from emptiness, freely existing and disappearing. Or they manifest their body, transparent and bright like crystal. Or they lower their hands and feet, emitting the fragrance of Candana (Candana, a type of fragrant wood). Or their excrement and urine are like thick rock candy. They slander the precepts, despise monasticism, and constantly say that there is no cause and effect, that death is the end, and there is no afterlife, no ordinary beings, and no sages. Although they have attained emptiness, they secretly engage in greed and desire, and those who receive their lust also attain emptiness, denying cause and effect. These are called the essences of solar and lunar eclipses, gold, jade, Ganoderma lucidum, unicorns, phoenixes, turtles, and cranes, which have lived for millions of years without dying and have become spirits, born in the country, becoming demons in old age, and tormenting this person. When the mind of aversion and satisfaction arises, they leave that person's body. Disciples and teachers."
  ]
}

多陷王難。汝當先覺。不入輪迴。迷惑不知。墮無間獄。又善男子受陰虛妙。不遭邪慮。圓定發明。三摩地中。心愛長壽。辛苦研幾。貪求永歲。棄分段生。頓希變易。細相常住。爾時天魔候得其便。飛精附人。口說經法。其人竟不覺知魔著。亦言自得無上涅槃。來彼求生善男子處。敷座說法。好言他方往還無滯。或經萬里。瞬息再來。皆于彼方取得其物。或於一處。在一宅中。數步之間。令其從東詣至西壁。是人急行累年不到。因此心信。疑佛現前。口中常說十方眾生。皆是吾子。我生諸佛。我出世界。我是元佛。出世自然。不因修得。此名住世自在天魔。使其眷屬如遮文茶。(啖精氣鬼)及四天王毗舍童子。(即毗舍遮隸四天王)未發心者。利其虛明。食彼精氣。或不因師。其修行人。親自觀見稱執金剛與汝長命。現美女身。盛行貪慾。未逾年歲。肝腦枯竭。口兼獨言。聽若妖魅。前人未詳。多陷王難。未及遇刑。先已乾死。惱亂彼人。以至殂殞。汝當先覺。不入輪迴。迷惑不知。墮無間獄。阿難。當知是十種魔。于末世時。在我法中。出家修道。或附人體。或自現形。皆言已成正遍知覺。讚歎淫慾。破佛律儀。先惡魔師。與魔弟子。淫淫相傳。如是邪精魅其心腑。近則九生。多逾百世令真修行。總為魔眷。命終之後。必為魔民。失正遍知。墮無間獄。汝今未須先取寂滅。縱得無學。留愿入彼末法之中。起大慈悲。救度正心深信眾生。令不著魔。得正知見。我今度汝已出生死。汝遵佛語。名報佛恩。阿難。如是十種禪那現境。皆是想陰

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "多會陷入王法災難。你應當事先覺察,不進入輪迴。迷惑無知,就會墮入無間地獄。還有,善男子在受陰虛妄微妙的境界中,如果沒有遇到邪惡的思慮,圓滿的禪定得以發明,在三摩地(Samadhi,禪定)中,心中貪愛長壽,辛苦地研究探求,貪求永遠的壽命,拋棄分段生死,一下子希望改變,得到細微之相的常住。這時,天魔就伺機而動,飛出精氣附在人身上,口中宣說經法,那人竟然沒有察覺到自己被魔附體,也說自己得到了無上涅槃(Nirvana,寂滅)。來到那些求生之地的善男子處,鋪設座位說法,喜歡說自己往返於他方世界毫無阻礙,或者說經過萬里路程,瞬間就能回來,都是從那個地方取得物品。或者在一個地方,在一所住宅中,幾步之間,就能讓那人從東邊走到西墻,而那人即使急速行走多年也到不了。因此,人們就相信了他,懷疑是佛顯現了。口中常常說十方眾生都是我的兒子,我生出了諸佛,我創造了世界,我是元佛,出世是自然而然的,不是通過修行得到的。這叫做住在世間的自在天魔。讓他的眷屬,比如遮文茶(Jhe-wen-cha,啖精氣鬼)以及四天王毗舍童子(Vaisravana,即毗舍遮隸四天王),去利益那些沒有發菩提心的人,吸食他們的精氣。或者不依靠師父,那些修行人親自看見稱執金剛(Vajrapani,佛教護法神)賜予他們長壽,顯現美女之身,大行貪慾。不到一年,肝腦就枯竭了,口中胡言亂語,聽起來像妖怪鬼魅。先前的人沒有詳細瞭解情況,大多會陷入王法災難。還沒等到被判刑,就已經**了,惱亂那些人,以至於死亡。你應當事先覺察,不進入輪迴。迷惑無知,就會墮入無間地獄。阿難(Ananda,佛陀十大弟子之一),應當知道這十種魔,在末世之時,在我的佛法中,出家修道,或者附在人體上,或者自己顯現形體,都說自己已經成就了正遍知覺(Sammasambuddha,佛的稱號),讚歎淫慾,破壞佛的戒律。先是惡魔的師父,與魔的弟子,淫亂相傳。這樣邪惡的精氣迷惑他們的心腑,近則九生,多則百世,讓真正的修行人,都成為魔的眷屬。命終之後,必定成為魔的子民,失去正遍知覺,墮入無間地獄。你現在不必急於先求取寂滅,即使得到了無學果位,也要發願留在末法時代,生起大慈悲心,救度那些正心深信的眾生,使他們不著魔,得到正確的知見。我現在度你已經脫離了生死,你遵從佛的教誨,就叫做報答佛恩。阿難(Ananda,佛陀十大弟子之一),像這樣十種禪那(Dhyana,禪定)中出現的境界,都是想陰的作用。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "They will easily fall into the difficulties of the king's law. You should be aware of this beforehand, so as not to enter into reincarnation. If you are deluded and ignorant, you will fall into the Avici Hell (Avici, the hell of incessant suffering). Furthermore, when good men experience the subtle and illusory states of the Skandha of Thinking (Samjna-skandha, the aggregate of perception), if they do not encounter evil thoughts, and their perfect Samadhi (Samadhi, meditative absorption) is manifested, and in that Samadhi, they cherish the love of longevity, laboriously researching and seeking, greedily desiring eternal life, abandoning segmented births and deaths, and suddenly hoping for transformation, seeking the permanence of subtle appearances. At this time, the heavenly demons seize the opportunity, flying out their essence to attach to people, speaking scriptures from their mouths. That person is completely unaware that he is possessed by a demon, and also claims to have attained unsurpassed Nirvana (Nirvana, liberation). They come to the places where those good men seek life, setting up seats to preach the Dharma, and like to say that they travel to and from other worlds without hindrance, or that after traveling tens of thousands of miles, they can return in an instant, always obtaining objects from that place. Or in one place, in a house, within a few steps, they can make that person walk from the east to the west wall, which that person could not reach even after walking rapidly for many years. Therefore, people believe them, suspecting that the Buddha has appeared. They often say that all beings in the ten directions are my children, I gave birth to all Buddhas, I created the world, I am the original Buddha, my appearance in the world is natural, not obtained through cultivation. This is called the Free Heavenly Demon dwelling in the world. They send their retinue, such as Jhe-wen-cha (Jhe-wen-cha, a ghost that devours essence) and the Four Heavenly Kings Vaisravana's (Vaisravana, one of the Four Heavenly Kings) children, to benefit those who have not aroused the Bodhi mind, and to devour their essence. Or without relying on a teacher, those practitioners personally see Vajrapani (Vajrapani, a Dharma protector in Buddhism) granting them longevity, manifesting as beautiful women, indulging in lust. Before a year has passed, their livers and brains are exhausted, and they speak nonsense, sounding like demons and ghosts. Those who came before did not understand the situation in detail, and many will fall into the difficulties of the king's law. Before they are sentenced, they are already dead, disturbing those people, to the point of death. You should be aware of this beforehand, so as not to enter into reincarnation. If you are deluded and ignorant, you will fall into the Avici Hell (Avici, the hell of incessant suffering). Ananda (Ananda, one of the ten great disciples of the Buddha), you should know that these ten kinds of demons, in the Age of Degenerate Dharma, in my Dharma, will leave home to cultivate the Way, or attach to human bodies, or manifest their own forms, all saying that they have attained Sammasambuddha (Sammasambuddha, the title of the Buddha), praising lust, and breaking the Buddha's precepts. First, the evil demon teachers, and the demon disciples, transmit lust to each other. In this way, evil spirits delude their minds, for as few as nine lives, or as many as hundreds of lives, causing true practitioners to become the retinue of demons. After death, they will surely become the people of demons, lose Sammasambuddha, and fall into the Avici Hell. You do not need to rush to seek Nirvana first. Even if you attain the state of No More Learning, you should vow to remain in the Age of Degenerate Dharma, arouse great compassion, and save those beings who have upright minds and deep faith, so that they will not be possessed by demons, and will attain correct knowledge and views. I have now delivered you from birth and death. If you follow the Buddha's teachings, it is called repaying the Buddha's kindness. Ananda (Ananda, one of the ten great disciples of the Buddha), these ten kinds of states that appear in Dhyana (Dhyana, meditation) are all the workings of the Skandha of Thinking."
  ]
}

用心互動。故現斯事。眾生頑迷。不自忖量。逢此因緣。迷不自識。謂言登聖。大妄語成。墮無間獄。汝等必須將如來語。於我滅后。傳示末法。遍令眾生開悟斯義。無令天魔得其方便。保持覆護。成無上道。

  通曰。受陰既盡。想陰未除。何得成就六十聖位。謂五根既拔。心已離形。從是凡身。上歷菩提。始之以三增進。繼之以五十五位真菩提路。終之以等妙二覺。共成六十聖位。曰聖者。所以別於凡也。未脫根塵。為根塵所礙。如鳥在籠。既根塵銷落。寄根明發。如鳥出籠。得意生身。自初地至十地。有三種意生身。一入三昧樂意生身。謂心寂不動。即相似初信至七信入空位也。二覺法自性意生身。謂普入佛剎。以法為自性。即相似八信出假位也。三種類俱生無作意生身。謂了佛所證法。即九信十信修中位也。此意生身。乃初入三昧樂意生身耳。然想陰未破。即前如幽室見。如人寱語。已成音韻倫次。謂由是上歷六十聖位。決定成就。令想盡不寐者。咸悟其語。是名想陰區宇。若浮想銷除。如夢既覺。不復為想所覆。于覺明本體。毫無纖塵。則一倫生死。首尾圓照。生死與涅槃無異相。故曰一倫生死。其生也為首。其滅也為尾。不見生相。不見滅相。故曰首尾圓照。如明鏡垢除。不亂光輝。名想陰盡。一切煩惱。因想念有。唯念儘想亡。生滅心滅。煩惱從何而起。故能超煩惱濁也。想所由生。以融通妄想為之本。想能融變。使心隨境。使境隨心。若動念盡則心境俱亡。故能破融通妄想也。味著虛明之體。則魔入其心。今不耽著虛

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本:",
    "因此現在才出現這種情況。眾生愚昧頑固,不能自己衡量,遇到這種因緣,迷惑而不能自己認識,說自己已經證得聖果,這成了大妄語,會墮入無間地獄。你們必須將如來的教誨,在我滅度后,傳示給末法時代的眾生,普遍令眾生開悟這個道理,不要讓天魔得到機會,要保持覆護,成就無上道。",
    
    "通問道:『受陰已經滅盡,想陰還沒有消除,怎麼能成就六十聖位呢?』(經文)說五根已經拔除,心已經脫離形體,從這個凡夫之身,向上經歷菩提道,開始以三增進,接著以五十五位真菩提路,最終以等覺、妙覺二覺,共同成就六十聖位。說『聖』,是用來區別于凡夫的。沒有脫離根塵,就被根塵所障礙,就像鳥在籠子里;既然根塵消落,依附於根而光明煥發,就像鳥出了籠子,得到意生身。從初地到十地,有三種意生身:一是入三昧樂意生身,說的是心寂靜不動,就是相似初信到七信進入空位的狀態。二是覺法自性意生身,說的是普遍進入佛剎,以法為自性,就是相似八信出假位的狀態。三種類俱生無作意生身,說的是了知佛所證的法,就是九信、十信修中位的狀態。這裡說的意生身,乃是初入三昧樂意生身罷了。然而想陰沒有破除,就像之前說的在幽暗的房間里看見東西,像人在說夢話,已經形成音韻的倫次,說的是由此向上經歷六十聖位,決定能夠成就,令想盡而不寐的人,都明白他所說的話,這叫做想陰的區域。如果浮想銷除,就像夢醒了一樣,不再被想所覆蓋,對於覺明的本體,毫無纖塵,那麼一倫生死,首尾都能夠圓滿照見,生死與涅槃沒有不同的相狀,所以說『一倫生死』,它的生起是開始,它的滅盡是結尾,不見生相,不見滅相,所以說『首尾圓照』,就像明鏡的污垢去除,不亂光輝,這叫做想陰滅盡。一切煩惱,因為想念而產生,只有念頭滅盡,想念消亡,生滅心滅,煩惱從哪裡產生呢?所以能夠超越煩惱濁。想所由來的產生,以融通妄想為根本。想能夠融化改變,使心隨境轉,使境隨心轉,如果動念滅盡,那麼心境都一起消亡,所以能夠破除融通妄想。如果貪戀虛明的本體,那麼魔就會進入他的心中,現在不貪戀虛明。",
    
    "English version:",
    "Therefore, this situation now arises. Sentient beings are foolish and stubborn, unable to measure themselves. Encountering such conditions, they are deluded and unable to recognize themselves, claiming to have attained sainthood. This becomes a great lie, leading to descent into the Avici Hell. You must transmit the Tathagata's teachings to sentient beings in the Dharma-ending Age after my Parinirvana, universally enabling them to awaken to this truth. Do not allow demons to gain an opportunity. Maintain protection and support, achieving unsurpassed enlightenment.",
    
    "Tong asked: 'The Skandha of Reception (受陰) is exhausted, but the Skandha of Conception (想陰) has not been eliminated. How can one achieve the sixty stages of sainthood?' (The scripture) says that the five roots have been eradicated, and the mind has separated from the body. From this ordinary body, one ascends through the Bodhi path, beginning with the Three Increments, followed by the fifty-five stages of the True Bodhi Path, and finally with the Equal Enlightenment and Wonderful Enlightenment, together achieving the sixty stages of sainthood. 'Saint' is used to distinguish from ordinary beings. Without detachment from the roots and dusts, one is obstructed by the roots and dusts, like a bird in a cage. Since the roots and dusts have fallen away, relying on the root to manifest luminosity, like a bird out of a cage, one obtains the Mind-made Body (意生身). From the First Ground to the Tenth Ground, there are three types of Mind-made Bodies: First, the Mind-made Body of Entering Samadhi Bliss, which refers to the mind being still and unmoving, which is the state of similar initial faith to the seventh faith entering the empty position. Second, the Mind-made Body of Awakening to the Self-nature of Dharma, which refers to universally entering Buddha-lands, with Dharma as its self-nature, which is the state of similar eighth faith exiting the provisional position. Third, the Innate and Uncreated Mind-made Body of the Same Category, which refers to understanding the Dharma realized by the Buddha, which is the state of the ninth and tenth faiths cultivating the middle position. The Mind-made Body mentioned here is merely the Mind-made Body of Entering Samadhi Bliss. However, if the Skandha of Conception has not been broken, it is like seeing things in a dark room as mentioned earlier, like a person talking in their sleep, already forming a sequence of sounds, which means that one can ascend through the sixty stages of sainthood and definitely achieve it, enabling those who are sleepless due to thinking to understand what they are saying. This is called the realm of the Skandha of Conception. If fleeting thoughts are eliminated, like waking up from a dream, no longer covered by thoughts, and there is no trace of dust on the luminous essence of awareness, then one cycle of birth and death can be fully illuminated from beginning to end. Birth and death are not different from Nirvana, so it is said 'one cycle of birth and death'. Its arising is the beginning, and its extinction is the end. One does not see the characteristic of birth, and one does not see the characteristic of extinction, so it is said 'fully illuminated from beginning to end', like the stains on a bright mirror being removed, not disturbing the radiance, this is called the exhaustion of the Skandha of Conception. All afflictions arise from thoughts, only when thoughts are exhausted and conceptions disappear, and the mind of arising and ceasing is extinguished, where do afflictions arise from? Therefore, one can transcend the turbidity of afflictions. The origin of conception is rooted in the fusion of deluded thoughts. Conception can fuse and transform, causing the mind to follow the environment, and the environment to follow the mind. If the arising of thoughts ceases, then both mind and environment disappear, so one can break the fusion of deluded thoughts. If one clings to the essence of empty brightness, then demons will enter their mind. Now, not clinging to empty brightness."
  ]
}

