菩薩藏佛教學會
20
背景
翻譯
下載 ▾

X14n0291_楞嚴經直指|X14n0291_楞嚴經直指

卍新續藏第 14 冊 No. 0291 楞嚴經直指

  No. 291-A 首楞嚴直指敘

  大覺能仁。成道十日。即說華嚴。以眾生住地煩惱。為諸佛不動智。如將寶位直授凡庸。故非三乘之流所能諦信。當時聲聞在坐。不見不聞。然而最後拈華。則金色頭陀。獨得別傳之囑。慶喜繼之。為西天二祖。雖登位於剎竿倒卻之時。而發悟在擊鐘驗常之際。則楞嚴一經。又宗門之法印也。古今疏此。俱擅所長。吾師 天然是和上。宴坐丹霞。以三月成直指。適屆示生之期。甘露降於叢竹。今釋受而伏讀。青蓮發筆端之瑞。赤珠映意地之光。微眹不留。是跡皆刬。言言本色。不借華詞。其不可思議之妙。實有與諸家迥絕者。彼皆悟門各得然。而見量未忘。往往以詞害志。執藥成病。原其所由。不過能推非心離塵有性而已。夫能推是妄離塵無體。此如來語也。如來不云性真常中求于去來迷悟生死了無所得耶。真覺無功。根塵何咎。極其轉名不轉體之致。未能迷悟並銷。而迷悟不銷。則常光便隔。妄即不存。真復何在。當下覺了。已落紆迴。故為之直示曰。非別有一真在緣慮之先影像之外也。若謂分別之心與塵俱滅。則無分別。晰不與塵俱生。各成一物。於何立界。故為之直示曰。但據其所謂全性者舍分別而更有。不知其所謂分別者舍全性而必無也。於此不明。詎稱圓悟。所以破心破目。無罪加誅。有正有倒。將名作實。體用上下。析見見於現前。人法后先。失空空于頓覺。斷而得顯。因緣自然之戲論滋深。修乃可成。諸佛眾生

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "大覺能仁(釋迦牟尼佛)。成道十日,即說《華嚴經》。以眾生安住的煩惱之地,作為諸佛不動的智慧。好比將寶貴的王位直接授予凡夫俗子,所以不是三乘(聲聞乘、緣覺乘、菩薩乘)之流所能真正相信的。當時聲聞眾在座,卻不見不聞。然而最後拈花微笑,則金色頭陀(摩訶迦葉),獨自得到佛陀特別傳授的囑託。慶喜(阿難)繼承了他,成為西天二祖。雖然證悟的時刻如同剎竿倒地,但開悟卻在擊鐘驗常之際。因此,《楞嚴經》一經,又是禪宗的法印。古往今來註解此經的,各有擅長。我的老師天然和尚,在丹霞山宴坐,用三個月的時間寫成《直指》。恰逢他誕生的日子,甘露降落在叢生的竹林中。如今我釋某人接受並恭敬閱讀,筆端涌現出青蓮般的祥瑞,赤珠般的光芒照耀在心田。細微的痕跡也不留下,所有的軌跡都消除。字字句句都是本來的面目,不借用華麗的辭藻。其中不可思議的妙處,實在與各家迥然不同。他們都是在悟門上各有心得,但見解上未能忘卻。往往因為文辭而損害了本意,執著于藥物反而成了疾病。追究其原因,不過是能夠推論非心離塵而有自性罷了。能夠推論是虛妄,離開塵境就沒有本體,這是如來說的話。如來不是說過嗎?在真常自性中尋求去來迷悟生死,最終一無所得。真覺本來就無功用,根塵又有什麼罪過?他們極力闡述轉名不轉體的道理,卻未能使迷悟一同消除。而迷悟不能消除,那麼常光就被隔斷。虛妄既然不存在,真實又在哪裡呢?當下覺悟,已經落入了迂迴曲折。所以為之直接開示說:並非另外有一真實存在於緣慮之前、影像之外。如果認為分別之心與塵境一同滅亡,那麼沒有分別,清晰的覺性不與塵境一同產生,各自成為一個事物,又在哪裡建立界限呢?所以為之直接開示說:只是根據他們所說的全性,捨棄分別而更有;卻不知道他們所說的分別,捨棄全性就必定沒有。對於這一點不明白,怎麼能稱為圓滿的覺悟呢?所以破心破目,沒有罪過也要加以懲罰;有正有倒,將名稱當作實體。體用上下,分析見性于現前;人法先後,喪失空性于頓悟。斷滅才能顯現,因緣自然之類的戲論更加深刻。修行才可以成就,諸佛眾生……",
    "English version",
    "The Greatly Enlightened and Capable One (Shakyamuni Buddha), within ten days of attaining enlightenment, immediately expounded the Avatamsaka Sutra (Flower Garland Sutra), taking the afflictions of beings' dwelling place as the immovable wisdom of all Buddhas. It was like directly bestowing the precious throne upon ordinary people, so it could not be truly believed by those of the Three Vehicles (Śrāvakayāna, Pratyekabuddhayāna, and Bodhisattvayāna). At that time, the Śrāvakas were present but did not see or hear. However, in the end, with the flower held up and a smile, the golden-headed ascetic (Mahākāśyapa) alone received the special transmission of the Buddha's entrustment. Ānanda succeeded him, becoming the Second Ancestor of the Western Heaven. Although the moment of enlightenment was like a flagpole falling, the awakening occurred at the moment of striking the bell to verify constancy. Therefore, the Śūraṅgama Sūtra is also the Dharma seal of the Zen school. Throughout history, commentaries on this sutra have each had their strengths. My teacher, the Venerable Tiānrán, sat in meditation at Mount Danxia and completed the 'Direct Pointing' in three months. It coincided with the anniversary of his birth, and sweet dew descended upon the bamboo groves. Now, I, Shi, receive and reverently read it, and auspicious signs like blue lotuses emerge from the tip of my pen, and the light like red pearls shines upon my mind. Not even the slightest trace remains, and all marks are erased. Every word and phrase is in its original color, without borrowing flowery language. The inconceivable wonder within it is truly distinct from all other schools. They each have their own insights into the gate of enlightenment, but their views have not forgotten. They often harm the meaning with words, and clinging to medicine becomes a disease. Tracing back the reason, it is nothing more than being able to infer that there is a self-nature apart from the mind and separate from the dust. Being able to infer is illusory, and without the dust, there is no substance. These are the words of the Tathagata (Buddha). Did the Tathagata not say that seeking coming and going, delusion and enlightenment, birth and death in the true and constant nature ultimately yields nothing? True awakening has no function, so what fault do the roots and dust have? They exhaustively explain the principle of changing the name but not the substance, but they fail to eliminate delusion and enlightenment together. And if delusion and enlightenment cannot be eliminated, then the constant light is cut off. Since illusion does not exist, where is the truth? To awaken immediately is to fall into circumlocution. Therefore, it is directly pointed out: There is no other truth existing before the causes and thoughts, outside of the images. If it is thought that the discriminating mind perishes together with the dust, then there is no discrimination. Clear awareness does not arise together with the dust, and each becomes a thing. Where then is the boundary established? Therefore, it is directly pointed out: It is only based on what they call the complete nature, abandoning discrimination and having something more; but they do not know that what they call discrimination, abandoning the complete nature, will certainly not exist. If this is not understood, how can it be called complete enlightenment? Therefore, breaking the mind and breaking the eye, punishment is added even without guilt; having right and wrong, taking names as reality. Essence and function, above and below, analyzing seeing in the present; people and Dharma, before and after, losing emptiness in sudden awakening. Extinction is needed to manifest, and the play of causality and nature deepens. Cultivation can be achieved, Buddhas and sentient beings..."
  ]
}

之分疆愈遠。倘能豎掃同時始信因果俱幻。是故。法性海中本絕思惟。四十九年不說一字。若云此謂權。此謂實。此謂見。此謂修。此謂圓融。此謂行布。才成實法。便非了義。乃至性覺必明。妄為明覺。依經立解。寧不較然。然于性覺生取心。則明能生所。無如其與妄俱來。于明覺生舍心。則所必障明。無如其並真俱棄。遂使覺與所明如來語下二俱有過。安知明與無明。如來藏中。一亦不存。故又為之直示曰。覺明不礙性覺之常然。性覺豈傷覺明之自異。悟理之士。亦可以立地冰消矣。而每至險崖輒生前卻者。蓋聖境不捐故。凡情競起也。識其惟一干慧。則流轉四生。名為亂想。洊登妙覺。名為極果。皆是分外。不契本然。故又為之直示曰。舍亂想必無干慧。亦猶舍干慧必無極果。遂以亂想為干慧。似有悟迷。至於干慧。而回觀亂想。悔不安住。尚若遜其所不及者。然後知迷之不可得也。迷不可得。悟亦何為。能仁成道之後。適還其眾生之初泯法界量。現法界身。說法界事。顯法界理。若作聖解。即受群邪。縱將寶位。直授凡庸。亦恐凡庸不應重受。彼聲聞在坐。不見不聞。正與破顏微笑。同一玄賞。今釋豈能更有思議于吾師不可思議之中耶。謹因讀疏之餘。隨見隨拈。因月有指非月所取。若其全經旨趣。則一總論。已化為無縫天衣。一切眾生。於一原題。全現出無見頂相。開卷瞭然。無塵不破。此即枝中覓本。委上求原。不妨引而伸之作鈍根之助爾。

  嗣法門人今釋稽首和南敬序

  No. 291-B 刻首楞嚴直指緣起

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本:",
    "區分界限越來越遠。倘若能夠同時破除主觀和客觀的執著,才能真正相信因果皆是虛幻。因此,在法性之海中,本來就沒有思慮分別。釋迦牟尼佛(公元前624-公元前544)四十九年間未說一字。如果說這是『權』(方便之法),這是『實』(真實之法),這是『見』(見解),這是『修』(修行),這是『圓融』(圓滿融合),這是『行布』(次第修行),一旦執著于這些實法,就不是究竟的意義。乃至執著于自性的覺悟必然光明,而錯誤地認為那是明覺。依據經文建立解釋,難道不是更加明顯的錯誤嗎?然而,對於自性的覺悟產生執取之心,那麼光明就能產生所照的對象,不如它與妄念一同到來。對於明覺產生捨棄之心,那麼所捨棄的必然會障礙光明,不如它與真理一同拋棄。於是使得覺悟與所覺悟的對象,在如來(佛)的言語之下,二者都有過失。怎知光明與無明,在如來藏中,連一絲痕跡都不存在。所以又直接指示說:覺明不妨礙性覺的常然,性覺豈會損傷覺明的自然差異。領悟這個道理的人,也可以立刻消除心中的疑惑。而每每到了危險的懸崖邊就產生退卻的人,是因為聖境沒有捨棄,所以凡夫的情感競相生起。認識到那唯一的干慧(以智慧觀照世間),那麼在四生中流轉,就叫做亂想。逐漸登上妙覺,就叫做極果。這些都是分外之事,不契合本然。所以又直接指示說:捨棄亂想必然沒有干慧,也像捨棄干慧必然沒有極果一樣。於是把亂想當作干慧,似乎有所領悟,等到達到干慧的境界,回頭看亂想,後悔不能安住其中,還好像不如亂想一樣。然後才知道迷惑是不可得的。迷惑不可得,覺悟又有什麼用呢?能仁(釋迦牟尼佛)成道之後,恰好迴歸到眾生最初的境界,泯滅法界的限量,顯現法界的身,說法界的事,顯現法界的理。如果作聖解,就會受到群邪的侵擾。縱然將寶位直接授予凡庸之人,也恐怕凡庸之人不應承受。那些聲聞在座,不見不聞,正與迦葉尊者破顏微笑,領會禪意,是同一種玄妙的賞識。如今我這個後輩釋子,怎能在我老師不可思議的境界中,再生出思議呢?謹因讀疏之餘,隨見隨拈,因為手指指向月亮,不是月亮所能獲取的。至於全部經文的旨趣,則一總論,已經化為無縫的天衣。一切眾生,於一原題,完全顯現出無見頂相。打開經卷就明白了,沒有塵埃不能破除。這就像從樹枝中尋找樹根,從末端追溯到源頭,不妨引導並延伸它,作為鈍根之人的幫助罷了。",
    
    "嗣法門人今釋稽首和南敬序",
    
    "No. 291-B 刻首楞嚴直指緣起"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version:",
    "The distinctions become increasingly distant. If one can simultaneously eradicate both subjective and objective attachments, only then can one truly believe that both cause and effect are illusory. Therefore, in the sea of Dharma-nature, there is originally no thought or discrimination. Shakyamuni Buddha (624-544 BC) did not speak a single word for forty-nine years. If one says this is 'Upaya' (expedient means), this is 'Reality' (true Dharma), this is 'View' (understanding), this is 'Practice' (cultivation), this is 'Harmony' (perfect integration), this is 'Sequential Progression' (gradual practice), once one clings to these real Dharmas, it is not the ultimate meaning. Even clinging to the self-nature's enlightenment as necessarily luminous, and mistakenly considering it as bright awareness, establishing interpretations based on scriptures, is it not an even more obvious error? However, if one generates a grasping mind towards the enlightenment of self-nature, then luminosity can produce an object to be illuminated, which is not as good as it coming together with delusion. If one generates a mind of abandonment towards bright awareness, then what is abandoned will inevitably obstruct luminosity, which is not as good as it being discarded together with truth. Thus, both enlightenment and the object of enlightenment, under the words of the Tathagata (Buddha), both have faults. How can one know that luminosity and non-luminosity, in the Tathagatagarbha (Buddha-nature), not even a trace exists. Therefore, it is directly pointed out again: Bright awareness does not hinder the constant nature of self-nature's enlightenment, how can self-nature's enlightenment harm the natural difference of bright awareness. Those who understand this principle can also immediately eliminate the doubts in their hearts. And those who retreat whenever they reach a dangerous cliff are because the sacred realm has not been abandoned, so the emotions of ordinary people arise in competition. Recognizing that unique dry insight (wisdom contemplating the world), then flowing in the four births is called random thoughts. Gradually ascending to wonderful enlightenment is called the ultimate fruit. These are all extraneous matters, not in accordance with the original nature. Therefore, it is directly pointed out again: Abandoning random thoughts will inevitably not have dry insight, just like abandoning dry insight will inevitably not have the ultimate fruit. Therefore, taking random thoughts as dry insight seems to have some understanding, and when reaching the realm of dry insight, looking back at random thoughts, regretting not being able to dwell in them, still seems inferior to random thoughts. Only then does one know that delusion is unattainable. If delusion is unattainable, what is the use of enlightenment? After Shakyamuni Buddha attained enlightenment, he happened to return to the original state of sentient beings, obliterating the limits of the Dharma realm, manifesting the body of the Dharma realm, speaking the affairs of the Dharma realm, and revealing the principles of the Dharma realm. If one makes a sacred interpretation, one will be invaded by hordes of evil. Even if the precious position is directly granted to ordinary people, it is feared that ordinary people should not accept it. Those Shravakas (disciples) in the seat, not seeing or hearing, are exactly the same as Mahakasyapa's smiling, understanding the Zen meaning, is the same kind of mysterious appreciation. Now, how can I, this later generation Shishi, generate further thoughts in the inconceivable realm of my teacher? I respectfully take advantage of the spare time of reading the commentary, picking up whatever I see, because the finger points to the moon, not what the moon can obtain. As for the purpose of the entire scripture, then a general discussion has already transformed into a seamless heavenly garment. All sentient beings, in one original topic, completely reveal the invisible crown. Opening the scripture, one understands, and there is no dust that cannot be broken. This is like looking for the root in the branches, tracing back to the source from the end, it may be guided and extended to help those with dull roots.",
    
    "The successor disciple, Jin Shi, respectfully bows and pays homage.",
    
    "No. 291-B Engraved Origin of the Straightforward 指示 of the Shurangama Sutra"
  ]
}

  老人疏是經。三月而成。入理深談。多提持向上。啓發悟門。真足為上根之助。遠邇緇素。渴仰法味。 大中丞傅公竹君。遂捐資全刊流通。何其易也。昔天臺智者大師。聞是經為天竺所秘重。晨夕西望懇禮。愿早至此土。歷百餘載。有沙門般剌密諦始攜來。以國禁嚴密屢不果。乃書于微細白氎。析臂藏之肉內。航海而達穗城。時值丞相房融出知南銓。請譯于訶林風幡堂。親為筆受。故經中文句皆明暢而曲析。

  傅公未識 老人。未讀經疏。而亟欲流通。使法雨得以均沾為快者。豈非於楞嚴宣勝義中大有夙契之緣歟。夫菩薩以利物為懷。就事就理。雖有淺深。究其指歸。原無二致 公昔守慶陽。今撫粵西。識度超卓。指麾敏捷。一舉止間。悉不落尋常蹊徑。其與會中文殊師利。摧邪輔正。選擇圓通。而終出於無是非是。機感相類。即事顯理。愿 公與大地含靈。同入圓通無礙門。親證如來無見頂相。即理顯事。愿諸閱者。與 公同發菩提心。現觀世音三十二應身。挽斯世斯民。躋于羲軒之治。則于 老人之法施 傅公之流通。兩無辜負爾。

  住丹霞今辯槃談謹述

  No. 291-C 首楞嚴直指總論

  丹霞沙門 釋天然函是 造

  威音王以前。無佛名。無眾生名。此時正是道。祇是無人覺知。大哉斯語。可謂揭光明于重晝。嘆浩淼于全潮。悟即醍醐。迷仍毒藥。所以掩室摩竭。杜口毗耶。豈惟真機絕待。實乃至道難言。菩提敷座。便欲示般涅槃。雙樹披胸。復言不說一字。前後斯旨。首尾全提。

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "《老人疏》是經文的疏解,歷時三個月完成。它深入探討了佛理,多次提持向上,啓發開悟之門,確實可以作為上等根器之人的助益。遠近的出家和在家信徒,都渴望仰慕佛法的滋味。",
    
    "大中丞傅公竹君,於是捐獻資金全部刊印流通,這是多麼容易的事啊。過去天臺智者大師(538-597),聽說這部經在天竺被秘密珍藏,早晚向西遙望懇切禮拜,希望它早日來到此土。經歷一百多年,有沙門般剌密諦(Prajñāmitra)才攜帶它來,因為國家禁令嚴密多次沒有成功,於是將經文書寫在極細的白色絲綢上,藏在手臂肌肉之內,航海到達穗城。當時正值丞相房融出任南銓,請他在訶林風幡堂翻譯此經,親自執筆記錄。所以經文中的語句都明白流暢而詳盡。",
    
    "傅公未曾認識《老人》(指作者),未曾讀過經文疏解,就急切地想要流通,使得佛法甘露能夠普遍沾溉,這難道不是在《楞嚴經》宣揚殊勝義理中,有著宿世的因緣嗎?菩薩以利益眾生為懷,就事論事,雖然有深淺之分,但探究其最終歸宿,原本沒有兩樣。傅公過去鎮守慶陽,現在安撫粵西,見識氣度超凡卓越,指揮排程敏捷果斷,一舉一動之間,都不落入尋常的窠臼。他與經會中的文殊師利(Mañjuśrī)菩薩,摧邪輔正,選擇圓滿通達之法,最終歸於無是無非的境界,其機緣感應非常相似。即事顯理,希望傅公與大地上的所有生靈,一同進入圓通無礙之門,親自證得如來無見頂相。即理顯事,希望各位閱讀者,與傅公一同發起菩提心,顯現觀世音(Avalokiteśvara)菩薩的三十二應化身,挽救這個時代的人民,使他們達到伏羲(傳說中的中國人文始祖,約公元前2852年-前2738年)和軒轅(即黃帝,傳說中的中國人文始祖,約公元前2697年-前2598年)時代的太平盛世。這樣才不會辜負《老人》的法施,以及傅公的流通之舉。",
    
    "住于丹霞的今辯槃談 謹述",
    
    "No. 291-C 《首楞嚴直指》總論",
    
    "丹霞沙門 釋天然函是 著",
    
    "在威音王佛(Vimalakirti)以前,沒有佛的名號,也沒有眾生的名號。此時正是道的本體,只是沒有人覺察知道。這句話多麼偉大啊,可謂在白晝揭示光明,在全潮中讚歎浩瀚。覺悟就是醍醐妙藥,迷惑仍然是毒藥。所以維摩詰(Vimalakirti)閉門謝客,毗耶離(Vaiśālī)城保持沉默。豈止是真機絕對待,實在是至道難以言說。菩提樹下剛一敷設座位,佛陀就想要示現般涅槃,娑羅雙樹下敞開胸懷,又說不說一字。前後這些旨意,首尾完全提點出來。",
    
    
    "English version",
    "The 'Elder's Commentary' is a commentary on the sutra, completed in three months. It deeply explores Buddhist principles, repeatedly emphasizing upward progress and enlightening the gateway to awakening, truly serving as an aid for those of superior faculties. Monastics and lay practitioners from near and far eagerly yearn for the taste of the Dharma.",
    
    "The Grand Censor Fu Gong Zhujun, therefore, donated funds to have it fully printed and circulated, how easy it is! In the past, the Tiantai Master Zhiyi (538-597) heard that this sutra was secretly treasured in India. Morning and evening, he looked westward and earnestly prostrated, hoping it would arrive in this land soon. After more than a hundred years, the Shramana Prajñāmitra finally brought it, but due to strict national prohibitions, he was unsuccessful many times. So he wrote the sutra on extremely fine white silk, hid it within the muscles of his arm, and sailed to Guangzhou. At that time, the Prime Minister Fang Rong was serving as the Nan Quan, and he invited him to translate the sutra at the Feng Fan Hall in Helin, personally taking notes. Therefore, the sentences in the sutra are all clear, fluent, and detailed.",
    
    "Lord Fu had not met the 'Elder' (referring to the author), nor had he read the commentary on the sutra, yet he eagerly wanted to circulate it, so that the rain of Dharma could be universally bestowed. Could it be that he had a karmic connection from a past life in the proclamation of the supreme meaning of the Shurangama Sutra? Bodhisattvas cherish the intention to benefit beings, addressing matters and principles, although there are differences in depth, but examining their ultimate destination, there is originally no difference. Lord Fu used to guard Qingyang, and now pacifies Guangxi, his knowledge and demeanor are extraordinary and outstanding, his command and dispatch are swift and decisive, and every action of his does not fall into the ordinary rut. He and the Manjushri Bodhisattva in the sutra assembly, destroying the heretical and assisting the orthodox, selecting the perfect and unobstructed Dharma, ultimately returning to the realm of neither right nor wrong, their karmic responses are very similar. Manifesting principle through events, I hope that Lord Fu and all sentient beings on earth will enter the gate of perfect and unobstructed interpenetration together, and personally realize the Tathagata's invisible crown. Manifesting events through principle, I hope that all readers will, together with Lord Fu, generate the Bodhi mind, manifest the thirty-two response bodies of Avalokiteśvara Bodhisattva, and save the people of this era, so that they may reach the peaceful and prosperous age of Fuxi (legendary Chinese sovereign, c. 2852–2738 BC) and Xuanyuan (the Yellow Emperor, legendary Chinese sovereign, c. 2697–2598 BC). In this way, neither the Dharma giving of the 'Elder' nor the circulation efforts of Lord Fu will be in vain.",
    
    "Respectfully narrated by Jin Bian Pan Tan, residing in Danxia",
    
    "No. 291-C General Discussion on the 'Straightforward Pointing at the Shurangama'",
    
    "Written by Shramana Shi Tianran Han Shi of Danxia",
    
    "Before the Buddha Vimalakirti, there were no names of Buddhas, nor were there names of sentient beings. At this time, it is precisely the essence of the Tao, but no one is aware of it. How great are these words, it can be said to reveal the light in broad daylight, and to praise the vastness in the full tide. Enlightenment is the nectar of immortality, delusion is still poison. Therefore, Vimalakirti closed his doors to guests, and the city of Vaishali remained silent. It is not only that the true opportunity is absolutely independent, but also that the supreme Tao is difficult to express in words. As soon as the seat was laid under the Bodhi tree, the Buddha wanted to manifest Nirvana, and under the twin Sala trees, he opened his chest and said not a word. These intentions, from beginning to end, are completely pointed out."
  ]
}

十二部中。真實皆為方便。三時五教。權小盡攝妙圓。法界何知。同覺迷而終始。智光自鑒。含真妄以圓常。從上以來。於今猶是。鼓萬靈之出入。而不與聖人同憂。窮三藏之指歸。要難明百姓之事。本自不迷。何當更悟。指爾𦦨為菩提。徒興獨尊之見。還涅槃于生死。誰識大覺之心。須知妄旋不覺。始信妙即無明。會三世于剎那。融十方于當念。此中最難泯合。動念即涉塵沙。自信已是移時。任運翻同罔象。凡庸日用。乃上哲之措心。愚外有無。悉至人所結舌。動亦匪妄。性智本自澄然。真竟何歸。虛空同於寂照。尚非劫外。孰謂今時。真如無性。明昧所以隨緣。生滅由心。能所因之互現。從一真界。妄見自他。于如幻門。別成心色。六塵逼塞。動靜兩緣。五陰堅凝。賢愚各執。從眼門入。名之曰色。從耳門入。名之曰聲。鼻舌身意。各自分司。香味觸法。更相容現。根塵何異。分別亦常。乃惑亂之我境我心。即聖神之真智真理。如斯差別。要須一回。共坐如來道場。恒終身而弗覺。誰示塵勞境界。啟眾昧以同歸。生死相續。首曰淫心。分別妄緣。良由見性。性本非見。寄根以明。心不是淫。因色所蔽。見色心昏。見相心發。同此心目。勝劣攸分。因心有想。達想即心。豈有暫常。覺迷遂別。知流轉之所自。心境豈殊。識常住之恒然。見聞不易。七處徴窮。多聞何益。面門光晃。示根性各各圓明。世界合開。表身土重重攝入。身心本無廣狹。體用似有滯圓。良由二種之根本弗明。遂使能推之離塵無體。是以現前之見相可辨。黑暗之心眼仍

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "『十二部』(佛教經典分類)之中,所有真實之語皆是方便之說。『三時五教』(佛教對佛陀教法的分類),權巧和小乘之法盡皆攝入妙法圓教之中。法界如何得知?如同覺悟與迷惑相伴相隨,直至終結。智慧之光自然照鑒,包含真與妄,達到圓滿常住之境。從過去到現在,一直如此。它推動萬物的生滅出入,卻不與聖人同憂。窮盡三藏十二部(佛教經典總稱)的指歸,卻難以明白百姓日常之事。本來就不迷惑,為何還要再去領悟?指著你的眼翳說是菩提(覺悟),只是徒然興起自以為是的見解。將涅槃(寂滅)寄託于生死之中,又有誰能認識大覺(佛陀)的本心?須知妄念旋轉不停,是因為不覺悟,開始相信妙法即是無明。將過去、現在、未來三世會歸於一剎那,將十方世界融攝於當下這一念。這其中最難泯滅融合,一動念就牽涉到無盡的塵沙。自以為已經明白,實際上卻如同罔象(傳說中的怪物)一般模糊不清。凡夫俗子的日常所用,卻是大智慧者的用心之處。愚昧之人執著于有無之見,所有這些都讓至人(具有極高智慧的人)無言以對。動念也並非虛妄,自性之智本來就澄澈明凈。真如究竟歸向何處?虛空與寂靜照耀相同。尚且不是劫外之事,又何必說是現在?真如沒有自性,明與昧隨著因緣而變化。生滅由心而生,能與所相互顯現。從一真法界(絕對真實的世界)中,妄見自他之別。在如幻的法門中,分別形成心與色。六塵(色、聲、香、味、觸、法)逼塞,動與靜成為兩種緣起。五陰(色、受、想、行、識)堅固凝結,賢與愚各自執著。從眼門進入,稱之為色。從耳門進入,稱之為聲。鼻、舌、身、意,各自掌管其職。香、味、觸、法,更相互容納顯現。根與塵有什麼不同?分別也是常有的。這乃是迷惑顛倒的我境我心,即是聖神的真智真理。像這樣的差別,必須要經歷一次轉變。共同坐在如來道場。終身都不覺悟,又有誰來指示塵勞境界?開啟眾人的愚昧,共同歸向真理。生死相續不斷,首先是淫心。分別妄想的緣起,實在是因為見性的緣故。自性本來就不是可見的,寄託于根(六根)而顯明。心不是淫慾,而是被色相所矇蔽。見到色相,心就昏昧;見到相,心就發動。同樣的心目,勝與劣由此區分。因為心中有想,通達想即是心。哪裡有暫時和永恒之分?覺悟與迷惑因此而區別。知道流轉的根源,心與境有什麼不同?認識到常住的本性,見聞也就不會改變。七處征心(佛教禪宗常用的一種參禪方式),多聞又有什麼益處?面門光芒照耀,顯示根性各自圓滿光明。世界合攏打開,表明身土重重攝入。身心本來就沒有廣狹之分,體與用似乎有滯礙和圓融之別。實在是因為兩種根本(無明和真如)沒有明白,於是使得能推離塵無體。因此現前的見相可以分辨,黑暗的心眼仍然存在。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Among the Twelve Divisions of Scriptures (a classification of Buddhist texts), all truths are expedient teachings. The Three Periods and Five Teachings (a classification of the Buddha's teachings) entirely encompass the wonderful and perfect teaching, including expedient and Hinayana (Small Vehicle) doctrines. How does the Dharma Realm know? It is like enlightenment and delusion accompanying each other until the end. The light of wisdom naturally illuminates, containing both truth and falsehood, reaching a state of perfect permanence. From the past until now, it has always been so. It propels the arising and ceasing of all things, yet does not share the worries of the sages. Exhausting the meaning of the Tripitaka (the three divisions of the Buddhist canon), it is difficult to understand the daily affairs of ordinary people. Originally there is no delusion, why seek further enlightenment? Pointing at your eye disease as Bodhi (enlightenment) only gives rise to the view of self-importance. Entrusting Nirvana (liberation) to birth and death, who can recognize the mind of the Great Awakening (Buddha)? Know that the continuous turning of delusion is due to non-awakening, and begin to believe that wonderful Dharma is none other than ignorance. Converging the past, present, and future into a single moment, merging the ten directions into the present thought. This is the most difficult to merge and integrate; a single thought involves endless dust and sand. Thinking you already understand, in reality, it is as vague as Wangxiang (a mythical creature). The daily activities of ordinary people are where the great wise ones apply their minds. The ignorant cling to views of existence and non-existence, all of which leave the supremely wise speechless. A thought is not necessarily false, the wisdom of self-nature is originally clear and pure. Where does the true ultimately return? Emptiness is the same as silent illumination. It is not even beyond the kalpa (eon), so why speak of the present? True Thusness (Tathata) has no self-nature; clarity and obscurity change with conditions. Birth and death arise from the mind; the subject and object appear mutually. From the One True Dharma Realm (the absolutely real world), delusions of self and other are seen. In the illusory Dharma gate, mind and form are separately created. The six sense objects (form, sound, smell, taste, touch, dharma) obstruct, movement and stillness become two conditions. The five aggregates (form, feeling, perception, volition, consciousness) solidify, the wise and foolish each cling to them. Entering through the eye gate, it is called form. Entering through the ear gate, it is called sound. Nose, tongue, body, and mind each manage their duties. Smell, taste, touch, and dharma further accommodate and manifest each other. What is the difference between the root and the object? Discrimination is also common. This is the confused realm of 'my' object and 'my' mind, which is the true wisdom and truth of the holy and divine. Such differences require a transformation. Sit together in the Bodhimanda (enlightenment place) of the Tathagata (Buddha). If one is not enlightened throughout their life, who will point out the realm of worldly troubles? Open the ignorance of the masses and together return to the truth. The continuous cycle of birth and death begins with lustful thoughts. The arising of discriminating thoughts is truly due to seeing the nature. The self-nature is originally not visible, relying on the roots (the six senses) to become manifest. The mind is not lustful, but obscured by form. Seeing form, the mind becomes confused; seeing appearance, the mind is aroused. With the same mind and eyes, superiority and inferiority are distinguished. Because there are thoughts in the mind, understanding thoughts is the mind. Where is there temporary and eternal? Enlightenment and delusion are thus distinguished. Knowing the origin of the cycle of transmigration, what is the difference between mind and environment? Recognizing the constant nature of permanence, seeing and hearing will not change. Investigating the mind in seven places (a common Chan Buddhist practice), what is the benefit of much learning? The light shines from the face, showing that the nature of each root is perfectly complete and bright. The world closes and opens, indicating that the body and land are repeatedly drawn in. The body and mind originally have no breadth or narrowness; the substance and function seem to have obstruction and completeness. It is truly because the two fundamental roots (ignorance and true thusness) are not understood, thus making the one who can push away from the dust without substance. Therefore, the present visible appearance can be distinguished, but the dark eye of the mind still exists."
  ]
}

迷。燈能顯色。如是見者。是眼非燈。眼能顯色。如是見性。是心非眼。始信心本常住。眼有虧全。住名主人。不住名客。亦猶空本澄寂。塵自動搖。心性真空。生滅從念。豈不知念為所緣。猶未明心必不滅。蓋以久在迷中。心已成想。以想緣心。心同想謝。離想徴見。見露想窮。故分別之餘。猶留根性以待發明。雖對現云暫。更歷陳年亦如現在。觀身遷謝。唸唸不停。觀河宛然。童耄無異。對境曉了。匪落思惟。回憶分明。豈勞誦習。故知眾生佛性。只在目前。忍見如來涅槃。瞥入心念。乘分別之弗及。指現量于當時。暫爾回頭。曠劫如昨。更窮顛倒所在。以究遺失之由。始知見聞之性。惑於色空。不可言悟。而不生滅心。仍居身內。豈得非迷。一臂無殊。各稱倒正。全潮已錯。誰論浮漚。於此不覺。妄意承當。則常住心地。但為所悟。而現領法音。祇是能緣。能緣之分別。既無自性。則所悟之心性。必有所還。豈知八種差別。盡屬世間。而八種見精。終非汝外。前塵是物。汝見非他。知覺不雜于無情。我汝仍分于隔體。各自遍周。見中豈分內外。亦無斷續。空體不定方圓。說理極其詳明。語證猶存份量。若指所悟為是。必以能緣為非。是非歷然。物我難化。物中徴見。先絕所悟之心。是盡無非。又窮能悟之識。大道無私。非二乘之可議。三摩自住。須大智以能言。華相本空。菩提悉遍。是非俱遣。但一文殊。一二兩亡。孤懸妙覺。茍非深徹法源。鮮不惑為神我。更若徘徊四種。將復誤作因緣。第一義諦。即在世間諸相之中。但一發明。

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "『迷』(無明)。燈能顯現顏色,如果這樣認為,是眼睛在起作用,而不是燈。眼睛能顯現顏色,如果這樣認為,是能見的本性在起作用,而不是眼睛。開始相信心性本是常住不變的,眼睛有健全和殘缺的時候。常住的叫做主人,不常住的叫做客人。也像虛空原本澄澈寂靜,是塵埃在自動搖動。心性本是真空,生滅變化是從念頭產生的。難道不知道念頭是所緣之境,如果還不明白心性是不滅的,那是因為長久處在迷惑之中,心已經變成了妄想。用妄想去緣心,心就和妄想一樣會消謝。離開妄想去尋求能見的本性,能見的本性顯露出來,妄想就窮盡了。所以,在分別之後,還留下根性等待啓發。即使面對現在,也只是暫時的,經歷多年也和現在一樣。觀察身體的遷變謝落,唸唸不停留。觀察河流,始終如一,孩童和老人看到的沒有差別。面對境界清楚明白,不要落入思惟分別。回憶過去清清楚楚,不需要誦讀學習。所以知道眾生的佛性,就在眼前。忍受見到如來涅槃,只是瞬間進入心念。趁著分別來不及產生,當下就指出現量。暫時回頭,曠劫就像昨天。進一步探究顛倒的所在,來追究遺失的原因。才知道見聞的本性,被色空所迷惑。不可說已經覺悟,而不生滅的心,仍然在身體內。難道不是迷惑嗎?一隻手臂沒有差別,卻各自稱說倒正。整個潮水已經錯了,誰還去評論浮漚?如果對此不覺悟,妄自承當,那麼常住的心地,就只是所悟的對象,而現在領受的法音,只是能緣的作用。能緣的分別,既然沒有自性,那麼所悟的心性,必定有所歸還。難道知道八種差別,都屬於世間,而八種見精,始終不在你之外。前面的塵境是外物,你的能見不是其他。知覺不會混雜于無情之物,我和你仍然區分于隔閡的個體。各自周遍,能見之中哪裡有內外之分,也沒有斷續。空性的本體沒有固定的方圓。說理說得極其詳明,語證還存在份量。如果指認所悟的是正確的,必定認為能緣的是錯誤的。是非分明,物我和解困難。在事物中尋求能見,首先斷絕所悟的心,這樣就完全沒有錯誤。又探究能悟的識,大道是無私的,不是二乘人可以議論的。三摩地自然安住,需要大智慧才能說出。華麗的表象本是空,菩提心普遍存在。是非都捨棄,只剩下一個文殊(Manjusri,智慧的象徵)。一和二都消失了,獨自懸掛著妙覺。如果不是深入徹悟法源,很少不迷惑地認為是神我。如果再徘徊於四種見精,將又會錯誤地認為是因緣。第一義諦,就在世間諸相之中,只要一旦發明。",
    "English version",
    "『Delusion』 (Avidya). A lamp can reveal colors. If one sees it this way, it is the eye that is functioning, not the lamp. The eye can reveal colors. If one sees the nature of seeing this way, it is the mind that is functioning, not the eye. Initially, believe that the nature of the mind is eternally abiding. Eyes have times of being complete and deficient. That which abides is called the master; that which does not abide is called the guest. It is also like the void, which is originally clear and still, but dust automatically shakes it. The nature of the mind is originally empty, and arising and ceasing come from thoughts. How can one not know that thoughts are what is being cognized? If one does not yet understand that the nature of the mind does not perish, it is because one has long been in delusion, and the mind has become imagination. Using imagination to cognize the mind, the mind will vanish along with imagination. Separating from imagination to seek the nature of seeing, the nature of seeing is revealed, and imagination is exhausted. Therefore, after discrimination, the root nature is still left to await enlightenment. Even facing the present is only temporary; experiencing many years is the same as the present. Observing the body's changes and decay, thoughts arise and cease without stopping. Observing the river, it remains the same; children and old people see no difference. Facing the realm, be clear and understand, and do not fall into thinking and discrimination. Recalling the past clearly and distinctly, there is no need for recitation and learning. Therefore, know that the Buddha-nature of sentient beings is right before their eyes. Enduring the sight of the Tathagata's (如來) Nirvana (涅槃), it is only a moment that enters the mind. Taking advantage of the fact that discrimination has no time to arise, point to the present measure at that moment. Turning back temporarily, countless eons are like yesterday. Further investigate the location of inversion to pursue the cause of loss. Only then will one know that the nature of seeing and hearing is deluded by form and emptiness. It cannot be said that one has awakened, and the non-arising and non-ceasing mind still resides within the body. How can it not be delusion? One arm is no different, yet each claims to be inverted or correct. The entire tide is already wrong; who will discuss the floating bubbles? If one is not aware of this, and presumptuously takes it upon oneself, then the eternally abiding mind-ground is only the object of enlightenment, and the Dharma sound that is now received is only the function of the cognizer. Since the discrimination of the cognizer has no self-nature, then the nature of the mind that is enlightened must have something to return to. How can one know that the eight kinds of differences all belong to the world, and the eight kinds of seeing essences are ultimately not outside of you? The preceding dust realm is an external object; your seeing is not other. Awareness does not mix with insentient things, and I and you are still distinguished by separate bodies. Each pervades, and in seeing, where is there a distinction between inside and outside, and there is no discontinuity. The substance of emptiness has no fixed square or round. The reasoning is explained in great detail, and the verbal proof still has weight. If one points to what is enlightened as correct, one must consider the cognizer as incorrect. Right and wrong are distinct, and it is difficult to transform things and self. Seeking seeing in things, first cut off the mind that is enlightened, and then there is completely no error. Also explore the consciousness that can enlighten. The Great Path is selfless and cannot be discussed by the Two Vehicles (二乘). Samadhi (三摩地) naturally abides, and great wisdom is needed to be able to speak. The appearance of flowers is originally empty, and Bodhi (菩提) pervades everywhere. Right and wrong are both abandoned, and only one Manjusri (文殊, symbol of wisdom) remains. One and two both disappear, and wonderful enlightenment hangs alone. If one does not deeply and thoroughly understand the source of the Dharma, one will rarely be deluded into thinking it is the divine self. If one lingers among the four kinds of seeing essences, one will again mistakenly think it is causation. The First Principle is in the midst of all phenomena in the world, but once it is discovered."
  ]
}

當無別事。四義成就。迥出明暗通塞之外。若能見見。頓證菩提。欲知見所由悟。當識見所由生。見本性真。境從妄得。由妄見境。遂使明妙局于根中。知心無妄。頓令見精超于塵外。別業喻根。同分約器。根迷既豁。如赤眚之忽消。器量本空。若圓影之非故。真智無見。真理無塵。目見從今。見緣依昔。十方國土。儘是妙明。當處見聞。何曾虛妄。如來藏中。陰入皆真。真如性內。處界元實。性色真空。乃至覺明真識。本然周遍。亦隨眾生所知。從此發明。得未曾有。自信心精無外。不在身中。反觀十界依空。含裹心內。恩切歸元之感。愿深同體之悲。已獲法身。希除細惑。人法之分別易捐。俱生之伏眠難見。猶須他請。以釋同疑清凈忽生。知覺明之妄立。同異互見。起含識之有為。世界既成。眾生流變。因緣各遘。業果相尋。在覺明起滅之內。如陽𦦨翻波。處性覺妙明之中。似太虛常寂。悟元不藉。須信眾生之覺性常如。迷豈有因。誰謂妙空之世界猶在。日明云暗。風動霽澄。虛空不動。諸相互流。觀性元真。觀相元妄。合妄成相。合性全真。真則惟妙覺明。一切皆非。真則隨緣周遍。一切皆即。由是應俗應真。現凡現聖。大覺之赴感恒周。群生之當念自滿。全憑妙指。發本真音。破經卷於一塵。同海光而普印。始信妙覺本圓。無因自妄。必使狂性忽歇。勝凈元周。了性空而不住生死。悟緣起而不住涅槃。三種相續。猶在夢中。一念熏修。暫出纏外。是皆不可功用而得。豈更復以戲論而成。所以發覺初心。先觀因地。后當審除。此發明