明。似有融通之妙。故曰受陰虛妙。不遭邪慮。然三摩地中。融通之意未化。則魔又乘其融通而惑之矣。故心愛圓明。貪求善巧。則貪習怪鬼年老成魔者附人。說自化善巧等法以惑之。心愛遊蕩。貪求經歷。則淫習魃鬼年老成魔者附人。說他化邪見等法以惑之。心愛綿㳷。貪求契合。則詐習魅鬼年老成魔者附人。說開悟他心宿命等法以惑之。心愛根本。貪求辨析。則冤習蠱毒及誑習魘勝惡鬼年老成魔者附人。說現前是佛等法以惑之。心愛懸應。貪求冥感。則瞋習癘鬼年老成魔者附人。說冥感度人等法以惑之。心愛深入。樂處陰寂。則慢習大力鬼年老成魔者附人。說未來因果等法以惑之。心愛知見。貪求宿命。則見習山林土地城隍川岳等鬼年老成魔者附人。說珠寶奇異等法以惑之。心愛神通。研究化元。則訟習依人之鬼。一切山河草木積劫精魅。及壽終仙為怪所附。年老成魔者附人。說撮光履水透垣入瓶神通等法以惑之。心愛入滅。貪求深空。則枉習休徴之類。日月精氣。金玉芝草。麟鳳龜鶴。不死為靈。年老成魔者附人。說無因果。出入虛空等法以惑之。心愛長壽。貪求永歲。欲棄分段而求變易。細相常住。乃斷見思惑而生法性土者。非世間之魔可得而惑也。於是住世自在天魔。居欲界第六天者。使其眷屬毗舍遮等。惱亂是人。毗舍遮中。已發心者。則護持正法。其未發心者。則啖人精氣至現美女身。令人肝腦枯竭。亦太磣矣。此所謂道愈高則魔愈盛。防範不可不嚴也。夫圓明善巧。遊歷佛土。綿密契證。辨析根元。冥感懸應。深入寂靜。

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "明,似乎有融通的微妙之處。所以說受陰是虛幻而微妙的,不會遭受邪惡的思慮。然而,在三摩地(Samadhi,一種精神集中的狀態)中,融通的意念如果未能轉化,那麼魔就會利用這種融通來迷惑人。因此,如果內心喜愛圓滿光明,貪求巧妙的手段,那麼貪婪成性的怪鬼,年老后變成魔,就會附在人身上,宣說自我變化的巧妙法門來迷惑人。如果內心喜愛遊蕩,貪求經歷,那麼淫慾成性的魃鬼,年老后變成魔,就會附在人身上,宣說他化邪見等法門來迷惑人。如果內心喜愛綿密潤澤,貪求契合,那麼欺詐成性的魅鬼,年老后變成魔,就會附在人身上,宣說開悟他心、宿命等法門來迷惑人。如果內心喜愛探究根本,貪求辨別分析,那麼冤仇成性的蠱毒鬼以及欺誑成性的魘勝惡鬼,年老后變成魔,就會附在人身上,宣說當下就是佛等法門來迷惑人。如果內心喜愛懸空感應,貪求冥冥中的感應,那麼嗔恨成性的癘鬼,年老后變成魔,就會附在人身上,宣說冥冥中感應度人等法門來迷惑人。如果內心喜愛深入,樂於處於陰暗寂靜之處,那麼傲慢成性的大力鬼,年老后變成魔,就會附在人身上,宣說未來因果等法門來迷惑人。如果內心喜愛知見,貪求宿命,那麼執著于見解的山林土地城隍川岳等鬼,年老后變成魔,就會附在人身上,宣說珠寶奇異等法門來迷惑人。如果內心喜愛神通,研究化元,那麼好爭訟的依附於人的鬼,一切山河草木經過漫長劫數的精怪,以及壽命終結的仙人變為妖怪所附,年老后變成魔,就會附在人身上,宣說撮光、履水、透墻入瓶等神通法門來迷惑人。如果內心喜愛入滅,貪求深空,那麼冤枉死亡的休徵之類,日月精氣,金玉芝草,麒麟鳳凰烏龜仙鶴等,不死而成為精靈,年老后變成魔,就會附在人身上,宣說沒有因果、出入虛空等法門來迷惑人。如果內心喜愛長壽,貪求永遠的壽命,想要捨棄分段生死而求變易生死,執著于細微的常住之相,這是斷除見思惑而生於法性土的人,不是世間的魔所能迷惑的。",
    "於是,居住在欲界第六天的住世自在天魔(Parinirmita-vasavartin,欲界第六天),派遣他的眷屬毗舍遮(Pisacha,一種惡鬼)等,來惱亂這個人。毗舍遮中,已經發菩提心的人,就會護持正法;那些尚未發菩提心的人,就會吞噬人的精氣,甚至顯現美女之身,使人肝腦枯竭,實在太慘了。這就是所謂的道行越高,魔障越盛,防範不可不嚴。圓明善巧,遊歷佛土,綿密契證,辨析根元,冥感懸應,深入寂靜,",
    "English version",
    "Clarity seems to have the subtlety of fusion. Therefore, it is said that the skandha of reception (受陰) is illusory and subtle, and will not suffer from evil thoughts. However, in Samadhi (三摩地), if the intention of fusion is not transformed, then the demon will take advantage of this fusion to confuse people. Therefore, if the mind loves perfect clarity and greedily seeks skillful means, then greedy monsters who become demons in old age will possess people and preach self-transforming skillful methods to confuse them. If the mind loves wandering and greedily seeks experience, then lustful Rakshasa ghosts (魃鬼) who become demons in old age will possess people and preach other-transforming heretical views to confuse them. If the mind loves continuous moisture and greedily seeks union, then deceptive Me ghosts (魅鬼) who become demons in old age will possess people and preach enlightenment, knowledge of others' minds, and past lives to confuse them. If the mind loves exploring the root and greedily seeks analysis, then vengeful Gu poison ghosts (蠱毒鬼) and deceptive Yansheng evil ghosts (魘勝惡鬼) who become demons in old age will possess people and preach that the present is the Buddha to confuse them. If the mind loves suspended responses and greedily seeks hidden sensations, then hateful Li ghosts (癘鬼) who become demons in old age will possess people and preach hidden sensations that save people to confuse them. If the mind loves deep entry and enjoys being in dark and quiet places, then arrogant powerful ghosts (大力鬼) who become demons in old age will possess people and preach future causes and effects to confuse them. If the mind loves knowledge and greedily seeks past lives, then those who cling to views, such as mountain, forest, land, city gods, rivers, and mountains ghosts (山林土地城隍川岳等鬼), who become demons in old age will possess people and preach jewels and strange methods to confuse them. If the mind loves supernatural powers and studies transformation, then litigious ghosts who rely on people, the spirits of all mountains, rivers, grass, and trees accumulated over countless kalpas, and immortals who have reached the end of their lives and are possessed by monsters, who become demons in old age will possess people and preach methods of gathering light, walking on water, passing through walls, and entering bottles to confuse them. If the mind loves entering extinction and greedily seeks deep emptiness, then those who have died unjustly, the essence of the sun and moon, gold, jade, ganoderma, phoenixes, turtles, cranes, and those who do not die and become spirits, who become demons in old age will possess people and preach that there is no cause and effect, entering and exiting emptiness, and other methods to confuse them. If the mind loves longevity and greedily seeks eternal life, wanting to abandon segmented life and death and seek variable life and death, clinging to the subtle and constant appearance, this is a person who has cut off the delusions of views and thoughts and is born in the Dharma-nature land, and cannot be confused by worldly demons.",
    "Therefore, the Parinirmita-vasavartin (住世自在天魔), the demon king residing in the sixth heaven of the desire realm (欲界第六天), sends his retinue of Pisachas (毗舍遮) and others to disturb this person. Among the Pisachas, those who have already aroused Bodhicitta (菩提心) will uphold the Dharma; those who have not yet aroused Bodhicitta will devour people's essence, even manifesting as beautiful women, causing people's livers and brains to wither, which is too miserable. This is what is meant by the higher the path, the greater the demons; prevention must be strict. Perfect clarity and skillful means, traveling through Buddha lands, close and meticulous verification, analyzing the root source, hidden sensation responses, deep entry into silence,"
  ]
}

知通宿命。神通無礙。入滅盡定。永劫不毀。皆真修行分內之事。於此精研。亦不為過。但始之以愛。繼之以貪。則心有所著。有著便是欲。故魔得乘其愛。遂其貪。引之以淫慾。至破律儀而不顧也。魔亦究心涅槃。唯不能斷淫。故入鬼神邪定。而以害正為事。害正使歸其黨。不欲使正道成也。正道若成。意想俱滅。彼魔宮盡為摧裂。安得不百計相撓哉。阿難於選擇圓通之後。愿度末劫一切眾生。深慮邪師說法如恒河沙。請問安立道場。遠諸魔事。于菩提心得無退屈。世尊至是盡數魔事而告之。令其留愿于彼末法之中。起大慈悲。救度眾生。令不著魔。得正知覺。拳拳以淫淫相傳為戒。誠懼淫機之難斷也。如摩登伽殊為眇劣。梵天神咒。亦未為奇。尚能破佛律儀。為毀一戒。何況飛精附人。現種種神變。有不為其所惑者乎。大都魔具五通而止。眩之以五通。而要歸於贊淫。伎倆止此矣。若破想陰。證漏盡通。內無其應。外無能為。魔且不能正眼而覷。敢為煩亂耶。天衣懷示眾云。二千年前。大覺世尊。欲將諸聖眾。往第六天上。說大集經。敕他方此土。人間天上。一切獰惡鬼神。悉皆集會。受佛付囑。擁護正法。設有不赴者。四天門王。飛熱鐵輪。追之令集。既集會已。無有不順佛敕者。各發宏誓。擁護正法。唯有一魔王謂世尊曰。瞿曇。我待一切眾產生佛盡。眾生界空。無有眾生名字。我乃發菩提心。臨危不變。真大丈夫。諸仁者。作么生著得一轉語。與黃面瞿曇出氣。尋常神通妙用。智慧辨才。到此總使不著。盡閻浮大地人。無不愛佛

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "知曉過去世的生命(知通宿命),神通運用沒有阻礙(神通無礙),進入滅盡一切感受和思想的禪定狀態(入滅盡定),永遠不會被摧毀(永劫不毀),這些都是真正修行人份內的事。對於這些深入研究,也不算過分。但如果一開始是出於愛,接著發展成貪,那麼心中就會有所執著。有了執著就是慾望,所以魔就能夠趁著你的愛,滿足你的貪,用淫慾來引誘你,以至於不顧戒律。魔也研究涅槃的道理,只是不能斷除淫慾,所以進入鬼神邪定,並且以危害正法為事。危害正法,使人歸順他的黨羽,不希望正道成就。正道如果成就,意念和想法都滅盡,那魔的宮殿就會完全被摧毀,怎麼能不千方百計地阻撓呢?阿難在選擇圓通法門之後,發願要度化末法時代的一切眾生,深深地擔憂邪師說法多如恒河沙數,所以請問如何安立道場,遠離各種魔事,在菩提心中不退轉。世尊於是詳細地講述了各種魔事來告誡他,讓他發願留在末法時代,發起大慈悲心,救度眾生,使他們不著魔,得到正確的知覺,反覆強調以斷除淫慾為戒,實在是擔心淫慾的難以斷除啊。像摩登伽這樣非常渺小卑劣的人,梵天的神咒也算不上奇異,尚且能夠破壞佛的律儀,爲了毀壞一條戒律,何況是妖魔鬼怪飛精附人,顯現種種神通變化,有誰不會被他們迷惑呢?大體上,魔具有五種神通而已,用五種神通來迷惑人,最終還是要歸結到讚美淫慾,伎倆僅此而已。如果破除了想陰,證得了漏盡通,內心沒有了相應的慾望,外面的魔就無能為力,魔尚且不能正眼看你,哪裡還敢來煩擾呢?天衣懷禪師開示大眾說:『二千年前,大覺世尊(釋迦牟尼佛)想要將各位聖眾帶到第六天上,宣說《大集經》,敕令他方和此土,人間和天上,一切兇惡的鬼神,全部聚集起來,接受佛的囑託,擁護正法。如果有不來的,四大天王就會用飛轉的熱鐵輪追趕他們,讓他們聚集。聚集完畢后,沒有不順從佛的敕令的,各自發下宏大的誓願,擁護正法。只有一位魔王對世尊(釋迦牟尼佛)說:「瞿曇(釋迦牟尼佛),我等待一切眾產生佛完畢,眾生界空無一人,沒有眾生的名字,我才發菩提心。」』臨危不變,真是大丈夫。各位仁者,怎樣才能說出一句轉語,為黃面瞿曇(釋迦牟尼佛)出氣呢?平常的神通妙用,智慧辯才,到這裡都用不上了。整個閻浮提的人,沒有不愛佛的。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Knowing past lives (knowing past destinies), unobstructed supernatural powers (unobstructed supernatural powers), entering the state of cessation of all feelings and thoughts (entering the state of extinction), never being destroyed (eternal destruction), these are all things within the scope of true practitioners. It is not an exaggeration to study these in depth. But if it starts with love and then develops into greed, then there will be attachments in the heart. Having attachments is desire, so the demon can take advantage of your love and satisfy your greed, using lust to lure you, to the point of disregarding the precepts. Demons also study the principles of Nirvana, but they cannot eliminate lust, so they enter into demonic and heretical states, and take harming the Dharma as their business. Harming the Dharma, making people submit to their party, not wanting the right path to be accomplished. If the right path is accomplished, thoughts and ideas will be extinguished, then the demon's palace will be completely destroyed, how can they not try every means to obstruct it? Ānanda, after choosing the path to perfect realization, vowed to save all beings in the Dharma-ending age, deeply worried that heretical teachers would preach like the sands of the Ganges River, so he asked how to establish a monastery, stay away from all demonic affairs, and not retreat in the Bodhi mind. The World Honored One then explained in detail all kinds of demonic affairs to warn him, so that he would vow to stay in the Dharma-ending age, arouse great compassion, save sentient beings, so that they would not be possessed by demons, and gain correct awareness, repeatedly emphasizing taking the elimination of lust as a precept, really worried about the difficulty of eliminating lust. Someone like Mātaṅgī, who is very small and humble, and the mantra of Brahma is not considered strange, can still destroy the Buddha's precepts, in order to destroy one precept, let alone demons flying and possessing people, manifesting all kinds of supernatural transformations, who would not be confused by them? In general, demons only have five supernatural powers, using the five supernatural powers to confuse people, and ultimately it still comes down to praising lust, the tricks are only this. If the skandha of thought is broken and the exhaustion of outflows is attained, there will be no corresponding desires in the heart, and the external demons will be powerless, the demons will not even dare to look at you directly, how dare they come to disturb you? Zen Master Tianyi Huai instructed the public: 'Two thousand years ago, the Great Awakened World Honored One (Śākyamuni Buddha) wanted to bring all the holy beings to the sixth heaven to preach the Great Collection Sutra, ordering all the fierce ghosts and gods in other lands and this land, in the human and heavenly realms, to gather together and accept the Buddha's entrustment to protect the Dharma. If there were any who did not come, the Four Heavenly Kings would chase them with flying hot iron wheels to gather them. After gathering, there was no one who did not obey the Buddha's decree, and each made great vows to protect the Dharma. Only one demon king said to the World Honored One (Śākyamuni Buddha): \"Gautama (Śākyamuni Buddha), I will wait until all sentient beings have become Buddhas, the realm of sentient beings is empty and there is no one, there is no name of sentient beings, and then I will arouse the Bodhi mind.\"』 Being unchangeable in the face of danger is truly a great man. Everyone, how can you say a turning word to vent your anger for the yellow-faced Gautama (Śākyamuni Buddha)? Ordinary supernatural powers, wisdom and eloquence are useless here. There is no one in the entire Jambudvipa who does not love the Buddha."
  ]
}

。到這裡。何者是佛。何者是魔。還有人辨得么。良久云。欲識魔么。開眼見明。欲識佛么。閤眼見暗。魔之與佛。以拄杖一時穿卻鼻孔。妙喜為代一轉語云。幾乎錯喚你作魔王。此語有兩負門。若人指點得出。許你具衲僧眼。五臺山秘魔巖和尚。常持一木叉。每見僧來禮拜。即叉卻頸曰。那個魔魅教汝出家。那個魔魅教汝行腳。道得也叉下死。道不得也叉下死。速道速道。學徒鮮有對者。法眼代云。乞命。法燈代云。但引頸示之。玄覺代云。老兒家放下叉子得也。霍山通和尚訪之。才見。不禮拜。便攛入懷裡。巖拊通背三下。通起拍手曰。師兄三千里外賺我來。三千里外賺我來。便回。此諸尊宿播弄神通。直使魔等覷不著。溈山一日問仰山。涅槃經四十卷。多少是佛說。多少是魔說。仰曰。總是魔說。溈曰。已后無人奈子何。仰曰。慧寂即一期之事行履在甚麼處。溈曰。祗貴子眼正。不說子行履。故能具仰山擇法眼。則無虞魔事矣。 卍新續藏第 16 冊 No. 0318 楞嚴經宗通

  大佛頂如來密因修證了義諸菩薩萬行首楞嚴經卷第十

  阿難。彼善男子修三摩提。想陰盡者。是人平常夢想銷滅。寤寐恒一。覺明虛靜。猶如晴空。無復粗重前塵影事。觀諸世間大地山河。如鏡鑑明。來無所黏。過無軌跡。虛受照應。了罔陳習唯一精真。生滅根元。從此披露。見諸十方十二眾生。畢殫其類。雖未通其各命由緒。見同生基。猶如野馬。熠熠清擾。為浮根塵究竟樞穴。此則名為行陰區宇。若此清擾熠熠元性。性入元澄。一