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "沒有什麼特別的事情。四種意義成就,完全超越了明暗通塞的侷限。如果能夠『見見』(能見之體),就能立刻證得菩提(覺悟)。想要知道『見』(能見之體)由何而悟,應當明白『見』(能見之體)由何而生。『見』(能見之體)的本體是真實的,境界是從虛妄中產生的。由於虛妄地執著于境界,才使得明妙的覺性侷限在根(六根)中。知道心沒有虛妄,就能立刻讓『見精』(能見之精)超越塵埃之外。別業好比根,同分好比器。根的迷惑一旦消除,就像紅眼病突然消失一樣。器的容量本來就是空虛的,就像圓形的影子並非本來就存在一樣。真智沒有能見的,真理沒有塵埃。眼睛所見是從現在開始的,見的因緣是依據過去的。十方國土,全部都是妙明。當下所見所聞,何曾有虛妄?如來藏中,五陰和十二入都是真實的。真如自性之內,十八界本來就是真實的。自性的色法是真空,乃至覺明真識,本來就周遍一切,也隨著眾生所知而從此顯發,得到前所未有的體驗。自信心精沒有在外,也不在身中,反觀十界依空而立,包含在心內。感恩迴歸本源的迫切,願望與眾生同體的悲憫。已經獲得了法身,希望消除細微的迷惑。人法二執的分別容易捨棄,俱生而來的潛伏難以察覺。仍然需要他人請法,來解釋共同的疑惑。清凈突然產生,知道知覺明是虛妄建立的。同異互相顯現,產生了含藏識的有為法。世界已經形成,眾生流轉變化,因緣各自遭遇,業果相互追尋。在覺明生滅之內,就像陽光下翻滾的波浪。處於性覺妙明之中,就像太虛一樣常寂。領悟本元不需要憑藉外力,必須相信眾生的覺性常常如此。迷惑哪裡有原因呢?誰說妙空的世界仍然存在?太陽光明,雲朵就暗淡,風吹動,天空就晴朗,虛空不動,各種現象相互流動。觀察自性是本來真實的,觀察現象是本來虛妄的。合虛妄而成現象,合自性而完全真實。真實就是惟妙覺明,一切都不是。真實就是隨緣周遍,一切都是。因此應俗應真,現凡現聖。大覺的赴感恒常周遍,群生的當念自然滿足。完全憑藉微妙的指引,發出本真的聲音。在一微塵中打破經卷,如同海光一樣普遍印照。開始相信妙覺本來圓滿,沒有原因自己虛妄。必須讓狂性突然止息,殊勝的清凈本來周遍。瞭解性空而不執著于生死,領悟緣起而不執著于涅槃。三種相續,仍然在夢中。一念熏修,暫時脫離纏縛之外。這些都不是可以憑藉功用而得到的,難道還能憑藉戲論而成就嗎?所以發起覺悟的初心,先觀察因地,然後應當審慎地去除,這個發明。",
    "English version",
    "There is nothing special. Four meanings are accomplished, completely transcending the limitations of brightness and darkness, obstruction and openness. If one can 『see the seeing』 (the essence of seeing), one can immediately attain Bodhi (enlightenment). If you want to know how 『seeing』 (the essence of seeing) is realized, you should understand how 『seeing』 (the essence of seeing) arises. The essence of 『seeing』 (the essence of seeing) is inherently true, while the realm arises from delusion. Because of falsely clinging to the realm, the wonderful and bright nature is confined within the roots (the six senses). Knowing that the mind is without delusion, one can immediately allow the 『seeing essence』 (the essence of seeing) to transcend beyond the dust. Separate karma is like the roots, and shared karma is like the vessels. Once the delusion of the roots is dispelled, it is like the sudden disappearance of a red haze in the eye. The capacity of the vessels is inherently empty, like a round shadow that is not originally there. True wisdom has no seer, and true principle has no dust. What the eyes see begins from now, and the conditions for seeing rely on the past. The ten directions of lands are all wonderfully bright. What is seen and heard in the present moment has never been false. Within the Tathagatagarbha (Buddha-nature), the five skandhas (aggregates) and twelve entrances are all true. Within the true nature of Suchness, the eighteen realms are originally real. The form of nature is emptiness, and even the true consciousness of awareness and brightness is inherently pervasive, also manifesting from this according to what sentient beings know, obtaining unprecedented experience. Believe that the essence of the self-confidence is not outside, nor is it within the body, but reflect that the ten realms are established based on emptiness, contained within the mind. The urgency of gratitude for returning to the source, and the compassion of wishing to be one with all beings. Having already attained the Dharmakaya (Dharma body), hoping to eliminate subtle delusions. The distinction between the attachment to self and Dharma is easy to abandon, but the innate dormant tendencies are difficult to see. It is still necessary to request teachings from others to resolve common doubts. Purity suddenly arises, knowing that the awareness and brightness are falsely established. Sameness and difference appear mutually, giving rise to the conditioned dharmas of the alaya consciousness. The world has already formed, sentient beings flow and change, conditions meet each other, and karmic results follow each other. Within the arising and ceasing of awareness and brightness, it is like waves rolling in the sunlight. Being in the wonderful brightness of the nature of awareness, it is like the constant stillness of the great void. Realizing the origin does not require external assistance, one must believe that the awareness nature of sentient beings is always like this. Where does delusion have a cause? Who says that the world of wonderful emptiness still exists? When the sun is bright, the clouds are dim; when the wind blows, the sky clears; the void does not move, and various phenomena flow mutually. Observe that the nature is originally true, and observe that phenomena are originally false. Combining falsehoods forms phenomena, and combining nature is completely true. True is only the wonderful awareness and brightness, everything is not. True is pervasive according to conditions, everything is. Therefore, responding to the mundane and responding to the true, manifesting as ordinary and manifesting as holy. The Great Enlightenment's response to feeling is constantly pervasive, and the present moment of sentient beings is naturally fulfilled. Relying entirely on subtle guidance, emitting the original true sound. Breaking scriptures in a single dust mote, universally illuminating like the light of the ocean. Beginning to believe that wonderful enlightenment is originally complete, and there is no cause for self-delusion. It is necessary to let the madness suddenly cease, and the supreme purity is originally pervasive. Understanding the emptiness of nature without clinging to birth and death, realizing the arising of conditions without clinging to Nirvana. The three continuations are still in a dream. Cultivating in a single thought, temporarily escaping beyond the entanglements. These are not attainable through effort, how can they be accomplished through frivolous discussions? Therefore, to initiate the initial aspiration for enlightenment, first observe the causal ground, and then carefully remove, this invention."
  ]
}

之見聞覺知。即究竟之常樂我凈。但能審擇生死。便可遠契涅槃。不隨虛妄。任運靜深。現前清水。無俟去泥。畢至到源。豈逾純凈。惟是迷中之根性無知。緣塵生識。悟后之結處宜辨。討賊尋媒。障分別于初心。融種習於后智。猶稱方便。未擬圓修。解六同一。黏脫俱旋。除器觀空。同異頓撤。知妙圓中之黏湛忽然。則勝義根之清凈原在。暗明由見。迷妄乃昏。根知非塵。不循自脫。七種之體性堅凝。何待杵音始驗。六門之知覺常妙。豈為寤寐所殊。妙性本凈。明妄當知。解應結心。根塵無咎。性憑凈力。理行相成。擇根境之圓滯。借鑑群機。悟直捷于修持。頓超權學。一切色法。皆聚于目。昔從見昏者今從見悟。十方音聲。悉達于聞。不為耳礙者還以耳旋。旋聞歸覺。頓轉不住之機。空覺極圓。誰解現前之寂。此觀音本證。已獲圓通。文殊選根。首稱方便。揀二十四聖。指三世一門。依悟圓修。決定惟二。循修起悟。無漏有三。行無虛假。斷愛見之魔。心直如弦。成真因之地。現業易制。自行可違。宿習難除。猶假神力。是以道場建立。加被憑他。然而章句妙微。契會由自。十方諸佛。從此出生。後世修行。不起于座。若欲發初干慧地。畢竟先由漸次進增。更期滿五十五心。然後圓成果地修證。是為廣垂修范。舍此即涉邪途。茍得直捷悟明。亦自默符正觀。靡有三業未清。六根未凈。可作人天楷模。即此十因不涉。六報不交。寧免禪那差互。所以純情入地。祇由一念之差。即或純想昇天。須知報滿仍墜。研窮心識。極於四空。放蕩沉迷

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "之見聞覺知,即是究竟的常樂我凈(永恒的喜樂真我清凈的境界)。只要能審慎地選擇生死,便可以遠離而契合涅槃(寂滅的境界)。不隨從虛妄,任憑自然地靜寂深遠。現前的清水,無需去除污泥。最終到達源頭,豈不是更加純凈?只是迷惑中的根性無知,因緣塵埃而生起意識。覺悟后的關鍵之處應該辨明,如同討伐賊寇要尋找內應。障礙分別心於最初的修行,融化潛在的習氣於後來的智慧,還可稱為方便之法,尚未達到圓滿的修行。理解六根同一,黏著和脫離都一起旋轉。去除器皿而觀空,同和異頓時消除。知道妙圓(不可思議的圓滿)中的黏著和清澈忽然顯現,那麼殊勝的根性的清凈原本就在。黑暗和光明由見(視覺)而生,迷惑和虛妄乃是昏昧。根性的知覺並非塵埃,不追隨它自然脫離。七種根性的體性堅固凝結,何必等待杵的聲音才驗證。六根門頭的知覺常常是微妙的,豈會因為睡著或醒來而有所不同。妙性(不可思議的本性)本來清凈,明白虛妄應當知道。解開應該解開的心結,根和塵都沒有過錯。本性憑藉清凈的力量,道理和修行相互成就。選擇根和境的圓滿和滯礙,借鑑眾生的根機。領悟直接了當的修行,頓時超越權巧之學。一切色法,都聚集在眼睛裡,過去從見(視覺)而昏昧的現在從見(視覺)而覺悟。十方音聲,都通達于聽聞,不被耳朵所障礙的還用耳朵來旋轉。旋轉聽聞迴歸覺悟,頓時轉變不停留的機能。空覺極其圓滿,誰能理解現前的寂靜?這是觀音(Avalokiteśvara)菩薩原本證得的,已經獲得圓通。文殊(Manjusri)菩薩選擇根性,首先稱讚方便。揀選二十四聖,指明三世同一法門。依靠覺悟而圓滿修行,決定只有兩種。遵循修行而生起覺悟,無漏有三種。行為沒有虛假,斷除愛和見的魔障,心像琴絃一樣正直,成就真因的根基。現在的業容易控制,自己的行為可以改變,宿世的習氣難以去除,還要藉助神力。因此道場建立,加持憑藉他人。然而章句微妙,契合在於自己。十方諸佛,從此出生。後世修行,不起于座。如果想要發起初干慧地(初果羅漢的境界),畢竟先要通過漸次增進,更要期望圓滿五十五心,然後圓成果地的修證。這是廣泛垂示修行的規範,捨棄這個就涉及到邪路。如果得到直接了當的覺悟,也自然默默符合正觀。沒有三業(身口意)不清凈,六根(眼耳鼻舌身意)未清凈,可以作為人天的楷模。即此十因不涉及,六報不相交,難道能免除禪那(Dhyana)的差錯?所以純粹的情感進入地獄,只因爲一念之差。即使純粹的思念升到天堂,要知道報盡仍然會墜落。研窮心識,達到四空定(無所有處定、非想非非想處定),放蕩沉迷。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Of seeing, hearing, perceiving, and knowing, is the ultimate eternal bliss, true self, purity (Nitya-sukha-atma-shuddha). If one can carefully choose between life and death, one can be far away and in accordance with Nirvana (extinction of suffering). Not following falsehood, allowing natural stillness to deepen. The clear water before us needs no removal of mud. Ultimately reaching the source, would it not be even purer? It is only the ignorance of the root nature in delusion, arising from the dust of conditions, that gives rise to consciousness. The key points after enlightenment should be discerned, like seeking an accomplice to defeat a thief. Obstructing the discriminating mind in the initial practice, melting the latent habits into later wisdom, can still be called expedient means, not yet reaching complete cultivation. Understanding the oneness of the six senses, clinging and detachment rotate together. Removing the vessel and contemplating emptiness, sameness and difference are instantly eliminated. Knowing that the clinging and clarity in the wondrous perfection suddenly appear, then the purity of the superior root is originally present. Darkness and light arise from seeing (vision), delusion and falsehood are ignorance. The knowledge of the root is not dust, not following it naturally detaches. The seven natures of the body are firm and solidified, why wait for the sound of the pestle to verify? The perception of the six gates is always wonderful, how can it be different because of being asleep or awake? The wonderful nature is originally pure, understanding falsehood should be known. Untie the knots that should be untied, the root and dust are without fault. The nature relies on the power of purity, principle and practice complement each other. Choose the perfection and stagnation of the root and environment, learn from the opportunities of all beings. Realize the direct and straightforward practice, instantly surpassing expedient learning. All forms of matter gather in the eyes, those who were once deluded by seeing (vision) are now enlightened by seeing (vision). The sounds of the ten directions all reach hearing, those who are not obstructed by the ears still use the ears to rotate. Rotating hearing returns to awareness, instantly transforming the function of non-stopping. Empty awareness is extremely perfect, who can understand the present stillness? This is what Avalokitesvara (Guanyin) originally realized, already attaining perfect penetration. Manjusri (Wenshu) Bodhisattva chooses the root nature, first praising expediency. Selecting the twenty-four sages, pointing out the one gate of the three worlds. Relying on enlightenment to perfect cultivation, there are definitely only two. Following cultivation to arise enlightenment, there are three without outflows. Actions are without falsehood, cutting off the demons of love and views, the mind is as straight as a string, accomplishing the foundation of true cause. Present karma is easy to control, one's own actions can be changed, past habits are difficult to remove, still relying on divine power. Therefore, the establishment of the monastery, blessings rely on others. However, the verses are subtle, the agreement lies in oneself. The Buddhas of the ten directions are born from this. Future generations practice, without rising from their seats. If one wants to initiate the initial dry wisdom ground (the state of the first Arhat), after all, one must first gradually increase, and even hope to perfect the fifty-five minds, and then complete the cultivation and realization of the fruit ground. This is the broad instruction of the practice, abandoning this involves the wrong path. If one obtains direct and straightforward enlightenment, one will also silently conform to the correct view. Without the three karmas (body, speech, and mind) being impure, the six senses (eyes, ears, nose, tongue, body, and mind) not being purified, one can be a model for humans and gods. That is, these ten causes are not involved, the six retributions do not intersect, how can one avoid the errors of Dhyana (meditation)? Therefore, pure emotion enters hell, only because of a single thought. Even if pure thought ascends to heaven, one must know that the reward is exhausted and one will still fall. Investigating the mind and consciousness, reaching the four formless realms (realm of nothingness, realm of neither perception nor non-perception), indulging and sinking."
  ]
}

。成於阿鼻。佛性流轉。隨念升沈。妄情匪他。如手反覆。但能識本自心。不循知見。便可隨順覺性。頓了聖情。三摩地中。得失俱泯。五陰盡處。境界不留。由初至終。從凡入聖。循顧所悟。不逾初心。非法眼之能窺。豈天魔之得便。若祇依教進修。由戒入定。茍不隨時自覺。未免因勝生心。著境便落邪思。動念即為魔攝。至於生滅已滅。識性現前。誤作菩提。亡失知見。別成諸論。不究妙圓。即使定性聲聞。未許見性。得少獨覺。遠背涅槃。所以不由積累。直下心開。與此遞歷深禪。循致識破。同名干慧。頓入金剛。彼由悟修。此乃修悟。修悟者先行布而後圓融。悟修者先圓融而後行布。悟則俱悟。互有異同。修則俱修。且分難易。頓悟者理虞差別。漸修者事涉淆訛。理之差別。乃在悟之失真。事之淆訛。常恐修多岐路。是以見性離塵。超分別而隨緣自在。真心無妄。出是非以妙慧莊嚴。悟既精詳。修應圓脫。行以理印。差別之義無虧。理以行嚴。根本之門靡逾。陰銷次第。豈閡圓融。因界分明。不淪偏證。本覺凈心。初無塵垢。妄想計度。始現色心。色因空有。觸以離知。記非忘無。生豈滅盡。即使生滅已旋于湛中。入合彌彰于識際。故行陰雖盡。覺心難圓。二乘既誤入于無為。初心猶錯擬乎即色。悟理未圓。才趨解脫之門。適已成於厭境。迷情不盡。侈言非道之行。究必底于撥無。萬法雖空。一真何住。三界之心已絕。現行豈濫俱生。千聖之眼既超。無身恐妨有事。所以同時啐啄。須還作家。無著真宗。未稱尊貴。此經示墮。要先

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本:",
    "最終墮入阿鼻地獄。佛性流轉不定,隨著念頭的變化而上升或下沉。虛妄的情感並非外物,就像手掌翻轉一樣簡單。只要能夠認識到自己本來的心性,不追隨各種知見,就可以順應覺悟的本性,立刻領悟聖人的心境。在三摩地(Samadhi,一種高度專注的精神狀態)中,得與失都消失了。當五陰(Skandha,構成個體存在的五種要素:色、受、想、行、識)消盡時,任何境界都不會留下。從最初到最終,從凡人到聖人,回顧所領悟的,都不會超出最初的發心。這不是法眼(Dharma-cakṣus,能見真理的智慧之眼)所能窺視的,也不是天魔(Mara,佛教中阻礙修行的惡魔)所能得逞的。如果只是按照教義進修,通過持戒而入定,如果不隨時自覺,就難免因為取得一點成就而生起驕慢之心。執著于境界就會陷入邪思,動念就會被魔所控制。等到生滅的現象已經止息,識性(Vijñāna,意識)顯現出來時,錯誤地認為是菩提(Bodhi,覺悟),喪失了正確的知見,從而創立各種不同的理論。不深入探究妙圓之理,即使是定性聲聞(Śrāvaka,聽聞佛法而修行的弟子),也不能算是見性。獲得少許成就的獨覺(Pratyekabuddha,不依賴他人教導而獨自覺悟的人),遠離了涅槃(Nirvana,解脫)。所以,不是通過積累,而是直接打開心扉。與那些經歷深禪(Dhyana,禪定)而逐漸識破的人,同樣被稱為干慧(Śuṣka-vipassanā,沒有定力基礎的智慧)。頓悟的人直接進入金剛(Vajra,比喻堅固不壞的智慧)。他們一個是先悟后修,一個是先修后悟。修悟的人先進行佈施,然後再達到圓融;悟修的人先達到圓融,然後再進行佈施。悟的時候都是一樣的悟,但彼此之間有差異;修的時候都是一樣的修,但有難易之分。頓悟的人在理上容易出現差別,漸修的人在事上容易出現混淆。理上的差別,在於悟的失真;事上的混淆,常常擔心修行走上歧路。因此,見性的人遠離塵垢,超越分別而隨緣自在;真心沒有虛妄,超越是非而以妙慧莊嚴。悟如果精詳,修就應該圓脫。用理來印證修行,差別的意義就不會缺失;用修行來嚴飾理,根本的門徑就不會逾越。五陰消融的次第,怎麼會妨礙圓融呢?因果界限分明,就不會淪為偏頗的證悟。本覺清凈的心,最初沒有塵垢。因為虛妄的想像和計度,才開始顯現色(Rūpa,物質)和心(Citta,精神)。色因空而有,觸以離而知。記憶不是遺忘,生不是滅盡。即使生滅已經在湛然的本性中旋轉,入合也更加彰顯于識的邊際。所以,行陰(Saṃskāra-skandha,意志)雖然消盡,覺心(Bodhi-citta,菩提心)難以圓滿。二乘(Śrāvaka-yāna and Pratyekabuddha-yāna,聲聞乘和緣覺乘)已經誤入無為(Asamskrta,不生不滅的境界),初心仍然錯誤地比擬於即色(Rūpa,物質)。悟理沒有圓滿,才趨向解脫之門,就已經形成了厭惡境界的心態。迷惑的情感沒有斷盡,就誇大地說不是正道的修行,最終必定會落入撥無因果的邪見。萬法雖然是空的,但一真(Tathatā,真如)住在哪裡呢?三界(Triloka,欲界、色界、無色界)的心已經斷絕,現行(Pravrtti,行為)怎麼會濫用俱生(Sahaja,與生俱來的)呢?千聖(Buddhas and Bodhisattvas,諸佛菩薩)的眼睛已經超越,沒有身體恐怕會妨礙有事。所以,同時啐啄(比喻師徒配合默契),必須還要有作家(指善於引導的老師)。沒有執著的真宗,不能稱為尊貴。這部經書揭示了墮落的原因,首先要……",
    "English version:",
    "Ultimately, one falls into Avīci (Avīci, the lowest level of hell). Buddha-nature flows and changes, rising and sinking with the fluctuations of thoughts. Deluded emotions are not external; they are as simple as the turning of a hand. If one can recognize one's original mind and not follow various views and opinions, one can accord with the nature of awakening and immediately realize the state of a sage. In Samadhi (Samadhi, a state of deep concentration), gain and loss both disappear. When the five Skandhas (Skandha, the five aggregates: form, feeling, perception, mental formations, and consciousness) are exhausted, no realm remains. From beginning to end, from ordinary person to sage, reviewing what has been realized does not exceed the initial aspiration. This cannot be窺視 by the Dharma-cakṣus (Dharma-cakṣus, the eye of wisdom that sees the truth), nor can it be taken advantage of by Mara (Mara, the demon who obstructs practice). If one merely cultivates according to the teachings, entering concentration through precepts, if one does not constantly awaken oneself, one will inevitably develop arrogance due to achieving some success. Attachment to realms leads to wrong thinking, and a single thought is seized by demons. When the phenomena of arising and ceasing have ceased, and the nature of consciousness (Vijñāna, consciousness) manifests, it is mistakenly taken as Bodhi (Bodhi, enlightenment), losing correct views and opinions, thus creating various different theories. Without deeply investigating the wonderful and complete principle, even a Śrāvaka (Śrāvaka, a disciple who practices by hearing the Buddha's teachings) with a fixed nature cannot be considered to have seen the nature. A Pratyekabuddha (Pratyekabuddha, one who awakens independently without relying on the teachings of others) who gains a little achievement is far from Nirvana (Nirvana, liberation). Therefore, it is not through accumulation, but directly opening the mind. Those who gradually discern through deep Dhyana (Dhyana, meditation) are similarly called Śuṣka-vipassanā (Śuṣka-vipassanā, dry insight without the foundation of concentration). Those who awaken suddenly directly enter Vajra (Vajra, diamond, symbolizing indestructible wisdom). One is awakened first and then cultivates, the other cultivates first and then awakens. Those who cultivate and awaken first perform giving and then achieve completeness; those who awaken and cultivate first achieve completeness and then perform giving. Awakening is the same for both, but there are differences between them; cultivation is the same for both, but there are easy and difficult aspects. Those who awaken suddenly are prone to differences in principle, while those who cultivate gradually are prone to confusion in practice. The difference in principle lies in the distortion of awakening; the confusion in practice often fears that cultivation will lead to divergent paths. Therefore, one who sees the nature is free from defilement, transcends discrimination, and is free and at ease according to conditions; the true mind is without falsehood, transcends right and wrong, and is adorned with wonderful wisdom. If awakening is precise and detailed, cultivation should be complete and free. Using principle to印證 practice, the meaning of difference will not be lost; using practice to adorn principle, the fundamental path will not be transgressed. How can the sequence of the dissolution of the five Skandhas hinder completeness? The boundaries of cause and effect are clear, so one will not fall into biased realization. The original pure mind has no defilement from the beginning. It is because of deluded imagination and calculation that form (Rūpa, matter) and mind (Citta, mind) begin to manifest. Form exists because of emptiness, and touch is known through detachment. Memory is not forgetting, and birth is not complete extinction. Even if arising and ceasing are already revolving in the serene nature, entry and union are even more manifest at the edge of consciousness. Therefore, although the Saṃskāra-skandha (Saṃskāra-skandha, mental formations) is exhausted, the Bodhi-citta (Bodhi-citta, the mind of enlightenment) is difficult to perfect. The two vehicles (Śrāvaka-yāna and Pratyekabuddha-yāna, the Hearer Vehicle and the Solitary Realizer Vehicle) have already mistakenly entered non-action (Asamskrta, the unconditioned realm), and the initial aspiration is still wrongly compared to form (Rūpa, matter). Without complete understanding of the principle, just approaching the gate of liberation has already formed a state of厭惡 realms. Without exhausting deluded emotions, exaggerating that it is not the practice of the right path will ultimately lead to the wrong view of denying cause and effect. Although all dharmas are empty, where does the Tathatā (Tathatā, suchness) reside? The mind of the Triloka (Triloka, the three realms: desire realm, form realm, and formless realm) has been cut off, so how can present action (Pravrtti, action) misuse the Sahaja (Sahaja, innate)? The eyes of the Buddhas and Bodhisattvas have already transcended, so the absence of a body may hinder having affairs. Therefore, at the same time, the teacher and student must cooperate tacitly, and there must also be a teacher who is good at guiding. The true tradition without attachment cannot be called noble. This scripture reveals the cause of falling, first..."
  ]
}

蕩其識心。終至圓修。亦即蠲夫聖解。行於異類。始許同廛。誰非見者。誰非聞者。眼見非色。耳聞非聲。全體大用。攝今古于當途。泯智絕愚。齊物我于劫外。猶屬指蹤。未當真詣。默而成之。不得其眹神。而明之。存乎其人。

  首楞嚴直指總論(終)

  No. 291

  大佛頂如來密因修證了義諸菩薩萬行首楞嚴經直指卷第一

  洞宗三十四世丹霞沙門 函是天然 疏

  嗣法門人 今釋澹歸 閱

  今辯樂說 較

  首楞嚴此云究竟堅固者。大定之名也。自性真定。當念寧謐。不可破壞。無有時量。亦無出入。以體而言。含裹法界。大而無外。細入無間。絕相離見。故即佛頂為喻。佛之頂相不可見也。以因而言。十方如來。微密寂照。非智慧知。非識能識。以修證而言。則自性真修。不落階級。不借功勛。所謂了義。非不了義。以體大而言。故曰如來。以用大而言。故曰菩薩。合普賢行愿。無不具足於因果同時之極也。今一切眾生。自性清凈。各不自見。即凡庸之不覺。得大聖之湛圓。夫見即不大。譬全渤局于浮漚。大故不見。似一滴投于巨壑。此眾生之大佛頂也。見即不密。聲光泄于所知。密即不見。虛空本無窺處。此眾生之如來密因也。見修非證。目前之法猶存。忘見為證。一真之量斯撤。此眾生之修證了義也。見行不妙。誰知足為眼礙。妙行不見。始信解絕行成。此眾生之普賢萬行也。見即不定。境紛心目之間。定即不見。知泯繁興之內。此眾生之究竟堅固也。首標經目。極如來因果理行

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "滌除他們的分別意識(識心),最終達到圓滿的修行。這也意味著去除對聖境的執著理解(聖解),在不同的境界中修行(異類),才允許與聖賢同住(同廛)。誰不是能看見真理的人(見者)?誰不是能聽聞真理的人(聞者)?眼睛所見並非真實的色相(眼見非色),耳朵所聽並非真實的聲音(耳聞非聲)。全體的偉大作用,將古今都攝入當下(當途)。泯滅智慧和愚昧的分別(泯智絕愚),使萬物與自我等同於永恒(劫外)。但這仍然只是指向真理的線索(指蹤),尚未真正到達(真詣)。在沉默中成就它,無法找到它的痕跡(眹神);在神性中明白它,存在於每個人的本性之中。",
    
    "《首楞嚴直指總論》(終)",
    
    "No. 291",
    
    "《大佛頂如來密因修證了義諸菩薩萬行首楞嚴經直指》卷第一",
    
    "洞宗第三十四世丹霞沙門 函是天然 疏",
    
    "嗣法門人 今釋澹歸 閱",
    
    "今辯樂說 較",
    
    "『首楞嚴』,這裡的意思是『究竟堅固』(究竟堅固者),是大定的名稱。自性本具的真定,當下念頭清凈安寧(寧謐),不可破壞,沒有時間限制(時量),也沒有出入。從本體上說,它包含整個法界,大到沒有邊際(大而無外),細到沒有間隙(細入無間),超越一切表象和分別見解(絕相離見),所以用佛頂來比喻。佛的頂相是不可見的。從因地上說,十方如來,微妙而寂靜地照耀(微密寂照),不是思辨的智慧所能瞭解(非智慧知),也不是分別意識所能認識(非識能識)。從修行證悟上說,自性本具的真實修行,不落入任何階段(不落階級),不依賴任何功勞(不借功勛),這就是所謂的『了義』,而不是不了義。從本體的廣大來說,所以稱為『如來』。從作用的廣大來說,所以稱為『菩薩』。綜合普賢菩薩的行愿,沒有不完備地體現在因果同時的極致境界中。現在一切眾生,自性本來清凈,但各自不能看見。這就是凡夫的不能覺悟,卻具備大聖的圓滿境界。如果執著于『見』,就不能體現其廣大,譬如將整個大海侷限於一個水泡之中。因為廣大,所以反而看不見,好比一滴水投入巨大的山谷。這就是眾生本具的『大佛頂』。如果執著于『見』,就不能體現其秘密,聲和光泄露于所知之中。因為秘密,所以無法看見,虛空本來就沒有窺視之處。這就是眾生本具的『如來密因』。如果執著于『修』,就不能達到『證』,眼前的法仍然存在。忘記一切見解,才能達到『證』,真實的本體才能顯現。這就是眾生本具的『修證了義』。如果執著于『行』,就不能達到『妙』,誰知道腳反而成為眼睛的障礙。不執著于妙行,才相信理解斷絕而修行成就。這就是眾生本具的『普賢萬行』。如果執著于『見』,就不能達到『定』,境界在心和眼之間紛亂。達到『定』,就看不見任何東西,知識泯滅于繁雜的念頭之中。這就是眾生本具的『究竟堅固』。首先標明經的題目,窮盡如來的因果、理體和修行。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Wash away their discriminating mind (識心, *shixin*, discriminating mind). Ultimately reach perfect cultivation. This also means eliminating attachment to holy understanding (聖解, *shengjie*, holy understanding). Practicing in different realms (異類, *yilei*, different realms) is the only way to be allowed to live with the sages (同廛, *tongchan*, same neighborhood). Who is not a seer (見者, *jianzhe*, seer)? Who is not a hearer (聞者, *wenzhe*, hearer)? What the eye sees is not true form (眼見非色, *yanjian feise*, what the eye sees is not true form), what the ear hears is not true sound (耳聞非聲, *erwen feisheng*, what the ear hears is not true sound). The great function of the whole encompasses the past and present in the present moment (當途, *dangtu*, the present moment). Eliminate the distinction between wisdom and foolishness (泯智絕愚, *minzhi jueyu*, eliminate the distinction between wisdom and foolishness), equalize things and self to eternity (劫外, *jiewai*, eternity). Yet this is still just a clue (指蹤, *zhizong*, clue), not yet truly arrived (真詣, *zhenyi*, truly arrived). Achieve it in silence, unable to find its trace (朕神, *zhenzhen*, trace); understand it in divinity, existing in the nature of each person.",
    
    "Direct Pointing to the Śūraṅgama Sūtra, General Treatise (End)",
    
    "No. 291",
    
    "Direct Pointing to the Śūraṅgama Sūtra, the Secret Cause of the Tathagata's (如來, *Rulai*, Tathagata) Enlightenment and Cultivation, the Definitive Meaning, and the Myriad Practices of All Bodhisattvas (菩薩, *Pusa*, Bodhisattva), Volume 1",
    
    "By Śramaṇa (沙門, *Shamen*, Monk) Han Shi Tian Ran (函是天然) of Danxia (丹霞) of the 34th Generation of the Caodong (洞宗) School",
    
    "Successor in Dharma, Shi Dan Gui (釋澹歸) Reviewed",
    
    "Now Bian Le Shuo (辯樂說) Compared",
    
    "'Śūraṅgama' (首楞嚴, *Shoulengyan*, Śūraṅgama), here means 'ultimate firmness' (究竟堅固者, *jiujing jiangu zhe*, ultimate firmness), the name of great samadhi (大定, *Dading*, great samadhi). The true samadhi inherent in self-nature, the present thought is peaceful and tranquil (寧謐, *ningmi*, peaceful), indestructible, without time limit (時量, *shiliang*, time limit), and without coming and going. From the perspective of the essence, it contains the entire Dharma Realm, so large that there is no outside (大而無外, *da er wu wai*), so small that there is no gap (細入無間, *xi ru wu jian*), transcending all appearances and discriminating views (絕相離見, *juexiang lijian*), so it is likened to the Buddha's crown. The Buddha's crown is invisible. From the perspective of the cause, the Tathagatas of the ten directions, subtly and quietly illuminate (微密寂照, *weimi jizhao*), which cannot be understood by speculative wisdom (非智慧知, *fei zhineng zhi*), nor can it be recognized by discriminating consciousness (非識能識, *fei shi neng shi*). From the perspective of cultivation and realization, the true cultivation inherent in self-nature does not fall into any stages (不落階級, *bu luo jieji*), does not rely on any merit (不借功勛, *bu jie gongxun*), this is the so-called 'definitive meaning' (了義, *liaoyi*, definitive meaning), not non-definitive meaning. From the perspective of the greatness of the essence, it is called 'Tathagata' (如來, *Rulai*, Tathagata). From the perspective of the greatness of the function, it is called 'Bodhisattva' (菩薩, *Pusa*, Bodhisattva). Combining the practices and vows of Samantabhadra (普賢, *Puxian*, Samantabhadra), there is nothing that is not completely embodied in the ultimate state of cause and effect at the same time. Now all sentient beings, their self-nature is originally pure, but they cannot see it for themselves. This is the non-awakening of ordinary people, but they possess the perfect state of great sages. If one clings to 'seeing' (見, *jian*, seeing), one cannot embody its greatness, like confining the entire ocean to a bubble. Because it is great, it cannot be seen, like a drop of water thrown into a huge valley. This is the 'Great Buddha Crown' (大佛頂, *Da Foding*, Great Buddha Crown) inherent in sentient beings. If one clings to 'seeing', one cannot embody its secrecy, sound and light are revealed in what is known. Because it is secret, it cannot be seen, emptiness originally has no place to peep. This is the 'Secret Cause of the Tathagata' (如來密因, *Rulai miyin*, Secret Cause of the Tathagata) inherent in sentient beings. If one clings to 'cultivation' (修, *xiu*, cultivation), one cannot reach 'realization' (證, *zheng*, realization), the Dharma before one's eyes still exists. Forgetting all views, one can reach 'realization', and the true essence can appear. This is the 'Definitive Meaning of Cultivation and Realization' (修證了義, *xiuzheng liaoyi*, Definitive Meaning of Cultivation and Realization) inherent in sentient beings. If one clings to 'practice' (行, *xing*, practice), one cannot reach 'wonder' (妙, *miao*, wonder), who knows that the foot becomes an obstacle to the eye. Not clinging to wonderful practice, one believes that understanding is cut off and practice is achieved. This is the 'Myriad Practices of Samantabhadra' (普賢萬行, *Puxian wanxing*, Myriad Practices of Samantabhadra) inherent in sentient beings. If one clings to 'seeing', one cannot reach 'samadhi' (定, *ding*, samadhi), the realm is chaotic between the mind and the eye. Reaching 'samadhi', one sees nothing, knowledge is extinguished in the midst of complex thoughts. This is the 'Ultimate Firmness' (究竟堅固, *jiujing jiangu*, Ultimate Firmness) inherent in sentient beings. First, the title of the sutra is marked, exhausting the cause and effect, essence, and practice of the Tathagata."
  ]
}

。不越眾生自性清凈各不自見之中。故悟為圓悟。修為圓修。自始至終。不墮邪外。圓覺云。一切眾生。皆證圓覺。知其皆證。即非眾生。若非眾生。即亦非證。如來所為直取現前根性。以合於無是非是。豈聲聞緣覺之所能構歟。

  △初序分。分二。初諸經通例。分二。初說時處。

  如是我聞一時。

  世尊臨般涅槃。阿難請問結集經首當置何語。世尊云。當置如是我聞一時。故為契經通例。如是指所說經。我聞謂阿難親從佛聞。一時正說經時也。

  佛在室羅筏城祇桓精舍。

  室羅筏具雲室羅伐悉底。此云豐德。以此城中。財寶五欲多聞解脫四皆豐足。祇具云祇陀。亦云逝多。此云戰勝。波斯匿王太子生時。適當戰勝。故以取名。桓林也。祇陀園為給孤長者以金布地。買置精舍。請佛說法。太子感動。並施林木。故當時並稱。

  △二列在會聽眾。

  與大比丘眾千二百五十人俱。皆是無漏大阿羅漢。

  大有三義。一數多。二名重。三德勝。比丘此翻亦三義。一乞士。二怖魔。三破惡。千二百五十人憍陳那等五人。舍利弗目犍連師徒各一百人。三迦葉師徒一千人。耶舍長者五十人。略五人者。舉大數也。漏有三。一無明。二欲。三有。阿羅漢亦有三翻。一應供。二無生。三殺賊。二乘應供。止於人天。大乘應供。通世出世二乘無生。止脫分段。大乘無生。並離變易。二乘殺賊。止窮四住。大乘殺賊。五住永盡。然此嘆眾。當是大乘。涅槃四依品第四人者。名阿羅漢。斷諸煩惱。舍于重擔。逮得

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "不超越眾生各自本具的清凈自性,而眾生自己卻不能覺察。因此,開悟是圓滿的開悟,修行是圓滿的修行,自始至終,不落入邪道外道。《圓覺經》說:『一切眾生,皆已證得圓滿覺性。』知道他們皆已證得,那就不是眾生;如果不是眾生,也就無所謂證得。如來所做的是直接取用眾生現前的根性,使之與無是無非的真理相合,這豈是聲聞、緣覺所能理解的呢?",
    
    "△ 初序分。分為二。初諸經通例。分二。初說時處。",
    
    "如是我聞,一時。",
    
    "世尊(釋迦牟尼佛)臨近般涅槃(入滅)時,阿難(佛陀十大弟子之一)請問結集經書時,經文開頭應當放置什麼語句。世尊說:『應當放置「如是我聞,一時」。』因此,這成為佛經通用的慣例。「如是」是指所說的這部經,「我聞」是說阿難親自從佛陀那裡聽聞,「一時」是指正當宣說這部經的時候。",
    
    "佛在室羅筏城(梵文Śrāvastī,古印度城市名,意為『豐德』)祇桓精舍(梵文Jetavana Vihara,又稱祇園精舍,是佛教最早的寺院之一)。",
    
    "室羅筏(Śrāvastī)完整地說是室羅伐悉底(Śrāvastī),這裡的意思是『豐德』。因為這座城中,財寶、五欲、多聞、解脫這四種都非常豐足。祇(Jeta)完整地說是祇陀(Jetavana),也說是逝多(Jeta),這裡的意思是『戰勝』。波斯匿王(Prasenajit,古印度拘薩羅國國王)的太子出生時,正當戰勝,因此用這個名字。桓是樹林。祇陀園(Jetavana)是給孤長者(Anathapindika,又稱須達多長者,佛教大護法)用金子鋪地的方式買下,建造精舍,請佛陀說法。太子(Jeta)被感動,也捐獻了林木。因此當時並稱為祇桓精舍。",
    
    "△ 二列在會聽眾。",
    
    "與大比丘眾千二百五十人俱。皆是無漏大阿羅漢。",
    
    "「大」有三種含義:一是數量多,二是名聲重,三是德行勝。「比丘」這裡翻譯也有三種含義:一是乞士(乞食為生的人),二是怖魔(能使魔恐懼的人),三是破惡(能破除惡行的人)。千二百五十人包括憍陳那(Kaundinya)等五人,舍利弗(Sariputta)和目犍連(Moggallana)師徒各一百人,三迦葉(Kasyapa)師徒一千人,耶舍(Yasa)長者五十人。只列舉五人,是舉其大數。「漏」有三種:一是無明,二是欲,三是有。「阿羅漢」也有三種翻譯:一是應供(應當接受供養的人),二是無生(不再輪迴的人),三是殺賊(殺死煩惱之賊的人)。二乘(聲聞乘和緣覺乘)的應供,只止於人天(人和天道);大乘的應供,通於世間和出世間。二乘的無生,只脫離分段生死;大乘的無生,並能脫離變易生死。二乘的殺賊,只窮盡四住地煩惱;大乘的殺賊,五住地煩惱永遠斷盡。然而這裡讚歎的聽眾,應當是大乘的阿羅漢。《涅槃經》四依法品中,第四種人被稱為阿羅漢,他們斷除各種煩惱,捨棄沉重的負擔,獲得……"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "It does not transcend the inherently pure self-nature of all sentient beings, which they themselves fail to perceive. Therefore, enlightenment is complete enlightenment, and practice is complete practice, from beginning to end, without falling into heretical or external paths. The *Śūraṅgama Sūtra* says: 'All sentient beings are already enlightened with complete awareness.' Knowing that they are all already enlightened, then they are not sentient beings; if they are not sentient beings, then there is nothing to be enlightened. What the *Tathagata* (Buddha) does is to directly take the present nature of sentient beings and make it conform to the truth that is neither right nor wrong. How can this be understood by *Śrāvakas* (Voice-Hearers) and *Pratyekabuddhas* (Solitary Buddhas)?",
    
    "△ The initial prologue is divided into two parts. The first part is the general convention for all sutras, which is divided into two parts. The first part describes the time and place.",
    
    "'Thus have I heard. At one time.'",
    
    "When the *Bhagavan* (World-Honored One, Buddha) was about to enter *Parinirvana* (final passing away), *Ananda* (one of the ten principal disciples of the Buddha) asked what words should be placed at the beginning of the sutra when compiling it. The *Bhagavan* said: 'It should be placed with 「Thus have I heard. At one time.」' Therefore, this became the common practice for sutras. 'Thus' refers to the sutra being spoken, 'I heard' means that *Ananda* personally heard it from the Buddha, and 'at one time' refers to the time when the sutra was being spoken.",
    
    "The Buddha was in the *Jetavana Vihara* (Jetavana Monastery, one of the earliest Buddhist monasteries) in *Śrāvastī* (an ancient city in India, meaning 'abundance of virtue').",
    
    "*Śrāvastī* in full is *Śrāvastī*, which means 'abundance of virtue'. This is because in this city, wealth, the five desires, learning, and liberation are all abundant. *Jeta* in full is *Jetavana*, also called *Jeta*, which means 'victorious'. When the prince of King *Prasenajit* (king of Kosala in ancient India) was born, it was at the time of victory, so he was named after it. *Vana* means forest. *Jetavana* was bought by *Anathapindika* (a wealthy merchant and a major patron of Buddhism) by covering the ground with gold, and a *vihara* (monastery) was built to invite the Buddha to preach. The prince (*Jeta*) was moved and also donated trees. Therefore, at that time, it was jointly called *Jetavana Vihara*.",
    
    "△ The second part lists the audience present.",
    
    "Together with a large *Sangha* (community) of 1,250 *bhikkhus* (monks), all of whom were *Arhats* (enlightened beings) free from outflows.",
    
    "'Large' has three meanings: one is a large number, two is a heavy reputation, and three is superior virtue. 'Bhikkhu' here also has three meanings: one is a mendicant (one who lives by begging), two is a terror to demons (one who can make demons fear), and three is a destroyer of evil (one who can destroy evil deeds). The 1,250 people include *Kaundinya* and the other five, *Sariputta* and *Moggallana* with 100 disciples each, the three *Kasyapas* with 1,000 disciples, and the elder *Yasa* with 50 people. Listing only five people is to give a large number. 'Outflows' have three types: one is ignorance, two is desire, and three is existence. 'Arhat' also has three translations: one is worthy of offerings (one who should receive offerings), two is unborn (one who is no longer reborn), and three is a slayer of thieves (one who kills the thieves of afflictions). The offerings of the Two Vehicles (*Śrāvakayāna* and *Pratyekabuddhayāna*) are limited to humans and gods; the offerings of the *Mahayana* (Great Vehicle) extend to both mundane and supramundane realms. The non-birth of the Two Vehicles only escapes from segmented birth and death; the non-birth of the *Mahayana* can also escape from variational birth and death. The slaying of thieves by the Two Vehicles only exhausts the four abodes of affliction; the slaying of thieves by the *Mahayana* completely eradicates the five abodes of affliction. However, the audience praised here should be *Arhats* of the *Mahayana*. In the fourth of the Four Reliances in the *Nirvana Sutra*, the fourth type of person is called an *Arhat*, who cuts off all afflictions, abandons heavy burdens, and obtains..."
  ]
}

己利。所作已辦。住第十地。

  佛子住持。善超諸有。

  從佛口生。從法化生。得佛法分。故云佛子。華嚴嘆眾。住一切菩薩智所住境。護持諸佛正法之輪。諸有欲有。色有。無色有。處於諸有。不為界系。故曰善超。

  能於國土成就威儀。從佛轉輪。妙堪遺囑。嚴凈毗尼。弘范三界。應身無量。度脫眾生。拔濟未來。越諸塵累。

  首二句。孤山云。隨剎現身。正容悟物。輪圓義。惟愨法師云。從佛受教。自證已圓。能演佛言。轉化群品。遺囑蒙鈔云。囑法令傳。囑生令度。毗尼此云律。律法也。法有輕重開遮持犯。所以調伏自他也。三界欲色無色。即此嚴凈。可為三界軌則。應身略有二。一大應。為十地菩薩。一隨類應。為十二類生。其數無量。此經為阿難啟教。度脫當時。實亦垂拔後世。使皆超諸塵累也。

  其名曰大智舍利弗。摩訶目犍連。摩訶拘絺羅。富樓那彌多羅尼子。須菩提。優波尼沙陀等。而為上首。

  舍利弗此云鹙子。母眼如鹙。因以為名。摩訶此云大。目犍連此云采菽氏。上古仙人。常食菉豆。母是彼種。從外立名。神通第一。摩訶拘絺羅。此云大膝。即長爪梵志。以一切不受為宗。問佛負墮。遂投出家。富樓那此云滿。父名。彌多羅尼此云慈。母名。連父母名。故云滿慈子。須菩提此云善吉。亦云空生。解空第一。優波尼沙陀此云塵性。因觀塵空得道故名。上首者為眾綱領也。

  復有無量辟支無學。並其初心。同來佛所。屬諸比丘休夏自恣。十方菩薩。咨決心疑。欽奉慈嚴

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "已經完成了應該做的事情,安住于第十地(菩薩修行果位的最高階段)。",
    
    "佛的弟子安住於此,能夠超越所有的存在形式(三有:欲有、色有、無色有)。",
    
    "他們從佛的教誨中誕生,從佛法的薰陶中化生,得到了佛法的一部分,所以被稱為佛子。如同《華嚴經》中所讚歎的大眾,安住於一切菩薩智慧所安住的境界,護持諸佛的正法之輪。雖然處於各種存在形式之中(欲有、色有、無色有),卻不被這些界限所束縛,所以說能夠善於超越。",
    
    "能夠在國土中成就威儀,依隨佛陀轉動法輪,能夠勝任遺囑重任,嚴謹清凈地持守毗尼(戒律),為三界樹立典範,應化之身無量無邊,度脫眾生,救拔未來的眾生,超越各種塵世的牽累。",
    
    "關於前兩句,孤山法師解釋說:『隨順不同的國土示現不同的身形,以端正的容貌使眾生覺悟。』『輪』有圓滿的含義。惟愨法師說:『從佛陀那裡接受教誨,自己證悟已經圓滿,能夠演說佛陀的語言,轉化各種眾生。』遺囑蒙鈔解釋說:『囑託法令得以流傳,囑託眾生得以度化。』毗尼,這裡指的是律,也就是律法。律法有輕重開遮持犯,所以能夠調伏自己和他人。三界指的是欲界、色界、無色界,嚴凈自身,可以成為三界的行爲準則。應化之身大致有兩種:一種是大應,為十地菩薩示現;一種是隨類應,為十二類眾生示現,其數量是無量的。這部經是阿難啟請佛陀宣說的,度脫了當時的眾生,實際上也是爲了救拔後世的眾生,使他們都能夠超越各種塵世的牽累。",
    