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "到這裡,誰是佛(Buddha,覺悟者),誰是魔(Mara,障礙者)?還有人能分辨得清楚嗎?",
    "(停頓片刻)想認識魔嗎?睜開眼睛看到光明就是。想認識佛嗎?閉上眼睛看到黑暗就是。魔與佛,用拄杖一時穿透鼻孔。",
    "妙喜禪師代為轉換一句說:『幾乎錯把你當成魔王了。』這句話有兩個破綻。如果有人能指出來,就認可你具有衲僧的眼力。",
    "五臺山秘魔巖和尚,常常拿著一根木叉。每次見到僧人來禮拜,就用木叉叉住僧人的脖子說:『哪個魔魅教你出家的?哪個魔魅教你行腳的?』說得出來,就在木叉下死去;說不出來,也在木叉下死去。快說!快說!",
    "學徒很少有人能回答。法眼禪師代為回答說:『乞命。』法燈禪師代為回答說:『但引頸示之。』玄覺禪師代為回答說:『老人家放下叉子也可以。』",
    "霍山通和尚拜訪他,剛一見面,不禮拜,就撲入秘魔巖和尚懷裡。秘魔巖和尚拍打通和尚的背三下。通和尚起身拍手說:『師兄三千里外騙我來,三千里外騙我來。』說完就走了。",
    "這些尊宿們施展神通,直接讓魔等都看不透。",
    "溈山禪師有一天問仰山禪師:《涅槃經》四十卷,多少是佛說的,多少是魔說的?仰山禪師說:『總是魔說的。』溈山禪師說:『以後沒人能奈何你了。』仰山禪師說:『慧寂我這一生的行履又在哪裡呢?』溈山禪師說:『只看重你的眼光是否端正,不談論你的行履。』所以能具備仰山禪師選擇佛法的眼光,就不會有魔事了。",
    "《卍新續藏》第16冊 No. 0318 《楞嚴經宗通》",
    "《大佛頂如來密因修證了義諸菩薩萬行首楞嚴經》卷第十",
    "阿難(Ananda,佛陀的十大弟子之一)。那些善男子修習三摩提(Samadhi,禪定),想陰(Skandha of Thought,五蘊之一)消盡的人,這個人平常的夢想都消滅了,睡著和醒著都是一樣的。覺悟的靈明虛空寂靜,就像晴朗的天空一樣。不再有粗重的以前的塵影舊事。觀察世間的大地山河,就像鏡子照物一樣明亮。來的時候沒有粘著,過去的時候沒有軌跡。虛空地接受照應。完全沒有陳舊的習氣,只有精真。生滅的根源,從此顯露出來。見到十方十二種眾生,完全窮盡了他們的種類。雖然還沒有通達他們各自生命的由來,但是見到了共同的生命基礎,就像野馬(Prabhakara,一種光影現象)一樣,閃耀著清凈的擾動。是浮根塵(Floating Roots of Dust,虛幻的感官體驗)的究竟樞紐。這就叫做行陰(Skandha of Volition,五蘊之一)的區域。如果這清凈擾動的閃耀元性,融入元澄,一切都..."
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Here, who is Buddha (覺悟者), who is Mara (障礙者)? Can anyone still distinguish them clearly?",
    "(Pause) Want to know Mara? Open your eyes and see the light. Want to know Buddha? Close your eyes and see the darkness. Mara and Buddha, pierce their nostrils at once with a staff.",
    "Chan Master Miaoxi substituted a turning phrase: 'Almost mistook you for the Demon King.' This sentence has two flaws. If someone can point them out, I will acknowledge that you have the eye of a monastic.",
    "The monk of Secret Demon Cliff on Mount Wutai often carried a wooden fork. Whenever he saw a monk come to bow, he would fork the monk's neck and say: 'Which demon taught you to leave home? Which demon taught you to travel on foot?' If you can say it, you will die under the fork; if you can't say it, you will also die under the fork. Speak quickly! Speak quickly!",
    "Few students could answer. Chan Master Fayan substituted the answer: 'Beg for life.' Chan Master Fadeng substituted the answer: 'Just stretch out your neck to show it.' Chan Master Xuanjue substituted the answer: 'Old man, you can put down the fork.'",
    "Monk Huoshan Tong visited him. As soon as they met, without bowing, he rushed into the arms of the Secret Demon Cliff monk. The Secret Demon Cliff monk patted Tong's back three times. Tong got up, clapped his hands, and said: 'Brother, you tricked me from three thousand miles away, tricked me from three thousand miles away.' Then he left.",
    "These venerable monks displayed their supernatural powers, directly making it impossible for Mara and others to see through them.",
    "One day, Chan Master Weishan asked Chan Master Yangshan: 'The Nirvana Sutra has forty volumes. How much of it was spoken by the Buddha, and how much by Mara?' Chan Master Yangshan said: 'All of it was spoken by Mara.' Chan Master Weishan said: 'No one will be able to do anything to you in the future.' Chan Master Yangshan said: 'Where is Huiji's conduct in this lifetime?' Chan Master Weishan said: 'I only value whether your vision is correct, I don't talk about your conduct.' Therefore, if one can possess Chan Master Yangshan's eye for choosing the Dharma, there will be no fear of demonic affairs.",
    "《卍 New Continued Collection》 Vol. 16 No. 0318 《Shurangama Sutra's General Principles》",
    "《The Great Buddha's Summit, the Secret Cause of the Tathagata, the Perfect Meaning of Cultivation and Enlightenment, All the Practices of the Bodhisattvas, the Shurangama Sutra》 Volume 10",
    "Ananda (佛陀的十大弟子之一). Those good men who cultivate Samadhi (禪定) and whose Skandha of Thought (五蘊之一) is exhausted, their ordinary dreams are extinguished, and they are the same whether asleep or awake. The awakened luminosity is empty and still, like a clear sky. There are no more heavy, old shadows of the past. Observing the mountains and rivers of the world, it is as bright as a mirror reflecting objects. When it comes, there is no attachment; when it passes, there is no trace. Empty space receives illumination. There are no old habits at all, only pure truth. The root of birth and death is revealed from this. Seeing the twelve kinds of beings in the ten directions, they completely exhaust their species. Although they have not yet understood the origin of their respective lives, they have seen the common foundation of life, like a mirage (Prabhakara, a phenomenon of light and shadow), shimmering with pure disturbance. It is the ultimate pivot of the Floating Roots of Dust (虛幻的感官體驗). This is called the realm of the Skandha of Volition (五蘊之一). If this pure, disturbing, shimmering original nature merges into the original purity, everything will..."
  ]
}

澄元習。如波瀾滅。化為澄水。名行陰盡。是人則能超眾生濁。觀其所由。幽隱妄想以為其本。阿難。當知是得正知奢摩他中諸善男子。凝明正心。十類天魔。不得其便。方得精研窮生類本。于類本中生元露者。觀彼幽清。圓擾動元。于圓元中起計度者。是人墜入二無因論。一者是人見本無因。何以故。是人既得生機全破。乘于眼根八百功德。見八萬劫所有眾生。業流灣環。死此生彼。祗見眾生輪迴其處。八萬劫外。冥無所觀。便作是解。此等世間十方眾生。八萬劫來。無因自有。由此計度。亡正遍知。墮落外道。惑菩提性。二者是人見末無因。何以故。是人于生既見其根。知人生人。悟鳥生鳥。烏從來黑。鵠從來白。人天本豎。畜生本橫。白非洗成。黑非染造。從八萬劫。無復改移。今盡此形。亦復如是。而我本來。不見菩提。云何更有成菩提事。當知今日一切物象。皆本無因。由此計度。亡正遍知。墮落外道。惑菩提性。是則名為第一外道立無因論。

  通曰。想陰未盡。寤則取像。寐則成夢。故逐前塵粗重影事。想陰既盡。內守幽閑。寤寐恒一。覺明虛靜。如鏡鑑明。雖無去來軌跡。卻有光明影子。猶為法塵邊事。向來前塵昏擾。但隨生滅流轉。不睹根元。今虛受照應。惟一精真。生滅既停。而其根元從此披露。見同生基。綿綿密密。微細遷流。是為無風匝匝之波。野馬者。游埃也。熠熠者。螢光也。行陰微細。如日光所照隙塵。熠熠然了無住相。乍生乍滅。無復粗影。故曰清擾。清擾四大為浮根四塵根元。其體本空。究竟樞穴

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本:",
    "澄凈圓滿的修行者,如同波濤平息,化為澄澈的水面,這被稱為『行陰』(Saṃskāra-skandha,五蘊之一,指行為和心理活動的潛在力量)消盡。這樣的人就能超越眾生的混濁。觀察其根源,是幽微隱蔽的妄想作為根本。阿難(Ānanda,佛陀十大弟子之一,以記憶力強著稱),應當知道,這些在獲得正知正見的奢摩他(Śamatha,止觀中的「止」,指內心的平靜和專注)中的善男子,凝練明澈的正心,十類天魔(指修行中的各種障礙和誘惑)無法找到破綻。他們才能深入研究,窮究眾生類別的根本。在各類根本中,產生最初的顯露時,觀察那幽微清凈、圓滿擾動的本元,在圓滿的本元中產生計度分別的,這些人就會墜入二種無因論。",
    
    "第一種是,這些人認為根本是無因的。為什麼呢?因為這些人已經徹底打破了生機的束縛,憑藉眼根的八百種功德,看見八萬劫(kalpa,極長的時間單位)以來所有眾生的業力流轉,在此處死亡,在彼處出生,只看見眾生在這些地方輪迴。超過八萬劫之外,就什麼也看不見了,於是就作出這樣的解釋:這些世間的十方眾生,從八萬劫以來,是無因而自然存在的。由於這樣的計度分別,喪失了正確的遍知,墮落到外道,迷惑了菩提(bodhi,覺悟)的自性。",
    
    "第二種是,這些人認為末端是無因的。為什麼呢?因為這些人對於生命的產生已經看到了它的根源,知道人是由人生的,鳥是由鳥生的,烏鴉向來是黑色的,天鵝向來是白色的,人天生是豎立的,畜生天生是橫臥的,白色不是洗出來的,黑色不是染成的,從八萬劫以來,就不會再改變。現在直到這個形體消亡,也是如此。而我本來就沒有看見菩提,怎麼還會有成就菩提的事情呢?應當知道今天的一切物象,都是本來無因而存在的。由於這樣的計度分別,喪失了正確的遍知,墮落到外道,迷惑了菩提的自性。這就是第一種外道所立的無因論。",
    
    "通曰:想陰沒有消盡,清醒時就執取外在的形象,睡著時就形成夢境,所以追逐前塵的粗重影子。想陰消盡后,內心守護幽靜閒適,清醒和睡夢始終如一,覺悟光明虛空寂靜,如同鏡子照亮事物,雖然沒有來去的軌跡,卻有光明影子,仍然是法塵邊的事情。向來前塵昏昧擾動,只是隨著生滅流轉,不看到根源。現在虛空接受照應,只有一精真,生滅已經停止,而它的根源從此顯露。看見如同生命基礎的東西,綿綿密密,微細遷流,這就是沒有風時的細微波紋。野馬,是遊動的塵埃。熠熠,是螢火蟲的光芒。行陰微細,如同陽光照射下縫隙中的塵埃,閃閃發光,沒有固定的相狀,乍生乍滅,沒有粗重的影子,所以說是清擾。清擾四大是浮根四塵的根源,它的本體本空,是究竟的關鍵。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version:",
    "A practitioner who is clear and complete, like waves subsiding and transforming into clear water, is said to have exhausted the 『Saṃskāra-skandha』 (one of the five skandhas, referring to the latent forces of actions and mental activities). Such a person can transcend the turbidity of sentient beings. Observing its origin, subtle and hidden delusions are its root. Ānanda (one of the Buddha's ten principal disciples, known for his strong memory), you should know that these virtuous men in the Śamatha (calm abiding, referring to inner peace and concentration in meditation) of attaining right knowledge and right view, with their minds refined and clear, the ten types of heavenly demons (referring to various obstacles and temptations in practice) cannot find a flaw. Only then can they deeply research and exhaustively investigate the root of sentient beings' categories. When the original manifestation arises within the categories, observing that subtle purity and the complete disturbance of the original element, and those who generate calculation and discrimination within the complete original element, these people will fall into two kinds of causelessness theories.",
    
    "The first is that these people believe the root is without cause. Why? Because these people have completely broken the bonds of the life force, relying on the eight hundred merits of the eye faculty, they see the karmic flow of all sentient beings for eighty thousand kalpas (an extremely long unit of time), dying here and being born there, only seeing sentient beings reincarnating in these places. Beyond eighty thousand kalpas, they see nothing, and thus they make this interpretation: these sentient beings in the ten directions of the world have existed naturally without cause for eighty thousand kalpas. Due to such calculation and discrimination, they lose correct and universal knowledge, fall into external paths, and are deluded about the self-nature of bodhi (enlightenment).",
    
    "The second is that these people believe the end is without cause. Why? Because these people have seen the root of the generation of life, knowing that humans are born from humans, birds are born from birds, crows have always been black, swans have always been white, humans are naturally upright, and animals are naturally horizontal, white is not made by washing, and black is not made by dyeing, and from eighty thousand kalpas, there will be no further change. Now, until this form perishes, it is also the same. And I have never seen bodhi, so how can there be the matter of achieving bodhi? It should be known that all phenomena today exist without cause from the beginning. Due to such calculation and discrimination, they lose correct and universal knowledge, fall into external paths, and are deluded about the self-nature of bodhi. This is the first causelessness theory established by external paths.",
    
    "Commentary: When the Saṃskāra-skandha has not been exhausted, one grasps external images when awake and forms dreams when asleep, thus pursuing the coarse and heavy shadows of past dust. After the Saṃskāra-skandha is exhausted, the mind guards tranquility and leisure, wakefulness and sleep are always the same, and awareness is bright, empty, and still, like a mirror illuminating things. Although there are no traces of coming and going, there are shadows of light, which are still matters on the edge of Dharma dust. Hitherto, the past dust has been dim and disturbing, merely following the flow of arising and ceasing, without seeing the root source. Now, emptiness receives response, only one essence is true, arising and ceasing have stopped, and its root source is revealed from this point. Seeing something like the foundation of life, continuous and dense, subtle and flowing, this is like the subtle ripples without wind. Wild horses are moving dust. Sparkling is the light of fireflies. The Saṃskāra-skandha is subtle, like dust in a gap illuminated by sunlight, sparkling without a fixed appearance, arising and ceasing suddenly, without coarse shadows, so it is said to be clear disturbance. The clear disturbance of the four great elements is the root source of the floating root and the four dusts, its substance is originally empty, and it is the ultimate key."
  ]
}

。實在於此。黏湛發起。故有六根。自人天以至螻蟻。莫不各有四大六根。故為十二眾生同生之基。是名行陰區宇。若通別相。能見眾生各命由緒。慧福不齊。由於多生積習種子發現。屬識陰邊事。故非行陰所測。然此行陰清擾之性。本自無擾。故曰元性。其不能不擾者。多生習氣也。故曰元習。習不能澄習。唯性歸元。則能澄靜。以一澄靜之性。澄其元習。則遷流相盡。無風匝匝之波滅。則化為澄水矣。化為澄水。至湛不搖處。名行陰盡。是人則能超眾生濁。眾生濁者。生滅不停。業運常遷。今于不停者停矣。常遷者不遷矣。幾入滅盡。故能超也。然行陰密移。曾無覺悟。以幽隱妄想為本。于其幽閑隱密而破除之。非徹悟性體者不能也。彼寤寐恒一。是得正知。與前動靜不移。憶忘如一。當住此處。入三摩地。同一脈路。以此為發悟階級則可。便執以為實證則不可。故想陰盡者。凝明正心。邪慮無自而生。即十類天魔。亦無緣而入。天魔未離邪想而現神變。今想陰盡。觀見幽清動元。蓋已入乎無想之天矣。六慾天魔所不得而窺也。幽清。本無所動也。圓擾。則動而未嘗動也。故謂之動元。動元雖圓。不離生滅。於此生計度者。總于生滅中計無因也。一者見本無因。不悟善惡業緣。唯識所造。祗憑生相暫無。行流不息。于其定中。發宿命通。見八萬劫來。眾生輪迴。如環無端。便以眾生無因。自然而有。自八萬劫外。冥無所觀。固不知菩提為正因也。二者見末無因。不悟善惡業果。唯心所召。祗憑通力。能見八萬劫后。長時業果。未轉移相