    "他們的名字是:大智舍利弗(智慧第一的佛陀十大弟子之一),摩訶目犍連(神通第一的佛陀十大弟子之一),摩訶拘絺羅(辯才第一的佛陀十大弟子之一),富樓那彌多羅尼子(說法第一的佛陀十大弟子之一),須菩提(解空第一的佛陀十大弟子之一),優波尼沙陀(佛陀弟子)等,他們是這些大眾的首領。",
    
    "舍利弗,這裡的意思是鹙子,因為他的母親的眼睛像鹙鳥,所以用這個來命名。摩訶,這裡的意思是『大』。目犍連,這裡的意思是采菽氏,上古時代的仙人,經常吃菉豆,他的母親是那個種族的人,所以從外貌來命名,他是神通第一。摩訶拘絺羅,這裡的意思是『大膝』,就是長爪梵志,以一切不受為宗旨,問佛陀問題而失敗,於是出家。富樓那,這裡的意思是『滿』,是他父親的名字。彌多羅尼,這裡的意思是『慈』,是他母親的名字。連用父母的名字,所以說是滿慈子。須菩提,這裡的意思是『善吉』,也叫『空生』,他是解空第一。優波尼沙陀,這裡的意思是『塵性』,因為觀察塵土的空性而得道,所以這樣命名。上首,就是大眾的綱領。",
    
    "還有無量的辟支佛(獨覺佛)和無學(阿羅漢,已證得最高果位者),以及初發心的修行者,一同來到佛陀的住所。正值眾比丘結束夏季安居進行自恣(僧眾互相指出過失)的時候,十方菩薩前來請教,決斷心中的疑惑,恭敬地接受佛陀的慈悲教誨。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "He has accomplished what needed to be done and dwells in the tenth Bhumi (the highest stage of Bodhisattva practice).",
    
    "The Buddha's disciples abide here, skillfully transcending all forms of existence (the three realms of existence: the desire realm, the form realm, and the formless realm).",
    
    "They are born from the Buddha's teachings, transformed by the Dharma, and have received a share of the Buddha's Dharma; therefore, they are called Buddha's children. Like the assembly praised in the Avatamsaka Sutra, they dwell in the realm where all Bodhisattva wisdom abides, protecting and upholding the Dharma wheel of all Buddhas. Although they are in various forms of existence (the desire realm, the form realm, and the formless realm), they are not bound by these limitations; therefore, it is said that they are skilled in transcending.",
    
    "They can establish dignified conduct in the land, follow the Buddha in turning the Dharma wheel, and are capable of fulfilling the Buddha's entrustment. They uphold the Vinaya (discipline) with purity and serve as models for the three realms. Their manifested bodies are countless, delivering sentient beings, rescuing future beings, and surpassing all worldly defilements.",
    
    "Regarding the first two lines, Master Gushan explains: 'They manifest different forms in accordance with different lands, using their upright appearance to awaken beings.' 'Wheel' has the meaning of completeness. Master Wei Que says: 'Having received teachings from the Buddha and personally realized completeness, they can expound the Buddha's words and transform various beings.' The commentary on the entrustment explains: 'Entrusting the Dharma so that it may be transmitted, entrusting beings so that they may be delivered.' Vinaya here refers to the precepts, which are the rules of conduct. The precepts have varying degrees of importance, allowing for opening, closing, upholding, and transgressing, so they can subdue both oneself and others. The three realms refer to the desire realm, the form realm, and the formless realm. By purifying themselves, they can become models for the three realms. There are roughly two types of manifested bodies: one is the great manifestation, appearing as a Bodhisattva of the tenth Bhumi; the other is the manifestation according to the type of being, appearing for the twelve types of beings, and their number is countless. This sutra was spoken by the Buddha at the request of Ananda, delivering beings at that time and also rescuing future beings, enabling them to transcend all worldly defilements.",
    
    "Their names are: Great Wisdom Shariputra (one of the ten great disciples of the Buddha, known for his wisdom), Maha Maudgalyayana (one of the ten great disciples of the Buddha, known for his supernatural powers), Maha Kaushtilya (one of the ten great disciples of the Buddha, known for his eloquence), Purna Maitrayaniputra (one of the ten great disciples of the Buddha, known for his skill in preaching), Subhuti (one of the ten great disciples of the Buddha, known for his understanding of emptiness), Upanishada (a disciple of the Buddha), and others, who are the leaders of this assembly.",
    
    "Shariputra here means 'son of a heron,' because his mother's eyes resembled a heron's eyes, so he was named after that. Maha here means 'great.' Maudgalyayana here means 'descendant of the bean-picker,' an ancient immortal who often ate green beans. His mother was from that lineage, so he was named after his appearance. He was the foremost in supernatural powers. Maha Kaushtilya here means 'great knee,' referring to the ascetic with long fingernails, who held the view of non-acceptance of everything. He questioned the Buddha and failed, so he became a monk. Purna here means 'full,' which was his father's name. Maitrayani here means 'compassionate,' which was his mother's name. Combining the names of his parents, he is called Purna Maitrayaniputra. Subhuti here means 'good fortune,' also called 'born of emptiness,' and he was the foremost in understanding emptiness. Upanishada here means 'nature of dust,' because he attained enlightenment by observing the emptiness of dust, so he was named that. The leader is the head of the assembly.",
    
    "There are also countless Pratyekabuddhas (Solitary Buddhas) and Arhats (those who have attained the highest stage of liberation, beyond learning), as well as practitioners who have just begun their practice, all coming to the Buddha's residence. It was the time when the Bhikshus (monks) were ending their summer retreat and performing the Pravarana (self-surrender ceremony, where monks point out each other's faults), and Bodhisattvas from the ten directions came to inquire and resolve their doubts, respectfully receiving the Buddha's compassionate teachings."
  ]
}

。將求密義。即時如來敷座宴安。為諸會中宣示深奧。法筵清眾。得未曾有。迦陵仙音。遍十方界。恒沙菩薩。來聚道場。文殊師利。而為上首。

  辟支一翻獨覺。出無佛世。寂居觀化而得悟者。一翻緣覺。出有佛世。奉佛指教。觀十二因緣而得道者。無學果滿取證。不復前進。聲聞有學。未至無學。皆云初心。新發意菩薩。信滿入住。亦云初心。屬當也。四月十六日夏安居。至七月十五日安居竟。曰休夏。九旬中所有疑問。自過不知。一任僧舉。曰自恣。菩薩具云菩提薩埵。此云覺有情。又菩提翻無上智慧。埵翻大心眾生。迦陵具云迦陵頻伽。仙鳥名。其音和雅。喻佛音也。文殊師利亦云曼殊室利。此云妙吉祥。又云妙德。文殊表根本智。具擇法眼。經中屢出。

  上初諸經通例竟。

  △二本經緣起。分四。初匿王請佛。

  時波斯匿王為其父王諱日營齋。請佛宮掖。自迎如來。廣設珍羞無上妙味。兼復親延諸大菩薩。城中復有長者居士。同時飯僧。佇佛來應。佛敕文殊。分領菩薩及阿羅漢應諸齋主。

  波斯匿此云勝軍。舍衛國王也。諱忌也。即先王昔年崩日。正當僧自恣。宮掖內庭也。長者德財俱備之稱。居士守道寡慾之號。

  △二阿難循乞被攝。

  唯有阿難先受別請。遠遊未還。不遑僧次。既無上座及阿阇黎。途中獨歸。其日無供。即時阿難執持應器。于所游城次第循乞。心中初求最後檀越以為齋主。無問凈穢剎利尊姓及旃陀羅。方行等慈。不擇微賤。發意圓成一切眾生無量功德。阿難已知

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "爲了探求深奧的密義,如來隨即鋪設座位,安詳入座,為法會中的大眾宣講精深玄妙的佛法。法會的清凈大眾,聽聞后都感到前所未有。迦陵頻伽(仙鳥名,其音和雅,喻佛音)的聲音,傳遍十方世界。無量無數的菩薩,都來到道場聚集。文殊師利(此云妙吉祥,又云妙德。文殊表根本智,具擇法眼)作為這些菩薩的首領。",
    
    "辟支佛,意為獨覺,出現在沒有佛陀住世的時代,獨自寂靜地觀察世間變化而證悟。又譯為緣覺,出現在有佛陀住世的時代,奉行佛陀的教導,觀察十二因緣而得道。阿羅漢是無學果位的圓滿證悟者,不再繼續前進。聲聞乘中的有學之人,尚未達到無學果位,都可稱為初心。新發菩提心的菩薩,信根圓滿入住正位,也可稱為初心。四月十六日開始夏季安居,到七月十五日安居結束,稱為休夏。九十天安居期間,如果有什麼疑問,自己無法解決,就由僧眾來評判,稱為自恣。菩薩,具稱為菩提薩埵(此云覺有情。又菩提翻無上智慧。埵翻大心眾生)。迦陵頻伽(仙鳥名。其音和雅。喻佛音也)。文殊師利(亦云曼殊室利。此云妙吉祥。又云妙德。文殊表根本智。具擇法眼。經中屢出)。",
    
    "以上是諸經通用的慣例。",
    
    "下面是本經的緣起,分為四個部分。首先是波斯匿王(此云勝軍。舍衛國王也)請佛。",
    
    "當時,波斯匿王爲了紀念他父親的忌日(諱忌也。即先王昔年崩日。正當僧自恣),在王宮內(宮掖內庭也)設齋供養,親自迎接如來,廣備各種珍貴的美味佳餚,並親自邀請諸大菩薩。城中還有一些長者(德財俱備之稱)和居士(守道寡慾之號),也同時設齋飯僧,等待佛陀前來應供。佛陀便敕令文殊師利,分領諸位菩薩和阿羅漢前去應諸位齋主的邀請。",
    
    "第二部分是阿難(尊者名)循例乞食卻被攝入淫舍。",
    
    "只有阿難因為事先接受了其他的邀請,遠遊在外尚未返回,錯過了僧眾依次接受供養的機會。因為沒有上座和阿阇黎帶領,便獨自返回。那天沒有得到供養,阿難便拿著缽,在所經過的城中依次乞食,心中首先希望能夠找到一位最後的施主作為齋主。他不問對方是乾淨還是污穢,是剎帝利(印度四大種姓之一,指武士和王族)貴族還是旃陀羅(印度最低等級的賤民),平等地施行慈悲,不選擇卑微低賤的人,發願圓滿一切眾生的無量功德。阿難已經知道"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Seeking to understand the profound esoteric meaning, the Tathagata (another name for Buddha) immediately arranged his seat and sat down peacefully, expounding the deep and mysterious Dharma (Buddhist teachings) to the assembly. The pure assembly at the Dharma gathering felt unprecedented joy. The sound of the Kalavinka (a mythical bird with a beautiful voice, symbolizing the Buddha's voice) resonated throughout the ten directions. Countless Bodhisattvas (enlightened beings) gathered at the Bodhimanda (place of enlightenment). Manjushri (meaning 'Wonderful Auspiciousness' or 'Wonderful Virtue', representing fundamental wisdom and the eye of discernment) was their leader.",
    
    "Pratyekabuddha (Solitary Buddha), meaning 'one who awakens alone,' appears in times without a Buddha, quietly observing the world and attaining enlightenment. Also translated as 'Enlightened by Conditions,' appearing in times with a Buddha, following the Buddha's teachings, and attaining the Way by observing the Twelve Links of Dependent Origination. Arhats (enlightened disciples) are those who have fully attained the fruit of No-More-Learning, no longer progressing further. Those in the Sravaka (Disciple) vehicle who are still learning, not yet having reached the state of No-More-Learning, can all be called beginners. Newly aspiring Bodhisattvas, with full faith and entering the position, can also be called beginners. The summer retreat begins on the sixteenth day of the fourth month and ends on the fifteenth day of the seventh month, called the end of summer. During the ninety-day retreat, any questions that one cannot resolve oneself are judged by the Sangha (Buddhist community), called Pravarana (self-surrender). Bodhisattva, fully called Bodhisattva (meaning 'sentient being seeking enlightenment'. Bodhi means 'supreme wisdom', and sattva means 'great-minded being'). Kalavinka (a mythical bird with a beautiful voice, symbolizing the Buddha's voice). Manjushri (also called Manjusri, meaning 'Wonderful Auspiciousness' or 'Wonderful Virtue', representing fundamental wisdom and the eye of discernment, frequently appearing in the sutras).",
    
    "The above is the common practice for all sutras.",
    
    "The following is the origin of this sutra, divided into four parts. First, King Prasenajit (meaning 'Victorious Army', the king of Sravasti) invites the Buddha.",
    
    "At that time, King Prasenajit, to commemorate the anniversary of his father's death (a taboo subject, referring to the day the former king passed away, coinciding with the Sangha's Pravarana), prepared a vegetarian feast in the palace (the inner court of the palace), personally welcoming the Tathagata, preparing various precious and delicious delicacies, and personally inviting the great Bodhisattvas. Some elders (those with both virtue and wealth) and lay practitioners (those who uphold the Way and have few desires) in the city also prepared vegetarian feasts for the Sangha, waiting for the Buddha to come and accept their offerings. The Buddha then instructed Manjushri to lead the Bodhisattvas and Arhats to respond to the invitations of the various patrons.",
    
    "The second part is Ananda (name of a disciple) following the practice of begging for alms but being drawn into a house of prostitution.",
    
    "Only Ananda, having previously accepted another invitation, was traveling far away and had not yet returned, missing the opportunity for the Sangha to receive offerings in order. Because there was no senior monk or Acharya (teacher) to lead him, he returned alone. Having not received any offerings that day, Ananda took his bowl and begged for alms in the city he was passing through, hoping to find a final benefactor to be the host of a meal. He did not ask whether the person was clean or unclean, whether they were Kshatriya (one of the four castes in India, referring to warriors and royalty) nobles or Chandala (the lowest caste in India), practicing equal compassion, not choosing those who were humble and lowly, vowing to perfect the immeasurable merits of all sentient beings. Ananda already knew"
  ]
}

如來世尊訶須菩提及大迦葉。為阿羅漢。心不均平。欽仰如來開闡無遮。度諸疑謗。經彼城隍。徐步郭門。嚴整威儀。肅恭齋法。爾時阿難因乞食次。經歷淫室。遭大幻術摩登伽女。以娑毗迦羅先梵天咒攝入淫席。淫躬撫摩。將毀戒體。

  阿難此云慶喜。佛成道曰。適斛飯王忽報生兒。凈飯王以此賜名。不遑僧次謂不在赴齋之列也。先於巳夏為上座。阿阇黎此云軌範。律制僧出。必從二師。此伏誤墮之由。缽多羅此云應量器。唯瓦與鐵。體量合法。檀越此云施主。從無善心行施者。謂之最後。剎利此云田主。劫初時。人食粳米。各為封殖。推有德者以為處分。此王者之始。旃陀羅此云殺者。即屠膾。所謂無問凈穢也。迦葉此云飲光氏。須菩提舍貧乞富。大迦葉舍富乞貧。均為如來所訶。謂偏貧多疑。偏富多謗也。城之濠塹曰隍。比丘辰巳應供。名為齋者。與眾生接。不得不齋。摩登伽此云本性。后出家稱性比丘尼。從昔號也。娑毗迦羅此云金頭。苦行外道。師事梵天而得此咒。聲聞無作戒體。從白四羯磨時發。屬意。意變即毀。將者未然之辭。

  △三敕文殊將咒往護。

  如來知彼淫術所加。齋畢旋歸。王及大臣。長者居士。俱來隨佛。愿聞法要。於時世尊頂放百寶無畏光明。光中出生千葉寶蓮。有佛化身。結跏趺坐。宣說神咒。敕文殊師利將咒往護。惡咒銷滅。提獎阿難及摩登伽歸來佛所。

  如來不自宣說。而以頂光化佛說者。示一切神通。皆智用上事。而於無相體中不動不搖。默寓眾生迷事。枉受驅馳。而於自

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "如來世尊呵斥須菩提(Subhuti,空行第一)和大迦葉(Mahakasyapa,頭陀第一),因為他們作為阿羅漢,心懷不均,不能平等對待眾生,只是欽佩如來開示闡明的無遮大愛,以此來度化那些心懷疑惑和誹謗的人。阿難(Ananda,多聞第一)在城外乞食時,沿著城墻緩緩走過城門,儀容莊嚴整肅,內心肅穆恭敬地遵守齋戒之法。當時,阿難在乞食的途中,經過一間淫室,遭遇了大幻術的摩登伽女(Matanggi,本性),摩登伽女用娑毗迦羅(Sabhikara,金頭)先梵天咒將阿難攝入淫席,用淫慾的身體撫摩他,即將毀壞他的戒體。",
    
    "阿難,意為『慶喜』。在佛陀成道之日,凈飯王(Suddhodana)突然稟報生了一個兒子,凈飯王因此賜名。阿難不遑僧次,意為不在赴齋之列。阿難先於巳夏成為上座,阿阇黎(Acarya,軌範)意為『軌範』,律制僧人外出,必須跟隨兩位老師,這暗示了阿難誤入歧途的原因。缽多羅(Patra,應量器)意為『應量器』,只有瓦和鐵兩種材質,體量符合法度。檀越(Danapati,施主)意為『施主』,從沒有善心卻行佈施的人,被稱為『最後』。剎利(Ksatriya,田主)意為『田主』,劫初之時,人們食用粳米,各自為土地封界種植,推舉有德之人來處理分配,這是王者的開始。旃陀羅(Candala,殺者)意為『殺者』,即屠夫,指不問凈穢之人。迦葉(Kasyapa,飲光氏),須菩提捨棄貧窮而乞求富貴,大迦葉捨棄富貴而乞求貧窮,都被如來呵斥,認為偏向貧窮的人多疑,偏向富貴的人多誹謗。城的護城河叫做『隍』。比丘在辰時和巳時應供,稱為『齋』,與眾生結緣,不得不齋戒。摩登伽意為『本性』,後來出家被稱為性比丘尼,沿用以前的稱號。娑毗迦羅意為『金頭』,是苦行外道,師事梵天而得到這個咒語。聲聞的無作戒體,從白四羯磨時生髮,屬於意念。意念改變,戒體就會被毀壞,『將』是未然的說法。",
    
    "如來知道阿難被淫術所加害,齋戒完畢后立即返回。國王以及大臣、長者、居士,都跟隨佛陀,希望聽聞佛法要義。這時,世尊從頭頂放出百寶無畏光明,光明中生出一千葉寶蓮,寶蓮上有佛的化身,結跏趺坐,宣說神咒。佛陀敕令文殊師利(Manjusri,大智)菩薩將神咒送去護持阿難,使惡咒消滅,並提攜阿難和摩登伽女回到佛陀的住所。",
    
    "如來不親自宣說,而是用頂光化佛來說,是爲了顯示一切神通都是智慧的運用,並且在無相的本體中不動不搖,默默地寓意眾生迷戀于外在事物,枉自奔波勞碌,卻不能在自身中找到解脫。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "The Tathagata (Thus Come One), the World-Honored One, rebuked Subhuti (Subhuti, foremost in understanding emptiness) and Mahakasyapa (Mahakasyapa, foremost in ascetic practices) because, as Arhats (worthy ones), their minds were not impartial. They admired the Tathagata's (Thus Come One) open and unobstructed teachings, using them to liberate those with doubts and slanders. Ananda (Ananda, foremost in hearing the Dharma), while begging for food outside the city, slowly walked along the city walls towards the gate, his demeanor solemn and dignified, his heart reverently observing the monastic rules of fasting. At that time, Ananda, while on his alms round, passed by a brothel and encountered Matanggi (Matanggi, the essence), a woman with great illusory powers. Matanggi used the Sabhikara (Sabhikara, golden head) pre-Brahma mantra to draw Ananda into the brothel, caressing him with her lustful body, on the verge of destroying his precepts.",
    
    "Ananda means 'Joyful.' On the day of the Buddha's enlightenment, King Suddhodana (Suddhodana) suddenly reported the birth of a son, and King Suddhodana gave him this name. Ananda did not prioritize the monastic order, meaning he was not on the list for the meal. Ananda became a senior monk before the summer retreat. Acarya (Acarya, model) means 'model.' Monastic rules stipulate that monks must be accompanied by two teachers when going out, which hints at the reason for Ananda's straying. Patra (Patra, appropriate vessel) means 'appropriate vessel,' made only of clay or iron, with a volume that conforms to the rules. Danapati (Danapati, donor) means 'donor.' Those who give alms without good intentions are called 'last.' Ksatriya (Ksatriya, lord of the fields) means 'lord of the fields.' At the beginning of the kalpa (eon), people ate japonica rice, each cultivating their own land, and they elected virtuous people to manage and distribute it. This was the beginning of kings. Candala (Candala, killer) means 'killer,' i.e., butchers, referring to those who do not discriminate between clean and unclean. Kasyapa (Kasyapa, drinker of light), Subhuti abandoned poverty to beg for wealth, and Mahakasyapa abandoned wealth to beg for poverty, both of whom were rebuked by the Tathagata (Thus Come One), who believed that those who leaned towards poverty were more suspicious, and those who leaned towards wealth were more slanderous. The moat of a city is called 'huang.' Bhikkhus (monks) should offer food at the hours of chen and si, called 'zhai,' to connect with sentient beings, and they must fast. Matanggi means 'essence,' and later she became a nun called 'Sex Bhikkhuni,' using her former name. Sabhikara means 'golden head,' a heretic who practiced asceticism and obtained this mantra from Brahma. The uncreated precepts of the Sravakas (hearers) arise from the white four karmas, belonging to the mind. If the mind changes, the precepts will be destroyed. 'Jiang' is a statement of what is not yet certain.",
    
    "The Tathagata (Thus Come One), knowing that Ananda was being harmed by the lustful magic, immediately returned after the meal. The king, ministers, elders, and laypeople all followed the Buddha, hoping to hear the essence of the Dharma. At that time, the World-Honored One emitted a hundred-jeweled fearless light from the crown of his head. From the light emerged a thousand-petaled treasure lotus, and on the lotus was a manifestation of the Buddha, sitting in the lotus position, proclaiming a divine mantra. The Buddha ordered Manjusri (Manjusri, great wisdom) Bodhisattva to take the divine mantra to protect Ananda, so that the evil mantra would be destroyed, and to bring Ananda and Matanggi back to the Buddha's residence.",
    
    "The Tathagata (Thus Come One) did not proclaim it himself, but used the Buddha manifested from the light of his crown to speak, in order to show that all supernatural powers are the application of wisdom, and that he remains unmoving and unshaken in the formless essence, silently implying that sentient beings are deluded by external things, vainly running around busily, and cannot find liberation within themselves."
  ]
}

性亦無得失。一回覺悟。復還本有也。文殊表根本智。以根本智慧伏邪外。故敕往護。

  △四阿難悲恨請修。

  阿難見佛頂禮悲泣。恨無始來一向多聞。未全道力。慇勤啟請十方如來得成菩提。妙奢摩他三摩禪那最初方便。於時復有恒沙菩薩。及諸十方大阿羅漢辟支佛等。俱愿樂聞。退坐默然。承受聖旨。

  世尊嘗云。我與阿難於空王佛所。發菩提心。阿難常樂多聞。而我常勤精進。故知空聞不如實證也。奢摩他此云寂靜。三摩此云觀照。禪那此云寂照不二。

  總言則首楞嚴。分言則奢摩他三摩禪那也。蓋由常住真心。常寂常照。寂照無二。即涅槃所謂定慧均等耳。聲聞定多慧少。故不見佛性。十住菩薩慧多定少。故少見佛性。以此而知佛性之為定慧均等。常住真心之為寂照無二。當無二揆也。孤山嘗以天臺三觀配之。覺范稍別。亦同此意。不與下文常住真心相符。此經指根性之迷。以復還性覺本有寂照。似與純用功勛者不可同日而語。天如補註依前釋。當爲確論也。

  上初序分竟。

  △二正宗分。分四。初直示圓悟。分十二。初徴心。分八。初標常住流轉之由。分四。初審發心。

  佛告阿難。汝我同氣。情均天倫。當初發心。於我法中。見何勝相。頓舍世間深重恩愛。阿難白佛。我見如來三十二相。勝妙殊絕。形體映徹。猶如琉璃。常自思惟。此相非是欲愛所生。何以故。欲氣粗濁。腥臊交遘。膿血雜亂。不能發生勝凈妙明紫金光聚。是以渴仰從佛剃落。

  佛出凈飯王。阿難出斛飯王

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "『性』(自性)也無所謂得失。一旦覺悟,就恢復到原本的狀態。文殊菩薩代表根本智,用根本智來降伏邪惡外道,所以佛敕令他前去護持。",
    
    "△四、阿難悲傷悔恨,請求修習。",
    
    "阿難見到佛,頂禮膜拜,悲傷哭泣,悔恨自己從無始以來只是一味地多聞,沒有完全證得道力。他殷切地請求佛開示十方如來得以成就菩提的『妙奢摩他』(止)、『三摩禪那』(觀)最初的方便法門。當時還有無數的菩薩,以及十方的大阿羅漢、辟支佛等,都願意聽聞,退回座位,默默地承受佛的聖旨。",
    
    "世尊曾經說過,『我』(釋迦牟尼佛)與阿難在空王佛那裡,發菩提心。阿難常常喜歡多聞,而『我』常常勤奮精進。所以知道空洞的聽聞不如真實的證悟。『奢摩他』,這裡翻譯為寂靜(止)。『三摩』,這裡翻譯為觀照(觀)。『禪那』,這裡翻譯為寂照不二(止觀雙運)。",
    
    "總的來說就是『首楞嚴』,分開來說就是『奢摩他』、『三摩』、『禪那』。大概是因為常住真心,常寂常照,寂照無二,就是涅槃所說的定慧均等。聲聞乘的人定多慧少,所以不見佛性。十住位的菩薩慧多定少,所以少見佛性。由此可知佛性是定慧均等,常住真心是寂照無二,應當沒有第二個準則。孤山法師曾經用天臺宗的三觀來配合解釋,覺范禪師稍有不同,但也是這個意思。與下文的常住真心不相符。這部經是指根性的迷失,從而恢復到自性覺悟本有的寂照,似乎與純粹依靠功勛的人不能相提並論。天如禪師的補註依照前面的解釋,應當是確切的論斷。",
    
    "以上是初序分結束。",
    
    "△二、正宗分。分為四個部分。首先,直接開示圓滿覺悟。分為十二個小部分。首先,徵詢真心。分為八個小部分。首先,標明常住和流轉的原因。分為四個小部分。首先,審問發心。",
    
    "佛告訴阿難,『你』(阿難)和『我』(釋迦牟尼佛)是同胞兄弟,情誼如同天倫。當初發心,在『我』(釋迦牟尼佛)的佛法中,看到什麼殊勝的相,能夠立刻捨棄世間深重的恩愛?阿難回答佛說,『我』(阿難)看到如來有三十二相,殊勝美妙,形體晶瑩剔透,猶如琉璃。常常自己思惟,這些相不是由欲愛所生。為什麼呢?因為欲愛的氣息粗濁,腥臭污穢交雜,膿血混濁雜亂,不能夠產生殊勝清凈美妙光明的紫金光聚。因此渴求仰慕,跟隨佛剃度出家。",
    
    "佛出自凈飯王(Śuddhodana),阿難出自斛飯王"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "'性' (Nature) has neither gain nor loss. Once enlightened, one returns to the original state. Mañjuśrī (文殊) represents fundamental wisdom, using it to subdue evil and heretical paths, hence the Buddha ordered him to protect.",
    
    "△4. Ānanda's (阿難) sorrow and regret, requesting cultivation.",
    
    "Ānanda, seeing the Buddha, prostrated and wept with sorrow, regretting that from beginningless time he had only been focused on extensive learning, without fully realizing the power of the Path. He earnestly requested the Buddha to reveal the initial expedient methods of 'sublime Śamatha' (奢摩他, cessation), 'Samāpatti-dhyāna' (三摩禪那, contemplation), by which the Tathāgatas of the ten directions attain Bodhi. At that time, countless Bodhisattvas, as well as great Arhats and Pratyekabuddhas from the ten directions, all wished to hear and retreated to their seats, silently receiving the Holy Edict.",
    
    "The World-Honored One once said, 'I' (Śākyamuni Buddha, 釋迦牟尼佛) and Ānanda generated the Bodhi mind at the place of the Empty King Buddha. Ānanda often delighted in extensive learning, while 'I' often diligently practiced. Therefore, it is known that empty hearing is not as good as actual realization. 'Śamatha' is translated here as tranquility (cessation). 'Samāpatti' is translated here as contemplation (observation). 'Dhyāna' is translated here as the non-duality of tranquility and contemplation (cessation and observation in unison).",
    
    "Generally speaking, it is the 'Śūraṅgama' (首楞嚴), and separately speaking, it is 'Śamatha', 'Samāpatti', and 'Dhyāna'. It is probably because the permanent true mind is always tranquil and always illuminating, and tranquility and illumination are non-dual, which is what Nirvāṇa calls the equality of Samādhi and Prajñā. Those of the Śrāvaka vehicle have more Samādhi and less Prajñā, so they do not see the Buddha-nature. Bodhisattvas in the Ten Abodes have more Prajñā and less Samādhi, so they see little of the Buddha-nature. From this, it can be known that the Buddha-nature is the equality of Samādhi and Prajñā, and the permanent true mind is the non-duality of tranquility and illumination, and there should be no second standard. Master Gushan (孤山) once used the Three Contemplations of the Tiantai school to match and explain it, and Chan Master Juefan (覺范) was slightly different, but also had this meaning. It does not match the permanent true mind in the following text. This sutra refers to the delusion of the root nature, thereby restoring the inherent tranquility and illumination of the self-awakened nature, and it seems that it cannot be mentioned in the same breath as those who rely purely on meritorious deeds. Chan Master Tianru's (天如) supplementary notes follow the previous explanation, which should be an accurate judgment.",
    
    "The above is the end of the initial preface section.",
    
    "△2. The main teaching section. Divided into four parts. First, directly revealing perfect enlightenment. Divided into twelve subsections. First, inquiring about the true mind. Divided into eight subsections. First, indicating the cause of permanence and impermanence. Divided into four subsections. First, examining the initial aspiration.",
    
    "The Buddha told Ānanda, 'You' (Ānanda) and 'I' (Śākyamuni Buddha) are siblings, and our affection is like that of family. When you first aspired, in 'my' (Śākyamuni Buddha) Dharma, what excellent aspect did you see that you were able to immediately abandon the deep and heavy love of the world?' Ānanda replied to the Buddha, 'I' (Ānanda) saw that the Tathāgata has thirty-two marks, which are excellent and wonderful, and the form is crystal clear, like lapis lazuli. I often think to myself that these marks are not born of lustful love. Why? Because the breath of lustful love is coarse and turbid, with a foul and filthy mixture, and a chaotic mess of pus and blood, unable to produce the supreme, pure, wonderful, and bright purple-gold light cluster. Therefore, I thirst and yearn, and follow the Buddha to shave my head and leave home.",
    
    "The Buddha came from King Śuddhodana (凈飯王), and Ānanda came from King Huhuafan (斛飯王)."
  ]
}

。凈斛同生。亦稱同氣。兄弟天倫也。詰心詰見。以為下文徴勘。我見如來三十二相者。答見也。常自思惟者。答心也。如來相好。自足安平。以至頂相。共三十二。

  △二分真妄。

  佛言。善哉阿難。汝等當知一切眾生。從無始來。生死相續。皆由不知常住真心性凈明體。用諸妄想。此想不真。故有輪轉。

  性之覺了曰心。心之湛圓曰性。不知者心性無體。隨順不覺。此原迷真之故也。迷則隨境分別而不自知。故有輪轉。是稱為妄。約真妄之由。蓋欲指真心之所露唯根。妄心之相續唯識。故下文徴心。先窮分別之妄。后示見性之真。若從見性而悟藏心之無分別。始知分別全真。輪轉非妄耳。

  迷常住真心而為妄想。故終日住妄想。而不知為常住真心。涅槃所謂佛性流轉五道也。今現在流轉。而誤以妄想為真心者。應觀生死相續。在於何處。圓覺云。未出輪迴。而辨圓覺。彼圓覺性。即同流轉。曹溪云。前念不生是心。后念不滅是佛。故知唸唸生滅之非佛心。尚在輪迴之非圓覺。妄想有性。更須知真智無體。一回決了。正未可儱侗真常耳。

  △三敕直心。

  汝今欲研無上菩提真發明性。應當直心酬我所問。十方如來同一道故。出離生死。皆以直心。心言直故。如是乃至終始地位中間永無諸委曲相。

  無上菩提即十方如來無上正等正覺。然皆發明真性而得成就。故先標此。肇公云。直心者謂內心真直。外無虛假。賢首云。向理之心。無別岐路也。發心為始。究竟為終。于其中間。絕諸岐路。

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "凈斛同生,也稱為同氣,指的是兄弟之間的天倫之情。』詰心詰見』,是爲了下文的征問勘驗做準備。』我見如來三十二相者』,回答的是』見』(視覺)。』常自思惟者』,回答的是』心』(思維)。如來的相好莊嚴,自身就已圓滿安寧,一直到頂相,總共有三十二種。",
    
    "△二、分辨真妄",
    
    "佛說:』善哉,阿難!你們應當知道,一切眾生,從無始以來,生死相續不斷,都是因為不知道常住真心(永恒不變的真實本性)性凈明體(清凈光明的本體),而使用了各種虛妄的念頭。這些念頭不是真實的,所以才會有輪迴轉動。』",
    
    "性的覺悟明瞭叫做』心』,心的澄澈圓滿叫做』性』。』不知』,指的是心性沒有本體,隨順於不覺的狀態。這是迷惑真性的原因。迷惑就會隨著外境而分別,卻不自知,所以才會有輪迴轉動。這被稱為』妄』。從真妄的由來來說,大概是要指出真心所顯露的唯有根(六根),妄心所相續的唯有識(六識)。所以下文征問心,先窮究分別的虛妄,后顯示見性的真實。如果從見性而悟到藏心(阿賴耶識)的無分別,才能知道分別全是真,輪迴並非妄。",
    
    "因為迷惑了常住真心而產生了妄想,所以終日住在妄想之中,卻不知道這就是常住真心。《涅槃經》所說的佛性流轉五道,就是這個意思。現在正在流轉,卻錯誤地把妄想當作真心的人,應當觀察生死相續,究竟在哪裡。《圓覺經》說:』未出輪迴,而辨圓覺,彼圓覺性,即同流轉。』曹溪(六祖慧能)說:』前念不生是心,后念不滅是佛。』所以要知道,唸唸生滅的不是佛心,還在輪迴中的不是圓覺。妄想有其自性,更要知道真智沒有實體。一旦徹底明白了,才不會含糊地認為真常是隨便說說而已。",
    
    "△三、敕令直心",
    
    "』你現在想要研究無上菩提(無上的覺悟),真正地發明本性,就應當以直心來回答我所問的問題。十方如來都是同一條道路,出離生死,都是依靠直心。因為心和言語都是正直的,這樣乃至從開始到最終的地位,中間永遠沒有各種委曲相。』",
    
    "無上菩提就是十方如來無上正等正覺。然而都是因為發明真性而得到成就,所以先標明這一點。肇公(僧肇)說:』直心,就是內心真正正直,外表沒有虛假。』賢首(法藏)說:』嚮往真理的心,沒有別的岔路。』發心是開始,究竟是最終,在其中間,斷絕各種岔路。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "'Jing Hu Tong Sheng' (Pure Calabash Together Born), also known as 'Tong Qi' (Sharing the Same Qi), refers to the natural bond between brothers. 'Jie Xin Jie Jian' (Questioning the Mind and Questioning the View) is in preparation for the questioning and examination in the following text. 'I see the Tathagata's Thirty-Two Marks' answers the question of 'seeing' (vision). 'Constantly contemplating' answers the question of 'mind' (thought). The Tathagata's excellent marks and characteristics are complete and peaceful in themselves, up to the crown of the head, totaling thirty-two.",
    
    "△ 2. Distinguishing Truth from Falsehood",
    
    "The Buddha said: 'Excellent, Ananda! You should know that all sentient beings, from beginningless time, continue in the cycle of birth and death because they do not know the constantly abiding true mind (eternal and unchanging true nature), the pure and bright essence of their nature (pure and luminous essence), and instead use various false thoughts. These thoughts are not true, so there is the cycle of reincarnation.'",
    
    "The awakening and understanding of nature is called 'mind,' and the clarity and perfection of mind is called 'nature.' 'Not knowing' refers to the mind and nature having no substance, following unawareness. This is the reason for being deluded about the true nature. Being deluded leads to distinguishing based on external circumstances without self-awareness, so there is the cycle of reincarnation. This is called 'falsehood.' In terms of the origin of truth and falsehood, it is probably meant to point out that the only thing revealed by the true mind is the root (the six roots), and the only thing that continues in the false mind is the consciousness (the six consciousnesses). Therefore, the following text questions the mind, first thoroughly investigating the falsehood of discrimination, and then showing the truth of seeing the nature. If one awakens to the non-discrimination of the hidden mind (Alaya consciousness) from seeing the nature, then one can know that all discrimination is true, and reincarnation is not false.",
    
    "Because of being deluded about the constantly abiding true mind, false thoughts arise, so one dwells in false thoughts all day long, without knowing that this is the constantly abiding true mind. The Nirvana Sutra says that the Buddha-nature flows through the five paths, which is what this means. Those who are currently flowing through the cycle but mistakenly take false thoughts as the true mind should observe where the cycle of birth and death is located. The Yuanjue Sutra says: 'Without leaving the cycle of reincarnation, one discusses perfect enlightenment; that nature of perfect enlightenment is the same as flowing through the cycle.' Caoxi (Huineng, the Sixth Patriarch) said: 'The thought that does not arise before is the mind; the thought that does not cease after is the Buddha.' Therefore, know that the thoughts that arise and cease are not the Buddha-mind, and what is still in the cycle of reincarnation is not perfect enlightenment. False thoughts have their own nature, and one should also know that true wisdom has no substance. Once one thoroughly understands, one will not vaguely think that true constancy is just casual talk.",
    
    "△ 3. Command to Have a Straightforward Mind",
    
    "'Now that you want to study Anuttara-Samyak-Sambodhi (unsurpassed enlightenment), truly discover the nature, you should answer my questions with a straightforward mind. All the Tathagatas of the ten directions follow the same path, and they all rely on a straightforward mind to escape birth and death. Because the mind and words are upright, there will never be any crookedness from beginning to end.'",
    
    "Anuttara-Samyak-Sambodhi is the unsurpassed perfect enlightenment of the Tathagatas of the ten directions. However, they all attain it by discovering their true nature, so this is stated first. Zhao Gong (Sengzhao) said: 'A straightforward mind is a mind that is truly upright inside and has no falsehood on the outside.' Xianshou (Fazang) said: 'The mind that yearns for truth has no other forks in the road.' Arousing the mind is the beginning, and ultimate attainment is the end. In between, all forks in the road are cut off."
  ]
}

  眾生日用。全身是妄。故如來特於現前提出直心。要在酬答中分明吐露。故下文得其由目觀見。心生愛樂。遂乃七處徴窮。至於情枯智竭。然後反之能推。目前雖未究竟。亦自可因其所明以通其暗也。今人觀此。盡謂能推之非我心。離塵之有全性。而不知冥心獨照。猶為內守幽閑。移時失候。仍是離塵無體。執自所見。附會聖言。其為心言不直。豈可勝言。故知如來最初丁寧之非無旨也。

  △四徴心目。

  阿難。我今問汝。當汝發心緣于如來三十二相。將何所見。誰為愛樂。阿難白佛言。世尊。如是愛樂。用我心目。由目觀見如來勝相。心生愛樂。故我發心愿捨生死。佛告阿難。如汝所說。真所愛樂。因於心目。若不識知心目所在。則不能得降伏塵勞。譬如國王為賊所侵。發兵討除。是兵要當知賊所在。使汝流轉。心目為咎。吾今問汝。唯心與目。今何所在。

  將何所見者。審見也。誰為愛樂者。審心也。如是愛樂用我心目者。總答心目也。由目觀見心生愛樂者。分答心目也。塵六塵。勞即六塵汩擾。心為塵勞所依。如賊窩主。目為塵勞所引。如賊嚮導。此窮妄之源也。諸家皆分心屬識。目屬根。故有破心破目之異。愚謂破其迷。非破心目。下經云。是心非眼。則又何用擇破耶。

  方將發明真心。因根顯性。而謂要當知賊所在。使汝流轉。心目為咎者。何也。須知賊本子民。子民無識。誤陷不良。心目亦然。真覺無性。迷於所明。根境區分。展轉流浪。得其咎因。勞眚頓消。即此四塵。號清明目。心分別性。

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本:\n\n  眾生每日的所用,整個身心都是虛妄的。所以如來佛特意在當下提出『直心』(坦誠之心),就是要(阿難)在回答中明白地吐露真心。因此下文(阿難)因為眼睛看見如來的三十二相,心中生起愛慕之情,於是(佛陀)才開始七處征心,直到(阿難)情慾枯竭、智慧用盡。然後(阿難)反過來推究能推究之心。雖然目前還未究竟明白,也可以憑藉他所明白的來通達他所不明白的。現在的人看這段經文,都認為能推究的不是我的心,離開塵世之外另有完整的自性。卻不知道冥心獨照,仍然是向內守護幽靜閒適,錯過時機。仍然是離開塵世而無實體,執著于自己所見,附會聖人的言論。他們心口不一,怎麼說得完呢?所以知道如來佛最初的叮嚀並非沒有深意。\n\n  △四處征問心目。\n\n  『阿難,我現在問你,當初你發心緣于如來的三十二相(佛的殊勝相好),是用什麼看見的?誰在愛慕喜悅?』阿難回答佛說:『世尊,這樣的愛慕喜悅,是用我的心和眼睛。由眼睛觀看到如來的殊勝相好,心中生起愛慕喜悅。所以我才發心願意捨棄生死。』佛告訴阿難:『如你所說,真正的愛慕喜悅,是因為心和眼睛。如果不認識心和眼睛在哪裡,就不能夠降伏塵勞(煩惱)。譬如國王被盜賊侵犯,發兵討伐剷除。這些士兵一定要知道盜賊在哪裡。使你流轉生死,心和眼睛是罪過。我現在問你,這個心和眼睛,現在在哪裡?』\n\n  『將何所見』,是審視所見之物。\n\n  『誰為愛樂』,是審視愛樂之心。\n\n  『如是愛樂用我心目者』,是總括地回答心和眼睛。\n\n  『由目觀見心生愛樂者』,是分別地回答心和眼睛。\n\n  塵,指六塵(色、聲、香、味、觸、法)。勞,就是六塵的擾亂。心是塵勞所依附的,如同盜賊的窩主。眼睛是塵勞所引誘的,如同盜賊的嚮導。這是窮究虛妄的根源。各家都將心歸於識,眼睛歸於根。所以有破心破眼的區別。我認為是破除迷惑,不是破除心和眼睛。下經說:『是心非眼』,那麼又何必選擇破除呢?\n\n  正要發明真心,通過根來顯現自性。卻說『要當知賊所在。使汝流轉。心目為咎者』,是什麼意思呢?要知道盜賊本來是子民,子民沒有見識,誤入歧途。心和眼睛也是這樣,真覺沒有自性,迷惑于所明之境,根和境區分開來,輾轉流浪,得到罪過的原因。勞累和災禍頓時消散,這四塵(地、水、火、風)就叫做清明之目。心的分別之性。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version:\n\n  Sentient beings use it daily, yet the entire body and mind are illusory. Therefore, the Tathagata (如來,another name for Buddha) specifically brings up 'straightforward mind' (直心, honest and sincere mind) in the present moment, wanting (Ananda 阿難, one of the principal disciples of the Buddha) to clearly reveal his true feelings in his responses. Thus, in the following text, (Ananda) develops affection because his eyes see the thirty-two marks of the Tathagata (三十二相, the 32 auspicious marks of a Buddha), and so (the Buddha) begins the seven locations of mind inquiry, until (Ananda's) emotions are exhausted and his wisdom is depleted. Then (Ananda) turns back to investigate the mind that can investigate. Although not fully understood at present, one can use what he understands to penetrate what he does not understand. People today, when viewing this, all think that what can be investigated is not my mind, that there is a complete nature apart from the dust of the world. But they do not know that solitary illumination of the mind is still guarding inner tranquility, missing the opportunity. It is still being without substance apart from the dust, clinging to what one sees, and conforming to the words of the sages. How can one overstate their insincerity? Therefore, know that the Tathagata's initial exhortation was not without purpose.\n\n  △ Four Inquiries into the Location of Mind and Eyes.\n\n  'Ananda, I now ask you, when you first developed your mind towards the thirty-two marks of the Tathagata, what did you use to see? Who was it that loved and rejoiced?' Ananda replied to the Buddha, 'World Honored One (世尊, a title for the Buddha), such love and joy were used by my mind and eyes. My eyes saw the excellent marks of the Tathagata, and my mind developed love and joy. Therefore, I resolved to renounce birth and death.' The Buddha told Ananda, 'As you said, true love and joy arise from the mind and eyes. If you do not recognize where the mind and eyes are located, you will not be able to subdue the dust and toil (塵勞, afflictions). It is like a king who is invaded by thieves, and sends troops to eliminate them. These soldiers must know where the thieves are. What causes you to transmigrate is the fault of the mind and eyes. I now ask you, where are this mind and eyes located?'\n\n  'What did you use to see' is to examine what is seen.\n\n  'Who was it that loved and rejoiced' is to examine the mind that loves and rejoices.\n\n  'Such love and joy were used by my mind and eyes' is a general answer about the mind and eyes.\n\n  'My eyes saw and my mind developed love and joy' is a specific answer about the mind and eyes.\n\n  Dust refers to the six dusts (六塵, the six sense objects: form, sound, smell, taste, touch, and dharma). Toil is the disturbance of the six dusts. The mind is what the dust and toil rely on, like the den of thieves. The eyes are what the dust and toil lead, like the guides of thieves. This is to thoroughly investigate the source of illusion. All schools attribute the mind to consciousness and the eyes to the root. Therefore, there is a difference between breaking the mind and breaking the eyes. I think it is to break the delusion, not to break the mind and eyes. The following sutra says, 'This mind is not the eye,' then why bother choosing to break it?\n\n  Just as we are about to reveal the true mind, using the root to manifest the nature, why say 'You must know where the thieves are. What causes you to transmigrate is the fault of the mind and eyes'? Know that the thieves are originally the people, and the people, lacking knowledge, mistakenly fall into bad ways. The mind and eyes are also like this. True awareness has no inherent nature, and is deluded by what it illuminates. The root and the environment are distinguished, and one transmigrates and wanders, obtaining the cause of the fault. The toil and misfortune are immediately dispelled, and these four dusts (地、水、火、風, earth, water, fire, wind) are called clear and bright eyes. The discriminating nature of the mind."
  ]
}