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本:",
    "實在的道理就在這裡。因為『黏湛』(指凝滯清澈的狀態)發起作用,所以才有了六根。從人天到螻蟻,沒有誰不具備四大和六根,因此這是十二類眾生共同生存的基礎。這被稱為行陰的區域。如果能瞭解行陰的通相和別相,就能看到眾生各自命運的由來,以及智慧和福報的不均等,這些都源於多生累劫積累的習氣種子顯現,屬於識陰的範疇,所以不是行陰所能測知的。然而,這行陰清凈與擾動並存的性質,本來是沒有擾動的,所以說它是『元性』(本來的清凈自性)。之所以不能不擾動,是因為多生累劫的習氣。所以說它是『元習』(本來的習氣)。習氣自身無法平息習氣,只有迴歸本元自性,才能澄靜。用這一個澄靜的自性,來澄凈那本來的習氣,那麼遷流變化就會窮盡,就像沒有風時,遍佈的波浪消失,就會化為澄澈的水。化為澄澈的水,到達完全清澈不動搖的狀態,就叫做行陰盡。這樣的人就能超越眾生的污濁。眾生的污濁,在於生滅不停,業力運轉常遷。現在對於那不停的,使其停下來了;對於那常遷的,使其不再遷變了。接近於進入滅盡定,所以能夠超越。然而行陰的秘密遷移,從來沒有覺察到,以幽隱的妄想為根本。要在其幽靜隱秘之處破除它,不是徹底覺悟自性本體的人不能做到。如果他醒著和睡著時始終如一,這是得到了正知。與前面所說的動靜不移,憶念和遺忘如一,應當安住於此,進入三摩地(禪定),是同一條脈絡。以此作為啓發覺悟的階梯是可以的,但如果執著地認為這是真實的證悟就不可以。所以想陰盡的人,凝聚光明正大的心,邪惡的念頭就無從產生,即使是十類天魔,也沒有機會進入。天魔沒有離開邪惡的念頭而顯現神通變化,現在想陰已盡,觀察到幽清的動元,大概已經進入了無想天了。六慾天的天魔都無法窺視到。幽清,本來就沒有動過。圓融的擾動,是動而未嘗動。所以稱之為動元。動元雖然圓融,但不離生滅。在這裡產生計度的人,總是在生滅中計度無因。第一種是隻見本無因,不明白善惡業緣,都是唯識所造。只憑生相暫時沒有了,行流沒有停止。於是在定中,發出宿命通,見到八萬劫(佛教時間單位)以來的眾生輪迴,像環一樣沒有開端,就認為眾生是無因而生,自然而有。因為八萬劫以外,就什麼也看不到了,所以不知道菩提(覺悟)才是真正的因。第二種是隻見末無因,不明白善惡業果,都是唯心所召。只憑神通力,能見到八萬劫以後的長時業果,沒有轉移變化的樣子。",
    "English version:",
    "The true principle lies right here. Because 'Nian Zhan' (referring to the state of solidified clarity) arises, there are the six sense organs. From humans and gods to ants, none lack the Four Great Elements and the six sense organs, thus this is the foundation upon which the twelve categories of beings commonly exist. This is called the realm of the formation aggregate (行陰). If one can understand the general and specific characteristics of the formation aggregate, one can see the origins of each being's destiny, and the inequality of wisdom and blessings, which stem from the accumulated habitual seeds manifested over many lifetimes, belonging to the realm of the consciousness aggregate (識陰), and therefore not knowable by the formation aggregate. However, the nature of this formation aggregate, with both purity and disturbance, is originally without disturbance, so it is called 'Yuan Xing' (original pure nature). The reason it cannot but be disturbed is due to the habitual energies of many lifetimes. Therefore, it is called 'Yuan Xi' (original habit). Habit cannot pacify habit; only returning to the original nature can bring about tranquility. Using this one tranquil nature to purify the original habits, then the flowing changes will be exhausted, just as when there is no wind, the pervasive waves disappear, transforming into clear water. Transforming into clear water, reaching the state of complete clarity and immovability, is called the exhaustion of the formation aggregate. Such a person can transcend the turbidity of sentient beings. The turbidity of sentient beings lies in the ceaseless arising and ceasing, the constant shifting of karmic forces. Now, for that which is unceasing, it is made to cease; for that which is constantly shifting, it no longer shifts. Approaching entering the extinction attainment, thus one can transcend. However, the secret migration of the formation aggregate is never noticed, taking hidden and obscure delusion as its root. One must eradicate it in its quiet and concealed places, which cannot be done by one who has not thoroughly awakened to the essence of the self-nature. If one is consistently the same whether awake or asleep, this is attaining right knowledge. Similar to what was said before about immovability in movement and stillness, and uniformity in memory and forgetting, one should abide here, entering Samadhi (禪定), it is the same path. Using this as a stepping stone for enlightenment is acceptable, but clinging to it as actual realization is not. Therefore, one whose thought aggregate (想陰) is exhausted, concentrates the bright and upright mind, and evil thoughts have no way to arise, even the ten categories of heavenly demons have no opportunity to enter. Heavenly demons manifest supernatural transformations without leaving evil thoughts; now that the thought aggregate is exhausted, observing the subtle and clear moving origin, one has probably entered the Heaven of Non-Perception (無想天). The demons of the Six Desire Heavens cannot even glimpse it. Subtlety and clarity are originally without movement. The harmonious disturbance is moving yet never having moved. Therefore, it is called the moving origin. Although the moving origin is harmonious, it does not depart from arising and ceasing. Those who generate calculations here are always calculating causelessness within arising and ceasing. The first is seeing only the original causelessness, not understanding that good and evil karmic conditions are all created by consciousness. Relying only on the temporary absence of arising appearances, the flowing stream does not cease. Thus, in meditation, one develops the power of knowing past lives, seeing the cycle of rebirth of sentient beings for eighty thousand kalpas (佛教時間單位), like a ring without a beginning, and concludes that sentient beings arise without cause, naturally existing. Because beyond eighty thousand kalpas, one can see nothing, one does not know that Bodhi (覺悟) is the true cause. The second is seeing only the final causelessness, not understanding that good and evil karmic results are all summoned by the mind. Relying only on supernatural powers, one can see the long-term karmic results after eighty thousand kalpas, without any sign of shifting or changing."
  ]
}

。便以人畜黑白橫豎從來如此。非因修得。固不知菩提為極果也。惑菩提性。不名正知。止知前後八萬劫。不名遍知。外道末伽黎。謂眾生苦樂。不因行得。皆自然爾。正坐此見。此二無因。僅見七識無根。傳送暫息。而生此計度。以七識內但依於八識。生之無本。遂謂本無因。以七識外但依於六識。推之無用。遂謂末無因。唯見其流注不息。乃謂自然如此。鏡清問靈云。混沌未分時如何。云曰。露柱懷胎。清云。分后如何。云曰。如片云點太清里。清云。祗如太清還受點也無。云不對。清云。恁么則含生不來也。云亦不對。清云。直得純清絕點時如何。云曰。猶是真常流注。清云。如何是真常流注。云曰。似鏡常明。清曰。向上更有事否。云曰有。清曰。如何是向上事。云曰。打破鏡來。與子相見。天童拈云。分與未分。玉機夜動。點與不點。金捘暗拋。直是一色純清。未得十成安隱。且道打破鏡來。向什麼處相見。還會么。清秋老兔吞光后。湛水蒼龍蛻骨時。此真常流注。恰與行陰相符。而似鏡常明。亦與如鏡鑑明無異。若能破鏡相見。如湛水蒼龍。蛻骨而出。則幾轉成智矣。寧但破行陰而已哉。

  阿難。是三摩中諸善男子。凝明正心。魔不得便。窮生類本。觀彼幽清。常擾動元。于圓常中起計度者。是人墜入四遍常論。一者是人窮心境性二處無因。修習能知二萬劫中十方眾生。所有生滅。咸皆循環。不曾散失。計以為常。二者是人窮四大元。四性常住。修習能知四萬劫中十方眾生。所有生滅。咸皆體恒。不曾散失。計以為常。

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "於是就以人與牲畜的毛髮有黑有白,身體有橫有豎,一直以來都是這樣,並非通過修行而得來的為理由,因此不知道菩提(bodhi,覺悟)是最高的果位。迷惑于菩提的自性,不能稱之為『正知』。只知道前後八萬劫的事情,不能稱之為『遍知』。外道末伽黎(Makali,印度古代思想家)說眾生的苦樂,不是因為行為所導致的,一切都是自然而然的。正是因為抱持這種見解。這兩種『無因論』,僅僅看到第七識沒有根本,只是暫時的傳遞和停息,就產生了這種推測。因為第七識內在只是依靠第八識,生起沒有根本,於是就認為本初沒有原因。第七識外在只是依靠第六識,推演沒有作用,於是就認為終末沒有原因。只看到它的流注沒有停息,就說是自然而然如此。鏡清問靈云:『混沌未分時如何?』靈云說:『露柱懷胎。』鏡清問:『分后如何?』靈云說:『如片云點太清里。』鏡清問:『就如太清還接受點染嗎?』靈云不回答。鏡清問:『這樣說來,含靈眾生就不會來了。』靈云也不回答。鏡清問:『直到純凈無染的時候如何?』靈云說:『仍然是真常流注。』鏡清問:『如何是真常流注?』靈云說:『似鏡常明。』鏡清問:『向上還有更高的事情嗎?』靈云說:『有。』鏡清問:『如何是向上事?』靈云說:『打破鏡來,與子相見。』天童拈云:『分與未分,玉機夜動。點與不點,金捘暗拋。直是一色純清,未得十成安隱。且道打破鏡來,向什麼處相見?還會么?清秋老兔吞光后,湛水蒼龍蛻骨時。』這真常流注,恰好與行陰(saṃskāra-skandha,行蘊)相符,而『似鏡常明』,也與如鏡子般明亮地照見沒有區別。如果能夠打破鏡子相見,就像湛水中的蒼龍,蛻去骨頭而出,那麼就幾乎轉識成智了。豈止是打破行陰而已呢?",
    
    "阿難(Ānanda,佛陀的十大弟子之一)。這些在三摩地(samādhi,禪定)中的善男子,凝聚明澈的正心,魔就無法得逞。他們窮究眾生種類的根本,觀察那幽微清凈、經常擾動本元的現象,在圓滿常住之中產生計度分別。這些人會墮入四種『遍常論』。第一種是,這些人窮究心境的自性,認為心和境這兩個地方沒有原因,通過修行能夠知道二萬劫中十方眾生的所有生滅,都完全循環往復,不曾散失,就以此為常。第二種是,這些人窮究四大(mahābhūta,組成物質世界的四種基本元素:地、水、火、風)的本元,認為四大之性常住不變,通過修行能夠知道四萬劫中十方眾生的所有生滅,都完全是本體恒常,不曾散失,就以此為常。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "They then use the argument that the hair of humans and animals is black and white, and their bodies are horizontal and vertical, and that this has always been the case, not acquired through cultivation. Therefore, they do not know that Bodhi (bodhi, enlightenment) is the highest fruit. Being deluded about the self-nature of Bodhi, they cannot be called 'right knowledge'. Knowing only about the events of the past and future eighty thousand kalpas, they cannot be called 'omniscience'. The heretic Makali (Makali, an ancient Indian thinker) said that the suffering and happiness of sentient beings are not caused by actions, but are all natural. It is precisely because they hold this view. These two 'theories of no cause' only see that the seventh consciousness has no root, and that it is only a temporary transmission and cessation, and then they produce this speculation. Because the seventh consciousness internally relies only on the eighth consciousness, and its arising has no root, they then believe that there is no cause in the beginning. The seventh consciousness externally relies only on the sixth consciousness, and its deduction is useless, so they then believe that there is no cause in the end. Seeing only that its flow does not cease, they then say that it is naturally so. Mirror Clarity asked Lingyun: 'What is it like when chaos has not yet separated?' Lingyun said: 'The dew pillar is pregnant.' Mirror Clarity asked: 'What is it like after separation?' Lingyun said: 'Like a piece of cloud dotting the vast sky.' Mirror Clarity asked: 'Does the vast sky still accept staining?' Lingyun did not answer. Mirror Clarity asked: 'In that case, sentient beings will not come.' Lingyun also did not answer. Mirror Clarity asked: 'What is it like when it is purely clear and without any stain?' Lingyun said: 'It is still the true and constant flow.' Mirror Clarity asked: 'What is the true and constant flow?' Lingyun said: 'Like a mirror always bright.' Mirror Clarity asked: 'Is there anything higher?' Lingyun said: 'Yes.' Mirror Clarity asked: 'What is the higher thing?' Lingyun said: 'Break the mirror and meet you.' Tiantong said: 'Separated or not separated, the jade machine moves at night. Dotted or not dotted, the golden shuttle is thrown away in the dark. Even if it is purely clear in one color, it has not yet achieved complete peace. But where will you meet after breaking the mirror? Do you understand? After the old rabbit in the clear autumn swallows the light, when the azure dragon in the deep water sheds its bones.' This true and constant flow is exactly in accordance with the formation aggregate (saṃskāra-skandha, the aggregate of mental formations), and 'like a mirror always bright' is no different from illuminating like a mirror. If you can break the mirror and meet, like the azure dragon in the deep water, shedding its bones and emerging, then you will almost transform consciousness into wisdom. How can it be just breaking the formation aggregate?",
    
    "Ananda (Ānanda, one of the Buddha's ten great disciples). These good men in Samadhi (samādhi, meditation), concentrating their clear and upright minds, the demons cannot take advantage of them. They exhaustively investigate the root of sentient beings, observing the subtle and pure phenomena that constantly disturb the original source, and generate measurement and discrimination in the perfect and constant. These people will fall into four 'pervasive constancy theories'. The first is that these people exhaustively investigate the nature of mind and environment, believing that there is no cause in these two places, mind and environment. Through cultivation, they can know that all the arising and ceasing of sentient beings in the ten directions during the twenty thousand kalpas completely cycle and return, never being lost, and they take this as constant. The second is that these people exhaustively investigate the original source of the four great elements (mahābhūta, the four basic elements that make up the material world: earth, water, fire, and wind), believing that the nature of the four great elements is constant and unchanging. Through cultivation, they can know that all the arising and ceasing of sentient beings in the ten directions during the forty thousand kalpas are completely constant in essence, never being lost, and they take this as constant."
  ]
}

三者是人窮盡六根末那執受。心意識中本元由處。性常恒故。修習能知八萬劫中一切眾生。循環不失。本來常住。窮不失性。計以為常。四者是人既儘想元。生理更無流止運轉。生滅想心。今已永滅。理中自然成不生滅。因心所度。計以為常。由此計常。亡正遍知。墮落外道。惑菩提性。是則名為第二外道。立圓常論。

  通曰。立無因論者。見其斷。立圓常論者。見其常。推之亦斷亦常。非斷非常。總不出斷常邪見也。窮生類本。至圓擾動元。見其虛而愈出。動而不窮。便計為常。從廣至狹。從粗入精。略有次第。一者通五陰四大心境二處。皆無因自有。循環不失。二者但指地水火風清凈四大之性。能成眾生色陰。體恒不變。三者但指心識六根所依末那七識。執受之心。執受之意。執受之識。本元由處。即行陰也。眾生雖有循環。而行陰不失。即此七識為常住性。如見細流。謂之止水。無始以來生死本。癡人喚作本來人。此之謂也。四者妄認行陰為自然理。謂生滅想心既已滅盡。其永滅處。自然成不生滅。於此生滅中。計不生滅。如見虛空謂之常住。不知虛空亦可滅也。且又因心計度為常。非真見其常者比。此四尚未睹八識真常流注。何況轉識而見菩提性乎。瑞巖問巖頭。如何是本常理。頭曰動也。巖曰。動時如何。頭曰。不見本常理。巖佇思。頭曰。肯即未脫根塵。不肯即永沉生死。巖乃禮拜。天童頌云。圓珠不穴。大璞不琢。道人所貴無棱角。拈卻肯路根塵空。脫體無依活卓卓。此于本來常住。見之極真。肯之一字。尚須拈卻。

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "第三種情況是,這些人窮盡了六根(眼、耳、鼻、舌、身、意)和末那識(Manas,第七識,意根)的執受作用,認為在心意識(心、意、識)中有一個本元之處,這個本元是恒常不變的。他們認為通過修行可以知曉八萬劫(kalpa,極長的時間單位)中一切眾生的輪迴,而這個本元始終存在,從未失去。他們將這種本來常住、窮盡而不失的『性』,錯誤地認為是永恒不變的。這是第三種外道,他們立『常』論。",
    
    "第四種情況是,這些人窮盡了『想』的根源,認為生理上的流轉和運轉已經停止,生滅的『想』心(念頭)已經永遠滅盡。他們認為在『理』中自然會形成不生不滅的狀態。他們因為內心的計度,而認為這是永恒不變的。由於這種計度,他們喪失了正確的遍知(正遍知,Samyak-sambuddha),墮落為外道,迷惑了菩提(Bodhi,覺悟)的自性。這被稱為第二種外道,他們立『圓常』論。",
    
    "通禪師說:『立無因論的人,只看到了斷滅;立圓常論的人,只看到了常。推論下去,要麼是亦斷亦常,要麼是非斷非常,總之都逃不出斷滅和常的邪見。』窮究眾生類別的根本,直到圓滿擾動的根源,看到它虛幻而愈發顯現,動盪而不窮盡,就認為它是常。從廣到狹,從粗到精,略有次第。第一種是認為五陰(色、受、想、行、識)、四大(地、水、火、風)、心境二處,都是無因而自然產生的,循環往復,不會失去。第二種是隻指地、水、火、風清凈四大之『性』,能夠構成眾生的色陰(物質),其本體恒常不變。第三種是隻指心識六根所依的末那識(Manas,第七識),執受之心、執受之意、執受之識,其本元之處,就是行陰(行為)。眾生雖然有輪迴,但行陰不會失去,就認為這第七識是常住的『性』。就像看到細小的水流,就認為是靜止的水一樣。無始以來生死的根本,愚癡的人卻把它叫做『本來人』,說的就是這種情況。第四種是錯誤地認為行陰是自然之理,認為生滅的『想』心既然已經滅盡,那麼其永滅之處,自然就成了不生不滅。在這種生滅之中,計度為不生不滅,就像看到虛空就認為是常住一樣,卻不知道虛空也是可以滅的。而且還是因為內心的計度而認為是常,並非真正見到其常。這四種情況都還沒有見到八識(阿賴耶識,Alaya-vijnana)真常的流注,更何況是轉識成智而見到菩提自性呢?",
    
    "瑞巖禪師問巖頭禪師:『如何是本常理?』巖頭禪師說:『動也。』瑞巖禪師問:『動時如何?』巖頭禪師說:『不見本常理。』瑞巖禪師佇立思考。巖頭禪師說:『肯即未脫根塵,不肯即永沉生死。』瑞巖禪師於是禮拜。天童禪師頌道:『圓珠不穴,大璞不琢,道人所貴無棱角。拈卻肯路根塵空,脫體無依活卓卓。』這對於本來常住的見解,已經到了極其真實的程度。『肯』之一字,尚且需要拋棄。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "The third case is where people exhaust the six roots (eye, ear, nose, tongue, body, and mind) and the clinging of Manas (the seventh consciousness, the root of mind), believing that within the mind-consciousness (mind, intention, consciousness) there is a fundamental origin, which is constant and unchanging. They believe that through practice, they can know the cycle of all sentient beings in eighty thousand kalpas (an extremely long unit of time), and this origin always exists and has never been lost. They mistakenly regard this originally permanent 'nature,' which is exhausted but not lost, as eternally unchanging. This is the third type of heretic, who establishes the theory of 'permanence'.",
    
    "The fourth case is where people exhaust the source of 'thought,' believing that the physiological flow and movement have stopped, and the thought-mind of arising and ceasing has been permanently extinguished. They believe that in 'principle,' a state of non-arising and non-ceasing will naturally form. Because of their internal calculation, they believe this is eternally unchanging. Due to this calculation, they lose the correct perfect knowledge (Samyak-sambuddha), fall into heresy, and are deluded about the self-nature of Bodhi (enlightenment). This is called the second type of heretic, who establishes the theory of 'perfect permanence'.",
    
    "Chan Master Tong said: 'Those who establish the theory of no cause only see annihilation; those who establish the theory of perfect permanence only see permanence. Reasoning further, it is either both annihilation and permanence, or neither annihilation nor permanence, but in any case, they cannot escape the heretical views of annihilation and permanence.' Exhaustively investigating the root of sentient beings, up to the source of perfect disturbance, seeing it as illusory yet increasingly manifest, turbulent yet inexhaustible, they then consider it permanent. From broad to narrow, from coarse to fine, there is a slight order. The first is to believe that the five skandhas (form, feeling, perception, volition, consciousness), the four great elements (earth, water, fire, wind), and the two places of mind and environment, all arise naturally without cause, cycling repeatedly without loss. The second is to only refer to the 'nature' of the pure four great elements of earth, water, fire, and wind, which can constitute the form skandha (matter) of sentient beings, and whose essence is eternally unchanging. The third is to only refer to Manas (the seventh consciousness), which is the basis of the six roots of mind-consciousness, the clinging mind, the clinging intention, the clinging consciousness, and its fundamental origin, which is the volition skandha (action). Although sentient beings have cycles of rebirth, the volition skandha is not lost, and they consider this seventh consciousness to be a permanent 'nature.' It's like seeing a small stream of water and thinking it is still water. The root of birth and death since beginningless time, foolish people call it the 'original person,' which is what this refers to. The fourth is to mistakenly believe that the volition skandha is a natural principle, believing that since the thought-mind of arising and ceasing has been extinguished, then the place of its permanent extinction will naturally become non-arising and non-ceasing. In this arising and ceasing, they calculate non-arising and non-ceasing, just like seeing emptiness and thinking it is permanent, but not knowing that emptiness can also be extinguished. Moreover, it is because of internal calculation that they believe it is permanent, not truly seeing its permanence. These four cases have not yet seen the true and constant flow of the eight consciousnesses (Alaya-vijnana), let alone transforming consciousness into wisdom and seeing the self-nature of Bodhi?",
    
    "Zen Master Ruiyan asked Zen Master Yantou: 'What is the fundamental permanent principle?' Zen Master Yantou said: 'Movement.' Zen Master Ruiyan asked: 'What about when it moves?' Zen Master Yantou said: 'You don't see the fundamental permanent principle.' Zen Master Ruiyan stood still and pondered. Zen Master Yantou said: 'Affirming it means you haven't escaped the roots and dust, denying it means you will sink into birth and death forever.' Zen Master Ruiyan then bowed. Zen Master Tiantong praised: 'A round pearl is not drilled, a great uncarved gem is not chiseled, what a Taoist values is having no sharp edges. Discarding the path of affirmation, the roots and dust are empty, freed from the body, without reliance, vividly independent.' This understanding of the originally permanent is extremely true. Even the word 'affirmation' must be discarded."
  ]
}

而況計度執受神我。墜入圓常窟中。終從淪墮。豈能常也。

  又三摩中諸善男子。堅凝正心。魔不得便。窮生類本。觀彼幽清。常擾動元。于自他中起計度者。是人墜入四顛倒見。一分無常。一分常論。一者是人觀妙明心。遍十方界。湛然以為究竟神我。從是則計我遍十方。凝明不動。一切眾生於我心中。自生自死。則我心性。名之為常。彼生滅者。真無常性。二者是人不觀其心。遍觀十方恒沙國土。見劫壞處。名為究竟無常種性。劫不壞處。名究竟常。三者是人別觀我心。精細微密。猶如微塵。流轉十方。性無改移。能令此身即生即滅。其不壞性。名我性常。一切死生。從是流出。名無常性。四者是人知想陰盡。見行陰流。行陰常流。計為常性。色受想等。今已滅盡。名為無常。由此計度一分無常。一分常故。墮落外道。惑菩提性。是則名為第三外道一分常論。

  通曰。此亦常亦無常見也。本妙明心。遍十方界。未嘗不是。但執為神我則非也。唯執是我。正是末那執受意識。雖云凝明不動。其中微細遷流。即生滅種子。特不自覺耳。既以暫時不動心性名之為常。又以一切眾生生滅為無常性。則所謂遍十方者有二我也。豈不顛倒。無論心性。只論國土。則三禪以下。三災所及。名之無常。四禪以上。災不能及。名究竟常。無論國土。但論心性。性無改移。名我性常。死此生彼。名無常性。始合自他總計常無常。既分自他各計常無常。又復以行陰為自。色受想為他。行陰常流。名為常性。想等滅盡。名無常性。於一心中分常無常

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "何況還去計較、思量、執著于神我(Atman,一種常住不變的自我概念),這樣就會墜入圓滿常住的空窟之中,最終沉淪墮落,又怎麼能達到真正的常住呢?",
    
    "再者,在禪定中的各位善男子,如果能堅定凝聚正念之心,魔就無法得逞。深入探究眾生的根本,觀察那幽微清凈、恒常擾動的本元,卻在自身與他者之間產生計較思量,這種人就會墜入四種顛倒見解之中,形成一部分是無常,一部分是常住的論調。第一種人,觀察那妙明真心,遍及十方世界,就認為這湛然不動的狀態是究竟的神我。由此就推論出『我』遍佈十方,凝定光明而不動搖,一切眾生都在『我』心中自生自滅,因此『我』的心性就稱為常住。而那些生滅變化的現象,才是真正的無常。第二種人,不觀察自己的心,而是遍觀十方恒河沙數般的國土,看到劫難毀滅的地方,就認為是究竟的無常之性;劫難無法毀滅的地方,就認為是究竟的常住。第三種人,分別觀察自己的心,精細微密,猶如微塵,流轉於十方,本性沒有改變,能夠使這個身體即生即滅,這不壞的本性,就稱為『我』的常性。一切生死,都從此流出,就稱為無常之性。第四種人,知道想陰(Saṃjñā-skandha,五蘊之一,指思想、概念)已經消盡,看到行陰(Saṃskāra-skandha,五蘊之一,指意志、行為)在流動,認為行陰恒常流動就是常性,而色(Rūpa-skandha,五蘊之一,指物質現象)、受(Vedanā-skandha,五蘊之一,指感受)、想(Saṃjñā-skandha,五蘊之一,指思想、概念)等已經滅盡,就是無常。由於這樣計較思量一部分是無常,一部分是常住,所以會墮落到外道之中,迷惑菩提(Bodhi,覺悟)的本性。這就是所謂的第三種外道,一部分常住的論調。",
    
    "通曰:這也是亦常亦無常的見解。本來的妙明真心,遍及十方世界,本來就是如此。但如果執著它為神我(Atman),那就是錯誤的。唯獨執著于『我』,正是末那識(Manas,八識之一,執著自我)執受意識(Vijñāna,八識之一,分別事物的能力)。雖然說凝定光明而不動搖,但其中微細的遷流,就是生滅的種子,只是自己沒有察覺罷了。既然把暫時不動的心性稱為常住,又把一切眾生的生滅變化稱為無常,那麼所謂遍及十方,就有兩個『我』了。這難道不是顛倒嗎?無論是心性,只論國土,那麼三禪(Tṛtīya Dhyāna,色界第三禪)以下,三災(Three Disasters,火災、水災、風災)所能波及的地方,就稱之為無常;四禪(Caturtha Dhyāna,色界第四禪)以上,災難不能波及的地方,就稱為究竟的常住。無論是國土,只論心性,本性沒有改變,就稱為『我』的常性;死在這裡,生在那裡,就稱為無常之性。開始是把自身與他者總合起來計較常與無常,後來又把自身與他者分開來各自計較常與無常,又把行陰(Saṃskāra-skandha)看作自身,把色(Rūpa-skandha)、受(Vedanā-skandha)、想(Saṃjñā-skandha)看作他者,行陰(Saṃskāra-skandha)恒常流動,就稱為常性;想(Saṃjñā-skandha)等滅盡,就稱為無常。於一個心中,區分常與無常。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Moreover, to engage in calculation, deliberation, and attachment to a self (Atman, a concept of a permanent, unchanging self) is to fall into the cave of perfect permanence, ultimately leading to sinking and degradation. How can one then attain true permanence?",
    
    "Furthermore, virtuous men in samadhi (Samādhi, a state of concentrated meditation), if they can firmly solidify their minds with right mindfulness, will not be exploited by demons. Deeply investigating the root of sentient beings, observing that subtle and pure, constantly agitating source, yet generating calculation and deliberation between self and others, such a person will fall into four inverted views, forming a doctrine of partial impermanence and partial permanence. The first type observes the wondrously bright mind, pervading the ten directions, and considers this still and unmoving state to be the ultimate self. From this, they deduce that 'I' pervades the ten directions, solidified and bright, without movement. All sentient beings are born and die within 'my' mind, therefore 'my' mind-nature is called permanent. Those phenomena that arise and cease are truly impermanent. The second type does not observe their own mind, but instead observes the lands of the ten directions, as numerous as the sands of the Ganges. They see places destroyed by kalpas (Kalpa, an aeon or cosmic cycle) and consider them to be of an ultimately impermanent nature; places not destroyed by kalpas, they consider to be ultimately permanent. The third type separately observes their own mind, finely and subtly, like a mote of dust, flowing through the ten directions, its nature unchanging, capable of causing this body to be born and die. This indestructible nature is called the permanent nature of 'I'. All birth and death flows from this, and is called impermanent nature. The fourth type knows that the skandha (Skandha, one of the five aggregates that constitute a person) of thought (Saṃjñā-skandha) has ended, and sees the flow of the skandha of volition (Saṃskāra-skandha). They consider the constant flow of the skandha of volition to be permanent nature, while form (Rūpa-skandha), sensation (Vedanā-skandha), thought (Saṃjñā-skandha), etc., have already ceased and are called impermanent. Because of this calculation and deliberation of partial impermanence and partial permanence, they fall into external paths, confused about the nature of Bodhi (Bodhi, enlightenment). This is what is called the third type of external path, the doctrine of partial permanence.",
    
    "Commentary: This is also a view of both permanence and impermanence. The original wondrously bright mind pervades the ten directions, and that is how it is. But if one clings to it as a self (Atman), then it is wrong. To cling solely to 'I' is precisely the Manas (Manas, one of the eight consciousnesses, the mind that clings to self) clinging to the consciousness (Vijñāna, one of the eight consciousnesses, the ability to distinguish things). Although it is said to be solidified and bright without movement, the subtle changes within are the seeds of arising and ceasing, only one is not aware of it. Since one calls the temporarily unmoving mind-nature permanent, and calls the arising and ceasing of all sentient beings impermanent, then the so-called pervading the ten directions has two 'I's. Is this not inverted? Regardless of mind-nature, only discussing lands, then below the Third Dhyana (Tṛtīya Dhyāna, the third meditation stage in the Form Realm), where the Three Disasters (Three Disasters, fire, water, and wind) can reach, is called impermanent; above the Fourth Dhyana (Caturtha Dhyāna, the fourth meditation stage in the Form Realm), where disasters cannot reach, is called ultimately permanent. Regardless of lands, only discussing mind-nature, its nature unchanging is called the permanent nature of 'I'; dying here and being born there is called impermanent nature. Initially, self and others are combined to calculate permanence and impermanence; later, self and others are separated to calculate permanence and impermanence separately. Furthermore, the skandha of volition (Saṃskāra-skandha) is regarded as self, while form (Rūpa-skandha), sensation (Vedanā-skandha), and thought (Saṃjñā-skandha) are regarded as others. The constant flow of the skandha of volition (Saṃskāra-skandha) is called permanent nature; the cessation of thought (Saṃjñā-skandha), etc., is called impermanent. Within one mind, permanence and impermanence are distinguished."
  ]
}

。是以心有二也。豈不顛倒。此視前圓常之論。稍無拘執。然源頭不清。總屬謬計。忠國師問僧何方來。曰南方來。師曰。南方知識如何示人。曰。彼方知識。直下示學人即心即佛。佛是覺義。汝今悉具見聞覺知之性。此性善能揚眉瞬目。去來運用。遍於身中。挃頭頭知。挃腳腳知。故名正遍知。離此之外。更無別佛。此身即有生滅。心性無始以來。未曾生滅。身生滅者。如龍換骨。蛇蛻皮。人出故宅。即身是無常。其性常也。南方所說。大約如此。師曰。若然者。與彼先尼外道。無有差別。彼云。我此身中。有一神性。此效能知痛癢。身壞之時。神則出去。如舍被燒。舍主出去。舍即無常。舍主常矣。審如此者。邪正莫辨。孰為是乎。吾比遊方。多見此色。近尤盛矣。聚卻三五百眾。目視雲漢。云是南方宗旨。把他壇經改換。添糅雜譚。削除聖意。惑亂后徒。豈成言教。苦哉吾宗喪矣。若以見聞覺知是佛性者。凈名不應云法離見聞覺知。若行見聞覺知。是則見聞覺知。非求法也。僧又問法華了義經開佛知見。此復若為。師曰。他云開佛知見。不言菩薩二乘。豈以眾生癡倒。便同佛之知見耶。行昌問於六祖曰。弟子常覽涅槃經。未曉常無常義。乞為解說。祖曰。無常者。即佛性也。有常者。即一切善惡諸法分別心也。曰和尚所說。大違經文。祖曰。吾傳佛心印。安敢違于佛經。曰。經說佛性是常。和尚卻言無常。善惡諸法。乃至菩提心。皆是無常。和尚卻言常。此即相違。令學人轉加疑惑。祖曰。涅槃經。吾聽尼無盡藏讀誦一遍。便為講說

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本:",
    "因此說,這是因為心中存在二元對立。這難道不是顛倒嗎?這種觀點相比之前圓融常住的理論,稍微少了一些拘束。然而,如果源頭不清,那麼一切都將是錯誤的。忠國師問一位僧人從哪裡來,僧人回答說從南方來。國師問:『南方的大德是如何教導人們的?』僧人說:『南方的大德直接向學人開示,即心即佛,佛是覺悟的意思。你們現在都具備見聞覺知的本性。這個本性善於揚眉瞬目,來來去去,遍佈全身。觸碰頭部,頭部知道;觸碰腳部,腳部知道,所以稱為正遍知。除了這個之外,沒有別的佛。這個身體有生滅,但心性從無始以來,從未生滅。身體的生滅,就像龍換骨,蛇蛻皮,人離開舊宅一樣。身體是無常的,而心性是常住的。南方所說的,大概就是這樣。』國師說:『如果這樣的話,那和先尼外道(印度古代的一種外道)沒有什麼區別。他們說,我的身體中有一個神性,這個神效能夠感知痛癢。身體壞滅的時候,神性就會離開,就像房屋被燒燬,主人離開一樣。房屋是無常的,而主人是常住的。如果真是這樣,那麼邪正就無法分辨,誰是對的呢?我以前遊方的時候,經常見到這種說法,最近尤其盛行。他們聚集三五百人,眼高於頂,自稱是南方宗旨,把《壇經》改頭換面,新增雜亂的言論,刪除聖人的意思,迷惑後來的學徒。這怎麼能成為言教呢?可悲啊,我的宗門要衰落了!如果認為見聞覺知就是佛性,那麼《維摩詰經》(Vimalakirti Sutra)就不應該說『法離見聞覺知』。如果執著于見聞覺知,那就是見聞覺知,而不是求法。』僧人又問:『《法華經》(Lotus Sutra)說開佛知見,這又該如何解釋?』國師說:『他們說開佛知見,卻沒有說菩薩和二乘(聲聞和緣覺)。難道因為眾生愚癡顛倒,就和佛的知見一樣了嗎?』行昌問六祖慧能(Sixth Patriarch Huineng)說:『弟子經常閱讀《涅槃經》(Nirvana Sutra),但不明白常與無常的含義,請您為我解說。』六祖說:『無常的,就是佛性。常的,就是一切善惡諸法的分別心。』行昌說:『和尚您所說的,大大違背了經文。』六祖說:『我傳的是佛心印,怎麼敢違背佛經呢?』行昌說:『經中說佛性是常,和尚您卻說是無常;善惡諸法,乃至菩提心,都是無常,和尚您卻說是常,這實在是矛盾,讓學人更加疑惑。』六祖說:『《涅槃經》,我聽尼姑無盡藏讀誦一遍,就為她講解了。』",
    "English version:",
    "Therefore, it is said that the mind has duality. Isn't this inverted? This view is slightly less restrictive than the previous theory of perfect and constant permanence. However, if the source is unclear, then everything will be a miscalculation. National Teacher Zhong asked a monk where he came from, and the monk replied that he came from the South. The National Teacher asked, 'How do the virtuous ones in the South teach people?' The monk said, 'The virtuous ones in the South directly reveal to the students that the mind is the Buddha, and the Buddha means enlightenment. You all now possess the nature of seeing, hearing, knowing, and perceiving. This nature is good at raising eyebrows and blinking, coming and going, and pervading the whole body. Touching the head, the head knows; touching the foot, the foot knows, so it is called Right and Universal Knowledge (Sammasambuddha). Apart from this, there is no other Buddha. This body has birth and death, but the mind-nature has never been born or died since beginningless time. The birth and death of the body is like a dragon changing bones, a snake shedding its skin, and a person leaving an old house. The body is impermanent, but the mind-nature is permanent. What is said in the South is roughly like this.' The National Teacher said, 'If that is the case, then there is no difference between that and the Sianni heretics (an ancient Indian heretical sect). They say that there is a divine nature in my body, and this divine nature can perceive pain and itching. When the body is destroyed, the divine nature will leave, just like when a house is burned down, the owner leaves. The house is impermanent, but the owner is permanent. If this is really the case, then it is impossible to distinguish between right and wrong, who is right? When I used to travel around, I often saw this kind of statement, and it has become especially prevalent recently. They gather three to five hundred people, look down from above, claim to be the Southern school, change the *Platform Sutra* (Liuzu tanjing), add miscellaneous remarks, delete the meaning of the sages, and confuse later disciples. How can this become a teaching? Alas, my school is going to decline! If seeing, hearing, knowing, and perceiving are considered to be Buddha-nature, then the *Vimalakirti Sutra* (Vimalakirti Sutra) should not say 'the Dharma is apart from seeing, hearing, knowing, and perceiving.' If one is attached to seeing, hearing, knowing, and perceiving, then that is seeing, hearing, knowing, and perceiving, not seeking the Dharma.' The monk then asked, 'The *Lotus Sutra* (Lotus Sutra) says to open the Buddha's knowledge and vision, how should this be explained?' The National Teacher said, 'They say to open the Buddha's knowledge and vision, but they do not mention Bodhisattvas and the Two Vehicles (Sravakas and Pratyekabuddhas). Is it because sentient beings are ignorant and inverted that they are the same as the Buddha's knowledge and vision?' Xingchang asked the Sixth Patriarch Huineng (Sixth Patriarch Huineng), 'This disciple often reads the *Nirvana Sutra* (Nirvana Sutra), but does not understand the meaning of permanence and impermanence, please explain it to me.' The Sixth Patriarch said, 'What is impermanent is the Buddha-nature. What is permanent is the discriminating mind of all good and evil dharmas.' Xingchang said, 'What you say, Master, greatly contradicts the scriptures.' The Sixth Patriarch said, 'What I transmit is the Buddha's mind-seal, how dare I contradict the scriptures?' Xingchang said, 'The scriptures say that Buddha-nature is permanent, but you say it is impermanent; all good and evil dharmas, even the Bodhi mind, are impermanent, but you say they are permanent, this is really contradictory, making students more confused.' The Sixth Patriarch said, 'I listened to the nun Wujinzang recite the *Nirvana Sutra* once, and then explained it to her.'"
  ]
}