何異妙觀。革面相從。賊元吾子。亦猶治不易民耳。

  上初標常住流轉之由竟。

  △二執心在內。分四。初正執身內。

  阿難白佛言。世尊。一切世間十種異生。同將識心居在身內。縱觀如來青蓮華眼。亦在佛面。我今觀此浮根四塵。祇在我面。如是識心實居身內。

  十二類生。除空散無身相故。除土木無心相故。浮粗浮。別非勝義。五根俱具八法。能造四大。地水火風。所造四塵。色香味觸。此指所造。塵污染義。

  △二舉現前約定。

  佛告阿難。汝今現坐如來講堂。觀祇陀林。今何所在。世尊。此大重閣清凈講堂。在給孤園。今祇陀林。實在堂外。阿難。汝今堂中。先何所見。世尊。我在堂中。先見如來。次觀大眾。如是外望。方矚林園。阿難。汝矚林園。因何有見。世尊。此大講堂。戶牖開豁。故我在堂得遠瞻見。

  堂在園中。林在堂外。此約境之內外。以伏見有次第。先見次觀。又約見之先後。以伏在內之心。當先見內。汝矚林園。因何有見。亦以起其講堂戶牖之答。取講堂喻身。戶牖喻根也。直解云。阿難執見由眼。故有因何有見之問。下經云。汝在室中。門能見不。便含是心非眼之意。

  △三撫慰廣示。

  爾時世尊在大眾中舒金色臂。摩阿難頂。告示阿難及諸大眾。有三摩提。名大佛頂首楞嚴王。具足萬行。十方如來一門超出妙莊嚴路。汝今諦聽。阿難頂禮。伏受慈旨。

  前已約定。以待后徴。此先撫慰。廣標修門也。三摩提大般若云。世尊入等持王妙三摩地

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "『何異妙觀』(如何才能算是精妙的觀察呢)?『革面相從』(徹底改變,真心歸順),『賊元吾子』(原本是盜賊的頭目,現在成了我的兒子),『亦猶治不易民耳』(這也就像治理難以馴服的百姓一樣啊)。",
    
    "(世尊)上面已經標明了常住真心隨逐流轉的原因,完畢。",
    
    "△二、執著於心在身體內部。分為四個部分。首先,正式執著於心在身體內部。",
    
    "阿難(Ananda,佛陀的十大弟子之一)對佛說:『世尊(Bhagavan,對佛的尊稱)。一切世間的十種不同型別的眾生,都認為識心(consciousness)存在於身體內部。縱然觀察如來(Tathagata,佛的稱號)的青蓮華眼(眼睛像青蓮花一樣清澈),也在佛的面部。我現在觀察這浮根(不真實的根,指眼耳鼻舌身五根)和四塵(色聲香味觸),僅僅存在於我的面部。如此看來,識心確實是存在於身體內部的。』",
    
    "十二類眾生,排除了空散無身相的眾生,也排除了土木無心相的眾生。浮,是粗淺的意思。別,是不究竟的意思,並非勝義(paramartha,殊勝的意義)。五根(眼耳鼻舌身)都具備八法(八種功能),能夠造作四大(地水火風)。所造的四塵(色聲香味觸),這裡指的是被造作出來的。塵,有污染的意思。",
    
    "△二、舉出現前的例子來約定。",
    
    "佛告訴阿難:『你現在坐在我的講堂里,觀察祇陀林(Jetavana,祇陀太子的樹林),現在在哪裡?』世尊,『這座高大莊嚴的清凈講堂,位於給孤園(Anathapindika's Park)。而祇陀林,確實在講堂外面。』阿難,『你現在在講堂中,首先看到的是什麼?』世尊,『我在講堂中,首先看到的是如來,然後觀察大眾,這樣向外望去,才能看到林園。』阿難,『你看到林園,是因為什麼才能看到?』世尊,『因為這座大講堂,戶牖(窗戶)開闊敞亮,所以我才能在講堂里遠遠地看到。』",
    
    "講堂在園中,林在講堂外。這是從境的內外來說,爲了伏藏見有次第的道理。先見,次觀,又是從見的先後來說,爲了伏藏在內的心,應當先見內。『你看到林園,是因為什麼才能看到?』也是爲了引出他回答講堂戶牖的問題,用講堂比喻身體,戶牖比喻根(眼耳鼻舌身)啊。直解說,阿難執著于見是由眼睛產生的,所以才有『因為什麼才能看到』的提問。下經說,『你在室內,門能看見嗎?』就包含了是心而非眼的意思。",
    
    "△三、撫慰並廣泛開示。",
    
    "這時,世尊在大眾中舒展金色的手臂,摩阿難的頭頂,告訴阿難和所有大眾:『有一種三摩提(samadhi,禪定),名為大佛頂首楞嚴王(Surangama Samadhi,一切事究竟堅固),具足萬行(無數的修行方法),十方如來(十個方向的佛)都是通過這一個法門超出,到達妙莊嚴路(通往覺悟的道路)。你們現在仔細聽好。』阿難頂禮,恭敬地接受佛的慈悲教誨。",
    
    "前面已經約定,是爲了等待後面的徵詢。這裡先撫慰,廣泛地標明修行的法門。三摩提,大般若經(Mahaprajnaparamita Sutra)中說:世尊進入等持王妙三摩地。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "What is different about a subtle observation? 'Radically change and follow' (completely change and sincerely submit), 'the thief's leader is my son' (originally the leader of thieves, now my son), 'it is just like governing unruly people' (this is just like governing people who are difficult to tame).",
    
    "The above (the World-Honored One) has already indicated the reason why the permanent true mind follows the flow of transmigration, completed.",
    
    "△2. Attachment to the mind being inside the body. Divided into four parts. First, formally attached to the mind being inside the body.",
    
    "Ananda (one of the Buddha's ten great disciples) said to the Buddha (Bhagavan, an honorific title for the Buddha): 'World-Honored One (Bhagavan, an honorific title for the Buddha). All ten different types of beings in the world believe that the consciousness (consciousness) resides inside the body. Even observing the blue lotus eyes (eyes as clear as blue lotus flowers) of the Tathagata (title of the Buddha), they are also on the Buddha's face. I now observe these floating roots (unreal roots, referring to the five senses of eyes, ears, nose, tongue, and body) and the four dusts (form, sound, smell, taste, and touch), which only exist on my face. Thus, it seems that the consciousness does reside inside the body.'",
    
    "The twelve types of beings exclude those who are empty, scattered, and without physical form, and also exclude those who are like earth and wood, without mental activity. Floating means superficial. Different means not ultimate, not the supreme meaning (paramartha, supreme meaning). The five senses (eyes, ears, nose, tongue, and body) all possess eight dharmas (eight functions), capable of creating the four great elements (earth, water, fire, and wind). The created four dusts (form, sound, smell, taste, and touch) here refer to what is created. Dust has the meaning of defilement.",
    
    "△2. Give a present example to agree upon.",
    
    "The Buddha said to Ananda: 'You are now sitting in my lecture hall, observing Jetavana (Jetavana, Prince Jeta's grove), where is it now?' 'World-Honored One, this tall and solemn pure lecture hall is located in Anathapindika's Park. And Jetavana is indeed outside the lecture hall.' Ananda, 'What do you see first now in the lecture hall?' 'World-Honored One, in the lecture hall, I first see the Tathagata, then observe the assembly, and then looking outward, I can see the garden.' Ananda, 'Why can you see the garden?' 'World-Honored One, because the doors and windows of this great lecture hall are open and bright, I can see it from afar in the lecture hall.'",
    
    "The lecture hall is in the park, and the forest is outside the lecture hall. This is from the inside and outside of the environment, in order to hide the principle that seeing has an order. First seeing, then observing, is also from the order of seeing, in order to hide the mind inside, which should first see the inside. 'Why can you see the garden?' is also to elicit his answer to the question of the doors and windows of the lecture hall, using the lecture hall as a metaphor for the body, and the doors and windows as a metaphor for the senses (eyes, ears, nose, tongue, and body). A direct explanation says that Ananda is attached to the view that seeing is produced by the eyes, so there is the question of 'why can you see'. The following sutra says, 'Can the door see when you are in the room?' which contains the meaning that it is the mind, not the eyes.",
    
    "△3. Comfort and widely explain.",
    
    "At this time, the World-Honored One stretched out his golden arm in the assembly, touched Ananda's head, and told Ananda and all the assembly: 'There is a samadhi (samadhi, meditation), named the Great Buddha Crown Surangama King (Surangama Samadhi, ultimate firmness in all things), complete with myriad practices (countless methods of practice), all the Buddhas of the ten directions (Buddhas of the ten directions) transcend through this one Dharma gate, reaching the wondrously adorned path (the path to enlightenment). You must listen carefully now.' Ananda bowed and respectfully accepted the Buddha's compassionate teachings.",
    
    "The previous agreement was to wait for the subsequent consultation. Here, first comfort, and widely indicate the Dharma gate of practice. Samadhi, in the Mahaprajnaparamita Sutra, it is said: The World-Honored One entered the Samadhi King's wondrous samadhi."
  ]
}

。諸三摩地皆攝入此三摩地。即此三摩提也。故曰名大佛頂首楞嚴王。具足萬行。稱性所起。福慧二嚴。還嚴本性。故云妙莊嚴。一門超出。無岐路。無等待也。

  三摩提所云三昧總持。此三昧總持。具有如是根本差別。體大用大。十方如來。皆從此路獲妙莊嚴。覺范以三摩提為但資變化。而妙莊嚴指為方便。所引法華妙莊嚴王。亦取身為異道。以明方便之旨。理固深玄。似非本經切要耳。

  △四窮非內。

  佛告阿難。如汝所言。身在講堂。戶牖開豁。遠矚林園。亦有眾生在此堂中。不見如來。見堂外者。阿難答言。世尊。在堂不見如來。能見林泉。無有是處。阿難。汝亦如是。汝之心靈。一切明瞭。若汝現前所明瞭心。實在身內。爾時先合了知內身。頗有眾生。先見身中。后觀外物。縱不能見心肝脾胃。爪生髮長筋轉脈搖誠合明瞭。如何不知。必不內知。云何知外。是故應知汝言覺了能知之心住在身內。無有是處。

  此窮心非身內。故以在堂之身。喻在身之心。在堂之身。先見如來。而在身之心。不見身內。以此而知心非身內。亦有者設言其必無也。頗有者亦因其先見后矚之語。是應有而出其終無也。縱不能見心肝脾胃。而爪生髮長筋轉脈搖誠合明瞭。又轉難之。總以明其必不能見內耳。

  上二執心在內竟。

  △三執心在外。分二。初正執身外。

  阿難稽首而白佛言。我聞如來如是法音。悟知我心實居身外。所以者何。譬如燈光。然于室中。是燈必能先照室內。從其室門。后及庭際。一切眾

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本:所有三摩地(Samadhi,一種冥想狀態)都包含在這一個三摩地之中。這本身就是三摩提。所以稱之為『大佛頂首楞嚴王』,它具足所有修行,是從本性中生起的,福德和智慧兩種莊嚴,反過來莊嚴本性,所以稱為『妙莊嚴』。通過這一法門可以直接超出,沒有歧路,無需等待。",
    
    "三摩提所說的三昧(Samadhi,正定)總持,這種三昧總持,具有這樣的根本差別,體性廣大,作用廣大。十方如來,都是從此路獲得妙莊嚴。覺范認為三摩提只是輔助變化,而妙莊嚴指的是方便。所引用的《法華經》中的妙莊嚴王,也是取其身為異道,來闡明方便的宗旨。道理固然深奧玄妙,但似乎並非本經的關鍵所在。",
    
    "△四、窮究心不在內。",
    
    "佛告訴阿難:『正如你所說,身體在講堂里,門窗敞開,可以遠眺林園。也有眾生在這個講堂中,看不見如來,卻能看見講堂外面的景色。』阿難回答說:『世尊,在講堂里看不見如來,卻能看見林泉,沒有這樣的道理。』阿難,你也是這樣。你的心性,一切都明瞭。如果你的眼前所明瞭的心,確實在身體內部,那麼首先應該能夠了知身體內部的情況。難道有眾生,先看見身體內部,然後才觀察外物的嗎?即使不能看見心肝脾胃,但指甲生長、頭髮變長、筋脈轉動、血液流動,總應該能夠明瞭。怎麼會不知道呢?必定是不能向內知曉,又怎麼能知曉外部呢?所以應該知道,你說覺了能知的心住在身體內部,是沒有道理的。",
    
    "這是窮究心不在身體內部。所以用在講堂中的身體,比喻在身體內部的心。在講堂中的身體,首先看見如來;而在身體內部的心,卻看不見身體內部。由此可知心不在身體內部。『亦有者』,是假設有人說必定沒有這種情況。『頗有者』,也是因為前面有『先見后矚』的說法,所以假設應該有這種情況,但最終還是沒有。『縱不能見心肝脾胃,而爪生髮長筋轉脈搖誠合明瞭』,這是進一步詰難。總之是爲了說明必定不能看見內部。",
    
    "以上是破斥執著心在身體內部的觀點。",
    
    "△三、執著心在身體外部。分為兩部分。首先是直接執著心在身體外部。",
    
    "阿難稽首(Qishou,一種古老的禮節,叩頭至地)稟告佛說:『我聽聞如來這樣的法音,領悟到我的心確實在身體外部。這是什麼原因呢?譬如燈光,點燃在房間里,這燈光必定先照亮室內,然後從門開始,照到庭院。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version: All Samadhis (Samadhi, a state of meditation) are included in this one Samadhi. This in itself is Samadhi. Therefore, it is called 'Great Buddha Crown Shurangama King', which is complete with all practices, arises from the inherent nature, and the two adornments of merit and wisdom, in turn, adorn the inherent nature, so it is called 'Wonderful Adornment'. Through this one Dharma gate, one can directly transcend, without detours, and without waiting.",
    
    "The Samadhi mentioned in Samadhi is the Dharani (Dharani, a type of mantra) of Samadhi. This Dharani of Samadhi has such fundamental differences, with great essence and great function. All Tathagatas (Tathagata, a title of the Buddha) attain wonderful adornment from this path. Juefan believes that Samadhi only assists in transformation, while wonderful adornment refers to skillful means. The Wonderful Adornment King in the Lotus Sutra, which is cited, also takes his body as a different path to illustrate the purpose of skillful means. The reasoning is certainly profound and mysterious, but it does not seem to be the key point of this sutra.",
    
    "△4. Exhaustive investigation of the mind not being inside.",
    
    "The Buddha told Ananda: 'Just as you said, the body is in the lecture hall, the doors and windows are open, and one can see the forest and gardens in the distance. There are also sentient beings in this lecture hall who cannot see the Tathagata, but can see the scenery outside the hall.' Ananda replied: 'World Honored One, there is no such thing as not being able to see the Tathagata in the lecture hall, but being able to see the forests and springs.' Ananda, you are also like this. Your mind is clear about everything. If the mind that you are clearly aware of is indeed inside the body, then you should first be able to know the internal conditions of the body. Is there any sentient being who first sees the inside of the body and then observes external objects? Even if you cannot see the heart, liver, spleen, stomach, but the growth of nails, the lengthening of hair, the movement of tendons, and the flow of blood should be clear. How can you not know? It must be that you cannot know internally, so how can you know externally? Therefore, you should know that your statement that the mind that is aware and knows resides inside the body is unreasonable.'",
    
    "This is an exhaustive investigation of the mind not being inside the body. Therefore, the body in the lecture hall is used as a metaphor for the mind inside the body. The body in the lecture hall first sees the Tathagata; while the mind inside the body cannot see the inside of the body. From this, it can be known that the mind is not inside the body. 'Also has' is a hypothesis that someone says there is definitely no such situation. 'Somewhat has' is also because there is the statement of 'seeing first and then looking', so it is assumed that there should be this situation, but in the end there is not. 'Even if you cannot see the heart, liver, spleen, and stomach, but the growth of nails, the lengthening of hair, the movement of tendons, and the flow of blood should be clear' is a further refutation. In short, it is to illustrate that it is definitely impossible to see the inside.",
    
    "The above is a refutation of the view that the mind is inside the body.",
    
    "△3. Attachment to the mind being outside the body. Divided into two parts. First, directly attaching to the mind being outside the body.",
    
    "Ananda bowed (Qishou, an ancient etiquette, kowtowing to the ground) and reported to the Buddha: 'I have heard such Dharma sounds from the Tathagata and realized that my mind is indeed outside the body. What is the reason for this? For example, a lamp is lit in a room, and the light from this lamp must first illuminate the room, and then, starting from the door, illuminate the courtyard."
  ]
}

生。不見身中。獨見身外。亦如燈光居在室外。不能照室。是義必明。將無所惑。同佛了義。得無妄耶。

  窮於身內。故疑身外。似理所無。然眾生迷於境物。隨緣飄泊。不能自主。比之執內。亦無優劣。

  △二窮非外。

  佛告阿難。是諸比丘。適來從我室羅筏城循乞摶食。歸祇陀林。我已宿齋。汝觀比丘。一人食時。諸人飽不。阿難答言。不也。世尊。何以故。是諸比丘。雖阿羅漢。軀命不同。云何一人能令眾飽。佛告阿難。若汝覺了知見之心實在身外。身心相外。自不相干。則心所知。身不能覺。覺在身際。心不能知。我今示汝兜羅綿手。汝眼見時。心分別不。阿難答言。如是。世尊。佛告阿難。若相知者。云何在外。是故應知汝言覺了能知之心住在身外。無有是處。

  一人之食。不能眾飽。喻身心相外。則不相知。今以相知。窮非身外也。摶食即段食。謂有形段可摶也。宿預也。溫陵曰。乞食歸林。乃舉現前方食之眾。故曰我已宿齋。兜羅具云兜沙羅。此云霜。佛手柔軟。如兜羅綿。

  上三執心在外竟。

  △四計潛根。分二。初正執潛根。

  阿難白佛言。世尊。如佛所言。不見內故。不居身內。身心相知。不相離故。不在身外。我今思惟。知在一處。佛言。處今何在。阿難言。此了知心。既不知內。而能見外。如我思忖。潛伏根里。猶如有人取琉璃碗。合其兩眼。雖有物合。而不留礙。彼根隨見。隨即分別。然我覺了能知之心。不見內者。為在根故。分明矚外無障礙者。潛根內故。

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "生。不見自身之中,只見到身體之外。就像燈光在室外,不能照亮室內一樣。這個道理如果明白了,就不會有什麼疑惑,與佛的究竟之義相同,就不會有虛妄了。",
    
    "侷限於自身之內,所以懷疑身體之外。似乎道理上沒有這種情況。然而眾生迷惑于外境事物,隨順因緣漂泊不定,不能自主。與執著于自身之內相比,也沒有什麼優劣之分。",
    
    "△二、否定心在外。",
    
    "佛告訴阿難(Ananda,佛陀的十大弟子之一):『這些比丘(bhikkhu,佛教出家男眾),剛才從我所住的室羅筏城(Śrāvastī,古印度城市)依次乞食,回到祇陀林(Jetavana,祇樹給孤獨園,佛陀常住的精舍)。我已經提前用過齋飯了。你觀察這些比丘,一個人吃飯的時候,其他人會飽嗎?』阿難回答說:『不會的,世尊(Lokajyestha,對佛陀的尊稱)。為什麼呢?因為這些比丘,即使是阿羅漢(Arhat,斷盡煩惱,證得解脫的聖者),他們的身體和生命也各不相同,怎麼可能一個人吃就能讓所有人都飽呢?』佛告訴阿難:『如果你的覺了知見之心確實在身體之外,身心互相外在於對方,互不相干,那麼心所知道的,身體就不能覺察;覺察發生在身體,心就不能知道。我現在給你看兜羅綿(Tula,一種柔軟的棉花)手,你的眼睛看到的時候,心能分別嗎?』阿難回答說:『是的,世尊。』佛告訴阿難:『如果互相知道,怎麼能說在外面呢?所以應該知道,你說覺了能知的心住在身體之外,是沒有道理的。』",
    
    "一人吃飯,不能讓眾人飽。比喻身心互相外在於對方,就不會互相知道。現在因為互相知道,所以否定心在身體之外。摶食就是段食,指有形狀可以摶握的食物。宿是預先的意思。溫陵說:『乞食回到林中,是舉出現前方吃飯的眾人,所以說我已經提前用過齋飯了。』兜羅,全稱是兜沙羅(Tusara),這裡譯為霜。佛的手柔軟,像兜羅綿一樣。",
    
    "以上是三種執著心在外的說法結束。",
    
    "△四、計較潛藏的根源。分為兩部分。首先,正式執著潛藏的根源。",
    
    "阿難稟告佛說:『世尊,正如佛所說,因為看不見內在,所以不在身體之內;身心互相知道,不互相分離,所以不在身體之外。我現在思考,知道心在一個地方。』佛說:『這個地方現在在哪裡?』阿難說:『這個了知的心,既然不知道內在,卻能看見外在。正如我所思忖,它潛伏在根里,就像有人拿琉璃碗蓋住眼睛,雖然有東西蓋住,卻不留下阻礙。眼睛的根隨著所見,隨即進行分別。然而我的覺了能知的心,看不見內在,是因為在根里的緣故;能分明地看到外面沒有障礙,是因為潛藏在根里的緣故。』"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "'It arises. It does not see within the body, only sees outside the body. It is like a lamp's light residing outside a room, unable to illuminate the room. If this meaning is understood, there will be no confusion, and it will be the same as the Buddha's ultimate meaning, free from delusion.'",
    
    "'Being confined to within the body, one doubts what is outside the body. It seems unreasonable. However, sentient beings are deluded by external objects, drifting along with conditions, unable to be autonomous. Compared to being attached to the internal, there is no superiority or inferiority.'",
    
    "△2. Denying the Mind is External.",
    
    "The Buddha told Ananda (one of the ten principal disciples of the Buddha): 'These bhikkhus (ordained male monastics), just now went from Śrāvastī (ancient Indian city) to beg for alms, returning to Jetavana (Jetavana Anathapindika Monastery, where the Buddha often resided). I have already had my meal. Observe these bhikkhus, when one person eats, do the others become full?' Ananda replied: 'No, World Honored One (a title of respect for the Buddha). Why? Because these bhikkhus, even if they are Arhats (those who have extinguished all afflictions and attained liberation), their bodies and lives are different. How can one person eating make everyone full?' The Buddha told Ananda: 'If your knowing and perceiving mind is truly outside the body, with the body and mind being external to each other and not interfering with each other, then what the mind knows, the body cannot perceive; and when perception occurs in the body, the mind cannot know. Now I show you a Tula (a type of soft cotton) cotton hand. When your eyes see it, does the mind discriminate?' Ananda replied: 'Yes, World Honored One.' The Buddha told Ananda: 'If they know each other, how can it be said to be outside? Therefore, you should know that your statement that the knowing and perceiving mind resides outside the body is unreasonable.'",
    
    "One person's food cannot satisfy everyone. This is a metaphor for the body and mind being external to each other, in which case they would not know each other. Now, because they know each other, it is denied that the mind is outside the body. 'Tuan shi' (摶食) is 'duan shi' (段食), referring to food that has a shape that can be grasped. 'Su' (宿) means 'in advance'. Wenling said: 'Begging for food and returning to the forest is to point out the crowd who are currently eating, so it is said that I have already had my meal in advance.' Tula, in full, is Tusara, which is translated here as frost. The Buddha's hand is soft, like Tula cotton.",
    
    "The above concludes the three attachments to the mind being external.",
    
    "△4. Calculating the Hidden Root. Divided into two parts. First, formally clinging to the hidden root.",
    
    "Ananda said to the Buddha: 'World Honored One, as the Buddha said, because one does not see the internal, it does not reside within the body; the body and mind know each other and are not separated, so it is not outside the body. Now I think, I know the mind is in one place.' The Buddha said: 'Where is this place now?' Ananda said: 'This knowing mind, since it does not know the internal, yet can see the external. As I ponder, it is hidden in the root, like someone taking a crystal bowl to cover their eyes. Although there is something covering, it does not leave any obstruction. The root of the eye follows what is seen and immediately discriminates. However, my knowing and perceiving mind, which does not see the internal, is because it is in the root; and it can clearly see the external without obstruction because it is hidden in the root.'"
  ]
}

  阿難以琉璃籠眼。喻根籠心。不知眼見琉璃。而心不能見眼。以眼非境也。下文自徴。

  △二窮非潛根。

  佛告阿難。如汝所言。潛根內者。猶如琉璃。彼人當以琉璃籠眼。當見山河。見琉璃不。如是。世尊。是人當以琉璃籠眼。實見琉璃。佛告阿難。汝心若同琉璃合者。當見山河。何不見眼。若見眼者。眼即同境。不得成隨。若不能見。云何說言此了知心潛在根內如琉璃合。是故應知汝言覺了能知之心潛伏根里如琉璃合。無有是處。

  彼根隨見。隨即分別。是心眼相隨。若能見眼。眼即同境。故不成隨。若不能見。則心非潛根如琉璃合上四計潛根竟。

  △五開合明暗。分二。初正執開合明暗。

  阿難白佛言。世尊。我今又作如是思惟。是眾生身。腑藏在中。竅穴居外。有藏則暗。有竅則明。今我對佛。開眼見明。名為見外。閉眼見暗。名為見內。是義云何。

  以有藏則暗。有竅則明。脫既不見內而能見外之難。仍是心在身內之說。

  △二窮非開合明暗。

  佛告阿難。汝當閉眼見暗之時。此暗境界。為與眼對。為不對眼。若與眼對。暗在眼前。云何成內。若成內者。居暗室中。無日月燈。此室暗中。皆汝焦腑。若不對者。云何成見。

  阿難以見暗即為見內。是對眼則暗在眼前。不成為內。故又有此室暗中皆汝焦腑之難。不對無見。總以證成其見暗非內耳。

  若離外見。內對所成。閤眼見暗。名為身中。開眼見明。何不見面。若不見面。內對不成。

  前以對眼為外

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "阿難用琉璃籠罩眼睛,比喻根籠罩心。卻不知眼睛能看見琉璃,而心卻不能看見眼睛,因為眼睛不是所見的境界。下文佛陀親自進行辨析。",
    
    "△二、 破斥『窮極探究,心潛藏於根內』的觀點。",
    
    "佛陀告訴阿難:『如你所說,心潛藏在根內,就像琉璃一樣。如果有人用琉璃籠罩眼睛,他應當能看見山河,那麼他能看見琉璃嗎?』阿難回答:『是的,世尊。這個人用琉璃籠罩眼睛,確實能看見琉璃。』佛陀告訴阿難:『如果你的心和琉璃一樣結合在一起,應當能看見山河,為什麼看不見眼睛呢?如果能看見眼睛,眼睛就成了所見的境界,就不能隨順於心了。如果不能看見眼睛,又怎麼能說這了知的心潛藏在根內,像琉璃一樣結合在一起呢?』所以應當知道,你說覺了能知的心潛伏在根里,像琉璃一樣結合在一起,是沒有道理的。",
    
    "如果根隨著所見而立即分別,這是心與眼相互隨順。如果能看見眼睛,眼睛就成了所見的境界,所以不能隨順於心。如果不能看見眼睛,那麼心就不是潛藏在根內,像琉璃一樣結合在一起。以上破斥了四種計度心潛藏在根內的觀點。",
    
    "△五、 破斥『開眼見明,閉眼見暗』的觀點。 分為兩部分,首先是正面執著于開眼見明,閉眼見暗的觀點。",
    
    "阿難對佛陀說:『世尊,我現在又這樣思惟,這個眾生的身體,五臟六腑在裡面,竅穴在外面。有五臟六腑的地方就暗,有竅穴的地方就明。現在我面對佛陀,睜開眼睛看見光明,這叫做見外;閉上眼睛看見黑暗,這叫做見內。這種說法怎麼樣呢?』",
    
    "認為有五臟六腑的地方就暗,有竅穴的地方就明,這樣就擺脫了既不能見內又能見外的詰難,仍然是心在身內的說法。",
    
    "△二、 破斥『開眼見明,閉眼見暗』的觀點。",
    
    "佛陀告訴阿難:『當你閉上眼睛看見黑暗的時候,這黑暗的境界,是與眼睛相對,還是不與眼睛相對?如果與眼睛相對,黑暗就在眼前,怎麼能成為見內呢?如果成為見內,住在黑暗的房間里,沒有日月燈光,這房間里的黑暗,豈不都是你的焦黑的內臟?如果不與眼睛相對,又怎麼能說是看見呢?』",
    
    "阿難認為看見黑暗就是見內。佛陀反駁說,如果黑暗是對著眼睛的,那麼黑暗就在眼前,不能成為見內。所以又有這房間里的黑暗豈不都是你的焦黑的內臟的詰難。如果黑暗不與眼睛相對,就不能說是看見。總之,用這些來證明看見黑暗不是見內。",
    
    "如果離開外面的所見,僅僅是內在相對而成的,閉上眼睛看見黑暗,就說是身中;那麼睜開眼睛看見光明,為什麼看不見自己的臉面呢?如果看不見自己的臉面,內在相對就不能成立。",
    
    "前面用『對著眼睛』來論證是『外』。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Ānanda uses a crystal (liúlí 琉璃) to cover his eyes, which is a metaphor for the roots (of perception) covering the mind. However, he doesn't realize that the eyes can see the crystal, but the mind cannot see the eyes, because the eyes are not the object of perception. The following text is the Buddha's own analysis.",
    
    "△2. Refuting the view that 'after thorough investigation, the mind is hidden within the roots'.",
    
    "The Buddha told Ānanda: 'As you said, the mind is hidden within the roots, just like crystal. If someone uses crystal to cover their eyes, they should be able to see mountains and rivers, so can they see the crystal?' Ānanda replied: 'Yes, World Honored One. That person covers their eyes with crystal and can indeed see the crystal.' The Buddha told Ānanda: 'If your mind is combined with the crystal in the same way, you should be able to see mountains and rivers, why can't you see your eyes? If you could see your eyes, then the eyes would become the object of perception, and could not follow the mind. If you cannot see your eyes, how can you say that this knowing mind is hidden within the roots, combined like crystal?' Therefore, you should know that your statement that the knowing mind is hidden within the roots, combined like crystal, is unreasonable.",
    
    "If the roots immediately discriminate according to what is seen, this is the mind and eyes following each other. If you could see your eyes, the eyes would become the object of perception, so they cannot follow the mind. If you cannot see your eyes, then the mind is not hidden within the roots, combined like crystal. The above refutes the four views that the mind is hidden within the roots.",
    
    "△5. Refuting the view of 'opening the eyes to see light, closing the eyes to see darkness'. Divided into two parts, the first is the positive adherence to the view of opening the eyes to see light and closing the eyes to see darkness.",
    
    "Ānanda said to the Buddha: 'World Honored One, I now think in this way, the body of this sentient being has the internal organs inside, and the orifices outside. Where there are internal organs, it is dark; where there are orifices, it is bright. Now I face the Buddha, open my eyes and see light, this is called seeing outside; close my eyes and see darkness, this is called seeing inside. What about this statement?'",
    
    "The idea that where there are internal organs it is dark, and where there are orifices it is bright, thus escaping the difficulty of neither seeing inside nor seeing outside, is still the idea that the mind is inside the body.",
    
    "△2. Refuting the view of 'opening the eyes to see light, closing the eyes to see darkness'.",
    
    "The Buddha told Ānanda: 'When you close your eyes and see darkness, is this state of darkness facing the eyes, or not facing the eyes? If it is facing the eyes, the darkness is in front of the eyes, how can it be seeing inside? If it becomes seeing inside, living in a dark room without sunlight or lamps, wouldn't the darkness in this room all be your charred internal organs? If it is not facing the eyes, how can it be called seeing?'",
    
    "Ānanda believes that seeing darkness is seeing inside. The Buddha refutes that if the darkness is facing the eyes, then the darkness is in front of the eyes, and cannot be seeing inside. Therefore, there is also the difficulty that the darkness in this room would all be your charred internal organs. If the darkness is not facing the eyes, it cannot be called seeing. In short, these are used to prove that seeing darkness is not seeing inside.",
    
    "If it is separated from external seeing, and only formed by internal facing, closing the eyes and seeing darkness is said to be inside the body; then opening the eyes and seeing light, why can't you see your own face? If you cannot see your own face, then internal facing cannot be established.",
    
    "The previous argument used 'facing the eyes' to argue that it is 'outside'."
  ]
}

。不得成內。今縱許離外見之非。而以見暗成其內對。則見明亦應成為內矚。故曰何不見面。內矚不成。則內對非義。良以暗在眼前。不得成為見內。亦猶明在眼前。不應名為內矚也。

  見面若成。此了知心。及與眼根。乃在虛空。何成在內。若在虛空。自非汝體。即應如來今見汝面。亦是汝身。汝眼已知。身合非覺。必汝執言身眼兩覺。應有二知。即汝一身。應成兩佛。是故應知汝言見暗名見內者。無有是處。

  此又許其見面亦成內對。則唯心與眼。皆在虛空。既不成內。又非汝體。故又有如來見汝亦是汝身之難也。眼在虛空而知。則身應不覺。若謂身眼兩覺。故又有一身兩佛之難。此皆虛縱。以證見明必非內矚。則見暗不成內對。

  上五開合明暗竟。

  △六隨所合處。分二。初正執隨合。

  阿難言。我常聞佛開示四眾。由心生故種種法生。由法生故種種心生。

  佛語本意。謂由阿賴耶識不覺妄動。變起根器。復由根器境界風動。轉生識浪。今引惟取法生心生。以照下語。

  我今思惟。即思惟體實我心性。隨所合處。心則隨有。亦非內外中間三處。

  雖認思惟之體。然在迷中。不能自返。仍是緣慮。隨合隨有。則不合便無。此即緣慮之驗。三處謂內外潛根也。

  △二窮非隨合。

  佛告阿難。汝今說言。由法生故種種心生。隨所合處。心隨有者。是心無體。則無所合。若無有體而能合者。則十八界因七塵合。是義不然。若有體者。如汝以手自挃其體。汝所知心。為復內出。

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "不得成為『內』。現在即使允許你離開『外見』的錯誤觀點,而用『見暗』來成立『內對』,那麼『見明』也應該成為『內矚』。所以說,為什麼不能『見面』呢?『內矚』如果不能成立,那麼『內對』就沒有道理。因為黑暗就在眼前,不能成為『見內』,就像光明就在眼前,不應該稱為『內矚』一樣。",
    
    "如果『見面』能夠成立,那麼這個了知的心,以及和眼根,就都在虛空中,怎麼能說是在『內』呢?如果在虛空中,自然就不是你的本體。那麼,如來現在看見你的面,也就是你的身體了。你的眼睛已經知道了,身體結合卻不知道,這不合理。如果你堅持說身體和眼睛都能覺知,那就應該有兩個知覺。那麼,你的一個身體,就應該成為兩個佛了。所以應該知道,你說『見暗』叫做『見內』,是沒有道理的。",
    
    "這又是假設『見面』也可以成立『內對』。那麼,唯有心和眼睛,都在虛空中。既然不能成為『內』,又不是你的本體。所以又有如來看見你也等於看見你身體的責難。眼睛在虛空中而能知,那麼身體應該沒有感覺。如果說身體和眼睛都能感覺,所以又有一個身體兩個佛的責難。這些都是假設,用來證明『見明』一定不是『內矚』,那麼『見暗』就不能成立『內對』。",
    
    "以上五種開合明暗的辯論結束。",
    
    "△六、隨所合處,分兩部分。首先是正面執著于隨合。",
    
    "阿難(Ananda,佛陀的十大弟子之一)說:『我常常聽佛開示四眾,由於心生起,所以種種法生起;由於法生起,所以種種心生起。』",
    
    "佛陀(Buddha)說法的本意,是說由於阿賴耶識(Alaya-vijñana,第八識,含藏識)不覺妄動,變現出根器;又由於根器境界風動,轉而生起識浪。現在引用只是取『法生心生』,用來照應下面的話。",
    
    "『我現在思惟,就是思惟的本體實在是我心性,隨著所合之處,心就隨著存在,也不是內外中間這三個地方。』",
    
    "雖然認識到思惟的本體,但是在迷惑之中,不能自己反省。仍然是緣慮,隨著所合而存在,那麼不合就沒有。這就是緣慮的驗證。三個地方指的是內外和潛根。",
    
    "△二、窮究並非隨合。",
    
    "佛告阿難(Ananda):『你現在說,由於法生起,所以種種心生起,隨著所合之處,心就隨著存在。』這個心沒有自體,就沒有什麼可以和合。如果沒有自體而能夠和合,那麼十八界(十八界:六根、六塵、六識)就因為七塵(七塵:色聲香味觸法空)和合而生。這個道理是不對的。如果有自體,比如你用手自己指自己的身體,你所知道的心,是從內而出嗎?"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "It cannot become 'internal'. Now, even if I allow you to depart from the erroneous view of 'external seeing', and use 'seeing darkness' to establish 'internal opposition', then 'seeing light' should also become 'internal contemplation'. Therefore, why can't there be 'face-to-face seeing'? If 'internal contemplation' cannot be established, then 'internal opposition' is unreasonable. Because darkness is right before the eyes, it cannot become 'seeing internally', just as light is right before the eyes, it should not be called 'internal contemplation'.",
    
    "If 'face-to-face seeing' could be established, then this knowing mind, as well as the eye-root, would all be in empty space. How could it be said to be 'internal'? If it is in empty space, then it is naturally not your own body. Then, the Tathagata (如來,Buddha's title) seeing your face now would also be seeing your body. Your eyes already know, but the body, being combined, does not know, which is unreasonable. If you insist that both the body and eyes can perceive, then there should be two perceptions. Then, your one body should become two Buddhas. Therefore, you should know that your saying 'seeing darkness' is called 'seeing internally' is without reason.",
    
    "This is again assuming that 'face-to-face seeing' can also establish 'internal opposition'. Then, only the mind and eyes are in empty space. Since it cannot become 'internal' and is not your own body, there is again the difficulty of the Tathagata (如來) seeing you also being equal to seeing your body. If the eyes are in empty space and can know, then the body should not feel. If it is said that both the body and eyes can feel, then there is again the difficulty of one body being two Buddhas. These are all assumptions used to prove that 'seeing light' is definitely not 'internal contemplation', then 'seeing darkness' cannot establish 'internal opposition'.",
    
    "The above five discussions on opening, closing, light, and darkness are concluded.",
    
    "△6. Depending on the place of combination, divided into two parts. First, directly clinging to combination.",
    
    "Ananda (阿難, one of the Buddha's ten great disciples) said: 'I often hear the Buddha (佛陀) explain to the four assemblies that because the mind arises, all kinds of dharmas (法, teachings, phenomena) arise; because dharmas (法) arise, all kinds of minds arise.'",
    
    "The Buddha's (佛陀) original intention was that due to the Alaya-vijñana's (阿賴耶識, eighth consciousness, storehouse consciousness) non-awakening and delusional movement, the roots and faculties are manifested; and due to the wind-like movement of the roots and faculties, waves of consciousness arise. Now, the quotation only takes 'dharmas (法) arise, minds arise' to correspond to the following words.",
    
    "'I am now contemplating, that is, the substance of contemplation is truly my mind-nature. Wherever it combines, the mind exists accordingly, and it is not in the three places of inside, outside, or middle.'",
    
    "Although he recognizes the substance of contemplation, he is in delusion and cannot reflect on himself. It is still dependent thought, existing wherever it combines, then it does not exist where it does not combine. This is the verification of dependent thought. The three places refer to inside, outside, and latent roots.",
    
    "△2. Exhaustively investigating non-combination.",
    
    "The Buddha (佛) told Ananda (阿難): 'You are now saying that because dharmas (法) arise, all kinds of minds arise, and wherever it combines, the mind exists accordingly.' This mind has no self-nature, so there is nothing to combine with. If there is no self-nature and it can combine, then the eighteen realms (十八界: six sense organs, six sense objects, six consciousnesses) would arise because of the combination of the seven dusts (七塵: form, sound, smell, taste, touch, dharma, void). This reasoning is incorrect. If it has self-nature, for example, you use your hand to point to your own body, does the mind that you know come from within?'"
  ]
}

為從外入。若復內出。還見身中。若從外來。先合見面。

  十九界七塵皆喻有名無體也。復以內出外入。推窮所知之心。使之自覺。至后窮盡體覺。聖意自見。

  阿難言。見是其眼。心知非眼。為見非義。佛言。若眼能見。汝在室中。門能見不。則諸已死。尚有眼存。應皆見物。若見物者。云何名死。

  心知非眼。雖免所見之難。而見是其眼。反彰迷根之過。故曰門能見不。正責其以見屬眼也。此處已伏是心非眼之旨。

  阿難。又汝覺了能知之心。若必有體。為復一體。為有多體。今在汝身。為復遍體。為不遍體。若一體者。則汝以手挃一支時。四支應覺。若咸覺者。挃應無在。若挃有所。則汝一體自不能成。若多體者。則成多人。何體為汝。若遍體者。同前所挃。若不遍者。當汝觸頭。亦觸其足。頭有所覺。足應無知。今汝不然。是故應知隨所合處心則隨有。無有是處。

  前徴有體。但窮內外。此復窮一多遍與不遍。默示心根無二。使之直下自認也。若挃有在。不能咸覺。窮非一體。設能咸覺。則成多人。窮非多體。遍體同挃。謂如前有所之挃。不能成遍也。若不遍者。同時受觸。不應同覺耳。

  上六隨所合處竟。

  △七在中間。分二。初正執中間。

  阿難白佛言。世尊。我亦聞佛與文殊等諸法王子談實相時。世尊亦言心不在內。亦不在外。

  不在內。則內不見心。不在外。則外不見法。乃如來指示實相。此引以為不在內外。故應中間。

  如我思惟。內無所見。外不相知

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "是從外面進入的。如果又是從裡面出來,還是會看到在身體裡面。如果是從外面來的,應該先和(你的)面相合。",
    
    "十九界(六根、六塵、六識加意識和末那識)和七塵(色、聲、香、味、觸、法,加上空)都比喻為有名無實。再用從內出、從外入的方法,推究所知的心,使它自己覺悟。到了後來窮盡體覺,聖人的意思自然顯現。",
    
    "阿難(釋迦牟尼佛的十大弟子之一,以記憶力強著稱)說:『見是眼睛的功能,心知不是眼睛的功能,那麼說見不是眼睛的功能是有道理的。』佛說:『如果眼睛能見,你在房間里,門能見嗎?那麼那些已經死了的人,還有眼睛存在,應該都能看見東西。如果能看見東西,怎麼能叫死呢?』",
    
    "心知不是眼睛的功能,雖然免除了所見的責難,但說『見是眼睛的功能』,反而更加顯露出執迷於根的過錯。所以說『門能見嗎?』正是責備他把見的功能歸屬於眼睛。這裡已經埋下了『是心非眼』的主旨。",
    
    "阿難,再者,你覺了能知的心,如果一定有實體,是隻有一個實體,還是有多個實體?現在在你身上,是遍佈全身,還是不遍佈全身?如果只有一個實體,那麼你用手觸碰一支肢體的時候,四肢都應該感覺到。如果都能感覺到,觸碰應該沒有特定之處。如果觸碰有特定之處,那麼你的一體就不能成立。如果有很多實體,那就成了很多人,哪個實體是你?如果遍佈全身,和前面觸碰的情況一樣。如果不遍佈全身,當你觸碰頭的時候,也觸碰了腳,頭有所感覺,腳應該沒有知覺。現在你不是這樣,所以應該知道心隨著所接觸的地方而有,沒有一個固定的地方。",
    
    "前面推究有實體,只是推究內外。這裡又推究一多、遍與不遍,默默地顯示心根沒有兩個,使他直接地自己認識。如果觸碰有特定之處,不能全部感覺到,推究不是一個實體。假設能全部感覺到,那就成了很多人,推究不是多個實體。遍佈全身和觸碰一樣,說如前面有特定之處的觸碰,不能成為遍佈全身。如果不遍佈全身,同時受到觸碰,不應該同時感覺到。",
    