。無一字一義不合經文。乃至為汝終無二說。曰。學人識量淺昧。愿和尚委曲開示。祖曰。汝知否。佛性若常。更說什麼善惡諸法。乃至窮劫無有一人發菩提心者。故吾說無常。正是佛說真常之道也。又一切諸法若無常者。即物物皆有自性。容受生死。而真常性有不遍之處。故吾說常者。正是佛說真無常義。佛比為凡夫外道。執于邪常。諸二乘人。于常計無常。共成八倒。故於涅槃了義教中。破彼偏見。而顯說真常真樂真我真凈。汝今背義。以斷滅無常。及確定死常。而錯解佛之圓妙最後微言。縱覽千遍。有何所益。行昌忽然大悟。乃說偈曰。因守無常心。佛說有常性。不知方便者。猶春池拾礫。我今不施功。佛性而現前。非師相授與。我亦無所得。祖曰。汝今徹也。宜名志徹。禮謝而退。若此甚深常無常義。彼諸外道。未夢見在。

  又三摩中諸善男子。堅凝正心。魔不得便。窮生類本。觀彼幽清。常擾動元。于分位中生計度者。是人墜入四有邊論。一者是人心計生元。流用不息。計過未者。名為有邊。計相續心。名為無邊。二者是人觀八萬劫則見眾生。八萬劫前。寂無聞見。無聞見處。名為無邊。有眾生處。名為有邊。三者是人計我遍知得無邊性。彼一切人現我知中。我曾不知彼之知性。名彼不得無邊之心。但有邊性。四者是人窮行陰空。以其所見心路。籌度一切眾生。一身之中。計其咸皆半生半滅。明其世界一切所有。一半有邊。一半無邊。由是計度有邊無邊。墮落外道。惑菩提性。是則名為第四外道立有邊論。

  通曰。

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "'沒有一個字、一個義不符合經文。甚至爲了你,我始終不會有第二種說法。'行昌說:'學人我的見識淺薄愚昧,希望和尚您詳細開示。'六祖慧能說:'你知道嗎?如果佛性是恒常不變的,還說什麼善惡諸法呢?甚至窮盡劫數也不會有一個人發起菩提心。所以我說無常,這正是佛所說的真常之道啊。又,如果一切諸法都是無常的,那麼事物就都各自具有自性,能夠容納生死,而真常的佛性就不能遍及一切地方了。所以我說常,這正是佛所說的真無常之義。佛將凡夫外道比作執著于邪常,而二乘之人,又在常中計較無常,共同形成了八種顛倒。所以在涅槃了義教中,破除他們的偏見,而明顯地說出真常、真樂、真我、真凈。你現在背離了經義,用斷滅的無常,以及確定的死常,來錯誤地理解佛的圓滿微妙的最後教言,縱然讀覽千遍,又有什麼益處呢?'行昌忽然大悟,於是說偈語道:'因為執守無常之心,佛才說有常之性。不明白方便法門的人,就像在春天的池塘里拾取瓦礫。我現在不用任何功力,佛性自然顯現於眼前。這不是老師傳授給我的,我也並沒有得到什麼。'六祖慧能說:'你現在徹底明白了。應該改名叫志徹。'行昌禮拜感謝後退下。像這樣甚深的常與無常之義,那些外道,連做夢都沒有夢到過。",
    
    "又,在三摩地(Samadhi,禪定)中,各位善男子,堅定凝聚正心,邪魔就無法得逞。窮究眾生類別的根本,觀察那幽微清凈、經常擾動的本元,在分位之中產生計度分別的人,就會墜入四種有邊論。第一種是,這個人用心計度生命的本元,認為其流轉作用永不停息,計較過去和未來,就稱為有邊;計較相續不斷的心,就稱為無邊。第二種是,這個人觀察八萬劫,就能見到眾生;八萬劫之前,寂靜無聲,沒有見聞,沒有見聞之處,就稱為無邊;有眾生存在之處,就稱為有邊。第三種是,這個人認為我的遍知能夠得到無邊之性,所有的人都出現在我的知覺之中,但我卻從來不知道他們的知覺之性,這就叫做他們不能得到無邊之心,而只有有邊之性。第四種是,這個人窮究行陰(Saṃskāra-skandha,行蘊)的空性,用他所見的心路,來推測衡量一切眾生,認為在一個人的身體之中,都有一半生一半滅。明白這個世界的一切所有,一半是有邊,一半是無邊。由於這樣計度有邊無邊,就會墮落到外道之中,迷惑菩提(Bodhi,覺悟)之性。這就是第四種外道所立的有邊論。",
    
    "通曰:"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "'Not a single word or meaning deviates from the sutras. Even for your sake, I will never have a second explanation.' Xingchang said, 'My knowledge is shallow and ignorant. I hope that the Venerable One will explain it in detail.' The Sixth Patriarch Huineng said, 'Do you know? If the Buddha-nature were constant, what would be the point of talking about good and evil dharmas? Even if the kalpas were exhausted, no one would generate Bodhicitta (the mind of enlightenment). Therefore, when I speak of impermanence, it is precisely the true permanence taught by the Buddha. Furthermore, if all dharmas were impermanent, then everything would have its own self-nature, capable of accommodating birth and death, and the true permanent nature would not be able to pervade everywhere. Therefore, when I speak of permanence, it is precisely the true meaning of impermanence taught by the Buddha. The Buddha compared ordinary people and externalists to those who cling to false permanence, while those of the Two Vehicles (Śrāvakayāna and Pratyekabuddhayāna) calculate impermanence within permanence, together forming the eight inversions. Therefore, in the definitive teachings of the Nirvana Sutra, their biased views are refuted, and true permanence, true bliss, true self, and true purity are clearly explained. You are now deviating from the meaning of the sutras, using the impermanence of annihilation and the fixed permanence of death to misunderstand the Buddha's perfect and subtle final teachings. Even if you read them a thousand times, what benefit would there be?' Xingchang suddenly had a great awakening and then spoke a verse, 'Because of clinging to the mind of impermanence, the Buddha spoke of the nature of permanence. Those who do not understand skillful means are like picking up pebbles in a spring pond. Now, without any effort on my part, the Buddha-nature naturally manifests before me. This was not taught to me by the teacher, nor have I gained anything.' The Sixth Patriarch Huineng said, 'You now understand thoroughly. You should be renamed Zhiche (Thorough Understanding).' Xingchang bowed in gratitude and withdrew. Such a profound meaning of permanence and impermanence is something those externalists have never even dreamed of.",
    
    "Furthermore, in Samadhi (concentration), you good men, if you firmly concentrate your right mind, demons will not be able to take advantage. Exhaustively investigate the root of sentient beings, observe that subtle and pure, constantly disturbing origin, and those who generate calculation and discrimination within the divisions will fall into the four doctrines of limited existence. The first is that this person uses the mind to calculate the origin of life, believing that its flow and function never cease, calculating the past and future, which is called limited existence; calculating the continuously connected mind, which is called unlimited existence. The second is that this person observes eighty thousand kalpas and can see sentient beings; before eighty thousand kalpas, there is silence, no hearing or seeing, and the place where there is no hearing or seeing is called unlimited existence; the place where sentient beings exist is called limited existence. The third is that this person believes that my all-knowingness can attain the nature of unlimited existence, and all people appear in my perception, but I have never known their nature of perception, which is called they cannot attain the mind of unlimited existence, but only the nature of limited existence. The fourth is that this person exhaustively investigates the emptiness of the Saṃskāra-skandha (aggregate of mental formations), using the path of the mind that he has seen to speculate and measure all sentient beings, believing that within one person's body, there is half birth and half extinction. Understanding that everything in this world is half limited existence and half unlimited existence. Because of calculating limited and unlimited existence in this way, one will fall into externalism and be deluded about the Bodhi (enlightenment) nature. This is the fourth doctrine of limited existence established by externalists.",
    
    "Tong said:"
  ]
}

此就常無常。例起邊無邊。論常無常以性言。屬見分。邊無邊以分位言。屬相分。一三際分位。二見聞分位。三彼我分位。四生滅分位。總局於行陰之分位。而妄生計度也。一者因行陰流用不息。以其流用也。成過未現三際。故名有邊。以其不息也。相續無際。故名無邊。二者但計眾生八萬劫內見聞所及。故名有邊。八萬劫外無聞見處。故名無邊。三者計我遍知一切眾生。名無邊性。彼之知性遍與不遍。但彼自知我曾不知。彼則局于自知。不能通之於我。但有邊性。四者窮行陰空。昔有今無。因計正報眾生。半生半滅。依報世界。亦半生半滅。半生為有邊。半滅為無邊。此四有邊總不出前眾生生滅循環及劫壞不壞等見。特以邊量論耳。僧問忠國師曰。有知識示學人。但自識性。了無常時。拋卻殼漏子一邊著。靈臺智性。迥然而去。名為解脫。此復若為。師曰。前已說了。猶是二乘外道之量。二乘厭離生死。欣樂涅槃。外道亦言吾有大患。為吾有身。乃趣乎冥諦。須陀洹入八萬劫。餘三果入六四二萬劫。辟支佛一萬劫住空定中。外道八萬劫住非非想中。二乘劫滿。猶能迴心向大。外道還即輪迴。曰。佛性一種。為別。師曰。不得一種。曰何也。師曰。或有全不生滅。或半生半滅。半不生滅。曰孰為此解。師曰。我此間佛性。全無生滅。汝南方佛性。半生半滅。半不生滅。曰如何區別。師曰。此則身心一如。身外無餘。所以全不生滅。汝南方身是無常。神性是常。所心半生半滅。半不生滅。曰和尚色身。豈得便同法身不生滅耶。師曰。汝那得入

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "此就常與無常,例如有邊與無邊。討論常與無常,是從自性的角度來說,屬於見分(能見之主體)。討論有邊與無邊,是從分位的角度來說,屬於相分(所見之客體)。",
    "一、三際分位:因為行陰(五蘊之一,指遷流變化的心理活動)的流轉作用沒有止息,因為它的流轉作用,形成了過去、未來、現在這三際,所以稱為『有邊』。因為它沒有止息,相續不斷,所以稱為『無邊』。",
    "二、見聞分位:僅僅計算眾生在八萬劫(佛教時間單位)內見聞所能達到的範圍,所以稱為『有邊』。八萬劫之外,沒有見聞的地方,就稱為『無邊』。",
    "三、彼我分位:認為我的知性遍知一切眾生,稱為『無邊性』。至於他的知性是普遍還是不普遍,只有他自己知道,我並不知道。他侷限於自己的知性,不能與我相通,所以只有『有邊性』。",
    "四、生滅分位:窮盡行陰的空性,過去有而現在無。因此認為正報眾生(承受果報的主體,即眾生本身)一半生一半滅,依報世界(眾生所依賴的生存環境)也是一半生一半滅。一半生為『有邊』,一半滅為『無邊』。這四種『有邊』的見解,總的來說,都離不開前面所說的眾生生滅循環以及劫(佛教時間單位)壞與不壞等等的見解,只不過是用邊際來衡量罷了。",
    "有僧人問忠國師(唐代國師)說:『有知識的人教導學人,只要認識自己的本性,了悟沒有常住不變的時候,把像殼和漏子一樣的東西拋在一邊,讓靈臺(指心)的智性,迥然獨立而去,這叫做解脫。』這又該如何理解呢?",
    "國師說:『前面已經說過了,這仍然是二乘(聲聞乘和緣覺乘)和外道的見解。二乘厭惡捨棄生死,欣然嚮往涅槃。外道也說我最大的憂患,就是因為我有這個身體,於是追求冥諦(一種虛無的境界)。須陀洹(小乘初果)要經過八萬劫,斯陀含、阿那含、阿羅漢(小乘二、三、四果)要經過六萬四千、四萬、兩萬劫。辟支佛(緣覺)在一萬劫中住在空定之中。外道在八萬劫中住在非想非非想處定中。』",
    "『二乘在劫數滿了之後,還能迴心向大乘,外道卻立刻又會輪迴。』",
    "僧人問:『佛性只有一種,還是有所區別?』",
    "國師說:『不能說只有一種。』",
    "僧人問:『為什麼呢?』",
    "國師說:『有的完全不生不滅,有的半生半滅,有的半不生滅。』",
    "僧人問:『誰是這樣理解的呢?』",
    "國師說:『我這裡的佛性,完全沒有生滅。你南方的佛性,一半生一半滅,一半不生滅。』",
    "僧人問:『如何區別呢?』",
    "國師說:『這裡身心一如,身外沒有其餘,所以完全不生不滅。你南方身是無常的,神性是常的,所以心一半生一半滅,一半不生滅。』",
    "僧人問:『和尚您的色身(肉身),難道就能和法身(佛的真身)一樣不生不滅嗎?』",
    "國師說:『你如何才能進入這種境界呢?』"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "This concerns permanence and impermanence, for example, having boundaries and having no boundaries. Discussing permanence and impermanence is from the perspective of self-nature, belonging to the seeing aspect (the subject that sees). Discussing having boundaries and having no boundaries is from the perspective of division and position, belonging to the object aspect (the object that is seen).",
    "1. Divisions of the Three Times: Because the flowing function of the Skandha of Formation (one of the Five Skandhas, referring to the ceaseless flow of mental activities) does not cease, and because of its flowing function, it forms the three times of past, future, and present, hence it is called 'having boundaries.' Because it does not cease and continues uninterrupted, it is called 'having no boundaries.'",
    "2. Divisions of Seeing and Hearing: Merely calculating the range that sentient beings can reach within eighty thousand kalpas (Buddhist unit of time) through seeing and hearing, hence it is called 'having boundaries.' Beyond eighty thousand kalpas, where there is no seeing or hearing, it is called 'having no boundaries.'",
    "3. Divisions of Self and Other: Thinking that my knowing nature pervades all sentient beings is called 'having no boundaries.' As for whether his knowing nature is pervasive or not, only he himself knows; I do not know. He is limited to his own knowing nature and cannot communicate it to me, so it only has 'having boundaries.'",
    "4. Divisions of Birth and Death: Exhausting the emptiness of the Skandha of Formation, it existed in the past but does not exist now. Therefore, it is thought that the primary retribution beings (the subject that receives karmic retribution, i.e., sentient beings themselves) are half-born and half-extinguished, and the dependent world (the environment upon which sentient beings rely for survival) is also half-born and half-extinguished. Half-born is 'having boundaries,' and half-extinguished is 'having no boundaries.' These four kinds of views of 'having boundaries,' generally speaking, cannot be separated from the aforementioned views of the cycle of birth and death of sentient beings and the destruction and non-destruction of kalpas (Buddhist unit of time), etc., but are merely measured by boundaries.",
    "A monk asked National Teacher Zhong (a Tang Dynasty national teacher): 'A knowledgeable person instructs students to simply recognize their own nature, realizing that there is no permanence, casting aside things like shells and leaky vessels, allowing the wisdom of the spiritual platform (referring to the mind) to depart independently, which is called liberation.' How should this be understood?",
    "The National Teacher said: 'What was said earlier is still the measure of the Two Vehicles (Śrāvakayāna and Pratyekabuddhayāna) and external paths. The Two Vehicles detest and abandon birth and death, and joyfully aspire to Nirvana. External paths also say that their greatest suffering is because they have this body, and thus they pursue the Dark Truth (a nihilistic state). A Stream-Enterer (Sotāpanna, the first fruit of the Lesser Vehicle) must pass through eighty thousand kalpas, while Once-Returners, Non-Returners, and Arhats (the second, third, and fourth fruits of the Lesser Vehicle) must pass through sixty-four thousand, forty thousand, and twenty thousand kalpas.'",
    "'A Pratyekabuddha (Solitary Buddha) dwells in emptiness samadhi for one thousand kalpas. External paths dwell in the state of neither perception nor non-perception for eighty thousand kalpas.'",
    "'After the kalpas of the Two Vehicles are completed, they can still turn their minds towards the Great Vehicle, but external paths will immediately return to reincarnation.'",
    "The monk asked: 'Is Buddha-nature only one kind, or are there differences?'",
    "The National Teacher said: 'It cannot be said that there is only one kind.'",
    "The monk asked: 'Why?'",
    "The National Teacher said: 'Some are completely unproduced and unextinguished, some are half-produced and half-extinguished, and some are half-unproduced and half-unextinguished.'",
    "The monk asked: 'Who understands it this way?'",
    "The National Teacher said: 'The Buddha-nature here is completely without production or extinction. The Buddha-nature in your south is half-produced and half-extinguished, and half-unproduced and half-unextinguished.'",
    "The monk asked: 'How are they distinguished?'",
    "The National Teacher said: 'Here, body and mind are one, and there is nothing remaining outside the body, so it is completely unproduced and unextinguished. In your south, the body is impermanent, and the divine nature is permanent, so the mind is half-produced and half-extinguished, and half-unproduced and half-unextinguished.'",
    "The monk asked: 'Venerable Teacher, how can your physical body be the same as the Dharma body (the true body of the Buddha) and be unproduced and unextinguished?'",
    "The National Teacher said: 'How can you enter this state?'"
  ]
}