    "上面六個部分是隨著所接觸的地方而結束。",
    
    "△七、在中間。分為兩部分。首先,正式執著于中間。",
    
    "阿難對佛說:『世尊,我也聽佛和文殊(文殊菩薩,象徵智慧)等各位法王子談論實相的時候,世尊也說心不在內,也不在外。』",
    
    "不在內,那麼在內就不能看見心。不在外,那麼在外就不能看見法。這是如來指示實相。這裡引用這句話,認為心不在內外,所以應該在中間。",
    
    "像我思考的那樣,在內沒有所見,在外沒有所知。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "It enters from the outside. If it comes out from the inside again, it will still be seen within the body. If it comes from the outside, it should first meet the face.",
    
    "The nineteen realms (six senses, six sense objects, six consciousnesses plus Manas and Alaya consciousness) and the seven dusts (form, sound, smell, taste, touch, dharma, plus space) are all metaphors for having names without substance. Furthermore, using the methods of going out from within and entering from without, investigate the knowing mind, so that it awakens itself. When the embodied awareness is exhausted, the meaning of the sage will naturally appear.",
    
    "Ānanda (one of the ten major disciples of Śākyamuni Buddha, known for his strong memory) said, 'Seeing is the function of the eye, and knowing is not the function of the eye, so it is reasonable to say that seeing is not the function of the eye.' The Buddha said, 'If the eye can see, when you are in a room, can the door see? Then those who have already died, still having eyes, should all be able to see things. If they can see things, how can they be called dead?'",
    
    "Although the statement 'knowing is not the function of the eye' avoids the difficulty of what is seen, saying 'seeing is the function of the eye' further reveals the fault of being attached to the root. Therefore, saying 'can the door see?' is precisely to rebuke him for attributing the function of seeing to the eye. Here, the main point of 'it is the mind, not the eye' is already implied.",
    
    "Ānanda, furthermore, if your awakened and knowing mind must have a substance, is it one substance or many substances? Now, in your body, is it all over the body or not all over the body? If it is one substance, then when you touch one limb with your hand, all four limbs should feel it. If all can feel it, then the touch should not be in a specific place. If the touch is in a specific place, then your one substance cannot be established. If there are many substances, then it becomes many people, which substance is you? If it is all over the body, it is the same as the previous case of touching. If it is not all over the body, when you touch your head, you also touch your foot. The head feels something, but the foot should not know. Now you are not like this, so you should know that the mind is present wherever it is in contact, there is no fixed place.",
    
    "The previous investigation of having a substance only investigated inside and outside. Here, it further investigates one or many, all over or not all over, silently showing that the root of the mind is not two, so that he directly recognizes it himself. If the touch is in a specific place, it cannot all be felt, investigating that it is not one substance. Suppose it can all be felt, then it becomes many people, investigating that it is not many substances. All over the body is the same as touching, saying that like the previous touch in a specific place, it cannot become all over the body. If it is not all over the body, receiving touch at the same time, it should not be felt at the same time.",
    
    "The above six parts end with wherever it is in contact.",
    
    "△7. In the middle. Divided into two parts. First, formally attached to the middle.",
    
    "Ānanda said to the Buddha, 'World Honored One, I have also heard the Buddha and Mañjuśrī (Mañjuśrī Bodhisattva, symbolizing wisdom) and other Dharma princes discussing the real aspect, and the World Honored One also said that the mind is not inside, nor is it outside.'",
    
    "Not inside, then the mind cannot be seen inside. Not outside, then the Dharma cannot be seen outside. This is the Tathagata indicating the real aspect. This is quoted to mean that the mind is not inside or outside, so it should be in the middle.",
    
    "As I think, there is nothing seen inside, and nothing known outside."
  ]
}

。內無知故。在內不成。身心相知。在外非義。今相知故。復內無見。當在中間。

  承上心不在內。故內無所見。亦不在外。則外不相知。今內無知。成內無見。而身心相知。顯外非義。是當在根塵之中也。

  △二窮非中間。

  佛言。汝言中間。中必不迷。非無所在。今汝推中。中何為在。為覆在處。為當在身。若在身者。在邊非中。在中同內。

  處謂塵。身謂根。此分窮根塵。下乃兼窮。以責無體。身有中邊。故曰在邊非中。在中同內。此先窮根也。

  若在處者。為有所表。為無所表。無表同無。表則無定。何以故。如人以表。表為中時。東看則西。南觀成北。表體既混。心應雜亂。

  表者標物以顯中也。東西南北。所見不同。則所表無定。心應雜亂者言中無所取也。

  阿難言。我所說中。非此二種。如世尊言。眼色為緣。生於眼識。眼有分別。色塵無知。識生其中。則為心在。

  相宗分別根塵識之所緣起。非第一義。阿難認識為心。已在迷位。更謂根塵之中。益見差謬。

  佛言。汝心若在根塵之中。此之心體。為復兼二。為不兼二。

  以兼二不兼二。窮其不在根塵之中。使之自悟。謂此二中無有心體也。

  若兼二者。物體雜亂。物非體知。成敵兩立。云何為中。

  物指塵。體指根。一知一不知。故云雜亂。知非不知。不知非知。故云成敵兩立。兩立則中無所表。

  兼二不成。非知不知。即無體性。中何為相。是故應知當在中間。無有是處。

  

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本:",
    "『內在』沒有知覺的緣故,所以不能在『內』成立。身和心相互知覺,認為在『外』是不合道理的。現在因為相互知覺的緣故,又說『內』沒有見,那麼(心)應當在中間嗎?",
    
    "承接上文,心不在『內』,所以『內』沒有所見;也不在『外』,那麼『外』就不能相互知覺。現在說『內』沒有知覺,成立了『內』沒有見,而身和心相互知覺,顯示『外』是不合道理的。這就是說(心)應當在根塵之中了。",
    
    "二、 窮究不在中間",
    
    "佛說:『你說在中間,這個『中』必然不是迷惑的,不是沒有所在。現在你推求這個『中』,這個『中』在哪裡呢?是在『處』(塵)呢?還是在『身』(根)呢?如果在『身』,那麼在『邊』就不是『中』,在『中』就和在『內』一樣了。』",
    
    "『處』指的是塵,『身』指的是根。這裡分別窮究根和塵,下面就兼顧窮究,來責問『中』沒有自體。身有中邊,所以說在『邊』就不是『中』,在『中』就和在『內』一樣。這是先窮究根。",
    
    "『如果在『處』,那麼是『有所表』,還是『無所表』?『無所表』就和沒有一樣,『有所表』就沒有定準。為什麼呢?比如人設立一個標幟,標幟作為『中』的時候,從東邊看就是西邊,從南邊看就成了北邊。標幟的體性既然混淆不清,心也應該雜亂無章。』",
    
    "『表』是標立事物來顯示『中』。東西南北,所見不同,那麼所標立的就沒有定準。『心也應該雜亂無章』,是說『中』沒有什麼可以取用的。",
    
    "阿難(Ananda,佛陀十大弟子之一)說:『我所說的『中』,不是這兩種。就像世尊(釋迦牟尼佛的尊稱)所說,眼和色為緣,產生眼識。眼有分別,色塵沒有知覺,識生在它們中間,這就是心所在的地方。』",
    
    "相宗(佛教宗派之一,又稱唯識宗)分別根、塵、識的所緣起,不是第一義諦。阿難認識(眼)識為心,已經在迷惑的地位,更認為(心)在根塵之中,更加顯得差錯謬誤。",
    
    "佛說:『你的心如果在根塵之中,這個心的本體,是兼具根塵二者呢?還是不兼具根塵二者呢?』",
    
    "用兼具和不兼具二者,來窮究心不在根塵之中,使阿難自己醒悟。意思是說這二者之中沒有心體。",
    
    "『如果兼具二者,物體就雜亂不清,物不是本體的知覺,就成了敵對的兩方。怎麼能說是『中』呢?』",
    
    "『物』指的是塵,『體』指的是根。一個有知覺,一個沒有知覺,所以說雜亂不清。知覺不是沒有知覺,沒有知覺不是知覺,所以說成了敵對的兩方。兩方對立,那麼『中』就沒有所表。",
    
    "『兼具二者不能成立,非知非不知,就沒有體性,『中』又有什麼形象呢?所以應當知道(心)應當在中間,是沒有這個道理的。』",
    
    
    "English version:",
    "『Because there is no awareness within, it cannot be established 『within』. Body and mind perceive each other, considering it righteous to be 『outside』 is unreasonable. Now, because of mutual perception, it is said that there is no seeing 『within』. Then, should (the mind) be in the middle?』",
    
    "Following the previous text, the mind is not 『within』, so there is nothing seen 『within』; it is also not 『outside』, so the 『outside』 cannot perceive each other. Now it is said that there is no awareness 『within』, establishing that there is no seeing 『within』, while the body and mind perceive each other, revealing that the 『outside』 is unreasonable. This means that (the mind) should be in the root and dust.",
    
    "Two, Exhaustively Investigating Not Being in the Middle",
    
    "The Buddha said, 『You say in the middle, this 『middle』 must not be confused, not without location. Now you investigate this 『middle』, where is this 『middle』? Is it in the 『place』 (dust)? Or is it in the 『body』 (root)? If it is in the 『body』, then being on the 『edge』 is not the 『middle』, being in the 『middle』 is the same as being 『within』.』",
    
    "『Place』 refers to dust, 『body』 refers to root. Here, the root and dust are investigated separately, and below, they are investigated together to question that the 『middle』 has no self-nature. The body has a middle and an edge, so it is said that being on the 『edge』 is not the 『middle』, being in the 『middle』 is the same as being 『within』. This is first investigating the root.",
    
    "『If it is in the 『place』, then is it 『having something to represent』, or 『having nothing to represent』? 『Having nothing to represent』 is the same as having nothing, 『having something to represent』 has no fixed standard. Why? For example, when a person sets up a marker, when the marker is the 『middle』, looking from the east is the west, looking from the south becomes the north. Since the nature of the marker is confused, the mind should also be chaotic.』",
    
    "『Represent』 is to set up things to show the 『middle』. East, west, south, and north, what is seen is different, so what is set up has no fixed standard. 『The mind should also be chaotic』 means that there is nothing to take from the 『middle』.",
    
    "Ananda (one of the ten principal disciples of the Buddha) said, 『The 『middle』 I am talking about is not these two kinds. Just as the World-Honored One (a title of respect for Shakyamuni Buddha) said, the eye and form are the conditions for the arising of eye-consciousness. The eye has discrimination, the dust of form has no awareness, and consciousness arises between them, which is where the mind is.』",
    
    "The Yogācāra school (a school of Buddhism, also known as the Consciousness-only school) distinguishes the conditions for the arising of root, dust, and consciousness, which is not the ultimate truth. Ananda recognizes (eye) consciousness as the mind, already in a state of confusion, and further believes that (the mind) is in the root and dust, which is even more erroneous.",
    
    "The Buddha said, 『If your mind is in the root and dust, does the substance of this mind combine the two, root and dust, or does it not combine the two?』",
    
    "Using combining and not combining the two to exhaustively investigate that the mind is not in the root and dust, so that Ananda can awaken himself. It means that there is no mind substance in these two.",
    
    "『If it combines the two, then the objects are confused and unclear, and the object is not the awareness of the substance, then it becomes two opposing sides. How can it be said to be the 『middle』?』",
    
    "『Object』 refers to dust, 『substance』 refers to root. One has awareness, one has no awareness, so it is said to be confused and unclear. Awareness is not non-awareness, non-awareness is not awareness, so it is said to be two opposing sides. If the two sides are opposed, then the 『middle』 has nothing to represent.",
    
    "『Combining the two cannot be established, neither knowing nor not knowing, then there is no substance, what form does the 『middle』 have? Therefore, it should be known that (the mind) should be in the middle, there is no such reason.』"
  ]
}

不成兼根。故非知。不成兼塵。故非不知。二義已非。失其所據。故曰即無體性。體性豈無。惟當自覺也上七在中間竟。

  △八一切無著。分二。初正執無著。

  阿難白佛言。世尊。我昔見佛與大目連須菩提富樓那舍利弗四大弟子。共轉法輪。常言覺知分別心性。既不在內。亦不在外。不在中間。俱無所在。一切無著。名之為心。則我無著。名為心不。

  金剛般若云。不住色生心。不住聲香味觸法生心。應無所住而生其心。彼無所住。即此一切無著也。不知而生其心一句著落。即以無所住為心。豈不錯會。

  △二窮非無著。

  佛告阿難。汝言覺知分別心性俱無在者。世間虛空水陸飛行諸所物象。名為一切。汝不著者。為在為無。

  目前一切現在。而所謂不著者。將以現在為有為無。此明不識本心。而欲一切無著。不可得也。世尊徴心所在。阿難不能自覺。即使一切無著。而於當下發明之旨。遠若霄壤。而況能所終不能相奪耶。下意益見。

  無則同於龜毛兔角。云何不著。有不著者。不可名無。無相則無。非無則相。相有則在。云何無著。是故應知一切無著名覺知心。無有是處。

  龜毛兔角。言畢竟無也。承上汝不著者為在為無。無則同於兔角。何用不著。既有不著之相。豈無一切之心。故曰有不著者。不可名無也。夫心境不能互無。相見終非獨有。故又反覆推明曰。無相則無。非無則相。相有則在。云何無著。若能發明自心。則萬象森羅。隨所對現。不落有無。不則心外有法。茫然兩頭

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "不成兼根,所以不是『知』(jnana,智慧)。不成兼塵,所以不是『不知』。『知』與『不知』這兩種意義都已經不成立,失去了它的依據,所以說它『即無體性』。體性難道真的沒有嗎?只有應當自己去覺悟啊!以上七種關於『在中間』的推論完畢。",
    
    "△八、一切無著。分為兩部分。首先,正面執著于『無著』。",
    
    "阿難(Ananda,佛陀十大弟子之一)對佛說:『世尊,我過去看見佛與大目連(Mahamaudgalyayana,佛陀十大弟子之一)、須菩提(Subhuti,佛陀十大弟子之一)、富樓那(Purna,佛陀十大弟子之一)、舍利弗(Sariputra,佛陀十大弟子之一)這四大弟子,共同轉法輪(Dharmacakra,佛法之輪),常常說覺知分別的心性,既不在內,也不在外,不在中間,完全沒有所在,一切都無所執著,稱之為『心』。那麼我無所執著,可以稱之為『心』嗎?』",
    
    "《金剛般若經》(Vajracchedika Prajnaparamita Sutra)說:『不住色生心,不住聲香味觸法生心,應無所住而生其心。』那『無所住』,就是這『一切無著』。不瞭解而生起『其心』一句的著落,就以『無所住』為『心』,豈不是完全錯會了?",
    
    "△二、窮究『非無著』。",
    
    "佛告訴阿難:『你說覺知分別的心性完全沒有所在。世間的虛空、水陸、飛行等各種物象,名為『一切』。你所說的『不著』,是在還是無?』",
    
    "眼前一切都是現在,而所謂『不著』,是將現在的存在看作是有還是無?這說明不認識本心,而想要一切都無所執著,是不可能得到的。世尊追問心在哪裡,阿難不能自己覺悟,即使說一切無所執著,對於當下發明本心的旨意,也相差遙遠。更何況能與所終究不能互相取代呢?下面的意思更加明顯。",
    
    "『無』就等同於龜毛兔角,怎麼能說『不著』?『有』不著,就不能稱之為『無』。沒有相就沒有,不是沒有就有相。有相就在,怎麼能說『無著』?所以應當知道以一切無著來稱呼覺知心,是沒有道理的。",
    
    "龜毛兔角,是說畢竟沒有。承接上面『你所說的「不著」,是在還是無?』,『無』就等同於兔角,哪裡需要『不著』?既然有『不著』的相,難道沒有一切的心嗎?所以說『有不著者,不可名無』。心與境不能互相消滅,相見最終不是單獨存在。所以又反覆推明說:『無相則無,非無則相,相有則在,云何無著?』如果能夠發明自心,那麼萬象森羅,隨著所對之境而顯現,不落入有無的分別。否則心外有法,茫然不知所措。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "It does not combine with the root, therefore it is not 'jnana' (wisdom). It does not combine with the dust, therefore it is not 'non-knowing'. The two meanings of 'knowing' and 'non-knowing' are already untenable, losing their basis, so it is said that it 'immediately has no inherent nature'. Does inherent nature really not exist? One should only awaken to it oneself! The above seven arguments about 'being in the middle' are completed.",
    
    "△8. Non-attachment to everything. Divided into two parts. First, directly clinging to 'non-attachment'.",
    
    "Ananda (one of the Buddha's ten great disciples) said to the Buddha: 'World Honored One, in the past I saw the Buddha with the four great disciples Mahamaudgalyayana (one of the Buddha's ten great disciples), Subhuti (one of the Buddha's ten great disciples), Purna (one of the Buddha's ten great disciples), and Sariputra (one of the Buddha's ten great disciples), jointly turning the Dharma wheel (Dharmacakra, the wheel of Dharma), often saying that the nature of the mind that knows and distinguishes is neither inside nor outside, nor in the middle, completely without location, and everything is without attachment, called the 'mind'. Then, can my non-attachment be called the 'mind'?'",
    
    "The Vajracchedika Prajnaparamita Sutra says: 'Not dwelling in form to produce the mind, not dwelling in sound, smell, taste, touch, or dharma to produce the mind, one should produce the mind without dwelling anywhere.' That 'not dwelling' is this 'non-attachment to everything'. Not understanding the implication of the phrase 'to produce the mind', and taking 'non-dwelling' as the 'mind', isn't that a complete misunderstanding?",
    
    "△2. Exhaustively investigating 'non-non-attachment'.",
    
    "The Buddha told Ananda: 'You say that the nature of the mind that knows and distinguishes has no location at all. The various objects in the world, such as emptiness, water, land, flying, etc., are called 'everything'. What you call 'non-attachment', is it existent or non-existent?'",
    
    "Everything before your eyes is present, and what is called 'non-attachment', do you regard the present existence as being or non-being? This shows that not recognizing the original mind, and wanting to be without attachment to everything, is impossible. The World Honored One asks where the mind is, and Ananda cannot awaken to it himself. Even if he says that he is without attachment to everything, he is far from the meaning of directly revealing the original mind. Moreover, how can the subject and object ultimately replace each other? The following meaning is even clearer.",
    
    "'Non-existence' is the same as turtle hair and rabbit horns, how can you say 'non-attachment'? If 'existence' is non-attached, then it cannot be called 'non-existence'. Without form, there is nothing; if it is not non-existent, then there is form. If there is form, then it exists; how can you say 'non-attachment'? Therefore, you should know that it is unreasonable to call the knowing mind 'non-attachment to everything'.",
    
    "Turtle hair and rabbit horns mean that it is completely non-existent. Continuing from above, 'What you call 「non-attachment」, is it existent or non-existent?', 'Non-existence' is the same as rabbit horns, where is the need for 'non-attachment'? Since there is the form of 'non-attachment', how can there not be the mind of everything? Therefore, it is said that 'if there is non-attachment, it cannot be called non-existence'. The mind and the environment cannot mutually annihilate each other, and seeing each other is ultimately not a solitary existence. Therefore, it is repeatedly explained: 'Without form, there is nothing; if it is not non-existent, then there is form; if there is form, then it exists; how can you say 'non-attachment'?' If one can reveal one's own mind, then the myriad phenomena will appear according to the environment, without falling into the distinction of existence and non-existence. Otherwise, there is Dharma outside the mind, and one is at a loss."
  ]
}

。著與無著。皆為剩義矣。

  自無明發業而後。此心久已不安本位矣。所有見性。黏色而發。未發懵然。發已茫然。當發紛然。不經一回窮盡。宜乎其不能自返。所以必藉了緣也。住在身內。此眾生通見。身外之疑。人皆謂拙。其以心包太虛。一切有情無情。均在容現。此種見解。幾希其不在身外者鮮矣。潛根竅穴。猶乎在內。思惟之體。隨合而有。亦同在外。在中無著。內外無從。真可謂業識茫茫。無本可據。吾人於此。能不聳然。

  上初徴心竟。

  △二顯根見。分十一。初恨多聞求詣真際。

  爾時阿難在大眾中。即從座起。偏袒右肩。右膝著地。合掌恭敬。而白佛言。我是如來最小之弟。蒙佛慈愛。雖今出家。猶恃嬌憐。所以多聞。未得無漏。不能折伏娑毗羅咒。為彼所轉。溺於淫舍。當由不知真際所詣。惟愿世尊大慈哀愍。開示我等奢摩他路。令諸闡提隳彌戾車。作是語已。五體投地。及諸大眾傾渴翹佇。欽聞示誨。

  真際即常住真心。欲詣常住真心。必由奢摩他路。涅槃明奢摩他五義。一能滅。能滅煩惱結故。二能調。能調諸根故。三寂靜。三業寂靜故。四遠離。遠離五欲故。五能消。能消貪等故。圓覺翻寂靜。可以義括。一闡翻信。提翻不具。亦云斷善根。隳壞也。彌戾車翻惡見。

  △二放光表根性圓明。

  爾時世尊從其面門放種種光。其光晃曜。如百千日。普佛世界六種震動。如是十方微塵國土。一時開現。佛之威神。令諸世界合成一界。其世界中所有一切諸大菩薩。皆住本國。

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "執著于『有』或『無』,都是多餘的理解。",
    
    "自從無明(avidyā,佛教中的根本煩惱,指對事物真相的迷惑和無知)引發業力之後,這顆心早已無法安住于原本的位置。所有的見性,都是依附於色(rūpa,物質現象)而生髮。未生髮時一片懵懂,生髮后又茫然無知,生髮之時更是紛亂不已。如果不經歷一番徹底的窮盡,自然無法迴歸本源。所以必須藉助了緣(pratyaya,因緣條件)。認為心住在身內,這是眾生的普遍見解。懷疑心在身外,人們都認為是愚笨的想法。如果認為心能包容整個宇宙,一切有情(sentient beings,有感覺和意識的生命)無情(non-sentient beings,沒有感覺和意識的物質)都包含在其中,這種見解很少有不落在身外的。潛藏在根身竅穴之中,仍然如同在內。思惟的本體,隨因緣聚合而生,也如同在外。認為心在中無所執著,內外無從捉摸,真可謂業識(karma-vijñāna,由業力形成的意識)茫茫,無所依據。我們對此,怎能不感到震驚呢?",
    
    "以上是最初的提問,關於心的所在。",
    
    "△二是顯現根性的圓滿光明。分為十一部分。首先是感嘆多聞卻未能達到真際(bhūta-koṭi,真實的邊際,指事物最終的真實狀態)。",
    
    "當時,阿難(Ānanda,佛陀的十大弟子之一,以記憶力超群著稱)在大眾之中,立即從座位上站起,袒露右肩,右膝跪地,合掌恭敬,對佛陀說:『我是如來(Tathāgata,佛陀的稱號之一,意為「如實而來者」)最小的弟弟,蒙受佛陀的慈愛。雖然現在已經出家,仍然依賴著嬌慣和憐愛。所以雖然聽聞很多佛法,卻未能證得無漏(anāsrava,沒有煩惱的智慧)。不能夠折服娑毗羅咒(Śabira mantra,一種咒語),反而被它所控制,沉溺於淫舍之中。這應當是因為不知道真際所要到達的地方。只希望世尊(Bhagavān,佛陀的稱號之一,意為「世尊」)大慈大悲,哀憐我,為我們開示奢摩他(Śamatha,止,禪定的一種)之路,使那些闡提(icchantika,斷善根者)能夠摧毀彌戾車(mleccha,惡見者)。』說完這些話,五體投地。所有的大眾都傾心渴望,翹首期盼,恭敬地聽聞佛陀的教誨。",
    
    "真際就是常住真心(nitya-citta,永恒不變的真心)。想要到達常住真心,必須通過奢摩他之路。《涅槃經》闡明了奢摩他的五種含義:一、能夠滅除,能夠滅除煩惱結縛的緣故;二、能夠調伏,能夠調伏諸根的緣故;三、寂靜,身口意三業寂靜的緣故;四、遠離,遠離五欲的緣故;五、能夠消融,能夠消融貪婪等煩惱的緣故。《圓覺經》翻譯為寂靜,可以用這個含義來概括。一闡提翻譯為不信,提翻譯為不具足,也說是斷善根。隳是毀壞的意思。彌戾車翻譯為惡見。",
    
    "△二是佛陀從面門放光,象徵根性的圓滿光明。",
    
    "當時,世尊從面門放出種種光明,那光明閃耀,如同百千個太陽。整個佛世界發生了六種震動。像這樣,十方(指東、西、南、北、上、下、東南、東北、西南、西北十個方向)微塵數(極多的數量)的國土,一時都顯現出來。佛陀的威神之力,使得所有世界合成為一個世界。在這些世界中,所有一切的大菩薩(bodhisattva,發願普度眾生的修行者),都安住在自己的國土。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Attachment to 'being' or 'non-being' is superfluous understanding.",
    
    "Since ignorance (avidyā) initiated karma, this mind has long been unable to dwell in its original position. All perceptions arise dependent on form (rūpa). Before arising, there is bewilderment; after arising, there is confusion; and during arising, there is chaos. If it does not undergo a thorough exhaustion, it naturally cannot return to its source. Therefore, it must rely on conditions (pratyaya). The idea that the mind resides within the body is a common view among beings. Doubting that the mind is outside the body is considered foolish. If one believes that the mind encompasses the entire universe, and all sentient beings (sentient beings) and non-sentient things (non-sentient beings) are contained within it, such a view rarely avoids falling outside the body. Lurking in the root orifices is still like being inside. The substance of thought, arising with the aggregation of conditions, is also like being outside. To think that the mind is without attachment in the middle, and cannot be grasped inside or outside, it can truly be said that karmic consciousness (karma-vijñāna) is vast and without foundation. How can we not be alarmed by this?",
    
    "The above is the initial question about the location of the mind.",
    
    "△ Two, revealing the perfect light of the root nature. Divided into eleven parts. First, lamenting that much learning has failed to reach the true realm (bhūta-koṭi).",
    
    "At that time, Ānanda, among the great assembly, immediately rose from his seat, bared his right shoulder, knelt on his right knee, joined his palms respectfully, and said to the Buddha: 'I am the youngest brother of the Tathāgata, receiving the Buddha's loving-kindness. Although I have now left home, I still rely on indulgence and affection. Therefore, although I have heard much Dharma, I have not attained the unconditioned (anāsrava). I am unable to subdue the Śabira mantra, but am instead controlled by it, indulging in the house of lust. This must be because I do not know where the true realm is to be reached. I only hope that the Bhagavan, with great compassion, will have mercy on me and reveal to us the path of Śamatha, so that those icchantikas can destroy the mlecchas.' After saying these words, he prostrated himself with five limbs to the ground. All the assembly were eagerly longing, craning their necks in anticipation, respectfully listening to the Buddha's teachings.",
    
    "The true realm is the eternal true mind (nitya-citta). To reach the eternal true mind, one must go through the path of Śamatha. The Nirvana Sutra explains the five meanings of Śamatha: First, it can extinguish, because it can extinguish the bonds of affliction; second, it can tame, because it can tame the senses; third, it is tranquil, because the three karmas of body, speech, and mind are tranquil; fourth, it is detachment, because it is detached from the five desires; fifth, it can dissolve, because it can dissolve greed and other afflictions. The Śūraṅgama Sūtra translates it as tranquility, which can be used to summarize the meaning. Icchantika is translated as unbelieving, and ti is translated as incomplete, also said to be cutting off the roots of goodness. HUI means to destroy. Mleccha is translated as evil views.",
    
    "△ Two, the Buddha emits light from his face, symbolizing the perfect light of the root nature.",
    
    "At that time, the Bhagavan emitted various kinds of light from his face, that light shone brightly, like hundreds of thousands of suns. The entire Buddha world experienced six kinds of earthquakes. In this way, countless lands like dust motes in the ten directions (referring to the ten directions: east, west, south, north, up, down, southeast, northeast, southwest, northwest) were revealed at once. The Buddha's majestic power caused all the worlds to merge into one world. In these worlds, all the great Bodhisattvas were dwelling in their own lands."
  ]
}

合掌承聽。

  前放頂光。表體無說。此放面門。表根性圓明內外無虧也。佛說妙法。有大因緣。則諸天魔梵。人與非人。或喜或駭。身心震動。故地應之。六者聲形吼擊起涌。一時開現合成一界者。國土本自開合。眾生迷隔。佛以威神令之暫見。故知本國無異十方。惟大菩薩達法源底。還住本國。見聞不易。

  將示二種根本。而先放光明。普佛世界。十方國土。一時開現。合成一界。諸大菩薩皆住本國。合掌承聽。蓋示生佛同一身土。而一則開合自由。一則根塵隔絕。縱觀廣狹自異。圓滯攸分。而身猶此身。土猶此土。所謂諸大菩薩皆住本國。合掌承聽。知神化之忽移。悟乖違之豈實。不妨見還目觀。色同對現也。雜華善財童子至彌勒樓閣。彌勒菩薩彈指門開。命善財入。入已還閉。見其樓閣廣博無量。一切宮殿門闥。七寶嚴飾。所有過現未來諸佛菩薩。名字種族。修行壽命。無不備悉。自見其身。皆在其前。恭敬圍繞。及遍觀已。彌勒菩薩即攝神力。彈指出聲。告善財言。善男子起。法性如是。如是自性。如幻如夢。如影如像。悉不成就。於是善財童子。自見其身。還在本處。夫善財所見。與此何異。及其起已。亦猶還住本國。合掌承聽。故知法性如幻。聞見匪他。迷悟相傾。根性不壞。惟當自信耳。

  △三示二種根本以別迷悟。

  佛告阿難。一切眾生。從無始來。種種顛倒。業種自然。如惡叉聚。諸修行人。不能得成無上菩提。乃至別成聲聞緣覺。及成外道諸天魔王及魔眷屬。皆由不知二種根本。錯亂修習。

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "合掌恭敬地接受並聆聽。",
    
    "先前釋放頂光,表示本體的無言之教。現在從面門釋放光明,表示根性的圓滿光明,內外沒有虧缺。佛陀宣說微妙之法,具有重大的因緣,因此諸天、魔、梵天,以及人與非人等眾生,或者歡喜,或者驚駭,身心震動,所以大地也隨之響應。這六種震動,包括聲音、形體、吼叫、撞擊、涌起,一時之間開顯併合成一個境界。國土本來就是開合變化的,眾生因為迷惑而有所隔閡。佛陀以威神之力,使他們暫時見到真相。因此可知,我們的本國與十方國土並沒有什麼不同,只有大菩薩才能通達法源的根本,仍然安住在本國,見聞沒有改變。",
    
    "佛陀將要開示兩種根本,首先釋放光明,普照佛世界,十方國土,一時之間開顯併合成一個境界,諸大菩薩都安住在本國,合掌恭敬地接受並聆聽。這表明眾生與佛陀的身土是同一的,而一個可以開合自如,一個則被根塵所隔絕。縱然觀看的廣狹不同,圓融與滯礙有所區分,但身還是這個身,土還是這個土。這就是所謂的諸大菩薩都安住在本國,合掌恭敬地接受並聆聽。明白神妙變化的迅速,領悟乖違差異並非真實。不妨礙見還目觀,色同對現。如同《雜華經》中,善財童子到達彌勒菩薩的樓閣,彌勒菩薩彈指,門就打開了,讓善財童子進入。進入之後門又關閉了,善財童子見到樓閣廣博無量,一切宮殿門闥,都用七寶裝飾,所有過去、現在、未來諸佛菩薩的名字、種族、修行、壽命,沒有不詳盡知曉的。善財童子自己也見到自己的身影,都在諸佛菩薩之前,恭敬圍繞。全部觀看完畢后,彌勒菩薩就收回神力,彈指發出聲音,告訴善財童子說:『善男子,起來吧,法性就是這樣,這樣的自性,如幻如夢,如影如像,一切都不是真實成就的。』於是善財童子,自己見到自己的身影,還在原來的地方。善財童子所見到的,與現在的情況有什麼不同呢?等到他起身之後,也就像仍然安住在本國,合掌恭敬地接受並聆聽。所以知道法性如幻,聞見並非外來的,迷惑與覺悟相互影響,根性並沒有損壞,只要相信自己就可以了。",
    
    "△三、開示兩種根本,用以區分迷惑與覺悟。",
    
    "佛陀告訴阿難(Ananda,佛陀的十大弟子之一):一切眾生,從無始以來,種種顛倒,業力的種子自然而然地聚集在一起,就像惡叉聚一樣。諸位修行人,不能夠成就無上菩提(Anuttara-samyak-sambodhi,無上正等正覺),甚至轉而成就聲聞(Śrāvaka,聽聞佛陀教誨而證悟的修行者)、緣覺(Pratyekabuddha,不依師教,自己證悟的修行者),以及成為外道、諸天魔王以及魔的眷屬,都是因為不知道這兩種根本,錯亂地修習的緣故。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Join your palms and listen respectfully.",
    
    "Previously, the light was emitted from the crown of the head, representing the unspoken teaching of the essence. Now, the light is emitted from the facial gate, representing the perfect and bright nature of the roots, without any deficiency inside or outside. The Buddha speaks the wonderful Dharma, which has great causes and conditions, so the gods, demons, Brahma, and beings both human and non-human, either rejoice or are terrified, their bodies and minds shaken, and thus the earth responds. These six kinds of vibrations, including sound, form, roar, strike, rise, all manifest and merge into one realm at once. The land is originally open and closed, but beings are separated by delusion. The Buddha uses his divine power to allow them to see the truth temporarily. Therefore, it can be known that our own country is no different from the ten directions, only the great Bodhisattvas can understand the root of the Dharma source and still reside in their own country, their seeing and hearing unchanged.",
    
    "The Buddha is about to reveal the two fundamental roots, first emitting light, illuminating the Buddha world, the lands of the ten directions, all manifesting and merging into one realm at once, all the great Bodhisattvas reside in their own country, joining their palms and listening respectfully. This shows that the body and land of beings and Buddhas are the same, but one can open and close freely, while the other is separated by the roots and dust. Even though the breadth of viewing is different, and the distinction between perfect integration and stagnation is made, the body is still this body, and the land is still this land. This is what is meant by all the great Bodhisattvas residing in their own country, joining their palms and listening respectfully. Understand the swiftness of divine transformation, and realize that the discrepancies and differences are not real. It does not hinder the seeing returning to the eyes, and the color appearing together. Just like in the *Avatamsaka Sutra*, Sudhana (Śreṣṭhidāraka, a youth who sought enlightenment) reached the pavilion of Maitreya (Maitreya, the future Buddha), Maitreya snapped his fingers and the door opened, allowing Sudhana to enter. After entering, the door closed again, and Sudhana saw that the pavilion was vast and boundless, all the palaces and gates were decorated with seven treasures, and all the names, lineages, practices, and lifespans of the Buddhas and Bodhisattvas of the past, present, and future were known in detail. Sudhana also saw his own figure, all before the Buddhas and Bodhisattvas, respectfully surrounding them. After viewing everything, Maitreya withdrew his divine power, snapped his fingers and made a sound, and told Sudhana: 'Good man, arise, the Dharma nature is like this, this nature is like a phantom, like a dream, like a shadow, like an image, everything is not truly achieved.' Then Sudhana saw his own figure, still in the original place. What is the difference between what Sudhana saw and the present situation? When he gets up, it is as if he is still residing in his own country, joining his palms and listening respectfully. Therefore, know that the Dharma nature is like a phantom, hearing and seeing are not external, delusion and enlightenment influence each other, the nature of the roots is not damaged, just believe in yourself.",
    
    "△3. Revealing the two fundamental roots to distinguish between delusion and enlightenment.",
    
    "The Buddha told Ananda (Ananda, one of the ten great disciples of the Buddha): All beings, from beginningless time, have various inversions, and the seeds of karma naturally gather together, like a cluster of Aksha. All practitioners cannot achieve Anuttara-samyak-sambodhi (Anuttara-samyak-sambodhi, unsurpassed perfect enlightenment), and even turn to achieve Śrāvaka (Śrāvaka, practitioners who attain enlightenment by hearing the Buddha's teachings), Pratyekabuddha (Pratyekabuddha, practitioners who attain enlightenment on their own without a teacher), and become heretics, heavenly demon kings, and the retinues of demons, all because they do not know these two fundamental roots and practice them in confusion."
  ]
}

猶如煮沙欲成嘉饌。縱經塵劫。終不能得。

  無始無明。熏習成種。故云業種。惡叉此云線貫珠。西域果名。三顆同蒂。喻惑業苦三。不相離也。聲聞悟明四諦。厭有為法。緣覺觀十二因緣。作流轉還滅二種觀。皆迷法界。與不入正教別有所循者。總名外道。圓覺云。知欲可厭。愛厭業道。舍惡樂善。復現人天。魔羅此云殺者。謂耽護欲境。惱害正修也。如來為此。特標二種根本。即在現前。開佛知見。學者所當憬然矣。劫此云長時。塵劫謂以微塵記彼劫數。

  云何二種。阿難。一者無始生死根本。則汝今者與諸眾生。用攀緣心為自性者。二者無始菩提涅槃元清凈體。則汝今者識精元明能生諸緣緣所遺者。由諸眾生遺此本明。雖終日行而不自覺。抂入諸趣。

  二種根本。皆自眾生現前指出。如日用動轉。與事物接。眾生無識。以為自性。此生死根本也。須知元是菩提涅槃清凈體性。不越現前分別明瞭。主張萬緣。任運緣生。徒自遺背。以此遺背。雖日在菩提涅槃之中。常自惺惺。常自懵懂。所謂佛性流轉也。菩提智果。涅槃斷果。此二果德。在藏識中。不與妄染相應。故曰元清凈體。是單指藏識真相。在動用中。謂之識精元明。為能肆應萬物。故曰能生諸緣。既在諸緣。不能自覺。故曰遺。遺即與攀緣無別矣。華嚴云。不了第一義諦。故名無明。無明即不自覺也。此不自覺。不唯眾生。凡在悟修。不與第一義相應。皆為不覺。不可不自省察耳。

  審知攀緣之心。與生緣之心。無二無別。止爭迷悟耳。迷則不能發揮

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "猶如煮沙子想要做成美味的食物。即使經過漫長的時間(塵劫),最終也是不可能得到的。",
    
    "從無始以來的無明(不知道真理),熏習形成了種子,所以叫做業種。惡叉(Aksha)在這裡指的是用線穿起來的珠子。是西域的一種果實的名字,三顆果實長在同一個蒂上,比喻迷惑、業和苦這三者是不可分離的。聲聞通過領悟苦、集、滅、道四諦,厭惡有為法。緣覺觀察十二因緣,做順流和逆流兩種觀察。他們都迷惑於法界。那些不進入正教,另外有所遵循的人,總稱為外道。《圓覺經》說:『知道慾望是可厭惡的,愛和厭惡都是業道的體現,捨棄惡行而行善,又會顯現人天果報。』魔羅(Mara)在這裡指的是殺害者,指貪戀守護慾望的境界,惱害正當的修行。如來因此特別標出兩種根本,就在眼前,開啟佛的知見,是學習的人應當醒悟的。劫(Kalpa)在這裡指的是很長的時間,塵劫指的是用微塵來計算劫數。",
    
    "什麼是這兩種根本?阿難,第一種是無始生死根本,就是你和現在的眾生,以攀緣心作為自己的本性。第二種是無始菩提涅槃原本清凈的本體,就是你現在的識精元明,能夠產生各種因緣,卻被因緣所遺忘的那個。由於眾生遺忘了這個原本的光明,即使整天都在運用它,卻不自覺,白白地墮入各種趣向(輪迴)。",
    
    "這兩種根本,都是從眾生眼前指出來的。就像日常的動作和運轉,與事物接觸,眾生沒有認識,把它當作自己的本性,這就是生死的根本。要知道原本是菩提涅槃清凈的體性,不超出眼前分別明瞭,主張萬緣,任憑因緣生起,只是自己遺背了它。因為這個遺背,即使每天都處在菩提涅槃之中,常常是清醒的,常常又是懵懂的,這就是所謂的佛性流轉。菩提是智慧的果實,涅槃是斷滅煩惱的果實。這兩種果德,在藏識中,不與虛妄的染污相應,所以叫做原本清凈的本體。這是單單指藏識的真相。在動用中,叫做識精元明,能夠充分地應對萬物,所以叫做能夠產生各種因緣。既然處在各種因緣中,不能自覺,所以叫做遺忘。遺忘就和攀緣沒有區別了。《華嚴經》說:『不瞭解第一義諦,所以叫做無明。』無明就是不自覺。這個不自覺,不只是眾生,凡是在悟修中,不與第一義相應的,都是不覺,不可以不自我反省。",
    
    "仔細地瞭解攀緣的心,和生起因緣的心,沒有兩樣,只是在于迷惑和覺悟罷了。迷惑了就不能發揮。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "It's like trying to cook a delicious meal by boiling sand. Even after countless eons (dust-like kalpas), it will never be achieved.",
    
    "From beginningless ignorance (not knowing the truth), habitual tendencies are formed into seeds, hence the term 'karma seeds.' Aksha here refers to beads strung together by a thread. It is the name of a fruit from the Western Regions, with three fruits growing on the same stem, symbolizing that delusion, karma, and suffering are inseparable. Sravakas, through understanding the Four Noble Truths (suffering, its cause, its cessation, and the path to its cessation), detest conditioned phenomena. Pratyekabuddhas observe the Twelve Links of Dependent Origination, contemplating both forward and reverse sequences. They are all deluded about the Dharma Realm. Those who do not enter the orthodox teaching and follow other paths are collectively called heretics (外道). The *Surangama Sutra* says: 'Knowing desire is detestable, love and hate are the path of karma; abandoning evil and embracing good, one manifests again in the realms of humans and gods.' Mara here refers to the killer, meaning clinging to and protecting the realm of desire, harming proper cultivation. Therefore, the Tathagata specifically points out the two fundamental roots, which are right before us, opening the Buddha's knowledge and vision, which is what learners should awaken to. Kalpa here refers to a very long time; dust-like kalpas refer to counting kalpas with dust particles.",
    
    "What are these two fundamental roots? Ananda, the first is the beginningless root of birth and death, which is your and all beings' nature of clinging to external conditions with a grasping mind. The second is the beginningless, originally pure essence of Bodhi and Nirvana, which is your present awareness, the fundamentally bright and clear essence of consciousness, capable of generating all conditions, yet forgotten by those conditions. Because beings forget this original brightness, even though they use it all day long, they are unaware, and vainly fall into various destinies (of reincarnation).",
    
    "These two fundamental roots are pointed out from right before all beings. Like daily actions and movements, and contact with things, beings are without awareness, and take it as their own nature; this is the root of birth and death. Know that originally it is the pure nature of Bodhi and Nirvana, not exceeding the present discriminating clarity, asserting all conditions, allowing conditions to arise spontaneously, but only abandoning it oneself. Because of this abandonment, even though one is daily within Bodhi and Nirvana, one is often awake, and often confused; this is what is called the flow of Buddha-nature. Bodhi is the fruit of wisdom, Nirvana is the fruit of the cessation of afflictions. These two virtues of fruit are in the Alaya consciousness (藏識), not corresponding to false defilements, therefore it is called the originally pure essence. This is simply referring to the true aspect of the Alaya consciousness. In its functioning, it is called the fundamentally bright and clear essence of consciousness, capable of fully responding to all things, therefore it is called capable of generating all conditions. Since it is in all conditions, one cannot be self-aware, therefore it is called forgotten. Forgotten is no different from clinging. The *Avatamsaka Sutra* says: 'Not understanding the first principle, therefore it is called ignorance.' Ignorance is not being self-aware. This lack of self-awareness is not only for beings, but all those in enlightenment and cultivation, not corresponding to the first principle, are all without awareness, and cannot but self-reflect.",
    
    "Carefully understand that the mind of clinging and the mind of arising conditions are no different, it only lies in delusion and enlightenment. If one is deluded, one cannot develop it."
  ]
}

諸緣。為緣所轉。遂使識精元明常在終日而當下錯過。是可知悟者之日用矣。龐居士云。日用事無別。惟吾自偶諧。偶諧之旨。當人自知。未易指注也。

  △四緣見徴心。

  阿難。汝今欲知奢摩他路。愿出生死。今復問汝。即時如來舉金色臂。屈五輪指。語阿難言。汝今見不。阿難言。見。佛言。汝何所見。阿難言。我見如來舉臂屈指為光明拳。曜我心目。佛言。汝將誰見。阿難言。我與大眾同將眼見。

  前請欲詣真際。求示奢摩他路。故今牒示也。五輪指觀佛三昧經云。一指端有十二輪現。輪端各有卍字。卍字點間。有千輻輪相。如來舉臂屈指。語阿難言。汝今見不。是第一直指也。舉臂屈指。現為阿難所見。故又曰。汝何所見。是第二直指也。既昧臂指。復提見者。故又曰。汝將誰見。是第三直指也。而阿難乃曰。我與大眾同將眼見。已為當下錯過。而復以見屬眼。到此始供。

  佛告阿難。汝今答我。如來屈指為光明拳。曜汝心目。汝目可見。以何為心。當我拳曜。阿難言。如來現今徴心所在。而我以心推窮尋逐。即能推者我將為心。

  汝目可見。而不自認。以何為心。而當拳曜。細味斯語。是猶欲即其迷以指悟也。不能於此豁然。而乃才起推尋。誤當心性。雖非別有。前後茫然。不免更費商量耳。

  △五指能推有體。分三。初斥能推。

  佛言。咄。阿難。此非汝心。阿難矍然避座。合掌起立白佛。此非我心。當名何等。佛告阿難。此是前塵虛妄相想。惑汝真性。由汝無始至於今生。認賊

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "諸緣(各種因緣)。被因緣所牽動。於是使得識精(能識別的精妙心性)本來是元明(圓滿光明)的,卻常常整天都在當下錯過。由此可知開悟者是如何運用日常的。龐居士說:『日常事無別,惟吾自偶諧。』(日常生活與常人無異,只是我偶爾與道相合。)『偶諧』的旨意,當事人自己知道,不容易用言語來指明。",
    