于邪道。曰學人早晚入邪道。(猶言學人那曾入邪道也)師曰。汝不見金剛經。色見聲求。皆行邪道。今汝所見不其然乎。曰某甲曾讀大小乘教。亦見有說不生不滅中道正性之處。亦見有說此陰滅彼陰生。身有代謝而神性不滅之文。那得盡撥同外道斷常二見。師曰。汝學出世無上正真之道。為學世間生死斷常二見耶。汝不見肇公云。談真則違俗。順俗則違真。違真故迷性而莫返。逆俗故言淡而無味。中流之人。如存如亡。下士拊掌而笑之。今汝欲學下士笑于大道乎。曰師亦言即心是佛。南方知識亦爾。那有異同。師不應自是而非他。師曰。或名異體同。或名同體異。因茲濫矣。只如菩提涅槃真如佛性。名異體同。真心妄心。佛智世智。名同體異。緣南方錯將妄心言是真心。認賊為子。有取世智稱為佛智。猶如魚目而亂明珠。不可雷同。事須甄別。曰若為得離此過。師曰。汝但子細返觀陰入界處。一一推窮有纖毫可得否。曰子細觀之。不見一物可得。師曰。汝壞身心相耶。曰身心性離。有何可壞。師曰。身外更有物否。曰身心無外。寧更有物耶。師曰。汝壞世間相耶。曰世間相即無相。那用更壞。師曰。若然者。即離過矣。華嚴經曰。一念普觀無量劫。無去無來亦無住。如是了知三世事。超諸方便成十力。此所謂自他不隔于毫端。始終不離於當念。不知有邊無邊之見。從何建立。

  又三摩中諸善男子。堅凝正心。魔不得便。窮生類本。觀彼幽清常擾動元。于知見中生計度者。是人墜入四種顛倒不死矯亂遍計虛論。一者是人觀變化元。見

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "落入邪道。學人問道:『我什麼時候落入邪道了?』(意思是說學人我什麼時候落入邪道了呢?)師父說:『你沒看見《金剛經》上說,以色相見我,以音聲求我,都是在行邪道。現在你所見的,不就是這樣嗎?』學人說:『我曾經讀過大乘和小乘的教義,也看到有說不生不滅、中道正性的地方,也看到有說這個陰滅了,那個陰生了,身體有新陳代謝,而神性不滅的文章。怎麼能完全否定,和外道的斷滅見和常見一樣呢?』師父說:『你學的是出世間無上正真的道,還是學世間生死的斷滅見和常見呢?你沒看見僧肇大師說,談論真理就違背世俗,順應世俗就違背真理。違背真理,所以迷失本性而不能返回;違逆世俗,所以言語平淡而沒有味道。中等資質的人,好像存在又好像不存在。下等資質的人拍手嘲笑。現在你想學下等資質的人嘲笑大道嗎?』學人說:『師父也說即心是佛,南方禪宗的知識也是這樣說的,那有什麼不同呢?師父不應該自以為是,否定別人。』師父說:『有的名稱不同,本體相同;有的名稱相同,本體不同。因此就混亂了。比如菩提(覺悟),涅槃(寂滅),真如(實相),佛性(覺悟的本性),名稱不同,本體相同。真心和妄心,佛智和世智,名稱相同,本體不同。因為南方禪宗錯誤地把妄心當成真心,認賊作子,把世間的智慧稱為佛的智慧,就像用魚眼睛來冒充明珠一樣,不能混為一談,必須加以甄別。』學人說:『怎樣才能避免這些過失呢?』師父說:『你只要仔細地反觀陰、入、界這些地方,一一推究,看有沒有絲毫可以得到的東西。』學人說:『仔細觀察,沒有一樣東西可以得到。』師父說:『你破壞了身心之相了嗎?』學人說:『身心之性本來就是分離的,有什麼可以破壞的呢?』師父說:『身外還有別的東西嗎?』學人說:『身心之外,哪裡還有別的東西呢?』師父說:『你破壞了世間之相了嗎?』學人說:『世間之相就是無相,哪裡用得著再去破壞呢?』師父說:『如果這樣,那就是離開了過失了。《華嚴經》說:一念普遍觀察無量劫,沒有去,沒有來,也沒有住。這樣了知過去、現在、未來三世的事情,超越各種方便法門,成就十力。這就是所說的自己和他人不隔于毫端,從始至終不離於當下這一念。不知有邊無邊的見解,從何處建立呢?』",
    
    "又,在三摩地(禪定)中,各位善男子,堅定凝聚正心,魔就無法得逞。窮究眾生的根本,觀察那些幽暗不清、經常擾動的本元,在知見中產生計度分別的人,這些人就會墮入四種顛倒、不死矯亂、遍計虛論之中。第一種是,這些人觀察變化的本元,見到..."
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Falling into evil paths. The disciple asked: 'When did I fall into evil paths?' (Meaning, when did I, the disciple, fall into evil paths?) The master said: 'Have you not seen the Diamond Sutra, which says that seeking me through form or sound is practicing evil paths? Is what you see now not the same?' The disciple said: 'I have read the teachings of both Mahayana and Hinayana, and I have seen places that speak of non-birth and non-death, the Middle Way and true nature. I have also seen writings that say when this skandha (aggregate) ceases, another arises, the body has metabolism, but the divine nature does not perish. How can you completely deny this and equate it with the annihilationist and eternalist views of external paths?' The master said: 'Are you learning the supreme and truly genuine path of transcendence, or are you learning the worldly views of annihilation and permanence regarding birth and death? Have you not seen what Master Zhao said: 'To speak of truth violates the mundane; to accord with the mundane violates the truth. Violating the truth leads to confusion of nature and no return; opposing the mundane leads to bland and tasteless words. Those of middling capacity are as if existing and as if not. Those of lower capacity clap their hands and laugh.' Do you now wish to learn from those of lower capacity and laugh at the Great Path?' The disciple said: 'The master also says that the mind itself is Buddha, and the teachers of the Southern School (Huineng's school) say the same. What is the difference? The master should not be self-righteous and deny others.' The master said: 'Some have different names but the same essence; some have the same name but different essences. Because of this, there is confusion. For example, Bodhi (enlightenment), Nirvana (liberation), Tathata (suchness), Buddha-nature (the nature of enlightenment), have different names but the same essence. True mind and deluded mind, Buddha-wisdom and worldly wisdom, have the same name but different essences. Because the Southern School mistakenly takes the deluded mind to be the true mind, recognizing a thief as their son, and calls worldly wisdom Buddha-wisdom, like using fish eyes to pass off as pearls, they cannot be equated and must be distinguished.' The disciple said: 'How can one avoid these faults?' The master said: 'You only need to carefully reflect on the places of skandhas (aggregates), entrances (sense bases), and realms (objects of sense), and thoroughly investigate whether there is anything that can be obtained.' The disciple said: 'Upon careful observation, nothing can be obtained.' The master said: 'Have you destroyed the appearance of body and mind?' The disciple said: 'The nature of body and mind is inherently separate, what is there to destroy?' The master said: 'Is there anything outside the body?' The disciple said: 'Outside of body and mind, where else is there anything?' The master said: 'Have you destroyed the appearance of the world?' The disciple said: 'The appearance of the world is non-appearance, what need is there to destroy it further?' The master said: 'If that is so, then you have left behind the faults. The Avatamsaka Sutra says: 'In one thought, universally observing countless kalpas (eons), there is no going, no coming, and no abiding. Thus knowing the affairs of the three times (past, present, future), surpassing all expedient means, accomplishing the ten powers.' This is what is meant by oneself and others not being separated by a hair's breadth, from beginning to end not being apart from the present moment. From where can the views of knowing the finite and infinite be established?'",
    
    "Furthermore, in samadhi (meditative concentration), you good men, firmly solidify the correct mind, and the demons will not be able to take advantage. Exhaustively investigate the origin of living beings, observe those obscure and constantly agitated primordial elements, and those who generate calculation and discrimination in their knowledge and views, these people will fall into four kinds of inverted, immortal, deceptive, and pervasive empty theories. The first is that these people observe the origin of change, and see..."
  ]
}

遷流處。名之為變。見相續處。名之為恒。見所見處。名之為生。不見見處。名之為滅。相續之因。性不斷處。名之為增。正相續中。中所離處。名之為減。各各生處。名之為有。互互亡處。名之為無。以理都觀。用心別見。有求法人。來問其義。答言我今亦生亦滅。亦有亦無。亦增亦減。於一切時。皆亂其語。令彼前人遺失章句。二者是人諦觀其心。互互無處。因無得證。有人來問。唯答一字。但言其無。除無之餘。無所言說。三者是人諦觀其心。各各有處。因有得證。有人來問。唯答一字。但言其是。除是之餘。無所言說。四者是人有無俱見。其境枝故。其心亦亂。有人來問。答言亦有即是亦無。亦無之中。不是亦有。一切矯亂。無容窮詰。由此計度。矯亂虛無。墮落外道。惑菩提性。是則名為第五外道。四顛倒性不死矯亂遍計虛論。

  通曰。此猶然亦有亦無見也。上言常無常。邊無邊。尚有區別。未至溷淆。此則即常即無常。即邊即無邊。一切矯亂。無容窮詰。實為虛無荒唐之論。顛倒之甚者。就上遷流有邊處。名之為變。相續無邊處。名之為常。八萬劫內所見處。名之為生。八萬劫外不見處。名之為滅。又于相續中不斷處。計為增。如白黑月漸生。中所離處。計為減。如晦夕白黑俱盡。又于各各生處。總謂之有。互互亡處。總謂之無。於一行陰生滅。分為八義。以理都觀。兩可俱是。不能定其端的。於一切時。皆亂其語。沉溺於行陰之中。不能超越於行陰之外。故為生滅所轉耳。又從有無而分之。于唸唸滅相而得證者。但言

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "『遷流』(變化流動)之處,稱之為『變』(變化)。見到『相續』(連續不斷)之處,稱之為『恒』(永恒)。見到『所見』之處,稱之為『生』(產生)。見不到『見』(看見)之處,稱之為『滅』(消滅)。『相續』的原因,『性』(本質)不斷之處,稱之為『增』(增長)。在『正相續』(正在連續)之中,中間所分離之處,稱之為『減』(減少)。各自產生之處,稱之為『有』(存在)。互相消失之處,稱之為『無』(不存在)。用道理全面觀察,用心分別看待。如果有求法之人來問其中的含義,回答說我如今也是生也是滅,也是有也是無,也是增也是減。在一切時候,都擾亂他的語言,使那前來問的人遺失了章句。這第一種人是顛倒的。",
    "第二種人仔細觀察他的心,在互相都沒有的地方,因為『無』(不存在)而得到證悟。有人來問,只回答一個字,只說『無』(不存在)。除了『無』(不存在)之外,沒有其他可說的。",
    "第三種人仔細觀察他的心,在各自都有的地方,因為『有』(存在)而得到證悟。有人來問,只回答一個字,只說『是』(存在)。除了『是』(存在)之外,沒有其他可說的。",
    "第四種人有和無都看見,他的境界繁雜,他的心也混亂。有人來問,回答說『有』(存在)也就是『無』(不存在),『無』(不存在)之中,不是『有』(存在)。一切都混亂顛倒,無法窮盡詰問。因為這樣的計度,混亂虛無,墮落外道,迷惑『菩提性』(覺悟的本性)。",
    "這就是第五種外道,四種顛倒的『性』(本質),不死而混亂,普遍計度而虛假的理論。",
    
    "通曰:這仍然是『亦有亦無』的見解。上面說的『常無常』(永恒與無常),『邊無邊』(有邊與無邊),尚且還有區別,還沒有到混淆的地步。這裡則是『即常即無常』(既永恒又無常),『即邊即無邊』(既有邊又無邊),一切都混亂顛倒,無法窮盡詰問。實在是虛無荒唐的理論,顛倒得厲害。就上面的遷流有邊之處,稱之為『變』(變化),相續無邊之處,稱之為『常』(永恒)。八萬劫(極長的時間單位)內所見之處,稱之為『生』(產生),八萬劫外不見之處,稱之為『滅』(消滅)。又在相續中不斷之處,認為是『增』(增長),如白月黑月漸漸生長。中間所分離之處,認為是『減』(減少),如晦夕白月黑月都消失。又在各自產生之處,總稱為『有』(存在),互相消失之處,總稱為『無』(不存在)。對於一行陰(五蘊之一,指心理活動)的生滅,分為八種意義。用道理全面觀察,兩方面都可以說是對的,不能確定其正確的。在一切時候,都擾亂他的語言,沉溺於行陰之中,不能超越於行陰之外,所以被生滅所轉變罷了。又從『有無』(存在與不存在)而區分。對於唸唸滅相而得到證悟的人,只說『無』(不存在)。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "The place of 『change』 (qiān liú, flowing and changing) is called 『transformation』 (biàn, change). Seeing the place of 『continuity』 (xiāng xù, continuous and uninterrupted) is called 『permanence』 (héng, eternal). Seeing the place of 『what is seen』 is called 『birth』 (shēng, arising). Not seeing the place of 『seeing』 is called 『cessation』 (miè, ceasing). The cause of 『continuity』, the place where 『nature』 (xìng, essence) is unbroken, is called 『increase』 (zēng, increasing). In the midst of 『right continuity』, the place of separation in the middle is called 『decrease』 (jiǎn, decreasing). Each place of arising is called 『existence』 (yǒu, being). Each place of mutual disappearance is called 『non-existence』 (wú, non-being). Observing comprehensively with reason, viewing separately with the mind. If there is a Dharma seeker who comes to ask its meaning, answer that I am now also arising and also ceasing, also existing and also non-existing, also increasing and also decreasing. At all times, he confuses his words, causing the questioner to lose the meaning of the sentences. This first type of person is inverted.",
    "The second type of person carefully observes his mind, in the place where there is nothing mutual, he attains enlightenment because of 『non-existence』 (wú, non-being). If someone comes to ask, he only answers one word, only saying 『non-existence』 (wú, non-being). Apart from 『non-existence』 (wú, non-being), there is nothing else to say.",
    "The third type of person carefully observes his mind, in the place where each exists, he attains enlightenment because of 『existence』 (yǒu, being). If someone comes to ask, he only answers one word, only saying 『is』 (shì, being). Apart from 『is』 (shì, being), there is nothing else to say.",
    "The fourth type of person sees both existence and non-existence, his realm is complex, and his mind is also confused. If someone comes to ask, he answers that 『existence』 (yǒu, being) is also 『non-existence』 (wú, non-being), and in 『non-existence』 (wú, non-being), it is not 『existence』 (yǒu, being). Everything is confused and inverted, impossible to exhaustively question. Because of such deliberation, confused and empty, he falls into external paths, deluded about 『Bodhi-nature』 (pú tí xìng, the nature of enlightenment).",
    "This is the fifth type of heretic, the four inverted 『natures』 (xìng, essence), undying and confused, universally calculated and false theories.",
    