    "△四緣見徴心(四種因緣顯現,以徵驗真心)。",
    
    "阿難(釋迦牟尼佛的弟子)。你現在想要知道奢摩他(止息)的道路,願意脫離生死。現在我再問你。當時如來舉起金色的手臂,彎曲五輪指(五根手指),對阿難說:『你現在看見了嗎?』阿難說:『看見了。』佛說:『你看見了什麼?』阿難說:『我看見如來舉起手臂彎曲手指,成為光明拳,照耀我的心和眼睛。』佛說:『你用什麼看見的?』阿難說:『我和大眾都用眼睛看見的。』",
    
    "前面阿難請求想要到達真際(真實的邊際),請求指示奢摩他(止息)的道路,所以現在佛詳細地指示他。《五輪指觀佛三昧經》說:『一指端有十二輪顯現,輪端各有卍字(吉祥的符號),卍字點間,有千輻輪相。』如來舉起手臂彎曲手指,對阿難說:『你現在看見了嗎?』這是第一重直接指明。舉起手臂彎曲手指,顯現給阿難看見,所以又說:『你看見了什麼?』這是第二重直接指明。既然不明白手臂手指,又提起能見之性,所以又說:『你用什麼看見的?』而阿難卻說:『我和大眾都用眼睛看見的。』已經是在當下錯過了,而且又把見性歸於眼睛,到這裡才開始提供(機會)。",
    
    "佛告訴阿難:『你現在回答我,如來彎曲手指成為光明拳,照耀你的心和眼睛,你的眼睛可以看見,用什麼作為心,來感受我的拳頭照耀?』阿難說:『如來現在征問心在哪裡,而我用心去推究尋找,能夠推究的那個,我就把它當作心。』",
    
    "你的眼睛可以看見,卻不自己認識,用什麼作為心,來感受拳頭的照耀?仔細體會這句話,這就像想要就著他的迷惑來指引他開悟。不能在這裡豁然開朗,卻才開始推究尋找,錯誤地把推究的念頭當作心性。雖然心性並非別的東西,但前後茫然,免不了要再費一番商量。",
    
    "△五指能推有體(五指能夠推究,說明它有自體)。分三部分。首先,駁斥能推。",
    
    "佛說:『咄(呵斥聲)!阿難,這不是你的心。』阿難驚懼地離開座位,合掌站立對佛說:『這不是我的心,應當叫什麼?』佛告訴阿難:『這是前塵(過去經歷的塵境)虛妄的相想(虛假的想像),迷惑你的真性(真實的本性)。由於你從無始以來直到今生,認賊(認賊為子)。'"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "All conditions (various causes and conditions). Being turned by conditions. Consequently, the essence of consciousness (the subtle nature of discerning) is originally complete and bright, yet it is often missed in the present moment all day long. From this, one can know how the enlightened use their daily lives. Layman Pang said: 'Daily affairs are no different, only I occasionally harmonize with the Tao.' The meaning of 'occasional harmony' is known by the person involved, and it is not easy to point out with words.",
    
    "△ Four Conditions Manifest to Verify the Mind.",
    
    "Ananda (Shakyamuni Buddha's disciple). Now you want to know the path of Shamatha (cessation), willing to escape from birth and death. Now I will ask you again. At that time, the Tathagata raised his golden arm and bent his five fingers, saying to Ananda: 'Do you see it now?' Ananda said: 'I see it.' The Buddha said: 'What do you see?' Ananda said: 'I see the Tathagata raising his arm and bending his fingers, becoming a fist of light, illuminating my mind and eyes.' The Buddha said: 'With what do you see?' Ananda said: 'I and the assembly all see with our eyes.'",
    
    "Earlier, Ananda requested to reach the true realm (the true boundary), requesting instructions on the path of Shamatha (cessation), so now the Buddha explains it in detail to him. The *Five Wheel Finger Contemplation Buddha Samadhi Sutra* says: 'At the tip of one finger, twelve wheels appear, and at the end of each wheel, there is a Swastika (an auspicious symbol), and between the points of the Swastika, there is an image of a thousand-spoked wheel.' The Tathagata raised his arm and bent his fingers, saying to Ananda: 'Do you see it now?' This is the first direct pointing. Raising his arm and bending his fingers, appearing for Ananda to see, so he also said: 'What do you see?' This is the second direct pointing. Since he does not understand the arm and fingers, he also brings up the nature of seeing, so he also said: 'With what do you see?' But Ananda said: 'I and the assembly all see with our eyes.' He has already missed it in the present moment, and also attributes the nature of seeing to the eyes, only now beginning to provide (an opportunity).",
    
    "The Buddha told Ananda: 'Now answer me, the Tathagata bends his fingers into a fist of light, illuminating your mind and eyes, your eyes can see, what do you use as the mind to perceive my fist illuminating?' Ananda said: 'The Tathagata is now questioning where the mind is, and I use my mind to investigate and search, that which is able to investigate, I will take it as the mind.'",
    
    "Your eyes can see, but you do not recognize yourself, what do you use as the mind to perceive the fist illuminating? Carefully contemplate this sentence, it is like wanting to guide him to enlightenment based on his confusion. Unable to suddenly understand here, but only then beginning to investigate and search, mistakenly taking the thought of investigation as the nature of the mind. Although the nature of the mind is not something separate, but being confused before and after, it is inevitable to spend more discussion.",
    
    "△ Five Fingers Can Investigate, Explaining It Has a Self-Substance. Divided into three parts. First, refuting the ability to investigate.",
    
    "The Buddha said: 'Tush (a sound of rebuke)! Ananda, this is not your mind.' Ananda was startled and left his seat, clasping his hands and standing up, saying to the Buddha: 'If this is not my mind, what should it be called?' The Buddha told Ananda: 'This is the false appearance of past dust (past experiences), deluding your true nature (true nature). Because you have recognized a thief (mistaking a thief for your son) from beginningless time until this life.'"
  ]
}

為子。失汝元常。故受輪轉。

  相即前塵。攬彼前塵。成於分別。曰想。此想不真。故云虛妄。迷中執此。誤為元常。故云惑汝真性也。七處所酬。皆屬所推。今才起即覺。乃是能推。宗鏡云。能推是妄心。皆有緣慮之用。然非真心。又云妄心是真心上影像。愚謂此皆形容其迷中。未能當下覺了。號之緣慮。目為影像。而非別有真心在緣慮之先。影像之外耳。即世尊斥為前塵虛妄相想。亦責其不能當下覺了。觀下經云。我非敕汝執為非心。益知迷則即子為賊。悟則即賊為子。無第二人也。

  △二求開示。

  阿難白佛言。世尊。我佛寵弟。心愛佛故。令我出家。我心何獨供養如來。乃至遍歷恒沙國土。承事諸佛。及善知識。發大勇猛。行諸一切難行法事。皆用此心。縱令謗法。永退善根。亦因此心。若此發明不是心者。我乃無心。同諸土木。離此覺知。更無所有。云何如來說此非心。我實驚怖。兼此大眾無不疑惑。惟垂大悲。開示未悟。

  承事諸佛。及善知識。行諸難行法事。此乃發菩提心邊事。涅槃云。菩提之心。實非佛性。是無常故。乃至相續不斷。名為修道。猶如燈𦦨。雖唸唸滅。亦能破暗。菩提之心。亦復如是。故知在迷位中。亦能發菩提心。既在迷位。未曾知歸。雖非別有。祇名菩提之心。不名真心常住也。即使謗法永退。祇名闡提。亦非別有。此涅槃所以許闡提當有佛性也。

  七處徴窮。一切攀緣。俱已頓盡。更承逼拶。才起推尋。忽然磕著。慶喜於此。若能瓦解冰消。縱復千咄萬咄。直是無人

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "爲了兒子(子)的緣故。失去了你的元常(指原本常住不變的真心)。所以才承受輪迴流轉。",
    
    "相,就是之前的塵境(前塵)。執取那些塵境,形成分別,就叫做『想』。這個『想』不是真實的,所以說是虛妄的。在迷惑中執著於此,錯誤地認為是元常(真心)。所以說迷惑了你的真性。之前的七處征心,都屬於所推求的對象。現在才剛剛生起覺察,才是能推求的主體。《宗鏡錄》說:『能推求的是妄心,都有緣慮的作用。』然而不是真心。又說:『妄心是真心上的影像。』我認為這些都是形容在迷惑之中,未能當下覺悟,才稱之為緣慮,看作是影像。而不是另外有一個真心在緣慮之前,影像之外。即使世尊斥責為前塵虛妄的相想,也是責備其不能當下覺悟。看下面的經文說:『我不是命令你執著認為不是心。』更加知道迷惑了就認兒子(子)為強盜,覺悟了就認強盜為兒子(子),沒有第二個人。",
    
    "△二、請求開示。",
    
    "阿難(Ananda,佛陀的十大弟子之一,以記憶力超群著稱)對佛說:『世尊,我是佛的愛弟,因為心中愛慕佛的緣故,才讓我出家。我的心何止是供養如來(Tathagata,佛的稱號之一),乃至遍游恒河沙數國土,承事諸佛以及善知識(Kalyanamitra,指引人向善的良師益友),發大勇猛心,行諸一切難行的法事,都用這個心。縱然是誹謗佛法,永遠退失善根,也是因為這個心。如果這個發明不是心的話,我就沒有心了,如同那些土木一樣。離開這個覺知,就再也沒有什麼了。為什麼如來說這個不是心呢?我實在感到驚慌恐懼,而且這裡的大眾沒有不疑惑的。只希望您垂憐大悲,開示我們這些還沒有覺悟的人。』",
    
    "承事諸佛以及善知識,行諸難行的法事,這乃是發菩提心(Bodhicitta,覺悟之心)的事情。《涅槃經》說:『菩提之心,實際上不是佛性(Buddha-nature),因為是無常的緣故。』乃至相續不斷,叫做修道。猶如燈焰,雖然唸唸生滅,也能破除黑暗。菩提之心,也是這樣。所以知道在迷惑的地位中,也能發起菩提心。既然在迷惑的地位,未曾知道歸宿,雖然不是另外有一個,只叫做菩提之心,不叫做真心常住。即使誹謗佛法永遠退失,只叫做闡提(Icchantika,斷善根的人),也不是另外有一個。這就是《涅槃經》之所以允許闡提當有佛性的原因。",
    
    "七處征心,一切攀緣,都已經頓然窮盡。更承受逼迫追問,才剛剛生起推尋,忽然磕著。阿難(Ananda)對此感到慶幸。如果能像瓦解冰消一樣,縱然再三呵斥,也實在是無人可得。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "For the sake of the son. You lost your original constant (referring to the originally constant and unchanging true mind). Therefore, you endure the cycle of reincarnation.",
    
    "'Appearance' is the previous dust (past experiences). Grasping those dusts forms discrimination, which is called 'thought'. This 'thought' is not real, so it is said to be illusory. In delusion, clinging to this, mistakenly thinking it is the original constant (true mind). Therefore, it is said to delude your true nature. The previous seven locations of inquiry all belong to the objects being sought. Now, only when awareness arises is there a subject that can seek. The *Zong Jing Lu* says: 'The mind that seeks is the deluded mind, which has the function of conditioned thought.' However, it is not the true mind. It also says: 'The deluded mind is an image on the true mind.' I believe these are all descriptions of being in delusion, failing to awaken in the present moment, thus it is called conditioned thought and seen as an image. It is not that there is another true mind before or outside of conditioned thought and images. Even when the World-Honored One rebukes it as the illusory appearance of past dust, it is also blaming the inability to awaken in the present moment. Looking at the following sutra, it says: 'I am not ordering you to cling to it as not being the mind.' It is further known that in delusion, one mistakes the son for a thief; in awakening, one recognizes the thief as the son. There is no second person.",
    
    "△ Two, requesting instruction.",
    
    "Ananda (one of the Buddha's ten principal disciples, known for his exceptional memory) said to the Buddha: 'World-Honored One, I am the Buddha's beloved brother. Because my heart loves the Buddha, I was allowed to leave home. My heart not only makes offerings to the Tathagata (one of the Buddha's titles), but also travels through countless lands like the sands of the Ganges, serving all Buddhas and Kalyanamitras (spiritual friends and teachers who guide one towards goodness), generating great courage, and practicing all kinds of difficult Dharma practices, all with this mind. Even if I slander the Dharma and forever lose my roots of goodness, it is also because of this mind. If this manifestation is not the mind, then I have no mind, like those earth and wood. Apart from this awareness, there is nothing else. Why does the Tathagata say this is not the mind? I am truly terrified, and all the assembly here are also in doubt. I only hope you will have great compassion and enlighten us who have not yet awakened.'",
    
    "Serving all Buddhas and Kalyanamitras, practicing all kinds of difficult Dharma practices, this is the matter of generating Bodhicitta (the mind of enlightenment). The *Nirvana Sutra* says: 'The mind of Bodhi is actually not Buddha-nature, because it is impermanent.' Even continuing without interruption is called cultivation. Like the flame of a lamp, although it arises and ceases moment by moment, it can still dispel darkness. The mind of Bodhi is also like this. Therefore, it is known that in the state of delusion, one can also generate the mind of Bodhi. Since one is in the state of delusion, not yet knowing the return, although it is not something separate, it is only called the mind of Bodhi, not the true, constant, and abiding mind. Even if one slanders the Dharma and forever regresses, it is only called an Icchantika (one who has severed their roots of goodness), and it is not something separate. This is why the *Nirvana Sutra* allows that Icchantikas have Buddha-nature.",
    
    "The seven locations of inquiry, all clinging, have already been exhausted. Enduring further pressure and questioning, only when seeking arises does one suddenly stumble upon it. Ananda rejoices in this. If one can dissolve like ice melting, even with repeated scolding, there is truly no one to be found."
  ]
}

承當矣。乃聞指良為賤。便生疑網。無上真性。翻成妄想。夫輪轉豈屬前塵。知歸寧論涂路。故謂推尋未脫能所。猶未是如來所訶耳。

  △三正示全性。

  爾時世尊開示阿難及諸大眾。欲令心入無生法忍。于師子座摩阿難頂。而告之言。如來常說諸法所生。唯心所現。一切因果世界微塵。因心成體。阿難。若諸世界一切所有。其中乃至草葉縷結。詰其根元。咸有體性。縱令虛空。亦有名貌。何況清凈妙凈明心性一切心而自無體。

  無生法忍。華嚴十忍品頌云。觀察一切法。悉從因緣起。無生故無滅。無滅故無盡。此忍最為上。了法無有盡。菩薩住此忍。普見諸如來。同時與授記。斯名稱佛職。師子座名。凡如來坐處。若床若地。皆名師子座。清凈妙凈明心者定林曰。離垢而凈曰清凈。即垢而凈曰妙凈。亦即亦離。故曰清凈妙凈明心。清涼云。心性是一。謂心之性故。是如來藏。謂心即性故。是自性清凈心。溫陵雲。一切因果。指十界正報。世界微塵。指十界依報。依正二報。因心成體。而豈人乃無心。同於土木。此經語意。本酬前文也愚謂實示一切前塵分別。悉無自性。唯心所現。故曰因心成體。所現唯心。故曰咸有體性。此湛然常住。所當自認。不應迷於前塵。妄同生滅。以伏下文離塵有性。即真汝心。離塵無體。斯為影事之旨。

  若汝執吝分別覺觀所了知性必為心者。此心即應離諸一切色香味觸諸塵事業別有全性。如汝今者承聽我法。此則因聲而有分別。縱滅一切見聞覺知。內守幽閑。猶為法塵分別影事。

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本:",
    "我明白了你的意思。但聽到將『良』(指好的、真實的)說成『賤』(指低劣的、虛假的),便產生了疑惑。原本至高無上的真如自性,反而變成了虛妄的念想。輪轉生死之事,難道是由之前的塵境所決定?尋求歸宿,又怎能只看重道路的選擇?所以說,如果還在推尋、分別能與所,就還沒有脫離能所的對立,這還不是如來所呵斥的境界。",
    
    "△三、 正面開示全體自性。",
    
    "這時,世尊開示阿難和所有大眾,想要讓他們內心證入無生法忍(對一切法不生不滅的深刻體悟)。在師子座(佛所坐之處)上,摩阿難的頭頂,並告訴他說:『如來常說,一切諸法的生起,都是唯心所現。一切因果、世界、微塵,都是因心而成就其體性。阿難,如果一切世界中的一切事物,其中乃至一草一葉、一絲一結,追究其根源,都具有體性。即使是虛空,也有其名相。更何況是清凈、妙凈、明凈的心性,一切心的根本,反而會沒有自體呢?』",
    
    "無生法忍。《華嚴經·十忍品》中的偈頌說:『觀察一切法,都從因緣而生起。因為不生,所以不滅;因為不滅,所以沒有窮盡。這種忍最為殊勝,徹了知法沒有窮盡。菩薩安住于這種忍,普遍見到諸如來,同時得到授記,這個名稱是佛的職分。』師子座的含義是,凡是如來所坐之處,無論是床還是地面,都稱為師子座。『清凈妙凈明心』,定林法師說:『離開垢染而清凈,叫做清凈;在垢染中而清凈,叫做妙凈。』既是離開,又是不離,所以叫做清凈妙凈明心。清涼澄觀法師說:『心性是一體的,因為是心的本性,所以是如來藏;因為心就是性,所以是自性清凈心。』溫陵法師說:『一切因果,指的是十法界(地獄、餓鬼、畜生、阿修羅、人、天、聲聞、緣覺、菩薩、佛)的正報(眾生的身心);世界微塵,指的是十法界的依報(眾生所居住的環境)。依報和正報,都是因心而成就其體性。難道人反而沒有心,如同土木一樣嗎?』這部經的語言和意義,本來是爲了迴應前文的疑問。我認為,實際上是開示一切之前的塵境分別,都沒有自性,都是唯心所現,所以說『因心成體』。所顯現的都是唯心,所以說『咸有體性』。這種湛然常住的體性,應當自己去認識,不應該迷惑於之前的塵境,妄自與生滅法相同。以此來伏筆下文所說的,離開塵境而有體性,就是你真實的真心;離開塵境而沒有體性,那就是虛幻的影子。",
    
    "如果你執著于分別覺觀所了知的『性』,認為那就是心,那麼這個心就應該離開一切色、香、味、觸等塵境事業,而另外具有完整的體性。比如你現在聽聞我的說法,這便是因為聲音而產生了分別。即使滅絕一切見聞覺知,內心守護幽靜閒適,仍然是法塵的分別影事。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version:",
    "I understand. But upon hearing 'good' (referring to what is virtuous and true) being called 'base' (referring to what is inferior and false), doubts arise. The supreme true nature is transformed into deluded thoughts. How can the cycle of rebirth be determined by past dust? Seeking refuge, how can one only value the choice of paths? Therefore, to say that one is still searching and distinguishing between subject and object means one has not yet escaped the duality of subject and object, and this is not the state rebuked by the Tathagata.",
    
    "△3. Directly revealing the complete nature.",
    
    "At that time, the World-Honored One expounded to Ananda and all the assembly, desiring to lead their minds into the forbearance of non-origination (a profound realization of the non-arising and non-ceasing of all dharmas). On the Lion Throne (the place where the Buddha sits), he stroked Ananda's head and said: 'The Tathagata always says that the arising of all dharmas is solely a manifestation of the mind. All causes and effects, worlds, and motes of dust are formed in their essence by the mind. Ananda, if everything in all the worlds, even a blade of grass, a leaf, a thread, or a knot, is traced to its origin, it has a nature. Even empty space has a name and form. How much more so the pure, wondrously pure, and bright mind-essence, the root of all minds, could be without its own substance?'",
    
    "The Forbearance of Non-Origination. The verse in the 'Ten Forbearances' chapter of the *Avatamsaka Sutra* says: 'Observing all dharmas, they all arise from causes and conditions. Because they do not arise, they do not cease; because they do not cease, they are inexhaustible. This forbearance is the most supreme, thoroughly understanding that dharmas are inexhaustible. Bodhisattvas abide in this forbearance, universally seeing all the Tathagatas, and simultaneously receiving predictions, this title is the duty of the Buddha.' The meaning of Lion Throne is that wherever the Tathagata sits, whether it is a bed or the ground, it is called the Lion Throne. 'Pure, wondrously pure, and bright mind' is explained by Master Dinglin: 'To be pure by being apart from defilement is called pure; to be pure within defilement is called wondrously pure.' It is both apart and not apart, therefore it is called pure, wondrously pure, and bright mind. Qingliang Chengguan says: 'Mind and nature are one, because it is the nature of the mind, therefore it is the Tathagata-garbha; because mind is nature, therefore it is the self-nature pure mind.' Master Wenling says: 'All causes and effects refer to the positive retribution (the body and mind of sentient beings) of the ten realms (hells, hungry ghosts, animals, asuras, humans, devas, sravakas, pratyekabuddhas, bodhisattvas, and Buddhas); worlds and motes of dust refer to the circumstantial retribution (the environment in which sentient beings live) of the ten realms.' Circumstantial and positive retributions are formed in their essence by the mind. How can humans be without mind, like earth and wood?' The language and meaning of this sutra are originally to respond to the questions in the previous text. I believe that it actually reveals that all previous discriminations of dust have no self-nature, but are solely manifestations of the mind, therefore it is said 'formed in their essence by the mind.' What is manifested is solely the mind, therefore it is said 'all have a nature.' This serene and constant nature should be recognized by oneself, and one should not be deluded by the previous dust, falsely equating oneself with the phenomena of arising and ceasing. This foreshadows what is said below, that having a nature apart from dust is your true mind; not having a nature apart from dust is an illusory shadow.",
    
    "If you cling to the 'nature' understood by discriminating awareness and consider it to be the mind, then this mind should be separate from all forms, sounds, smells, tastes, tactile sensations, and other activities of the dust, and have a complete nature of its own. For example, you are now listening to my teachings, which is because sound has given rise to discrimination. Even if you extinguish all seeing, hearing, feeling, and knowing, and guard inner tranquility and leisure, it is still a discriminating shadow of the dharma-dust."
  ]
}

  吝不捨也。覺觀了知即能推之心也。色香等事。能牽內心而成業用。未牽之前。既牽之後。當牽之中。如雲與空。云去云來。虛空常在。所謂全性也。因聲分別。亦復隨聲有無。祇為未曾發明。聲前聲后。不得安住。即滅分別之見聞覺知。而幽閑內守。名為別緣。亦同分別。皆屬影事。非得全性也。

  我非敕汝執為非心。但汝於心微細揣摩。若離前塵有分別性。即真汝心。若分別性離塵無體。斯則前塵分別影事。塵非常住。若變滅時。此心則同龜毛兔角。則汝法身同於斷滅。其誰修證無生法忍。

  龜毛兔角言絕無也。同者猶如之辭。夫依心之塵難住。則緣塵之心茫然。即此茫然。便同兔角。以其無所據以為修證。同於斷滅。非真斷滅也。諸師指分別之心。以為與塵俱滅。但據其所謂全性者。舍分別而更有。不知其所謂分別者。舍全性而必無。迷悟暫岐。真妄同體。聖人復起。不易吾言矣。

  此如來指人於色香味觸中。而識其所謂全性也。離者揀別之義。謂於物我現前。揀別而得之。非遠離前塵而絕諸分別也。迷全性者。附分別而暫見。分別同塵。以其同而滅之。其所謂全性者。亦冥然于無所覺知而已。故西域之冥初。此土之太極。不可語于見性者。非揀別於物我而得之者也。自以為滅分別者之為離塵。而不知內守昏默。其為前塵分別更細。愚先謂輪轉豈屬前塵。知歸寧論涂路。正有見此。此所貴乎別有全性矣。

  上五指能推有體竟。

  △六顯見性非眼。分四。初責多聞。

  即時阿難與諸大眾。

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本\n\n  吝嗇是不願施捨。覺察、觀察、瞭解,並能推己及人,就是慈悲心。色、香等事物,能牽動內心而形成業力。在未被牽動之前,已被牽動之後,以及正在被牽動之中,(內心的狀態)就像云與天空的關係,云來云去,虛空卻始終存在,這就是所謂的『全性』(本性)。因為聲音而產生的分別,也隨著聲音的有無而變化。只因爲沒有明白,在聲音出現之前和消失之後,(分別心)都無法安住。於是滅除分別的見聞覺知,而幽靜閒適地守護內心,這叫做『別緣』,也和分別一樣,都屬於外在事物的影子,無法獲得『全性』(本性)。\n\n  我並非命令你執著地認為(分別心)不是真心。只是讓你對自己的心進行細微的揣摩。如果離開外在事物,還有分別的性質存在,那就是你的真心。如果分別的性質離開外在事物就沒有實體,那麼這只是外在事物分別的影子。外在事物並非恒常存在,如果發生變化而消滅時,這個心就如同龜毛兔角一樣不存在,那麼你的法身就如同斷滅一樣。這樣,又有誰來修證無生法忍呢?\n\n  『龜毛兔角』是說絕對沒有。『同』是『猶如』的意思。依附於心的外在事物難以停留,那麼緣于外在事物的心也就茫然無措。這種茫然無措,就如同兔角一樣不存在,因為它沒有可以憑藉的依據來進行修證,所以如同斷滅一樣,但並非真正的斷滅。有些法師認為分別之心會和外在事物一同消滅,但他們所說的『全性』(本性),是捨棄分別之後才有的。卻不知道他們所說的『分別』,是捨棄『全性』(本性)之後必然不存在的。迷悟只在一念之間,真妄本是同體。即使聖人再次出現,也不會改變我的說法。\n\n  這就像如來佛(佛陀)指引人們在色、香、味、觸中,去認識他們所說的『全性』(本性)。『離』是揀擇分別的意思。指的是在事物和自我現前時,通過揀擇分別而得到的,並非遠離外在事物而斷絕一切分別。迷惑于『全性』(本性)的人,依附於分別而暫時見到,分別和外在事物一樣,因為它們相同而想要滅除它。他們所說的『全性』(本性),也就在冥然無知中消失了。所以西域的冥初,中土的太極,都無法和見性的人談論,因為他們不是通過在事物和自我之間揀擇分別而得到的。自以為滅除了分別的人,認為這就是離開了外在事物,卻不知道內心守護昏昧沉默,這其實是更細微的外在事物分別。愚者先前說輪轉難道屬於外在事物,知道歸宿又何必談論道路。正是因為看到了這些,所以才珍視另外擁有的『全性』(本性)啊。\n\n  上面五指能推動有形之物的內容結束。\n\n  △六、顯示見性並非眼睛。分為四個部分。首先是責備多聞。\n\n  當時,阿難和所有大眾。",
    "English version\n\n  Stinginess is unwillingness to give. Awareness, observation, and understanding, along with the ability to extend compassion to others, constitute the mind of compassion. Forms, scents, and other things can stir the inner mind and create karmic actions. Before being stirred, after being stirred, and in the midst of being stirred, (the state of the inner mind) is like the relationship between clouds and the sky. Clouds come and go, but the void remains constant. This is what is meant by 'wholeness of nature' (original nature). Distinctions arising from sound also change with the presence or absence of sound. It is only because it has not been understood that (the discriminating mind) cannot abide before and after the sound. Therefore, extinguish the discriminating seeing, hearing, awareness, and knowing, and quietly and peacefully guard the inner mind. This is called 'separate condition,' which, like discrimination, belongs to the shadows of external things and cannot attain 'wholeness of nature' (original nature).\n\n  I am not ordering you to stubbornly believe that (the discriminating mind) is not the true mind. I am simply asking you to subtly examine your own mind. If there is a discriminating nature apart from external things, then that is your true mind. If the discriminating nature has no substance apart from external things, then it is merely a shadow of the discrimination of external things. External things are not permanent. If they change and disappear, this mind will be as nonexistent as a tortoise's hair or a rabbit's horn. Then your Dharma body will be like annihilation. Who then will cultivate and realize the forbearance of non-arising?\n\n  'Tortoise's hair and rabbit's horn' means absolutely nonexistent. 'Like' means 'similar to.' External things that depend on the mind are difficult to abide in, so the mind that depends on external things is at a loss. This state of being at a loss is like a rabbit's horn, because it has no basis on which to cultivate and realize, so it is like annihilation, but it is not true annihilation. Some teachers believe that the discriminating mind will disappear along with external things, but what they call 'wholeness of nature' (original nature) is something that exists after abandoning discrimination. They do not know that what they call 'discrimination' is necessarily nonexistent after abandoning 'wholeness of nature' (original nature). Delusion and enlightenment are only a moment apart, and truth and falsehood are of the same essence. Even if a sage were to appear again, he would not change my words.\n\n  This is like the Tathagata (Buddha) guiding people to recognize what they call 'wholeness of nature' (original nature) in forms, scents, tastes, and touches. 'Apart from' means the meaning of selecting and distinguishing. It refers to obtaining it through selecting and distinguishing when things and self are present, not to cutting off all distinctions by staying away from external things. Those who are deluded about 'wholeness of nature' (original nature) temporarily see it by clinging to discrimination. Discrimination is the same as external things, and they want to eliminate it because they are the same. What they call 'wholeness of nature' (original nature) also disappears in a state of dark ignorance. Therefore, the primordial darkness of the Western Regions and the Taiji of the Central Lands cannot be discussed with those who have seen their nature, because they are not obtained through selecting and distinguishing between things and self. Those who think they have eliminated discrimination think that this is being apart from external things, but they do not know that guarding the inner mind in a state of dull silence is actually a more subtle form of discrimination of external things. The foolish ones previously said that does reincarnation belong to external things, and why discuss the road when one knows where to return. It is precisely because they have seen these things that they value the 'wholeness of nature' (original nature) that they possess.\n\n  The above concludes the content about the five fingers being able to push tangible things.\n\n  △ Six, showing that the seeing nature is not the eye. Divided into four parts. First is rebuking much learning.\n\n  At that time, Ananda and all the assembly."
  ]
}

默然自失。佛告阿難。世間一切諸修學人。現前雖成九次第定。不得漏盡成阿羅漢。皆由執此生死妄想。誤為真實。是故汝今雖得多聞。不成聖果。

  九次第定謂四禪四空。加滅想受。前八凡外。第九無漏聖位。此云不得漏盡成阿羅漢者。以二乘羅漢。猶屬權誘。即法華所謂非真涅槃也。按此當指大乘。大乘阿羅漢。乃是十地以後。故知二乘變易亦名生死。愚于爾𦦨。未見初心。皆為妄想。豈到真實。然則凡夫當下發明自性。殆非小緣。謬言擔荷。過何可言。

  △二敘障求示。

  阿難聞已。重複悲淚。五體投地。長跪合掌。而白佛言。自我從佛發心出家。恃佛威神。常自思惟。無勞我修。將謂如來惠我三昧。不知身心本不相代。失我本心。雖身出家。心不入道。譬如窮子。舍父逃逝。今日乃知雖有多聞。若不修行。與不聞等。如人說食。終不能飽。世尊。我等今者二障所纏。良由不知寂常心性。性愿如來哀愍窮露。發妙明心。開我道眼。

  二障謂煩惱障。所知障。煩惱分見思二惑。見惑乃作意分別。即后六結使。謂疑。身見。邊見。邪見。見取。戒取。思惑乃任運貪愛。即前四結使。謂貪瞋癡慢。所知障亦分取境法愛。取境乃不達外境惟心。見心外有法。法愛乃于所證不達性空。而生愛樂。皆能障自真心。不得常住。無財曰窮。無覆曰露。物不能礙曰妙。物不能混曰明。妙明是本覺。道眼是始覺。有抉擇之義。

  △三放光表說。

  即時如來從胸卍字涌出寶光。其光晃昱。有百千色。十方微塵普佛世界

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "默然自失(形容因領悟而神情沮喪)。",
    
    "佛陀告訴阿難(Ananda,佛陀的十大弟子之一):『世間所有修學佛法的人,即使能夠達到九次第定(Jiucidi Ding,佛教禪定修習的九個階段),如果不能斷盡煩惱,證得阿羅漢果(Arhat,佛教修行的一種果位),都是因為執著于生死的虛妄念想,誤以為是真實存在的。所以你現在雖然聽聞了很多佛法,卻不能證得聖果。』",
    
    "九次第定指的是四禪(Sichan,色界天的四種禪定)、四空(Sikong,無色界天的四種禪定),加上滅盡定(Miejin Ding,一種超越有想和無想的禪定)。前八種是凡夫和外道也能修成的,第九種是無漏的聖位。這裡說『不能斷盡煩惱,證得阿羅漢果』,是因為二乘(Ercheng,聲聞乘和緣覺乘)的阿羅漢,仍然屬於權巧方便的引導,就像《法華經》(Fahua Jing)所說的並非真正的涅槃(Nirvana,佛教修行的最終目標)。按照這個說法,這裡指的是大乘(Mahayana,佛教的一個主要流派)。大乘的阿羅漢,是十地(Shidi,菩薩修行的十個階段)以後的境界。所以說二乘的變易生死也叫做生死。對於這些細微之處不明白,沒有見到最初的發心,都被虛妄的念想所迷惑,怎麼能達到真實的境界呢?既然這樣,那麼凡夫當下就能發明自性,這絕不是小小的因緣。如果錯誤地說自己能夠承擔如來家業,那過錯又怎麼能說得完呢?",
    
    "△二、敘述障礙,請求開示。",
    
    "阿難聽了佛陀的教誨后,再次悲傷地流下眼淚,五體投地(Wuti Toudi,佛教的一種禮拜方式),長跪合掌,對佛陀說:『我自從跟隨佛陀發心出家以來,仗恃佛陀的威神之力,常常自己思量,不用自己努力修行,以為如來會賜予我三昧(Samadhi,佛教的禪定)。不知道身和心不能互相代替,失去了我本來的真心。雖然身體出了家,心卻沒有入道。就像一個窮困的兒子,捨棄父親逃離。今天才知道,即使聽聞了很多佛法,如果不修行,就和沒有聽聞一樣。就像一個人說食物,終究不能吃飽。世尊,我們現在被兩種障礙所纏縛,實在是因為不知道寂靜常住的心性。懇請如來哀憐我們這些窮困的人,發妙明真心(Miaoming Zhenxin,一種清凈光明的覺悟之心),開啟我的道眼(Daoyan,能夠看清真理的智慧之眼)。』",
    
    "兩種障礙指的是煩惱障(Fannao Zhang,由貪嗔癡等煩惱引起的障礙)和所知障(Suozhi Zhang,由對知識的執著引起的障礙)。煩惱障分為見惑(Jianhuo,知見上的迷惑)和思惑(Sihuo,思想上的迷惑)兩種。見惑是作意分別,也就是後面的六結使(Liujieshi,六種根本煩惱):疑(Yi,懷疑)、身見(Shenjian,執著于身體為我)、邊見(Bianjian,執著于斷常等極端觀點)、邪見(Xiejian,錯誤的見解)、見取見(Jianqujian,執著于自己的見解)、戒禁取見(Jinjinqujian,執著于不正確的戒律和禁忌)。思惑是任運貪愛,也就是前面的四結使(Sijieshi,四種根本煩惱):貪(Tan,貪婪)、嗔(Chen,嗔恨)、癡(Chi,愚癡)、慢(Man,傲慢)。所知障也分為取境法愛(Qujing Fa'ai,對境界和法的執著)。取境是不明白外在的境界都是唯心所現,認為心外有法。法愛是對所證悟的境界不明白其性空,而產生愛戀。這些都能障礙自己的真心,使其不能常住。沒有財富叫做窮,沒有遮蓋叫做露。事物不能阻礙叫做妙,事物不能混淆叫做明。妙明是本覺(Benjue,本有的覺悟),道眼是始覺(Shijue,開始的覺悟),有決斷選擇的意義。",
    
    "△三、放光顯示說法。",
    
    "就在這時,如來從胸前的卍字(Wanzi,佛教的吉祥符號)涌出寶光,那光芒閃耀,有百千種顏色,照耀十方微塵數般的普佛世界(Pufuo Shijie,充滿佛的世界)。",
    
    
    "english_translations": [
      "English version",
      "He was silently lost in thought and self-reproach.",
      
      "The Buddha told Ananda (one of the Buddha's ten principal disciples): 'All those in the world who study and practice, even if they attain the Nine Successive Dhyanas (Jiucidi Ding, the nine stages of meditative absorption in Buddhism), cannot exhaust their outflows and become Arhats (Arhat, a state of enlightenment in Buddhism) because they cling to the deluded thoughts of birth and death, mistaking them for reality. Therefore, although you have heard much, you have not attained the fruit of sainthood.'",
      
      "The Nine Successive Dhyanas refer to the Four Dhyanas (Sichan, the four meditative states of the Form Realm), the Four Formless Absorptions (Sikong, the four meditative states of the Formless Realm), and the Cessation of Perception and Sensation (Miejin Ding, a meditative state beyond thought and non-thought). The first eight are attainable by ordinary people and non-Buddhists. The ninth is a pure, undefiled state of sainthood. The statement 'cannot exhaust their outflows and become Arhats' indicates that the Arhats of the Two Vehicles (Ercheng, the Hearer Vehicle and the Solitary Realizer Vehicle) are still provisional and expedient, not true Nirvana (Nirvana, the ultimate goal of Buddhist practice) as described in the Lotus Sutra (Fahua Jing). According to this, it refers to the Mahayana (Mahayana, a major branch of Buddhism). The Arhats of the Mahayana are those who have reached the Tenth Ground (Shidi, the ten stages of Bodhisattva practice) and beyond. Therefore, the changing birth and death of the Two Vehicles is also called birth and death. Being ignorant of these subtle points and not seeing the initial aspiration, all are deluded by false thoughts. How can they reach the realm of reality? If this is the case, then ordinary people can realize their inherent nature in the present moment, which is by no means a small matter. If one falsely claims to be able to shoulder the responsibility of the Tathagata's (Tathagata, another name for the Buddha) family business, how can the fault be described completely?",
      
      "△2. Describing Obstacles and Requesting Guidance.",
      
      "Having heard this, Ananda wept again with sorrow, prostrated himself with his five limbs touching the ground (Wuti Toudi, a Buddhist form of prostration), knelt with his palms together, and said to the Buddha: 'Since I followed the Buddha and resolved to leave home, relying on the Buddha's majestic power, I often thought to myself that I did not need to cultivate diligently, assuming that the Tathagata would bestow Samadhi (Samadhi, a state of meditative concentration in Buddhism) upon me. I did not know that the body and mind cannot substitute for each other, and I lost my original mind. Although my body has left home, my mind has not entered the Path. It is like a poor son who abandons his father and runs away. Today I know that even if I have heard much, if I do not practice, it is the same as not hearing. It is like a person talking about food, but never being full. World Honored One, we are now entangled by two obstacles, truly because we do not know the nature of the still and constant mind. I earnestly request the Tathagata to have compassion on us poor and exposed ones, to awaken the wondrously bright true mind (Miaoming Zhenxin, a pure and luminous mind of enlightenment), and to open my Dharma eye (Daoyan, the eye of wisdom that can see the truth).'",
      
      "The two obstacles refer to the afflictive obstacles (Fannao Zhang, obstacles caused by afflictions such as greed, hatred, and delusion) and the cognitive obstacles (Suozhi Zhang, obstacles caused by attachment to knowledge). The afflictive obstacles are divided into the delusions of views (Jianhuo, delusions in understanding) and the delusions of thought (Sihuo, delusions in thought). The delusions of views are intentional discriminations, which are the six fetters (Liujieshi, six fundamental afflictions): doubt (Yi), self-view (Shenjian, clinging to the body as self), extreme views (Bianjian, clinging to extreme views such as permanence and annihilation), wrong views (Xiejian, incorrect views), clinging to views (Jianqujian, clinging to one's own views), and clinging to precepts and rituals (Jinjinqujian, clinging to incorrect precepts and rituals). The delusions of thought are spontaneous cravings, which are the four fetters (Sijieshi, four fundamental afflictions): greed (Tan), hatred (Chen), delusion (Chi), and pride (Man). The cognitive obstacles are also divided into attachment to objects and love of Dharma (Qujing Fa'ai, attachment to objects and the Dharma). Attachment to objects is not understanding that external objects are manifestations of the mind, and seeing Dharma outside the mind. Love of Dharma is not understanding the emptiness of the nature of the enlightened state, and developing attachment to it. These can all obstruct one's true mind, preventing it from abiding constantly. Having no wealth is called poor, having no cover is called exposed. That which cannot be obstructed is called wondrous, that which cannot be confused is called bright. Wondrous brightness is original enlightenment (Benjue, inherent enlightenment), and the Dharma eye is initial enlightenment (Shijue, the beginning of enlightenment), which has the meaning of decisive choice.",
      
      "△3. Emitting Light to Reveal the Dharma.",
      
      "At that moment, the Tathagata emitted a precious light from the swastika (Wanzi, a Buddhist auspicious symbol) on his chest. The light shone brightly, with hundreds of thousands of colors, illuminating the Buddha-worlds as numerous as dust motes in the ten directions (Pufuo Shijie, Buddha-worlds filled with Buddhas)."
    ]
  }

。一時周遍。遍灌十方所有寶剎諸如來頂。旋至阿難。及諸大眾。告阿難言。吾今為汝建大法幢。亦令十方一切眾生獲妙微密性凈明心。得清凈眼。

  華嚴相海品。如來胸前有大人相。形如卍字。名吉祥海云。智德洋廣如海。蓋物如雲。若放此光。將出妙音。宣揚法海。光普佛界者。表如來藏心流出。遍灌諸如來頂者。表佛佛理齊也。旋至阿難及諸大眾者。表各各性等也。清涼云。幢有五義。一高出。表三賢十聖位極故。二建立。大悲大智。建立眾生及菩提故。三歸向。大悲攝生。智愿攝善。歸向菩提及實際故。四摧殄。如猛將幢。降伏一切諸魔軍故。五滅怖畏。如帝釋幢。不怖惑業故。本覺妙明。此妙非十地所見曰微。唯佛究盡曰密。明能自守。不與物類曰凈。心既發明。自具擇法。故曰清凈眼。此酬前請。

  △四正指見是心。分三。初以拳例眼。

  阿難。汝先答我見光明拳。此拳光明。因何所有。云何成拳。汝將誰見。阿難言。由佛全體閻浮檀金。赩如寶山。清凈所生。故有光明。我實眼觀。五輪指端。屈握示人。故有拳相。

  初徴拳相。意在因手。以伏例見必因眼。乃帶言曰。汝將誰見。始終不離直指。而阿難仍曰。我實眼觀。猶是以見屬眼矣。閻浮樹名。檀洲名。此洲有河。底出金沙。其色赤𦦨。比佛身金。勝常金也。

  佛告阿難。如來今日實言告汝。諸有智者。要以譬喻而得開悟。阿難。譬如我拳。若無我手。不成我拳。若無汝眼。不成汝見。以汝眼根。例我拳理。其義均不。阿難言。唯然。世

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "一時之間,光明周遍,遍灑十方所有珍寶莊嚴的佛國剎土中諸佛的頭頂。光明迴旋來到阿難(Ananda,佛陀十大弟子之一)以及所有大眾處。佛陀告訴阿難說:『我今天為你建立大法幢(dharma-dhvaja,象徵佛法的旗幟),也令十方一切眾生獲得微妙、精微、本性清凈的光明明心,得到清凈的眼(cakṣu-viśuddhi,能洞察真理的智慧之眼)。』",
    
    "《華嚴經》〈相海品〉中說,如來胸前有大人相,形狀如同卍字(svastika,象徵吉祥的符號),名為吉祥海云(śrī-samudra-megha,吉祥如海,功德如雲)。智慧功德廣大如海,覆蓋萬物如雲。如果放出此光,將發出美妙的聲音,宣揚法海(dharma-samudra,佛法的海洋)。光明普照佛界,表示如來藏心(tathāgatagarbha,如來法身的藏身之處)流出。遍灑諸如來頂,表示佛佛理齊。迴旋至阿難及諸大眾,表示各各本性平等。清涼澄觀大師說,幢有五種含義:一是高出,表示三賢十聖的地位達到極點;二是建立,以大悲大智建立眾生和菩提(bodhi,覺悟);三是歸向,以大悲攝受眾生,以智愿攝受善法,歸向菩提和實際(bhūta-koṭi,真如實際);四是摧殄,如同猛將的旗幟,降伏一切諸魔軍;五是滅除怖畏,如同帝釋天(Indra,佛教護法神)的旗幟,不怖畏迷惑和業力。本覺妙明,這種妙明不是十地菩薩所能見到的,所以稱為『微』。只有佛才能究竟通達,所以稱為『密』。光明能夠自我守護,不與外物同流合污,所以稱為『凈』。心既然發明,自然具備選擇正法(dharma,佛法)的能力,所以稱為『清凈眼』。這是酬答之前的請求。",
    
    "△四、正式指明見性即是心。分為三部分。首先以拳頭為例來比喻眼睛。",
    
    "佛陀問阿難:『你先前回答我,看見光明拳頭。這個拳頭的光明,因何而有?如何形成拳頭?你用什麼看見的?』阿難回答說:『由於佛陀全體身軀是閻浮檀金(jambū-nadā,一種珍貴的金色),紅潤如寶山,清凈所生,所以有光明。我確實是用眼睛觀看,五輪指端屈曲握攏,展示給人,所以有拳頭的形狀。』",
    
    "首先征問拳頭的形狀,意在說明拳頭是因手而有。以此來類比,要說明見性必定是因眼而有。於是順帶問道:『你用什麼看見的?』始終不離直接指明心性。而阿難仍然說:『我確實是用眼睛觀看。』仍然是將見性歸屬於眼睛。閻浮(Jambudvīpa,贍部洲)是樹名,檀(nada)是洲名。此洲有河,河底出產金沙,其顏色赤紅,比佛身所呈現的金色,勝過普通的金子。",
    
    "佛陀告訴阿難說:『如來今天用真實的話告訴你,凡是有智慧的人,要用譬喻才能得到開悟。阿難,譬如我的拳頭,如果沒有我的手,就不能形成我的拳頭;如果沒有你的眼睛,就不能形成你的見性。用你的眼根來比喻我的拳頭之理,這個道理一樣嗎?』阿難回答說:『是的,世尊(Bhagavan,佛陀的尊稱)。』"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "At that moment, the light pervaded everywhere, showering all the precious and adorned Buddha lands in the ten directions, upon the crowns of all the Tathagatas (Tathāgata, 'Thus Gone One,' an epithet of the Buddha). The light then turned towards Ananda (Ananda, one of the Buddha's ten principal disciples) and the entire assembly. The Buddha said to Ananda, 'Today, I establish for you the great Dharma-dhvaja (dharma-dhvaja, the banner of Dharma), and also cause all beings in the ten directions to obtain the subtle, profound, and inherently pure bright mind, and to attain the pure eye (cakṣu-viśuddhi, the eye of wisdom that sees the truth).'",
    
    "In the 'Sea of Characteristics' chapter of the Avatamsaka Sutra, it says that on the Tathagata's chest is the mark of a great person, shaped like a swastika (svastika, a symbol of auspiciousness), named the Auspicious Sea Cloud (śrī-samudra-megha, auspiciousness like the sea, merits like clouds). Its wisdom and virtue are vast like the sea, and it covers all things like clouds. If this light is emitted, it will produce wonderful sounds, proclaiming the Dharma-samudra (dharma-samudra, the ocean of Dharma). The light universally illuminating the Buddha realms signifies the outflow of the Tathāgatagarbha (tathāgatagarbha, the womb of the Tathagata). Showering the crowns of all the Tathagatas signifies that the principles of all Buddhas are equal. Turning towards Ananda and the entire assembly signifies that each one's nature is equal. Qingliang Cheng Guan Master said that the banner has five meanings: first, it is high and prominent, representing the ultimate attainment of the Three Sages and Ten Saints; second, it establishes, using great compassion and great wisdom to establish beings and Bodhi (bodhi, enlightenment); third, it returns, using great compassion to gather beings, and using wisdom and vows to gather good, returning to Bodhi and Bhūta-koṭi (bhūta-koṭi, the ultimate reality); fourth, it destroys, like the banner of a fierce general, subduing all the armies of demons; fifth, it eliminates fear, like the banner of Indra (Indra, a Buddhist protector deity), not fearing delusion and karma. The inherently enlightened wondrous brightness, this wondrousness is not seen by the Ten Bhumi Bodhisattvas, so it is called 'subtle.' Only the Buddha can completely understand it, so it is called 'profound.' The brightness can protect itself, not mingling with external things, so it is called 'pure.' Since the mind has been illuminated, it naturally possesses the ability to choose the right Dharma (dharma, Buddhist teachings), so it is called 'pure eye.' This is in response to the previous request.",
    
    "△4. Directly pointing to seeing the mind. Divided into three parts. First, using the fist as an example to illustrate the eye.",
    
    "The Buddha asked Ananda, 'You previously answered me, seeing the bright fist. What is the cause of the light of this fist? How is the fist formed? What do you use to see it?' Ananda replied, 'Because the Buddha's entire body is Jambū-nadā gold (jambū-nadā, a precious type of gold), reddish like a jeweled mountain, born of purity, therefore there is light. I truly use my eyes to see, the five rounded fingertips are bent and clenched, shown to people, therefore there is the shape of a fist.'",
    
    "First, questioning the shape of the fist, the intention is to explain that the fist is caused by the hand. By analogy, it is to explain that seeing must be caused by the eye. So he incidentally asked, 'What do you use to see it?' Always staying on directly pointing to the mind-nature. But Ananda still said, 'I truly use my eyes to see.' Still attributing seeing to the eye. Jambudvipa (Jambudvīpa, the continent of Jambudvipa) is the name of a tree, Nada is the name of a continent. This continent has a river, the bottom of the river produces golden sand, its color is reddish, which is better than ordinary gold compared to the gold presented by the Buddha's body.",
    
    "The Buddha told Ananda, 'Today, the Tathagata tells you with truthful words, those who have wisdom must use metaphors to attain enlightenment. Ananda, for example, my fist, if there were no hand, my fist could not be formed; if there were no eyes, your seeing could not be formed. Using your eye-faculty to compare with the principle of my fist, is this principle the same?' Ananda replied, 'Yes, Bhagavan (Bhagavan, a title of the Buddha).'"
  ]
}

尊。既無我眼。不成我見。以我眼根。例如來拳。事義相類。

  此以手例眼。以拳例見。蓋為反出無手無拳無眼有見之旨。

  △二示暗非見無。

  佛告阿難。汝言相類。是義不然。何以故。如無手人。拳畢竟滅。彼無眼者。非見全無。所以者何。汝試于涂。詢問盲人。汝何所見。彼諸盲人。必來答汝。我今眼前。唯見黑暗。更無他矚。以是義觀。前塵自暗。見何虧損。

  此實示無手之拳必滅。無眼之見非無。故以盲人見暗為喻。蓋以明見不因眼也。

  △三以燈例眼顯見。分二。初疑睹暗非見。

  阿難言。諸盲眼前。唯睹黑暗。云何成見。

  阿難不知暗亦前塵。若無見精。誰知暗者。

  △二喻暗光無異。指見是心。

  佛告阿難。諸盲無眼。唯觀黑暗。與有眼人處於暗室。二黑有別。為無有別。如是。世尊。此暗中人。與彼群盲。二黑校量。曾無有異。阿難。若無眼人。全見前黑。忽得眼光。還於前塵見種種色。名眼見者。彼暗中人。全見前黑。忽獲燈光。亦於前塵。見種種色。應名燈見。

  有眼無眼。睹暗元同。則眼開燈現。觀色豈異。蓋欲以燈喻眼。但能顯色。而見暗見明。是心非眼。下文自明。

  若燈見者。燈能有見。自不名燈。又則燈觀。何關汝事。是故當知燈能顯色。如是見者。是眼非燈。眼能顯色。如是見性。是心非眼。阿難雖復得聞是言。與諸大眾。口已默然。心未開悟。猶冀如來慈音宣示。合掌清心。佇佛悲海。

  此直指見性即心。將知一切根塵

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "尊者。既然沒有我的眼睛,就不能形成我的見解。用我的眼根來比喻,就像如來的拳頭一樣,道理和意義是相似的。",
    
    "這裡用手和拳頭來比喻眼睛和見解,實際上是爲了反過來闡明沒有手就沒有拳頭,沒有眼睛也有見解的道理。",
    
    "△二、闡明黑暗並非沒有見性。",
    
    "佛陀告訴阿難(Ananda,佛陀十大弟子之一):『你說的相似,這個道理是不對的。為什麼呢?比如沒有手,拳頭就徹底消失了。但沒有眼睛的人,並非完全沒有見性。』為什麼這麼說呢?你可以在路上詢問盲人,『你看到了什麼?』那些盲人一定會回答你,『我現在眼前,只能看到黑暗,再沒有其他東西了。』從這個道理來看,是前面的塵境本身是黑暗的,見性有什麼虧損呢?』",
    
    "這實際上是闡明沒有手的拳頭必然消失,沒有眼睛的見性並非沒有。所以用盲人看見黑暗來比喻,是爲了說明見性不是依靠眼睛的。",
    
    "△三、用燈來比喻眼睛,來顯明見性。分為兩部分。首先是懷疑看見黑暗不是見性。",
    
    "阿難(Ananda)說:『那些盲人眼前,只能看到黑暗,怎麼能說是見性呢?』",
    
    "阿難(Ananda)不知道黑暗也是前面的塵境。如果沒有見性的精明,誰能知道黑暗呢?",
    
    "△二、比喻黑暗和光明沒有區別,指出見性就是心。",
    
    "佛陀告訴阿難(Ananda):『那些盲人沒有眼睛,只能看到黑暗,和有眼睛的人處在黑暗的房間里,這兩種黑暗有什麼區別嗎?』阿難(Ananda)回答說:『世尊,這黑暗中的人和那些盲人,兩種黑暗比較起來,沒有任何區別。』佛陀說:『阿難(Ananda),如果沒有眼睛的人,完全看見前面的黑暗,忽然得到了眼光,又在前面的塵境中看見各種顏色,這可以稱為眼睛看見。那麼黑暗中的人,完全看見前面的黑暗,忽然得到了燈光,也在前面的塵境中看見各種顏色,應該稱為燈看見。』",
    
    "有眼睛和沒有眼睛的人,看見黑暗原本是相同的。那麼眼睛睜開和燈光出現,看見顏色又有什麼不同呢?這實際上是用燈來比喻眼睛,只能顯現顏色。而看見黑暗和看見光明,是心而不是眼睛。下文會自然明白。",
    
    "『如果說是燈看見,燈能有見性,自身就不叫燈了。而且燈的觀看,和你又有什麼關係呢?所以應當知道,燈能顯現顏色,這樣,看見的是眼睛而不是燈。眼睛能顯現顏色,這樣,見性是心而不是眼睛。』阿難(Ananda)雖然聽到了這些話,和在座的大眾一樣,口中已經沉默,心中還沒有開悟,仍然希望如來用慈悲的聲音宣說開示,合掌清凈身心,期待佛陀的悲憫教誨。",
    
    "這裡直接指出見性就是心。將要知道一切根塵",
    
    
    "English version",
    "Venerable one. Since there is no 'my' eye, 'my' view cannot be formed. Using 'my' eye-faculty as an analogy, it is similar to the Tathagata's (如來,one of the titles of a Buddha) fist in terms of principle and meaning.",
    
    "Here, hands and fists are used to exemplify eyes and views, actually to conversely clarify the principle that without hands there are no fists, and without eyes there is still view.",
    
    "△2. Demonstrating that darkness is not the absence of seeing.",
    
    "The Buddha told Ananda (阿難,one of the ten great disciples of the Buddha): 'Your statement of similarity is incorrect. Why? For example, without a hand, the fist completely disappears. But for those without eyes, seeing is not entirely absent.' Why is this so? You can ask blind people on the road, 'What do you see?' Those blind people will surely answer you, 'Right now, before my eyes, I only see darkness, and nothing else.' From this principle, it is the preceding dust-object itself that is dark, what loss is there to seeing?'",
    
    "This actually demonstrates that a fist without a hand will inevitably disappear, and seeing without eyes is not absent. Therefore, the analogy of blind people seeing darkness is used to illustrate that seeing does not depend on the eyes.",
    
    "△3. Using a lamp to exemplify the eyes, to reveal seeing. Divided into two parts. First, doubting that seeing darkness is not seeing.",
    
    "Ananda (阿難) said: 'Those blind people can only see darkness before their eyes, how can this be considered seeing?'",
    
    "Ananda (阿難) does not know that darkness is also a preceding dust-object. If there were no essence of seeing, who would know the darkness?",
    
    "△2. Analogizing that darkness and light are no different, pointing out that seeing is the mind.",
    
    "The Buddha told Ananda (阿難): 'Those blind people without eyes can only see darkness. Is there any difference between this and a sighted person being in a dark room?' Ananda (阿難) replied: 'World Honored One (世尊,a title for the Buddha), there is no difference between the darkness experienced by the person in the dark room and the darkness experienced by the blind people.' The Buddha said: 'Ananda (阿難), if a person without eyes completely sees the darkness before them, and suddenly gains eyesight, and then sees various colors in the preceding dust-objects, this can be called the eyes seeing. Then, a person in darkness, completely seeing the darkness before them, and suddenly obtains lamplight, and also sees various colors in the preceding dust-objects, should this be called the lamp seeing?'",
    
    "Those with and without eyes originally see darkness the same way. Then, what difference is there between the eyes opening and the lamp appearing, and seeing colors? This is actually using the lamp to exemplify the eyes, which can only reveal colors. And seeing darkness and seeing light is the mind, not the eyes. The following text will naturally clarify this.",
    
    "'If it is said that the lamp sees, and the lamp has the nature of seeing, then it would not be called a lamp. Moreover, what does the lamp's seeing have to do with you? Therefore, it should be known that the lamp can reveal colors, and in this way, it is the eyes that see, not the lamp. The eyes can reveal colors, and in this way, the nature of seeing is the mind, not the eyes.' Although Ananda (阿難) heard these words, like the assembly, his mouth was silent, but his mind had not yet awakened. He still hoped that the Tathagata (如來) would proclaim and reveal with a compassionate voice, joining his palms together, purifying his mind, and awaiting the Buddha's compassionate teaching.",
    
    "Here, it is directly pointed out that the nature of seeing is the mind. It will be known that all roots and dusts"
  ]
}

。何曾局礙也。破色心論云。以彼夢中。于無色處。則見有色。于有色處。不見色故。益信一切根塵。皆自心現。山青水綠。豈作他觀。夜暗晝明。何人境界。聖凡無別。事理全彰。而諸師乃分顯真破妄。漸明究示。恐非當日聖意爾。

  光從胸涌遍灌諸如來頂者。示佛佛同一心法也。旋至阿難及諸大眾者。示聖凡無二心法也。人同此心。心同此見。見同此眼。眼同前塵。塵有明暗。眼有虧全。所以顯見非暫無。是益知心本常住耳。故總而言。則心達于見。見寓於眼。眼顯前塵。悟者之內外圓脫。即迷者之根境膠黏。膠黏而後有圓脫。所謂迷以起悟。圓脫而後知膠黏。所謂悟以達迷。如來法喻。如數黑白。非天下之至神。其孰能與此上六顯見性非眼竟。

  △七徴客塵二義。以出主空顯見。分三。初如來問悟因由。

  爾時世尊舒兜羅綿網相光手。開五輪指。誨敕阿難。及諸大眾。我初成道。于鹿園中。為阿若多五比丘等及汝四眾言。一切眾生。不成菩提及阿羅漢。皆由客塵煩惱所誤。汝等當時因何開悟。今成聖果。

  佛初出家。王遣五人追侍。三父族。一阿鞞。此云馬勝。二䟦提。此云小賢。三拘利。即摩訶男。長者之稱。二母族。一阿若多。此云解本際。即憍陳那。此云火器。其先事火。即以為姓。最先解法。故云若多。二迦葉。此云飲光。佛成道后。在鹿園中。三轉法輪。說苦集滅道四諦。客塵即指集諦。分別煩惱。粗動如客。俱生微細如塵。皆煩惱障。此當時所說。今客塵但喻身境。然身即根身。境即器界。審

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本:",
    "哪裡會有侷限阻礙呢?《破色心論》中說:『在夢中,于無色之處,則能見到有色之物;于有色之處,反而見不到色。』更加確信一切根塵(指眼、耳、鼻、舌、身、意六根及其所對應的色、聲、香、味、觸、法六塵),都是自心顯現。山是青的,水是綠的,難道要作其他的理解嗎?夜晚是黑暗的,白天是明亮的,這是誰的境界呢?聖人與凡人沒有區別,事和理完全彰顯。而各位法師卻要區分顯現的真如和破除的妄想,漸次開明,究竟指示,恐怕不是當年佛陀的本意吧。",
    
    "『光從胸口涌出,遍灑灌注各位如來的頭頂』,這是顯示佛與佛之間同一心法。『旋轉到阿難及各位大眾』,這是顯示聖人與凡人沒有二種心法。人同此心,心同此見,見同此眼,眼同前塵。塵有明暗,眼有虧缺和完整。所以顯現的見性不是暫時沒有,是更加知道心本來就是常住不變的。所以總而言之,就是心通達于見,見寄託于眼,眼顯現前塵。覺悟的人內外圓融解脫,就是迷惑的人根和境膠著粘連。先有膠著粘連,然後才有圓融解脫,這就是所謂的因迷惑而生起覺悟;先有圓融解脫,然後才知道膠著粘連,這就是所謂的因覺悟而通達迷惑。如來的法和譬喻,就像計算黑白一樣。如果不是天下最神奇的人,誰能夠與此相比,來窮盡以上六種顯見性不是眼睛的道理呢?",
    
    "△七、徵詢客塵二義,以出主空來顯現見性。分為三部分。首先是如來問阿難開悟的因由。",
    
    "這時,世尊舒展像兜羅綿網一樣光亮的手,張開五指,教誨阿難以及各位大眾:『我最初成道時,在鹿野苑中,為阿若多五比丘(Ajñāta Kauṇḍinya,解本際)等人以及你們四眾弟子說,一切眾生不能成就菩提(bodhi,覺悟)和阿羅漢(arhat,斷絕煩惱,證入涅槃的聖人),都是由於客塵煩惱所迷惑。你們當時因為什麼而開悟,現在成就聖果呢?』",
    
    "佛陀最初出家時,國王派遣五個人追隨侍奉。三個人是父族:一是阿鞞(Aśvajit),這裡翻譯為馬勝;二是䟦提(Bhaddiya),這裡翻譯為小賢;三是拘利(Koliya),也就是摩訶男(Mahānāma),是長者的稱呼。兩個人是母族:一是阿若多(Ajñāta Kauṇḍinya),這裡翻譯為解本際,也就是憍陳那(Kauṇḍinya),這裡翻譯為火器,他先前侍奉火,就以此為姓。他最先理解佛法,所以叫做若多。二是迦葉(Kāśyapa),這裡翻譯為飲光。佛陀成道后,在鹿野苑中,三轉法輪,宣說苦集滅道四諦。客塵就是指集諦。分別煩惱,粗顯動搖的像客人,俱生微細的像灰塵,都是煩惱障。這是當時所說的。現在客塵只是比喻身和境。然而身就是根身,境就是器界。仔細審察。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version:",
    "Where would there be limitations or obstructions? The 'Treatise on Breaking the Mind of Form' says: 'In a dream, in a place without form, one can see things with form; in a place with form, one cannot see form.' This further confirms that all roots and dusts (referring to the six sense organs of eyes, ears, nose, tongue, body, and mind, and their corresponding objects of form, sound, smell, taste, touch, and dharma) are manifestations of one's own mind. The mountains are green, and the water is blue; should we interpret them in any other way? Night is dark, and day is bright; whose realm is this? There is no difference between sages and ordinary people; phenomena and principles are fully revealed. Yet, the masters distinguish between the manifested true nature and the delusions to be broken, gradually enlightening and ultimately instructing. I fear this is not the original intention of the Buddha.",
    
    "'Light emanates from the chest, pouring and irrigating the crowns of all Tathagatas (如來,one of the titles of a Buddha)', this demonstrates that Buddhas share the same mind-dharma. 'Revolving to Ānanda (阿難,Buddha's attendant) and all the assembly', this demonstrates that there is no duality between the mind-dharma of sages and ordinary people. People share this mind, the mind shares this view, the view shares this eye, and the eye shares the preceding dust. Dust has brightness and darkness, and the eye has deficiency and completeness. Therefore, the manifested seeing is not temporarily absent; it further reveals that the mind is inherently permanent. So, in summary, the mind reaches the seeing, the seeing resides in the eye, and the eye manifests the preceding dust. The enlightened person has internal and external perfect liberation, while the deluded person has roots and objects glued together. Only after being glued together can there be perfect liberation; this is the so-called awakening arises from delusion. Only after perfect liberation can one know the glued together; this is the so-called enlightenment reaches delusion. The Buddha's dharma and metaphors are like counting black and white. If not for the most miraculous person in the world, who could compare to this and exhaust the principle that the above six manifested seeing natures are not the eye?",
    
    "△7. Questioning the two meanings of guest and dust, using the emptiness of the host to reveal the seeing nature. Divided into three parts. First, the Tathagata asks Ānanda about the causes of enlightenment.",
    
    "At that time, the World Honored One extended his hand, radiant like a tula cotton net, opened his five fingers, and instructed Ānanda and all the assembly: 'When I first attained enlightenment, in the Deer Park, I said to Ajñāta Kauṇḍinya (阿若多五比丘,one of the first five disciples of the Buddha) and the fourfold assembly, that all sentient beings cannot attain bodhi (菩提,enlightenment) and arhat (阿羅漢,one who has extinguished all defilements and attained nirvana), are all misled by the afflictions of guest and dust. What did you awaken to at that time, and now attain the holy fruit?'",
    
    "When the Buddha first left home, the king sent five people to follow and serve him. Three were from his father's clan: first, Aśvajit (阿鞞), here translated as Horse Victory; second, Bhaddiya (䟦提), here translated as Small Worthy; third, Koliya (拘利), which is Mahānāma (摩訶男), a title for an elder. Two were from his mother's clan: first, Ajñāta Kauṇḍinya (阿若多,one of the first five disciples of the Buddha), here translated as Understanding the Origin, which is Kauṇḍinya (憍陳那), here translated as Fire Vessel, he previously served fire, so he took this as his surname. He was the first to understand the Dharma, so he is called Ajñāta. Second, Kāśyapa (迦葉), here translated as Drinking Light. After the Buddha attained enlightenment, in the Deer Park, he turned the Dharma wheel three times, proclaiming the Four Noble Truths of suffering, accumulation, cessation, and path. Guest and dust refer to the truth of accumulation. Distinguishing afflictions, the coarse and moving ones are like guests, and the co-arisen subtle ones are like dust, all are afflictive obstructions. This is what was said at that time. Now guest and dust are only metaphors for body and environment. However, the body is the root body, and the environment is the vessel world. Examine carefully."
  ]
}

知根身器界。一如客塵。則煩惱所知。同時頓盡。借小鏡大。不可拘例。下文以動為身。以動為境。便是此意。蓋直指主空。以斥從前遺失真性。認物為己。更無別有耳。

  △二述悟客塵二義。分二。初述客義。

  時憍陳那起立白佛。我今長老。于大眾中。獨得解名。因悟客塵二字成果。世尊。譬如行客。投寄旅亭。或宿或食。宿食事畢。俶裝前涂。不遑安住。若實主人。自無攸往。如是思惟。不住名客。住名主人。以不住者。名為客義。

  德長臘高。故云長老。最初聞法。佛問解不。如雲已解。故曰獨得解名。俶作也。動也。裝束也。裹也。身境變還。剎那不住。誠如旅泊。遄往靡停。誰為主人。甘受流轉。觀化知歸。晏然常寂。

  △二述塵義。

  又如新霽。清晹昇天。光入隙中。發明空中諸有塵相。塵質搖動。虛空寂然。如是思惟。澄寂名空。搖動名塵。以搖動者。名為塵義。佛言如是。

  霽晴霽也。晹日也。隙光照空。塵相易見。塵遍法界。空性不搖。心在根境。妄見紛紜。見妄不紛。性空自爾。

  上二述悟客塵二義竟。

  △三以動靜顯見。分三。初輪掌開合。徴見常住。

  即時如來於大眾中。屈五輪指。屈已復開。開已又屈。謂阿難言。汝今何見。阿難言。我見如來百寶輪掌眾中開合。佛告阿難。汝見我手眾中開合。為是我手有開有合。為復汝見有開有合。阿難言。世尊寶手眾中開合。我見如來手自開合。非我見性有開有合。佛言誰動誰靜。阿難言。佛手不住。而我見性

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "知曉根身(構成身體的要素)、器界(物質世界)都如客塵(暫時的、不真實的現象),那麼煩惱障(由煩惱產生的障礙)和所知障(由知識產生的障礙)就能同時徹底消除。就像用小鏡子來比喻大的事物一樣,不能拘泥於固定的例子。下文用動來比喻身,用動來比喻境,就是這個意思。這實際上是直接指出主體是空性的,以此來駁斥從前遺失真性,認外物為自己的錯誤觀念,除此之外沒有別的意思了。",
    
    "△二、敘述領悟客塵二義。分為兩部分。首先敘述客義。",
    
    "這時,憍陳那(Kauṇḍinya,五比丘之一,最初的佛弟子之一)起立對佛說:『我現在年長,在大眾中,獨自獲得解脫之名,是因為領悟了客塵二字而證得果位。世尊,譬如一個行路的客人,投宿在旅店裡,或住宿或吃飯,住宿吃飯完畢,整理行裝前往下一個目的地,沒有時間安住。如果真是主人,自然不會離開。這樣思維,不住留的叫做客,住留的叫做主人。以不住留的,稱為客義。』",
    
    "德行高尚,年齡也大,所以稱為長老。最初聽聞佛法,佛問他是否理解,他回答說已經理解,所以說獨自獲得解脫之名。『俶』是開始,是動的意思,是裝束的意思,是包裹的意思。身和境的變化,剎那不停留,確實像旅客一樣,匆匆前往沒有停留。誰是主人呢?甘願承受流轉。觀察變化而知曉歸宿,安然常寂。",
    
    "△二、敘述塵義。",
    
    "『又如雨後初晴,清澈的陽光升上天空,光線從縫隙中射入,顯現出空中各種塵埃的形狀。塵埃的本質是搖動的,而虛空是寂靜的。這樣思維,澄靜的叫做空,搖動的叫做塵。以搖動的,稱為塵義。』佛說:『正是這樣。』",
    
    "雨後轉晴叫做霽,太陽叫做晹。光線照進空中,塵埃的形狀容易看見。塵埃遍佈法界,空性的本質不搖動。心執著于根(感官)和境(外物),錯誤地看見紛紜的現象。如果能看見虛妄而不被紛擾,空性自然顯現。",
    
    "以上是敘述領悟客塵二義完畢。",
    
    "△三、用動靜來顯示見性。分為三部分。首先是輪掌開合,徵詢見性常住。",
    
    "當時,如來在大眾中,彎曲五根手指,彎曲之後又張開,張開之後又彎曲。對阿難(Ānanda,佛陀的十大弟子之一,以記憶力強著稱)說:『你現在看見什麼?』阿難說:『我看見如來百寶輪的手掌在大眾中開合。』佛告訴阿難:『你看見我的手在大眾中開合,是我的手有開有合,還是你的見性有開有合?』阿難說:『世尊寶手在大眾中開合,我看見如來的手自己在開合,不是我的見性有開有合。』佛說:『誰動誰靜?』阿難說:『佛的手不住留,而我的見性"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Knowing that the roots of the body (the elements that constitute the body) and the realm of objects (the material world) are like transient dust (temporary, unreal phenomena), then the afflictive obscurations (obstacles arising from afflictions) and the cognitive obscurations (obstacles arising from knowledge) can be simultaneously and completely eliminated. Just as using a small mirror to illustrate large things, one should not be bound by fixed examples. The following text uses movement to represent the body and movement to represent the realm, which is the meaning of this. This actually directly points out that the subject is emptiness, in order to refute the previous mistake of losing the true nature and recognizing external objects as oneself, and there is no other meaning besides this.",
    
    "△2. Narrating the two meanings of understanding 'guest' and 'dust'. Divided into two parts. First, narrating the meaning of 'guest'.",
    
    "At that time, Kauṇḍinya (one of the five bhikshus, one of the first disciples of the Buddha) stood up and said to the Buddha: 'I am now old, and among the assembly, I have uniquely obtained the name of liberation, because I have realized the two words 'guest' and 'dust' and attained the fruit. World Honored One, it is like a traveler lodging in an inn, either staying or eating. After staying and eating, he prepares his luggage and goes to the next destination, without time to settle down. If he is truly the owner, he will naturally not leave. Thinking in this way, one who does not stay is called a guest, and one who stays is called the owner. That which does not stay is called the meaning of 'guest'.'",
    
    "His virtue is high and his seniority is great, so he is called an elder. When he first heard the Dharma, the Buddha asked him if he understood, and he replied that he already understood, so it is said that he uniquely obtained the name of liberation. '俶' means to begin, it means movement, it means to dress, it means to wrap. The changes of body and realm never stop for a moment, indeed like a traveler, hurrying on without stopping. Who is the owner? Willing to endure transmigration. Observing change and knowing the destination, peacefully and constantly still.",
    
    "△2. Narrating the meaning of 'dust'.",
    
    "'Also, like after a rain, when the clear sun rises into the sky, light shines through the cracks, revealing the shapes of various dust particles in the air. The nature of dust is to move, while the nature of space is still. Thinking in this way, that which is clear and still is called emptiness, and that which moves is called dust. That which moves is called the meaning of 'dust'.' The Buddha said: 'It is so.'",
    
    "Clearing up after rain is called 'ji', the sun is called 'yang'. When light shines into the air, the shapes of dust particles are easily seen. Dust pervades the Dharma realm, and the nature of emptiness does not move. The mind clings to the roots (senses) and objects (external things), mistakenly seeing diverse phenomena. If one can see illusion without being disturbed, emptiness will naturally manifest.",
    
    "The above is the completion of narrating the two meanings of understanding 'guest' and 'dust'.",
    
    "△3. Using movement and stillness to reveal the nature of seeing. Divided into three parts. First, rotating the palm to open and close, inquiring about the permanence of the nature of seeing.",
    
    "At that time, the Tathagata (如來,another name for Buddha) in the assembly, bent his five fingers, bent them and then opened them, opened them and then bent them. He said to Ānanda (阿難,one of the ten great disciples of the Buddha, known for his strong memory): 'What do you see now?' Ānanda said: 'I see the Tathagata's palm with a hundred treasures opening and closing in the assembly.' The Buddha told Ānanda: 'You see my hand opening and closing in the assembly, is it my hand that opens and closes, or is it your nature of seeing that opens and closes?' Ānanda said: 'World Honored One, the precious hand of the World Honored One opens and closes in the assembly, I see the Tathagata's hand opening and closing by itself, it is not my nature of seeing that opens and closes.' The Buddha said: 'Who moves and who is still?' Ānanda said: 'The Buddha's hand does not stay, but my nature of seeing"
  ]
}

尚無有靜。誰為無住。佛言。如是。

  以手有開合。反形見無開合。以手有動靜。反形見無動靜。開合動靜。此以喻境。

  △二飛光徴見無動。

  如來於是從輪掌中飛一寶光在阿難右。即時阿難回首右盼。又放一光在阿難左。阿難又則回首左盼。佛告阿難。汝頭今日因何搖動。阿難言。我見如來出妙寶光來我左右。故左右觀。頭自搖動。阿難。汝盼佛光。左右動頭。為汝頭動。為復見動。世尊。我頭自動。而我見性尚無有止。誰為搖動。佛言。如是。

  以頭自動。反形見性無動。此乃指身。故下有以動為身。以動為境之責。

  △三正示見性無有動靜卷舒。

  於是如來普告大眾。若復眾生。以搖動者名之為塵。以不住者名之為客。汝觀阿難。頭自動搖。見無所動。又汝觀我。手自開合。見無舒捲。

  此因阿難之明。並示大眾。若復眾生。審知搖動為塵。不住為客。則知在身在境。兩無顛倒。又以頭手現前發明。使無疑惑。然後總責其遺失之過。下文自明。

  云何汝今以動為身。以動為境。從始洎終。唸唸生滅。遺失真性。顛倒行事。性心失真。認物為己。輪迴是中。自取流轉。

  自體空寂。不能自見。而妄認四大。是以動為身也。牛有兔無。皆非法性。實相現前。而反滋妄計。是以動為境也。此凡夫我執難破。二乘法想尚存。所爲念念生滅。常計無常。不覺失真。無常計常。終成認物。故世尊總斥為遺夫真性。顛倒行事。輪迴是中。自取流轉。

  上章以塵顯見。以見顯心。今

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "尚且沒有靜止。誰是沒有住處(無所停留)的呢?佛說:『正是這樣。』",
    
    "用手有張開和閉合,反過來顯現見性沒有張開和閉合。用手有動和靜,反過來顯現見性沒有動和靜。張開閉合、動靜,這是用手來比喻外境。",
    
    "二、飛光顯示見性沒有動。",
    
    "這時,如來從輪狀的手掌中放出一道寶光在阿難(Ananda,佛陀十大弟子之一,以記憶力強著稱)的右邊。阿難立刻回頭向右看。又放出一道光在阿難的左邊,阿難又回頭向左看。佛告訴阿難:『你的頭今天因為什麼搖動?』阿難說:『我看見如來放出奇妙的寶光來到我的左右,所以我左右觀看,頭自己搖動。』阿難,你盼看佛光,左右轉動頭,是你的頭在動,還是你的見性在動?』世尊,我的頭自己動,而我的見性尚且沒有停止,誰在搖動呢?』佛說:『正是這樣。』",
    
    "用頭自己動,反過來顯現見性沒有動。這是指身體。所以下面有以動為身,以動為境的責問。",
    
    "三、正式開示見性沒有動靜卷舒。",
    
    "於是如來普遍告訴大眾:『如果還有眾生,把搖動的東西叫做塵,把不住的東西叫做客。你們看阿難,頭自己搖動,見性沒有動。又你們看我,手自己張開閉合,見性沒有舒捲。』",
    
    "這是因為阿難的明白,並開示大眾。如果還有眾生,確實知道搖動是塵,不住是客,就知道在身在境,都沒有顛倒。又用頭手現前發明,使沒有疑惑。然後總責備他遺失的過錯。下文自然明白。",
    
    "為什麼你現在把動的東西當作身體,把動的東西當作外境?從開始到結束,唸唸生滅,遺失了真性,顛倒行事。性心失去了真,認外物為自己,在輪迴中,自己招取流轉。",
    
    "自體空寂,不能自己看見,而妄自認為四大是自己,所以把動的東西當作身體。牛有兔無,都不是法性。實相現前,反而滋生妄想,所以把動的東西當作外境。這是凡夫的我執難以破除,二乘的法想還存在。所以所作所爲念念生滅,常常認為無常是常,不覺察遺失了真性。無常認為是常,終究成為認外物為自己。所以世尊總責備為遺失了真性,顛倒行事,在輪迴中,自己招取流轉。",
    
    "上一章用塵來顯示見性,用見性來顯示心。現在"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "There is still no stillness. Who is without abiding (nowhere to dwell)? The Buddha said, 'It is so.'",
    
    "With the hand having opening and closing, conversely, it reveals that the seeing nature has no opening and closing. With the hand having movement and stillness, conversely, it reveals that the seeing nature has no movement and stillness. Opening, closing, movement, and stillness, these are used as metaphors for the external environment.",
    
    "△2. The flying light demonstrates that the seeing nature has no movement.",
    
    "At that time, the Tathagata (如來,one of the titles of the Buddha) emitted a precious light from his wheel-like palm on Ananda's (阿難,one of the ten principal disciples of the Buddha, known for his excellent memory) right. Immediately, Ananda turned his head to look to the right. Then, he emitted another light on Ananda's left, and Ananda again turned his head to look to the left. The Buddha said to Ananda, 'Why is your head shaking today?' Ananda said, 'I saw the Tathagata emit wonderful precious lights coming to my left and right, so I looked left and right, and my head moved on its own.' 'Ananda, you are looking at the Buddha's light, turning your head left and right. Is it your head that is moving, or is it your seeing nature that is moving?' 'World Honored One (世尊,a title for the Buddha), my head is moving on its own, but my seeing nature has not stopped. Who is shaking?' The Buddha said, 'It is so.'",
    
    "Using the head moving on its own, conversely, it reveals that the seeing nature has no movement. This refers to the body. Therefore, below there is the questioning of taking movement as the body and taking movement as the environment.",
    
    "△3. Directly showing that the seeing nature has no movement, stillness, contraction, or expansion.",
    
    "Then the Tathagata universally announced to the assembly, 'If there are sentient beings who call what is shaking 'dust' and what is not abiding 'guest,' you see Ananda, his head shakes on its own, but the seeing nature does not move. Also, you see me, my hand opens and closes on its own, but the seeing nature does not expand or contract.'",
    
    "This is because of Ananda's understanding, and it is shown to the assembly. If there are sentient beings who truly know that shaking is dust and not abiding is guest, then they will know that in the body and in the environment, there is no inversion. Also, using the head and hand to manifest and clarify, so that there is no doubt. Then, he generally blames the fault of losing it. The following text will naturally clarify.",
    
    "Why do you now take what moves as the body and what moves as the environment? From beginning to end, with every thought arising and ceasing, you lose your true nature and act in a reversed way. The nature-mind loses its truth, and you recognize things as yourself, transmigrating within this, taking on the cycle of rebirth yourself.",
    
    "The self-nature is empty and still, unable to see itself, and falsely recognizes the four great elements as itself, therefore taking what moves as the body. What the cow has, the rabbit does not, none of these are the nature of Dharma. The true form appears, but instead, it generates false calculations, therefore taking what moves as the environment. This is because the ego-attachment of ordinary people is difficult to break, and the Dharma-attachment of the two vehicles (二乘, Śrāvakayāna and Pratyekabuddhayāna) still exists. Therefore, what is done arises and ceases with every thought, constantly considering impermanence as permanent, not realizing the loss of true nature. Considering impermanence as permanent, ultimately becomes recognizing things as oneself. Therefore, the World Honored One generally rebukes it as losing the true nature, acting in a reversed way, transmigrating within this, taking on the cycle of rebirth oneself.",
    
    "The previous chapter used dust to reveal seeing nature, and used seeing nature to reveal mind. Now"
  ]
}

乃言此見之本常住。此見之元不動也。眾生日用。與一切境憧憧往來。而不能安住者。非我心之水無住也。心不是客。心不是塵。從來久矣。心迷於客。心迷於塵。亦從來久矣。迷則不能自認。客去與去。塵搖與搖。唸唸生滅。甘同流轉。所謂以動為身。以動為境。而不知客中有主。在動不搖。曾無一念還觀自得。又安得其不顛倒行事。終其身而不自覺也耶。

  大佛頂如來密因修證了義諸菩薩萬行首楞嚴經直指卷第一

  音釋

  淼

  (音杪水渺茫貌)。

  晃

  (黃入聲光耀也)。

  眚

  (生上聲目病)。

  啐

  (音翠鳥食也)。

  謐

  (音密安也)。

  撤

  (音轍除也)。

  臊

  (音騷膏臭也)。

  儱侗

  (儱音壟侗音同未成器也)。

  碗

  (與碗同)。

  挃

  (音質擿也)。

  懵

  (音夢不明也)。

  隳

  (音灰)。

  矍

  (音钁遽視貌)。

  拶

  (贊入聲排迫也)。

  吝

  (音吝慳也)。

  謬

  (繆去聲差誤也)。

  昱

  (音育日光)。

  赩

  (音隙大赤也)。

  俶

  (音束)。 卍新續藏第 14 冊 No. 0291 楞嚴經直指

  大佛頂如來密因修證了義諸菩薩萬行首楞嚴經直指卷第二

  洞宗三十四世丹霞沙門 函是天然 疏

  嗣法門人 

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "於是說,能見之性的根本是恒常不變的,這個能見的本源也是不動的。眾生在日常生活中,與一切外境紛紛擾擾地來來往往,卻不能安住于本心,這並非是我的心像水一樣沒有定性。心不是外來的事物,心也不是塵埃。本來就是如此,已經很久了。心迷失於外境,心迷失於塵埃,也已經很久了。一旦迷失,就不能認識自己,外境離去就跟著離去,塵埃搖動就跟著搖動,唸唸生滅,甘願隨波逐流。這就是所謂的把動盪變化當作自身,把動盪變化當作境界,卻不知道在動盪的外境中有一個不變的主體,即使在動盪中也不會搖擺。從來沒有一念回頭觀照,從而自我覺悟,又怎麼能不顛倒行事,終其一生而不自覺悟呢?",
    
    "《大佛頂如來密因修證了義諸菩薩萬行首楞嚴經直指》卷第一",
    
    "音釋",
    
    "淼 (miǎo,水渺茫的樣子)。",
    "晃 (huǎng,光耀的樣子)。",
    "眚 (shěng,眼睛的疾病)。",
    "啐 (cuì,鳥吃東西的樣子)。",
    "謐 (mì,安靜)。",
    "撤 (chè,除去)。",
    "臊 (sāo,油脂的臭味)。",
    "儱侗 (lǒng tóng,未成器的樣子)。",
    "碗 (wǎn,同『碗』)。",
    "挃 (zhì,摘取)。",
    "懵 (měng,不明白)。",
    "隳 (huī)。",
    "矍 (jué,驚視的樣子)。",
    "拶 (zā,逼迫)。",
    "吝 (lìn,吝嗇)。",
    "謬 (miù,差錯)。",
    "昱 (yù,日光)。",
    "赩 (xì,大紅色)。",
    "俶 (shù)。",
    
    "《大佛頂如來密因修證了義諸菩薩萬行首楞嚴經直指》卷第二",
    
    "洞宗第三十四世丹霞沙門 函是天然 疏",
    
    "嗣法門人"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Therefore, it is said that the fundamental nature of seeing is constant and unchanging, and the origin of this seeing is also immovable. Sentient beings in their daily lives interact with all external environments in a bustling and chaotic manner, yet they cannot abide in their original mind. This is not because my mind is as unstable as water. The mind is not an external object, nor is it dust. It has always been this way, for a long time. The mind is lost in external environments, and the mind is lost in dust, also for a long time. Once lost, one cannot recognize oneself. When the external environment departs, one follows; when the dust shakes, one follows. Thoughts arise and cease in every moment, willingly going with the flow. This is what is meant by taking movement as the body and taking movement as the environment, without knowing that within the moving environment there is an unchanging subject, which does not waver even in movement. Never has there been a single thought of turning back to observe and attain self-realization. How then can one not act in a reversed manner, spending one's entire life without awakening?",
    
    "The Shurangama Sutra Direct Pointing, Volume 1",
    
    "Phonetic Annotations",
    
    "淼 (miǎo, the appearance of water being vast and indistinct).",
    "晃 (huǎng, the appearance of radiance).",
    "眚 (shěng, an eye disease).",
    "啐 (cuì, the way a bird eats).",
    "謐 (mì, quiet).",
    "撤 (chè, to remove).",
    "臊 (sāo, the smell of rancid grease).",
    "儱侗 (lǒng tóng, the appearance of being unfinished or unformed).",
    "碗 (wǎn, same as '碗' - bowl).",
    "挃 (zhì, to pluck or pick).",
    "懵 (měng, unclear or ignorant).",
    "隳 (huī).",
    "矍 (jué, the appearance of startled gaze).",
    "拶 (zā, to press or squeeze).",
    "吝 (lìn, stingy).",
    "謬 (miù, error).",
    "昱 (yù, sunlight).",
    "赩 (xì, bright red).",
    "俶 (shù).",
    
    "The Shurangama Sutra Direct Pointing, Volume 2",
    
    "Danxia Shamen Han Shi Tianran, 34th Generation of the Dong Sect, Commentary",
    
    "Successor Disciple"
  ]
}

今釋澹歸 閱

  今辯樂說 較

  上七徴客塵二義以出主空顯見竟。

  △八示見性不滅。分六。初求示生滅與不生滅。

  爾時阿難及諸大眾。聞佛示誨。身心泰然。念無始來。失卻本心。妄認緣塵分別影事。今日開悟。如失乳兒。忽遇慈母。合掌禮佛。愿聞如來顯出身心真妄虛實。現前生滅與不生滅。二發明性。

  阿難雖悟離塵有性。而性體之真妄。未究根源。則動用之虛實。目前難辨。是生滅之心。現在周旋。而不生滅性。尚紆湊泊。良由初獲知歸。識智未分。故如來更從根中指出。使知無憎愛之曉了。不假思惟。則不生滅之全機。即在當念。此下文觀河之見所由明也。

  △二匿王啟請。

  時波斯匿王起立白佛。我昔未承諸佛誨敕。見迦旃延毗羅胝子。咸言此身死後斷滅。名為涅槃。我雖值佛。今猶狐疑。云何發揮證知此心不生滅地。今此大眾諸有漏者。咸皆愿聞。

  迦旃延具云迦羅鳩陀迦旃延。此云翦發。此外道說殺害一切。若無慚愧。不墮地獄。猶如虛空。不受塵水。毗羅胝應云刪阇夜毗羅胝子。刪阇夜此云正勝。字也。毗羅胝此云不作。母名。略曰毗羅胝子。此外道說道不須求。生死劫數。苦儘自得。如轉縷圓于高山。縷儘自止。皆屬斷見。撥無因果。六師之二也。涅槃聲聞未許見性。則所見偏真。猶屬七識。未獲常住。皆名有漏。是不能無疑耳。