    "Tong says: This is still the view of 『both existence and non-existence』 (yì yǒu yì wú). The above-mentioned 『permanence and impermanence』 (cháng wú cháng), 『boundedness and unboundedness』 (biān wú biān), still have distinctions, and have not yet reached the point of confusion. Here, it is 『both permanence and impermanence』 (jí cháng jí wú cháng), 『both boundedness and unboundedness』 (jí biān jí wú biān), everything is confused and inverted, impossible to exhaustively question. It is truly a nihilistic and absurd theory, extremely inverted. Regarding the above-mentioned flowing and changing place with boundaries, it is called 『transformation』 (biàn, change), and the continuous and unbounded place is called 『permanence』 (cháng, eternal). The place seen within eighty thousand kalpas (bā wàn jié, extremely long unit of time) is called 『birth』 (shēng, arising), and the place not seen outside eighty thousand kalpas is called 『cessation』 (miè, ceasing). Furthermore, the unbroken place in continuity is considered 『increase』 (zēng, increasing), like the gradual growth of the white moon and the black moon. The place of separation in the middle is considered 『decrease』 (jiǎn, decreasing), like the disappearance of both the white moon and the black moon on a dark evening. Furthermore, the place of each arising is generally called 『existence』 (yǒu, being), and the place of mutual disappearance is generally called 『non-existence』 (wú, non-being). Regarding the arising and ceasing of one aggregate of activity (xíng yīn, one of the five skandhas, referring to mental activity), it is divided into eight meanings. Observing comprehensively with reason, both aspects can be said to be correct, unable to determine its correctness. At all times, he confuses his words, drowning in the aggregate of activity, unable to transcend beyond the aggregate of activity, so he is transformed by arising and ceasing. Furthermore, he distinguishes from 『existence and non-existence』 (yǒu wú). For those who attain enlightenment from the aspect of moment-to-moment cessation, he only says 『non-existence』 (wú, non-being)."
  ]
}

其無。于唸唸生相而得證者。但言其是。又從有無而合之。言亦有即是亦無。亦無即是亦有。亦有之中不是亦無。亦無之中不是亦有。語雖互見。與前微有別。前兩端並陳。不能決了。此但舉一端。兩端具在。言亦有即是亦無。不專言無。亦無之中不是亦有。不專言是。知見紛錯。莫有定衡。儱侗慌惚。歸於虛謬。外道計天為常住。名為不死。計不亂答得生彼天。若實不知而輒答者。恐成矯亂。佛訶云。此真矯亂議論。故名為不死矯亂遍計虛論。曰遍計者。計有又計無。生滅增減恒變。一切遍計。其實無益於得。總為戲論。雖然。通方作家。道有也得。道無也得。在在有出身之路。僧問趙州。狗子還有佛性也無。州云有。僧云。既有。為甚麼卻撞入這個皮袋。州云。為他知而故犯。又有僧問狗子還有佛性也無。州云無。僧云。一切眾生。皆有佛性。狗子為甚麼卻無。州云。為伊有業識在。天童頌云。狗子佛性有。狗子佛性無。直釣元求負命魚。逐氣尋香雲水客。嘈嘈雜雜作分疏。平展演。大鋪舒。莫怪儂家不慎初。指點瑕疵還奪璧。奉王不識藺相如。天童別有頌云。趙州道有。趙州道無。狗子佛性。天下分疏。面赤不如語直。心真必定言粗。七百甲子老禪伯。驢糞逢人換眼珠。又京兆惟寬禪師。僧問狗子還有佛性否。師曰有。曰和尚還有否。師曰。我無。曰一切眾生。皆有佛性。和尚因何獨無。師曰。我非一切眾生。曰。既非眾生。莫是佛否。師曰。不是佛。曰究竟是何物。師曰。亦不是物。曰可見可思否。師曰。思之不及。議之不得。故

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "有沒有這種情況:在每一個念頭的生滅變化中就認為自己證悟了?他們只是說『是』,又從『有』和『無』兩方面來調和,說『亦有即是亦無,亦無即是亦有』。在『亦有』之中,並非沒有『亦無』;在『亦無』之中,並非沒有『亦有』。言語雖然互相包含,但與前面所說的略有不同。前面是兩端並列,不能決斷;這裡只是舉出一端,兩端都包含在其中。說『亦有即是亦無』,不是隻說『無』;說『亦無之中不是亦有』,不是隻說『是』。這種知見紛亂錯雜,沒有一定的標準,含糊不清,最終歸於虛妄謬誤。外道認為天是常住不變的,稱之為『不死』。他們認為不亂回答問題就能往生到那個天界。如果實際上不知道卻隨便回答,恐怕會造成虛假混亂。佛呵斥說:『這真是虛假混亂的議論。』所以稱為『不死矯亂遍計虛論』。『遍計』的意思是,既計較『有』,又計較『無』,生滅增減,恒常變化,一切都加以計較,其實對於證悟沒有任何益處,總歸是戲論。雖然如此,通達權變的大師,說『有』也可以,說『無』也可以,處處都有出路。僧人問趙州禪師:『狗子還有佛性嗎?』趙州說:『有。』僧人說:『既然有,為什麼卻墮入這個皮囊?』趙州說:『因為他明知故犯。』又有僧人問:『狗子還有佛性嗎?』趙州說:『沒有。』僧人說:『一切眾生,皆有佛性,狗子為什麼沒有?』趙州說:『因為他有業識存在。』天童禪師作頌說:『狗子佛性有,狗子佛性無。直鉤垂釣,本來就是爲了釣那些不惜性命的魚。追逐氣息,尋覓香味的雲水僧,嘈嘈雜雜地在那裡分別解釋。』平鋪直敘,大肆展開,不要怪我一開始就不謹慎,指出瑕疵還要奪走寶玉,就像藺相如侍奉趙王卻不被賞識一樣。天童禪師還有另外的頌說:『趙州說有,趙州說無,狗子佛性,天下紛紛議論。面紅耳赤不如說話直率,心真必定言語粗糙。七百甲子(指時間久遠)的老禪師,把驢糞當成寶貝,逢人就想換取別人的眼珠。』又有京兆惟寬禪師,僧人問:『狗子還有佛性嗎?』禪師說:『有。』僧人問:『和尚您還有嗎?』禪師說:『我沒有。』僧人問:『一切眾生,皆有佛性,和尚您為什麼唯獨沒有?』禪師說:『我不是一切眾生。』僧人問:『既然不是眾生,莫非是佛嗎?』禪師說:『不是佛。』僧人問:『究竟是什麼?』禪師說:『也不是物。』僧人問:『可以理解和思考嗎?』禪師說:『思之不及,議之不得。』所以……"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Is it possible for someone to claim enlightenment with each arising and ceasing of thoughts? They merely affirm 'is' and attempt to reconcile it with both 'being' and 'non-being,' stating, 'To be is also to be not, and to be not is also to be.' Within 'to be,' there is not the absence of 'to be not'; within 'to be not,' there is not the absence of 'to be.' Although the language is mutually inclusive, it differs slightly from what was previously stated. The former presents both ends side by side, unable to make a definitive judgment; this only presents one end, with both ends contained within it. To say 'to be is also to be not' is not solely to say 'not'; to say 'within to be not, there is not the absence of to be' is not solely to say 'is.' Such knowledge is confused and disordered, lacking a fixed standard, vague and indistinct, ultimately leading to falsehood and error. Externalists consider the heavens to be permanent and unchanging, calling it 'immortality.' They believe that by answering questions without confusion, one can be reborn in that heaven. If one answers casually without truly knowing, it may lead to falsehood and confusion. The Buddha rebukes, 'This is truly false and confused discussion.' Therefore, it is called 'immortal, confused, pervasive, conceptual, and illusory discourse.' 'Pervasive' means calculating both 'being' and 'non-being,' arising, ceasing, increasing, decreasing, constant change, calculating everything, which is actually of no benefit to enlightenment, ultimately being mere play. Nevertheless, a master who understands expediency can speak of 'being' or 'non-being,' and there is a way out in every situation. A monk asked Zen Master Zhaozhou (778-897): 'Does a dog have Buddha-nature?' Zhaozhou said, 'Yes.' The monk said, 'Since it has, why is it trapped in this skin bag?' Zhaozhou said, 'Because he knowingly violates.' Another monk asked, 'Does a dog have Buddha-nature?' Zhaozhou said, 'No.' The monk said, 'All sentient beings have Buddha-nature, why does the dog not have it?' Zhaozhou said, 'Because it has karmic consciousness.' Zen Master Tiantong (1091-1157) composed a verse saying: 'Dog's Buddha-nature is, dog's Buddha-nature is not. Casting a straight hook, originally seeking fish that risk their lives. Cloud-traveling monks chasing scents, noisily making distinctions.' Spreading out flatly, expanding greatly, don't blame me for not being cautious at the beginning, pointing out flaws and taking away the jade, like Lin Xiangru serving King Zhao (reigned 265–245 BC) without being appreciated. Zen Master Tiantong also has another verse saying: 'Zhaozhou says is, Zhaozhou says is not, dog's Buddha-nature, the world discusses. A red face is not as good as straight talk, a true heart is sure to have rough words. An old Zen master of seven hundred Jiazi (a long time), treats donkey dung as treasure, wanting to exchange it for people's eyes.' Furthermore, Zen Master Weikuan of Jingzhao, a monk asked: 'Does a dog have Buddha-nature?' The master said, 'Yes.' The monk asked, 'Does the abbot have it?' The master said, 'I don't have it.' The monk asked, 'All sentient beings have Buddha-nature, why does the abbot alone not have it?' The master said, 'I am not all sentient beings.' The monk asked, 'Since you are not sentient beings, could you be a Buddha?' The master said, 'Not a Buddha.' The monk asked, 'What ultimately is it?' The master said, 'Also not a thing.' The monk asked, 'Can it be understood and thought about?' The master said, 'Beyond thought, beyond discussion.' Therefore..."
  ]
}

曰不可思議。外道欲于可思可議者遍計立論。豈不顛倒。

  又三摩中諸善男子。堅凝正心。魔不得便。窮生類本。觀彼幽清。常擾動元。于無盡流生計度者。是人墜入死後有相。發心顛倒。或自固身。云色是我。或見我圓。含遍國土。云我有色。或彼前緣。隨我回復。云色屬我。或復我依。行中相續。云我在色。皆計度言死後有相。如是循環。有十六相。從此或計畢竟煩惱。畢竟菩提。兩性並驅。各不相觸。由此計度死後有故。墮落外道。惑菩提性。是則名為第六外道立。五陰中死後有相心顛倒論。

  通曰。前五所計或有或無。或亦有亦無。不出三句。未見雙非。尚滯在行陰中。故今計及死後有相無相。及有無俱非。又於後後有無。起斷滅涅槃二見。蓋行陰幾空。而窺見識陰矣。且來先去後。唯識主之。故此以五陰並言。龍勝曰。五道中眾生身見力因緣故。見四種我。色眾是我。色是我。我中色。色中我。合云唯色是我。唯離色是我。我在色中。色在我中。如是推求。了不可得。受想行識。亦復如是。而外道返執為有相。或自固身。即色是我也。含遍國土。色在我中也。前緣回覆。離色是我也。依行相續。我在色中也。依此四計。受想行識皆然。乃至即行是我。離行是我。我在行中。行在我中。所計之我。即識陰也。皆計死後復有。成十六相。煩惱由陰而生。菩提由我而證。兩性並驅。入未來際。皆畢竟有。故云立五陰中死後有相心顛倒論。此從各各有處。因有得證而創為此論也。本庵道瓊首座。嘗舉只履西歸語謂眾曰。坐脫

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "說那是不可思議的。外道想要在可思可議的事物上遍計立論,豈不是顛倒了嗎?",
    
    "再說,在三摩地(Samadhi,定、等持)中的各位善男子,堅定凝聚正心,邪魔就無法得逞。他們窮究眾生類別的根本,觀察那幽微清凈、常擾動本元的現象,于無盡的流轉中產生計度,這樣的人就會墜入死後有相的境界,發起顛倒之心。或者他們執著于自身,說『色蘊(Rupa Skandha,物質、形色)是我』;或者見到『我』圓滿,包含遍及國土,說『我中有色蘊』;或者認為先前的因緣,隨著『我』而回復,說『色蘊屬於我』;或者『我』依賴於色蘊,在行蘊(Samskara Skandha,意志、行為)的相續中,說『我在色蘊中』。這些都是計度死後有相的言論。像這樣循環,共有十六種相狀。從此或者計度畢竟有煩惱,畢竟有菩提(Bodhi,覺悟),兩種性質並駕齊驅,各自不相接觸。由於這樣計度死後有,所以墮落外道,迷惑菩提的本性。這就叫做第六種外道,立基於五陰(Panca-skandha,色、受、想、行、識五種聚合)中死後有相的心顛倒論。",
    
    "通曰:前面五種所計,或者是有,或者是無,或者亦有亦無,沒有超出這三種句式,沒有見到雙非(既非有也非無)。仍然滯留在行陰中,所以現在計及死後有相、無相,以及有無俱非。又在後后的有無中,生起斷滅和涅槃(Nirvana,寂滅)兩種見解。大概是行陰將要空盡,而窺見了識陰(Vijnana Skandha,識別、了別)了。而且來先去後,唯有識陰主宰。因此這裡用五陰並列來說明。龍勝(Nagarjuna,印度佛教中觀學派創始人)說:五道中的眾生,由於身見的力量和因緣,見到四種『我』:色眾是我,色是我,我中*,*中我,合起來就是唯色是我,唯離色是我,我在色中,色在我中。像這樣推求,終究是不可得的。受陰(Vedana Skandha,感受)、想陰(Samjna Skandha,知覺)、行陰、識陰,也是這樣。而外道反而執著地認為是實有其相。或者執著于自身,就是色是我。包含遍及國土,就是色在我中。先前的因緣回覆,就是離色是我。依賴於行蘊相續,就是我在色中。依據這四種計度,受、想、行、識都是這樣。乃至即行是我,離行是我,我在行中,行在我中。所計度的『我』,就是識陰。都計度死後復有,成就十六種相狀。煩惱由陰而生,菩提由『我』而證。兩種性質並駕齊驅,進入未來際,都是畢竟存在的。所以說立基於五陰中死後有相的心顛倒論。這是從各各都有處,因為有而得到證悟,從而創立這種理論。本庵道瓊首座,曾經舉『只履西歸』(指達摩祖師去世后只剩下一隻鞋子的故事)的典故對大眾說:坐脫(坐化)"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "It is said to be inconceivable. The heretics wish to establish their theories based on what is conceivable and debatable. Isn't that a reversal?",
    
    "Furthermore, the virtuous men in Samadhi (定、等持), with their minds firmly concentrated and righteous, cannot be exploited by demons. They exhaustively investigate the origin of sentient beings, observing the subtle and pure, constantly disturbing source. Those who generate calculations in the endless flow fall into the realm of 'existence after death', giving rise to inverted minds. Either they cling to their bodies, saying, 'The Rupa Skandha (色蘊, form) is me'; or they see 'me' as complete, encompassing the entire land, saying, 'Form is in me'; or they believe that past causes return with 'me', saying, 'Form belongs to me'; or 'I' depend on form, continuing in the Samskara Skandha (行蘊, volition), saying, 'I am in form'. These are all statements calculating existence after death. Cycling in this way, there are sixteen aspects. From this, they either calculate that there is ultimately affliction, or ultimately Bodhi (菩提, enlightenment), the two natures running side by side, not touching each other. Because of calculating existence after death in this way, they fall into heretical paths, confused about the nature of Bodhi. This is called the sixth heretical view, establishing the theory of mental inversion regarding existence after death within the Panca-skandha (五陰, five aggregates).",
    
    "Tong says: The previous five calculations are either existence, or non-existence, or both existence and non-existence, not exceeding these three phrases, and not seeing double negation (neither existence nor non-existence). They are still stuck in the Samskara Skandha, so now they calculate existence after death, non-existence, and neither existence nor non-existence. Furthermore, in the later existence and non-existence, they give rise to two views: annihilation and Nirvana (涅槃, cessation). It is likely that the Samskara Skandha is about to be emptied, and the Vijnana Skandha (識蘊, consciousness) is glimpsed. Moreover, coming first and going later is governed solely by the Vijnana Skandha. Therefore, here the five aggregates are mentioned together to illustrate. Nagarjuna (龍勝) said: Beings in the five realms, due to the power and conditions of self-view, see four kinds of 'self': the multitude of form is me, form is me, * in me, me in *. Combined, it is only form is me, only apart from form is me, I am in form, form is in me. Seeking in this way, it is ultimately unattainable. The Vedana Skandha (受蘊, sensation), Samjna Skandha (想蘊, perception), Samskara Skandha, and Vijnana Skandha are also like this. However, the heretics stubbornly believe that they are real. Either clinging to the body is 'form is me'. Encompassing the entire land is 'form is in me'. The return of past causes is 'apart from form is me'. Relying on the continuation of the Samskara Skandha is 'I am in form'. According to these four calculations, sensation, perception, volition, and consciousness are all like this. Even to the point that volition is me, apart from volition is me, I am in volition, volition is in me. The calculated 'self' is the Vijnana Skandha. All calculate that there is existence after death, achieving sixteen aspects. Afflictions arise from the aggregates, and Bodhi is attained by 'me'. The two natures run side by side, entering the future, all being ultimately existent. Therefore, it is said to establish the theory of mental inversion regarding existence after death within the five aggregates. This is from each having a place, because of existence, enlightenment is obtained, and this theory is created. Chief Seat Ben'an Daoqiong once cited the story of 'returning west with a single shoe' (referring to the story of Bodhidharma leaving only one shoe after his death) and said to the assembly: Sitting liberation (sitting in meditation at the moment of death)"
  ]
}