  △三徴肉身遷變。

  佛告大王。汝身現在。今復問汝。汝此肉身。為同金剛常住不朽。為復變壞。世尊。我今此身。終

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "今釋澹歸閱",
    "今辯樂說較",
    "以上七重征問客塵和二重意義,是爲了顯明主空和顯現見性而結束。",
    "△第八部分展示見性不滅。分為六個部分。首先是請求開示生滅和不生滅的道理。",
    "這時,阿難(Ananda,佛陀十大弟子之一)和所有在場的大眾,聽聞佛陀的教誨,身心感到安泰平和。他們想到從無始以來,喪失了本來的真心,虛妄地執著于外在因緣和塵境所產生的分別念頭和虛幻影像。今天終於開悟,就像丟失了乳汁的嬰兒,忽然遇到了慈愛的母親。於是合掌向佛陀行禮,希望聽聞如來顯現身心的真實和虛妄,以及現前所見的生滅和不生滅的道理。",
    "阿難雖然領悟到離開塵境之外有真性存在,但是對於真性的本體是真還是妄,還沒有徹底探究根源。那麼對於真性所產生的動用是虛還是實,目前還難以分辨。是生滅之心,現在還在周圍運轉。而不生滅的真性,還需要進一步去理解和契合。這實在是由於剛剛獲得知見迴歸真性的門徑,識和智還沒有分清楚。所以如來更從根源上指點出來,使他們知道沒有憎愛之心的明瞭覺悟,不需要經過思惟。那麼不生滅的全部機能,就在當下這一念之中。這也就是下文觀河之見得以明瞭的原因。",
    "△第二部分是波斯匿王(Prasenajit,古印度憍薩羅國國王)的啟請。",
    "這時,波斯匿王(Prasenajit)起立,向佛陀稟白說:『我過去沒有接受諸佛的教誨,見到迦旃延(Katyayana,六師外道之一)和毗羅胝子(Pūraṇa Kassapa,六師外道之一),他們都說這個身體死後就斷滅了,這就叫做涅槃(Nirvana,佛教術語,指解脫)。我雖然遇到了佛陀,現在仍然心存狐疑。要怎樣才能闡發和證明這個心是不生不滅的呢?現在這裡的大眾,所有還有煩惱的人,都希望聽聞。』",
    "迦旃延(Katyayana)的全稱是迦羅鳩陀迦旃延,翻譯成漢語是『剪髮』。這個外道說殺害一切眾生,如果沒有慚愧之心,就不會墮入地獄,就像虛空一樣,不受塵土和水的沾染。毗羅胝子(Pūraṇa Kassapa)應該稱為刪阇夜毗羅胝子(Sanjaya Belatthiputta)。刪阇夜(Sanjaya)翻譯成漢語是『正勝』,是他的名字。毗羅胝(Belattha)翻譯成漢語是『不作』,是他母親的名字。省略地說就是毗羅胝子(Sanjaya Belatthiputta)。這個外道說修道不需要尋求,生死輪迴的劫數,苦難結束自然就能得到解脫,就像在高山上轉線團,線用完了自然就停止了。這些都屬於斷滅見,否定因果報應。他們是六師外道中的兩位。涅槃(Nirvana)是聲聞乘還沒有證見真性時所理解的,那麼他們所見的只是片面的真理,仍然屬於第七識的範疇,沒有獲得常住不變的境界,都叫做有漏。所以不能沒有疑惑。",
    "△第三部分是征問肉身的遷變。",
    "佛陀告訴波斯匿王(Prasenajit)說:『你的身體現在還在,我現在問你。你的這個肉身,是像金剛一樣常住不朽,還是會變化壞滅呢?』世尊,我現在這個身體,終究",
    "English version",
    "Now Released Dan Gui - Read",
    "Now Discussing Joyful Speech - Compare",
    "The above sevenfold questioning of the guest dust and twofold meanings concludes to reveal the emptiness of the host and manifest the seeing nature.",
    "△ Section 8 demonstrates the imperishable nature of seeing. Divided into six parts. The first is to request instruction on the principles of arising and ceasing versus non-arising and non-ceasing.",
    "At that time, Ananda (one of the Buddha's ten great disciples) and all the assembly, hearing the Buddha's teachings, felt peaceful and at ease in body and mind. They thought about how, from beginningless time, they had lost their original true mind, falsely clinging to the discriminations and illusory images produced by external conditions and dust realms. Today, they finally awakened, like an infant who had lost its milk, suddenly encountering its loving mother. They then joined their palms and bowed to the Buddha, wishing to hear the Tathagata reveal the truth and falsehood of body and mind, as well as the principles of arising and ceasing versus non-arising and non-ceasing that are present before them.",
    "Although Ananda (one of the Buddha's ten great disciples) realized that there is a nature beyond the dust, he had not yet thoroughly explored the root of whether the nature's essence is true or false. Then, whether the functions arising from the nature are illusory or real is currently difficult to distinguish. The mind of arising and ceasing is still revolving around them. And the non-arising and non-ceasing nature still needs further understanding and alignment. This is truly because they have just gained access to the path of returning to the true nature, and the discriminating consciousness and wisdom have not yet been clearly distinguished. Therefore, the Tathagata further points it out from the root, so that they know the clear awakening without hatred or love, not requiring thought. Then the entire function of non-arising and non-ceasing is in the present moment. This is why the seeing of the river in the following text is able to be clarified.",
    "△ Section 2 is King Prasenajit's (King of Kosala in ancient India) request.",
    "At that time, King Prasenajit (King of Kosala in ancient India) stood up and reported to the Buddha, 'In the past, I had not received the teachings of the Buddhas, and I saw Katyayana (one of the Six Heretical Teachers) and Pūraṇa Kassapa (one of the Six Heretical Teachers), who all said that this body would be annihilated after death, and this is called Nirvana (Buddhist term, referring to liberation). Although I have encountered the Buddha, I still have doubts. How can I explain and prove that this mind is non-arising and non-ceasing? Now the assembly here, all those who still have afflictions, wish to hear.'",
    "Katyayana's (one of the Six Heretical Teachers) full name is Kakuda Katyayana, which translates to 'cut hair' in Chinese. This heretic said that killing all beings, if without shame, will not fall into hell, just like the void, not affected by dust and water. Pūraṇa Kassapa (one of the Six Heretical Teachers) should be called Sanjaya Belatthiputta. Sanjaya translates to 'right victory' in Chinese, which is his name. Belattha translates to 'non-doing' in Chinese, which is his mother's name. The abbreviated form is Pūraṇa Kassapa. This heretic said that cultivation does not need to seek, the kalpas of samsara, the end of suffering will naturally be liberated, just like winding a ball of thread on a high mountain, the thread will stop when it runs out. These all belong to annihilationist views, denying cause and effect. They are two of the Six Heretical Teachers. Nirvana (Buddhist term, referring to liberation) is understood by the Sravakas when they have not yet witnessed the true nature, then what they see is only a partial truth, still belonging to the realm of the seventh consciousness, not having attained the state of permanence, all called with outflows. Therefore, they cannot be without doubt.",
    "△ Section 3 is questioning the impermanence of the physical body.",
    "The Buddha said to King Prasenajit (King of Kosala in ancient India), 'Your body is still present now, and I will ask you now. Is your physical body like diamond, permanent and imperishable, or will it change and decay?' 'World Honored One, my current body will ultimately"
  ]
}

從變滅。佛言。大王。汝未曾滅。云何知滅。世尊。我此無常變壞之身雖未曾滅。我觀現前唸唸遷謝。新新不住。如火成灰。漸漸銷殞。殞亡不息。決知此身當從滅盡。佛言。如是。

  以肉身無不變滅。起身中有不變滅。汝未曾滅。云何知滅。正動其自知唸唸遷謝。冀一覺察。返觀不遠。

  △四較顏貌童耄。

  大王。汝今生齡。已從衰老。顏貌何如童子之時。世尊。我昔孩孺。膚[勝-力+天]潤澤。年至長成。血氣充滿。而今頹齡。迫於衰耄。形色枯悴。精神昏昧。發白面皺。逮將不久。如何見比充益之時。

  以童年顏貌。較之衰老。蓋就身變以形身中有不變也。始生曰孩。始行曰孺。皮表曰膚。文理曰[勝-力+天]。齡謂年。年已六十。故云頹。頹衰朽也。八十曰耄。言逼近也。

  △五審遷化密移。

  佛言。大王。汝之形容。應不頓朽。王言。世尊。變化密移。我誠不覺。寒暑遷流。漸至於此。何以故。我年二十。雖號年少。顏貌已老初十歲時。三十之年。又衰二十。於今六十又過於二。觀五十時。宛然強壯。世尊。我見密移。雖此殂落。其間流易。且限十年。若復令我微細思惟。其變寧唯一紀二紀。實為年變。豈唯年變。亦兼月化。何直月化。兼又日遷。沉思諦觀。剎那剎那。唸唸之間不得停住。故知我身終從變滅。

  前結身變。此結年變。至於剎那。即與本際相近。然後出身中不滅一句。世人粗獷。不能見此。故下乃以根性相示也。變化密移四句。總嘆遷流之易。密移不覺。備極迷

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "從變滅說起。佛說:『大王,你並未曾滅亡,怎麼知道會滅亡呢?』國王說:『世尊,我這無常變壞之身雖然沒有滅亡,但我觀察現在,唸唸遷謝,新新不住,就像火燒成灰,漸漸消殞,殞亡不息,我確信此身終將滅盡。』佛說:『正是如此。』",
    
    "因為肉身沒有不變滅的,從起身中看到不變滅。你未曾滅亡,怎麼知道會滅亡呢?正在於動用你的自知之明,唸唸遷謝,希望你能覺察,反觀自身並不遙遠。",
    
    "△四、比較顏貌童年和老年。",
    
    "『大王,你現在的年齡,已經衰老,顏貌和童年時相比如何?』國王說:『世尊,我小時候,面板柔潤光澤,到了成年,血氣充滿。而現在到了衰老的年齡,迫近衰老,形色枯槁憔悴,精神昏昧,頭髮變白,面容皺紋,將不久於人世,怎麼能和充盈的時候相比呢?』",
    
    "用童年的顏貌,和衰老相比,大概是就身體的變化,來形容身體中不變的東西。剛出生叫孩,剛會走叫孺。皮表叫膚,紋理叫[勝-力+天](面板的紋理)。年齡指年歲,年齡已經六十,所以說頹,頹是衰朽的意思。八十歲叫耄,是逼近的意思。",
    
    "△五、審視遷化密移。",
    
    "佛說:『大王,你的形容,應該不是一下子就衰老的吧?』國王說:『世尊,變化在不知不覺中進行,我確實沒有察覺。寒暑遷流,漸漸到了現在這個地步。為什麼呢?我二十歲的時候,雖然號稱年少,但顏貌已經比十歲的時候老了。三十歲的時候,又比二十歲的時候衰老。現在六十多歲,看五十歲的時候,仍然覺得強壯。世尊,我看到這種不知不覺的轉移,雖然最終會衰落,但其間流逝變化,且以十年為限。如果讓我仔細思考,這種變化難道僅僅是十年二十年嗎?實際上是年年都在變化,豈止是年年變化,也包括月月的變化。豈止是月月的變化,還包括日日的遷移。沉思諦觀,剎那剎那,唸唸之間不得停住,所以知道我的身體終將變滅。』",
    
    "前面總結了身體的變化,這裡總結了年份的變化,直到剎那,就與本際(事物本來的狀態)相近了。然後引出身體中不滅的一句。世人粗獷,不能見到這些,所以下面用根性來顯示。",
    "『變化密移』四句,總嘆遷流的容易。不知不覺的轉移,極其迷惑。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Starting from change and extinction. The Buddha said, 'Great King, you have not yet perished, how do you know you will perish?' The King said, 'World Honored One, although this impermanent and decaying body of mine has not perished, I observe the present, with thoughts constantly changing and ceasing, new arising without stopping, like fire turning to ashes, gradually diminishing and ceasing. I am certain that this body will eventually perish.' The Buddha said, 'It is so.'",
    
    "Because the physical body is subject to constant change and extinction, from the arising of the body, one sees the unchanging and non-extinguishing. You have not yet perished, how do you know you will perish? It lies in using your self-awareness, with thoughts constantly changing and ceasing, hoping you can perceive it, and reflecting on yourself is not far away.",
    
    "△4. Comparing the appearance of childhood and old age.",
    
    "'Great King, your current age is already old, how does your appearance compare to that of your childhood?' The King said, 'World Honored One, when I was a child, my skin was soft and lustrous, and when I reached adulthood, my blood and energy were full. But now that I am old, approaching senility, my appearance is withered and haggard, my spirit is dim, my hair is white, my face is wrinkled, and I will not live much longer. How can it be compared to when I was full of vigor?'",
    
    "Comparing the appearance of childhood with old age, it is probably using the changes of the body to describe the unchanging thing in the body. The beginning of birth is called 'hai', the beginning of walking is called 'ru'. The skin is called 'fu', and the texture is called '[勝-力+天]' (texture of the skin). Age refers to years, and the age is already sixty, so it is said to be declining. Declining means decaying. Eighty years old is called 'mao', which means approaching.",
    
    "△5. Examining the subtle shifts of change.",
    
    "The Buddha said, 'Great King, your appearance should not have aged all at once, right?' The King said, 'World Honored One, the changes happen imperceptibly, and I did not notice them. The seasons change, and gradually I have reached this point. Why? When I was twenty years old, although I was called young, my appearance was already older than when I was ten years old. At thirty, I was older than at twenty. Now that I am over sixty, I still feel strong when I look at myself at fifty. World Honored One, I see this imperceptible shift, although it will eventually decline, but the passage of time is limited to ten years. If I were to think carefully, is this change only ten or twenty years? In fact, it changes every year, not only every year, but also every month. Not only every month, but also every day. Contemplating deeply, in every moment, in every thought, there is no stopping, so I know that my body will eventually change and perish.'",
    
    "The previous section summarized the changes in the body, and this section summarizes the changes in years, until the moment, which is close to the original state (the original state of things). Then it leads to the sentence of the imperishable in the body. Ordinary people are rough and cannot see these, so the following uses the root nature to show it.",
    "The four sentences 'Changes happen imperceptibly' generally lament the ease of change. The imperceptible shift is extremely confusing."
  ]
}

況。涅槃云。壯色不停。喻如奔馬。人命無常。過於山水。而乃火宅兒嬉。誠可憐愍耳。始由數十年。以限十年。又由十年。以限一年。由年限月。由月限日。以至剎那唸唸不住。此而不覺。則誠不覺矣。

  △六正示不生滅性。分二。初問身中不滅。

  佛告大王。汝見變化遷改不停。悟知汝滅。亦于滅時汝知身中有不滅耶。波斯匿王合掌白佛。我實不知。

  年變身化。至於剎那。唸唸遷謝。瞥爾返觀。豈同土木。此而不醒。又煩如來別生垂示耳。

  △二問見水同異。以表無生滅性。分四。初徴見水。

  佛言。我今示汝不生滅性。大王。汝年幾時。見恒河水。王言。我生三歲。慈母攜我謁耆婆天。經過此流。爾時即知是恒河水。

  耆婆此云長壽天。西域生子。必謁長壽。久歷年所。反觀如昨。即見即知。不假思量。

  △二徴見水同異。

  佛言。大王。如汝所說。二十之時。衰於十歲。乃至六十。日月歲時。唸唸遷變。則汝三歲見此河時。至年十三。其水云何。王言。如三歲時。宛然無異。乃至於今年六十二。亦無有異。

  還以歲時遷變。且限十年。詰其見此河時。於十年間。同異何似。蓋欲其自覺。所謂不塞悟門也。宛然二字。可謂于糞頭邊。忽爾拾得。未易語人。

  △三單徴見同異。

  佛言汝今自傷發白面皺。其面必定皺于童年。則汝今時觀此恒河。與昔童時觀河之見。有童耄不。王言。不也。世尊。

  宛然無異。已解自覺。此復勘其童耄差別。可謂再三丁寧

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "情況。《涅槃經》說:『強壯的容顏不會停留,比喻就像奔跑的馬。人的壽命無常,快過山間的流水。』然而卻像火宅中的孩子一樣嬉戲,實在可憐啊。最初由幾十年,限定為十年,又由十年,限定為一年,由年限定為月,由月限定為日,以至於剎那剎那不停留。對此還不覺悟,那就真是不覺悟了。",
    
    "△六、正式開示不生不滅的本性。分為兩部分。首先,問身體中是否有不滅的。",
    
    "佛告訴波斯匿王(約公元前6世紀):『你看到變化遷改不停,悟知你的身體會滅亡,那麼在滅亡的時候,你是否知道身體中有不滅的東西呢?』波斯匿王(約公元前6世紀)合掌對佛說:『我實在不知道。』",
    
    "年齡變化,身體轉化,以至於剎那,唸唸遷謝。稍微反觀一下,豈能和土木一樣無知無覺?對此還不醒悟,又要麻煩如來另外開示了。",
    
    "△二、問見水是否相同或相異,以此來表示無生滅的本性。分為四部分。首先,徵詢(波斯匿王)見水的情況。",
    
    "佛說:『我現在向你展示不生不滅的本性。大王,你幾歲的時候,見到恒河水?』波斯匿王(約公元前6世紀)說:『我三歲的時候,慈母帶我去拜謁耆婆天(長壽天),經過這條河流,那時就知道這是恒河水。』",
    
    "耆婆(Jivaka),這裡翻譯為長壽天(deva of longevity)。西域生了孩子,必定去拜謁長壽天。經歷了很久的歲月,反觀就像昨天一樣。立即見到,立即知道,不需要思考。",
    
    "△二、徵詢(波斯匿王)見水是否相同或相異。",
    
    "佛說:『大王,正如你所說,二十歲的時候,比十歲的時候衰老,乃至六十歲,日月歲時,唸唸遷變。那麼你三歲見到這條河的時候,到十三歲的時候,這河水怎麼樣呢?』波斯匿王(約公元前6世紀)說:『和三歲的時候一樣,完全沒有不同。乃至到今年六十二歲,也沒有什麼不同。』",
    
    "還是用歲時遷變,且限定十年,詰問他見到這條河的時候,在這十年間,相同或相異是什麼樣的。大概是想讓他自己覺悟,這就是所謂的不堵塞覺悟之門啊。『宛然』二字,真可謂是在糞堆旁邊,忽然撿到了寶貝。不容易和人說。",
    
    "△三、單獨徵詢(波斯匿王)見(河水)是否相同或相異。",
    
    "佛說:『你現在自己感傷頭髮變白,面容變皺,你的面容一定比童年時更皺。那麼你現在看這條恒河,和過去童年時看河的見解,有童年和老年(的區別)嗎?』波斯匿王(約公元前6世紀)說:『沒有,世尊。』",
    
    "『宛然無異』,已經理解自覺。這裡又考察他童年和老年的差別,真可謂是再三叮嚀。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "The situation. The *Nirvana Sutra* says: 'A strong complexion does not stay, it is like a galloping horse. Human life is impermanent, faster than mountain streams.' Yet they frolic like children in a burning house, truly pitiable. Initially, it's decades, limited to ten years, then from ten years, limited to one year, from year limited to month, from month limited to day, to the point of moment after moment without stopping. If one is not aware of this, then one is truly unaware.",
    
    "△6. Formally reveals the nature of non-birth and non-death. Divided into two parts. First, asks if there is something undying in the body.",
    
    "The Buddha told King Pasenadi (c. 6th century BCE): 'You see the changes and alterations that never stop, realizing that your body will perish, then at the time of perishing, do you know if there is something undying in the body?' King Pasenadi (c. 6th century BCE) put his palms together and said to the Buddha: 'I truly do not know.'",
    
    "Age changes, the body transforms, to the point of moment after moment, shifting and fading. A slight reflection, how can it be the same as earth and wood, without knowledge or awareness? If one is not awakened to this, then one must trouble the Tathagata to give separate instructions.",
    
    "△2. Asks whether the seeing of water is the same or different, to represent the nature of non-birth and non-death. Divided into four parts. First, inquires about (King Pasenadi's) seeing of water.",
    
    "The Buddha said: 'I will now show you the nature of non-birth and non-death. Great King, how old were you when you saw the Ganges River?' King Pasenadi (c. 6th century BCE) said: 'When I was three years old, my loving mother took me to visit Jivaka (deva of longevity), passing by this river, and at that time I knew it was the Ganges River.'",
    
    "Jivaka, here translated as the deva of longevity. In the Western Regions, when a child is born, they must visit the deva of longevity. Having experienced many years, looking back it is like yesterday. Immediately seeing, immediately knowing, without needing to think.",
    
    "△2. Inquires whether the seeing of water is the same or different.",
    
    "The Buddha said: 'Great King, as you said, at twenty years old, you are more aged than at ten years old, and even at sixty years old, the days, months, and years, shift and change moment after moment. Then when you saw this river at three years old, what was the water like when you were thirteen years old?' King Pasenadi (c. 6th century BCE) said: 'The same as when I was three years old, completely without difference. Even to this year, at sixty-two years old, there is no difference.'",
    
    "Still using the shifting and changing of years, and limiting it to ten years, questioning him about when he saw this river, what was the same or different during these ten years. Probably wanting him to awaken himself, this is the so-called not blocking the gate of awakening. The two words 'completely the same', can truly be said to be like suddenly picking up a treasure next to a pile of dung. It is not easy to tell people.",
    
    "△3. Singularly inquires whether (King Pasenadi's) seeing (of the river) is the same or different.",
    
    "The Buddha said: 'You now lament that your hair has turned white and your face has wrinkled, your face must be more wrinkled than in your childhood. Then when you now look at this Ganges River, and the view of the river when you were a child, is there (a difference between) childhood and old age?' King Pasenadi (c. 6th century BCE) said: 'No, World Honored One.'",
    
    "'Completely the same', already understanding self-awareness. Here again examining the difference between childhood and old age, it can truly be said to be repeated and earnest instructions."
  ]
}

。

  △四示見精不變。

  佛言。大王。汝面雖皺。而此見精。性未曾皺。皺者為變。不皺非變。變者受滅。彼不變者。元無生滅。云何于中受汝生死。而猶引彼末伽黎等。都言此身死後全滅。王聞是言。信知身後捨生趣生。與諸大眾。踴躍歡喜。得未曾有。

  此乃發明身中有不滅性也。現前生滅如彼。其不生滅如此。真在妄中。實在虛內。分別隨緣。知馬影之匪他。見性無遷。悟牛鼻之在手。末伽黎此云不見道。皆斷見外道。等遍指六師也。

  斷滅與不斷滅。正我法與外道之所岐。阿難之請。其始為天下後世借鑑歟。前云見無虧損。見無動搖。審知根性。不隨前塵遷變。而猶疑死後斷滅。此皆眾生通病。故即其自童至耄。曾所經見。易為證知。而猶藉聖口抑揚。始獲自認。故知無上秘密。祇在目前。而不覺變熏。流易累劫。夫目必有見。耳必有聞。一人返觀。千聖同軌。當念自信。十世靡移。豈更待捨生趣生而後知其不滅耶。波斯匿王曰。剎那剎那。唸唸之間。不得停住。故知我身終從變滅。夫唸唸不停。則豈非其心之生滅耶。心惑身世。隨其遷流。不遑安住。若當此時。覿面提命。自非夙智。未易憬然。而世尊乃曰。則汝今時觀此恒河。與昔童時觀河之見。有童耄不。真性所露。不落思量。隨見隨知。豈異今昔。此如來所為于眾生迷中。而擇其必不能迷者。一處自覺。則全體宛然。所謂五現量根。與八識同功。常在目前。而不自覺。一遇了緣。便同本得耳。

  上八示見性不滅竟。

  △九指顛倒所在

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "△四、揭示見精的不變性。",
    
    "佛陀說:『大王,你的面容雖然佈滿皺紋,但是這個能見的精明之性,本質上從未曾改變。產生皺紋的是會變化的,不產生皺紋的就不是變化的。會變化的就會經歷生滅,那個不變的,原本就沒有生滅。怎麼能讓它來承受你的生死呢?而你還引用末伽黎(懷疑論者)等人,完全說這身體死後就全部滅亡。』國王聽了這話,相信死後會捨棄此生而前往下一生,與大眾一起,踴躍歡喜,得到了前所未有的領悟。",
    
    "這正是爲了闡明身體中存在不滅的本性。眼前生滅的現象就像它(皺紋),那不生滅的本性就像這樣(見精)。真理存在於虛妄之中,實在存在於虛空之內。分別來自隨順因緣,從而得知馬的影子並非真實存在。見性沒有遷變,從而領悟到牛鼻子掌握在自己手中。末伽黎,這裡翻譯為『不見道』,都是斷見外道。『等』字泛指六師外道。",
    
    "斷滅和不斷滅,正是正法和我與外道的區別所在。阿難的請求,或許是爲了給天下後世借鑑吧。前面說見性沒有虧損,見性沒有動搖,審察得知根源的本性,不隨從前面的塵境遷變。但仍然懷疑死後會斷滅,這都是眾生的通病。所以就用他自己從童年到老年的經歷,容易理解和認知,來作為證明。但仍然藉助佛陀的口來闡揚,才開始自己認識到。所以知道無上的秘密,就在眼前,卻不覺知被變化所薰染,流轉經歷累劫。眼睛一定有見的功能,耳朵一定有聽的功能,一人反觀自照,千聖遵循同一軌跡。當下相信自己,十世也不會改變。難道還要等到捨棄此生前往下一生之後,才知道它是不滅的嗎?波斯匿王(約公元前6世紀)說:『剎那剎那,唸唸之間,不得停住,所以知道我的身體終究會變化滅亡。』唸唸不停,那難道不是他的心的生滅嗎?心被身體和世事迷惑,隨著它們遷流變化,沒有片刻安住。如果在這個時候,直接點明生命的本質,如果不是宿世有智慧的人,不容易醒悟。而世尊卻說:『那麼你現在觀看這條恒河,和你小時候觀看恒河的見性,有童年和老年的區別嗎?』真性所顯露的,不落入思量分別,隨著見而知,哪裡有今昔的差別?這是如來爲了眾生在迷惑之中,而選擇他們必定不會迷惑的地方。一處自覺,則全體都清楚明白。這就是所謂的五現量根,與八識有相同的功能,常常在眼前,卻不自覺知。一旦遇到開悟的因緣,就如同本來就擁有的。",
    
    "以上八個方面揭示了見性不滅的道理。",
    
    "△九、指出顛倒的所在。"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "△4. Showing the Immutability of the Seeing Essence.",
    
    "The Buddha said, 'Great King, although your face is wrinkled, this seeing essence has never wrinkled in its nature. Wrinkling is change; not wrinkling is not change. What changes is subject to extinction; that which does not change originally has no birth or death. How can it undergo your births and deaths? Yet you still cite the likes of Makali (a skeptic), who completely say that this body is utterly annihilated after death.' Hearing these words, the King believed that after death he would abandon this life and go to another, and with the assembly, he leaped with joy, gaining what he had never had before.",
    
    "This is precisely to elucidate that there exists an indestructible nature within the body. The present phenomena of birth and death are like that (wrinkles), while the indestructible nature is like this (seeing essence). Truth exists within falsehood, reality exists within emptiness. Distinctions arise from following conditions, thus knowing that the shadow of a horse is not real. The seeing nature does not change, thus realizing that the ox's nose is in one's own hand. Makali, here translated as 'not seeing the Way,' refers to the nihilistic heretics. 'Etc.' broadly refers to the Six Heretical Teachers.",
    
    "Annihilation and non-annihilation are precisely the distinction between the Proper Dharma and the heretics. Was Ananda's request perhaps for the sake of future generations to learn from? Earlier, it was said that the seeing is without loss or damage, the seeing is without wavering, carefully knowing the nature of the root, not following the changes of the preceding dust. Yet there was still doubt about annihilation after death; these are all common ailments of sentient beings. Therefore, using his own experiences from childhood to old age, which are easy to understand and recognize, as proof. But still relying on the Buddha's words to expound, he then began to recognize it himself. Therefore, know that the supreme secret is right before one's eyes, yet one is unaware of being influenced by change, transmigrating through countless kalpas. The eyes must have the function of seeing, the ears must have the function of hearing; one person reflects inwardly, and a thousand sages follow the same path. Believe in oneself in the present moment, and it will not change for ten lifetimes. Why wait until abandoning this life and going to another before knowing that it is indestructible? King Prasenajit (approximately 6th century BCE) said, 'Moment by moment, thought after thought, there is no stopping, so I know that my body will ultimately change and perish.' If thoughts are unceasing, then isn't that the birth and death of his mind? The mind is deluded by the body and worldly affairs, following their changes and transformations, without a moment of peace. If at this time, the essence of life were directly pointed out, it would not be easy to awaken unless one had wisdom from past lives. But the World Honored One said, 'Then when you now observe this Ganges River, is there a difference between your seeing of the river as a child and as an old man?' What is revealed by the true nature does not fall into thought and discrimination; following seeing and knowing, where is there a difference between past and present? This is how the Thus Come One, for sentient beings in delusion, chooses what they are certain not to be deluded about. One place is self-aware, then the whole is clearly understood. This is what is called the five directly perceived roots, having the same function as the eight consciousnesses, constantly before one's eyes, yet one is unaware. Once encountering the conditions for enlightenment, it is the same as having it originally.",
    
    "The above eight aspects reveal the principle of the indestructibility of the seeing nature.",
    
    "△9. Pointing out where the inversion lies."
  ]
}

。分三。初問遺失顛倒。

  阿難即從座起。禮佛合掌。長跪白佛。世尊。若此見聞必不生滅。云何世尊名我等輩遺失真性顛倒行事。愿興慈悲。洗我塵垢。

  雖悟見聞本不生滅。而四大臚然。五蘊宛爾。迷色空于目前。攬浮漚為自體。顛倒不知其在。真性誰解偏全。若非大闡無遮。法界何因證入矣。如來開示。單指見性。阿難此請。雙舉見聞。宗鏡謂六根中。惟見與聞。隨用常住。易於顯了。故羅睺擊鐘。文殊選耳。皆同此意。

  △二如來示臂以徴顛倒。

  即時如來垂金色臂。輪手下指。示阿難言。汝今見我母陀羅手。為正為倒。阿難言。世間眾生以此為倒。而我不知誰正誰倒。佛告阿難。若世間人以此為倒。即世間人將何為正。阿難言。如來豎臂。兜羅綿手上指于空。則名為正。

  如來一臂垂示。蓋以發眉劍之機。即以出顛倒之狀。阿難不知直領。乃推世間以此為倒。復推世間以豎為正。可謂當面錯過。母陀羅此云印。證真鈔云。結印手也。用以制伏魔外。

  佛即豎臂。告阿難言。若此顛倒。首尾相換。諸世間人。一倍瞻視。

  若此顛倒。總是如來一臂。不過換首為尾。換尾為首。有何同異。諸世間人。一倍瞻視。而不自覺。各生異見。於此若悟。首尾自換。一臂無殊。直下顛倒名字。無處安著矣。一一人也。倍多人也。

  則知汝身與諸如來清凈法身。比類發明。如來之身。名正遍知。汝等之身。號性顛倒。隨汝諦觀。汝身佛身。稱顛倒者。名字何處號為顛倒。

  如來清凈法身

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "分三部分。首先是關於遺失和顛倒的提問。",
    
    "阿難尊者立即從座位上站起,向佛陀行禮,合掌,長跪並稟告佛陀:『世尊,如果這見性和聞性必定不生不滅,為什麼世尊說我們這些人遺失了真性,做著顛倒的事情呢?希望您能興起慈悲心,洗去我們的塵垢。』(阿難的提問基於他領悟到見聞的本性不生不滅,但他仍然被四大假合之身和五蘊所困擾,迷失於色空的真相,執取虛幻的現象為自身。他不知道顛倒的根源在哪裡,也不知道如何才能完全理解真性。如果不是佛陀大開方便之門,徹底揭示真相,眾生又如何能夠證入法界呢?如來佛開示時,單單指出了見性的重要性。而阿難這次的請求,同時提到了見性和聞性。宗鏡錄中說,六根之中,只有見和聞,其作用是恒常存在的,並且容易顯現出來。所以羅睺羅敲鐘,文殊菩薩選擇耳根圓通,都是同樣的道理。)",
    
    "△第二部分是如來佛展示手臂來證明顛倒。",
    
    "這時,如來佛垂下金色的手臂,輪狀的手指向下指著,向阿難尊者展示並說道:『你現在看到我的母陀羅手(手印),是正的還是倒的?』阿難尊者回答說:『世間眾生認為這樣是倒的,但我不知道誰是正的,誰是倒的。』佛陀告訴阿難尊者:『如果世間人認為這樣是倒的,那麼世間人認為什麼才是正的呢?』阿難尊者回答說:『如來佛豎起手臂,兜羅綿(柔軟)的手指向上指向天空,就被稱為正的。』(如來佛垂下一隻手臂來展示,就像用眉間的劍來發動機會一樣,立即顯現出顛倒的狀態。阿難尊者沒有直接領悟,而是推說是世間人認為這樣是倒的,又推說是世間人認為豎起來是正的。可以說是當面錯過了。母陀羅,翻譯成漢語就是『印』。證真鈔中說,就是結印的手。用來制伏邪魔外道。)",
    
    "佛陀隨即豎起手臂,告訴阿難尊者說:『如果這(正和倒)只是首尾互相調換,那麼世間人只是多看一眼而已。』",
    
    "『如果這(正和倒)只是如來佛的一隻手臂,只不過是把頭換成尾,把尾換成頭,有什麼不同呢?世間人只是多看一眼,卻不自覺,各自產生不同的見解。如果能在這裡領悟,頭和尾可以自己調換,一隻手臂沒有什麼不同,那麼「顛倒」這個名字,就沒有地方可以安放了。』(一,指一個人。倍,指很多人。)",
    
    "『那麼要知道,你的身體和諸如來佛的清凈法身,可以用來比較說明。如來佛的身,名為正遍知(對一切事物都能正確、普遍地瞭解)。你們的身體,號為性顛倒。仔細觀察,你的身體和佛的身,被稱為顛倒的,這個「顛倒」的名字,應該在哪裡稱呼為顛倒呢?』",
    
    "如來佛的清凈法身",
    
    
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

。不分報化。現前三十二相。與一切隨類應身。即相即性。即有即空。覺自心所現為正知。覺所現唯心為遍知。此所名正遍知也。若執心在身內。山河大地。同居身外。此心外有法。即為顛倒之處。故因處得號。號性顛倒也。比類者比如來一臂垂豎。而世間人各各倒正。乃推類發明耳。故知如來之身。非正遍知。以此稱名。汝等之身。性非顛倒。以此得號。名正遍知。號性顛倒。無非顛倒。故曰汝身佛身。稱顛倒者。名字何處。號為顛倒。聖名凡號。總是處聲。殊相劣形。皆為幻質。愚意與諸解乖謬。然揆之聖意。當有微中。不敢雷同。俟之明哲。

  △三正示顛倒。

  於時阿難與諸大眾。瞪曹瞻佛。目睛不瞬。不知身心顛倒所在。佛興慈悲。哀愍阿難。及諸大眾。發海潮音。遍告同會。諸善男子。我常說言。色心諸緣。及心所使。諸所緣法。唯心所現。汝身汝心。皆是妙明真精妙心中所現物。云何汝等遺失本妙圓妙明心寶明妙性。認悟中迷。

  色指十一色法。心指八識。諸緣指二十四不相應行。心所使即五十一心所。諸所緣即六種無為。五位共一百法。攝盡一切。此一切法。悉唯心現。而曰汝身汝心。皆是妙明真精妙心中所現物者。指阿難現今想相為身。昏擾為性。同現妙明真精之中。而乃不自覺知。枉同遺失。此所謂悟中迷也。妙心而曰妙明真精者本妙而明。此明真精。揀非虛妄也。本妙圓妙明心者此本妙心。圓融寂照。揀非覺明也。寶明妙性者此明而妙。用全歸體也。瞪凝視。瞢不知之貌。

  晦昧為空。空晦

```json
{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "不分報身和化身。現在顯現的三十二相(佛陀所具有的三十二種殊勝的身體特徵),以及一切隨眾生種類而應化的身形,都是即相即性,即有即空。覺悟到自心所顯現的境界是『正知』,覺悟到所顯現的一切都只是心識的變現是『遍知』。這就是所謂的『正遍知』。如果執著於心在身體之內,認為山河大地都存在於身體之外,這就是心外有法,就是顛倒的見解。所以因為『因處』而得到『號』,這個『號』的性質就是顛倒。比類的意思是,比如如來的一隻手臂垂下來,而世間人各自以倒正來區分,這只是推類來闡明道理罷了。所以要知道如來的身體,並非是『正遍知』,而是以此來稱名。你們的身體,其本性並非顛倒,因此可以得到『正遍知』的稱號。稱號的性質是顛倒,但實際上並沒有什麼顛倒。所以說『你的身體』和『佛的身體』,稱之為顛倒。名字在哪裡呢?稱號又在哪裡呢?聖人的名號和凡夫的稱謂,都只是音聲而已。殊勝的相貌和低劣的形體,都只是虛幻的物質。我的理解或許與諸位有所乖謬,但如果按照聖人的意思來衡量,應該有微妙之處。不敢妄自雷同,等待明智的人來判斷。",
    
    "△三番兩次地開示顛倒。",
    
    "這時,阿難(佛陀的十大弟子之一,以記憶力超群著稱)和所有的大眾,睜大眼睛,一動不動地看著佛陀,不知道身心的顛倒在哪裡。佛陀生起慈悲心,憐憫阿難和所有的大眾,發出如海潮般的聲音,遍告在場的所有人:『各位善男子,我經常說,色(物質現象)心(精神現象)諸緣(各種因緣條件),以及心所使(各種心理活動),所有這些所緣之法,都是唯心所現。你們的身和你們的心,都是從妙明真精妙心中所顯現出來的東西。為什麼你們要遺失這本妙圓妙明心的寶明妙性,而在覺悟中產生迷惑呢?』",
    
    "『色』指的是十一色法(眼、耳、鼻、舌、身、色、聲、香、味、觸、法)。『心』指的是八識(眼識、耳識、鼻識、舌識、身識、意識、末那識、阿賴耶識)。『諸緣』指的是二十四不相應行(非色非心,不與心相應的各種事物)。『心所使』指的是五十一心所(各種心理活動)。『諸所緣』指的是六種無為(虛空無為、擇滅無為、非擇滅無為、不動無為、想受滅無為、真如無為)。五位(色法、心法、心所法、心不相應行法、無為法)總共一百法,涵蓋了一切。所有這些法,都是唯心所現。而說『你們的身和你們的心,都是從妙明真精妙心中所顯現出來的東西』,指的是阿難現在把想像的相狀當作身體,把昏昧擾動當作本性,這些都是在妙明真精之中顯現出來的,卻不自覺知,白白地遺失了。這就是所謂的在覺悟中產生迷惑。妙心而說『妙明真精』,是說本妙而光明,這個『明』是真精,用來區別于虛妄。『本妙圓妙明心』,是說這個本妙心,圓融寂照,用來區別于覺明。『寶明妙性』,是說這個光明而妙,作用完全歸於本體。『瞪』是凝視的意思,『瞢』是不知曉的樣子。",
    
    "晦昧為空,空晦"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "Without distinction between Reward Body and Transformation Body. The currently manifested Thirty-two Marks (the thirty-two auspicious physical characteristics of a Buddha) and all responsive bodies that appear according to the type of beings, are both form and nature, both existence and emptiness. To realize that the realm manifested by one's own mind is 'Right Knowledge,' and to realize that all that appears is merely a manifestation of mind is 'Universal Knowledge.' This is what is called 'Right and Universal Knowledge.' If one clings to the idea that the mind is within the body, and that mountains, rivers, and the great earth exist outside the body, this is to believe that there are things outside the mind, which is a distorted view. Therefore, the 'name' is derived from the 'cause,' and the nature of this 'name' is distorted. The analogy is like the Buddha's arm hanging down, while worldly people distinguish between upright and inverted, which is merely an analogy to explain the principle. Therefore, know that the Buddha's body is not 'Right and Universal Knowledge,' but is named as such. Your bodies, by nature, are not distorted, and therefore you can attain the title of 'Right and Universal Knowledge.' The nature of the title is distorted, but in reality, there is no distortion. Therefore, it is said that 'your body' and 'the Buddha's body' are called distorted. Where are the names? Where are the titles? The names of sages and the titles of ordinary people are all just sounds. Excellent appearances and inferior forms are all illusory matter. My understanding may differ from others, but if measured against the Buddha's intention, there should be subtle points. I dare not blindly agree, and await the judgment of the wise.",
    
    "△ Three times to show the inversion.",
    
    "At that time, Ānanda (one of the Buddha's ten principal disciples, known for his excellent memory) and all the assembly, stared intently at the Buddha, their eyes unblinking, not knowing where the inversion of body and mind lay. The Buddha, with compassion, took pity on Ānanda and all the assembly, and uttered a voice like the ocean tide, proclaiming to all present: 'Good men, I have often said that form (material phenomena), mind (mental phenomena), all conditions (various causal conditions), and all mental activities, all these objects of perception are manifested solely by the mind. Your body and your mind are all things manifested from the wonderful, bright, true, pure, wonderful mind. Why do you lose the precious, bright, wonderful nature of this fundamental, wonderful, perfect, bright mind, and become deluded in enlightenment?'",
    
    "'Form' refers to the eleven forms (eye, ear, nose, tongue, body, form, sound, smell, taste, touch, dharma). 'Mind' refers to the eight consciousnesses (eye consciousness, ear consciousness, nose consciousness, tongue consciousness, body consciousness, mind consciousness, manas consciousness, alaya consciousness). 'All conditions' refers to the twenty-four non-corresponding activities (things that are neither form nor mind, and do not correspond to the mind). 'Mental activities' refers to the fifty-one mental factors (various psychological activities). 'All objects of perception' refers to the six unconditioned dharmas (space unconditioned, selective cessation unconditioned, non-selective cessation unconditioned, unmoving unconditioned, cessation of perception and feeling unconditioned, suchness unconditioned). The five categories (form, mind, mental factors, non-corresponding activities, unconditioned dharmas) total one hundred dharmas, encompassing everything. All these dharmas are manifested solely by the mind. And to say 'your body and your mind are all things manifested from the wonderful, bright, true, pure, wonderful mind,' refers to Ānanda now taking the imagined appearance as the body, and the confused disturbance as the nature, which are all manifested within the wonderful, bright, true, pure mind, yet he is not aware of it, and loses it in vain. This is what is called becoming deluded in enlightenment. The wonderful mind is called 'wonderful, bright, true, pure,' meaning that it is fundamentally wonderful and bright, and this 'brightness' is true and pure, distinguishing it from the false. 'Fundamental, wonderful, perfect, bright mind' means that this fundamental, wonderful mind is perfectly integrated and serenely illuminating, distinguishing it from the illuminating awareness. 'Precious, bright, wonderful nature' means that this brightness is wonderful, and its function completely returns to the essence. 'Stare' means to gaze intently, 'mēng' means not knowing.",
    
    "Obscurity is emptiness, emptiness is obscurity."
  ]
}

暗中。結暗為色。色雜妄想。想相為身。聚緣內搖。趣外奔逸。昏擾擾相。以為心性。一迷為心。決定惑為色身之內。

  晦昧即根本無明。無明晦昧。本性蕩然。所謂迷妄有虛空也。空中結暗。此能變之無明。依空起見。所謂想澄成國土也。又以所變之色。映所成能。故曰色雜妄想。想相為身。既成根身。即此色陰。攬彼六塵。成四名蘊。內搖外逸。所謂昏擾擾者。乃支潤無明。一迷為心。則必惑為身內也。大地眾生。從是倒執。遂同遺失矣。

  不知色身外洎山河虛空大地。咸是妙明真心中物。譬如澄清百千大海棄之。惟認一浮漚體。目為全潮窮盡瀛渤。汝等即是迷中倍人。如我垂手等無差別。如來說為可憐愍者。

  色身即根身。虛空大地即器界。根身器界。皆為內識變似。本無自性。唯是一心。故曰咸是妙明真心中物也。百千大海即喻妙明真心。一浮漚體喻惑為身內之心。即前所云汝身汝心也。棄即遺失也。倍人即一倍瞻視之人。猶云此一倍迷人。如我垂手。各見倒正。更無差別。

  夫人迷於前塵。良由境見不分。故境在見生。境沈見滅。雖生非真生。滅非真滅。然迷中之心性。待因緣而後有。則目前之對現。逐境物以成無。此能推之心。所為離前塵無分別性也。自客塵不住。主空寂然。身限歲時。見無童耄。亦可以悟見聞之必無生滅矣。然乍回之心。雖能脫身世之緣。而離塵之見未易融分別之慮。自以為真性究竟無他。夫安知顛倒誠難自覺。法界元無彼我。渤海不住浮漚。乃以身內為心。詎信色前匪物。自心

{
  "translations": [
    "現代漢語譯本",
    "『暗中。結暗為*。*雜妄想。想相為身。聚緣內搖。趣外奔逸。昏擾擾相。以為心性。一迷為心。決定惑為色身之內。』",
    
    "在黑暗中,相互結合形成黑暗的實體。這些黑暗實體又與虛妄的念頭混合,虛妄的念頭又顯現為身體的形象。各種因緣聚合,內在的念頭搖動,向外追逐奔逸,昏昧擾動的情狀,被認為是心性。一旦迷惑,就誤認為這是心,並且堅決地認為心就在這個色身之內。",
    
    "『晦昧即根本無明(avidyā,佛教術語,指對事物真相的迷惑和無知)。無明晦昧。本性蕩然。所謂迷妄有虛空也。空中結暗。此能變之無明。依空起見。所謂想澄成國土也。又以所變之色。映所成能。故曰色雜妄想。想相為身。既成根身。即此色陰。攬彼六塵。成四名蘊。內搖外逸。所謂昏擾擾者。乃支潤無明。一迷為心。則必惑為身內也。大地眾生。從是倒執。遂同遺失矣。』",
    
    "這裡的『晦昧』就是根本的無明。無明使人昏昧,本性因此而消失。這就是所謂的因為迷惑而產生虛空。在虛空中結成黑暗,這就是能變的無明。依據虛空而產生見解,這就是所謂的念頭澄澈而形成國土。又用所變現的色,來映照所形成的能,所以說色與虛妄的念頭混合。虛妄的念頭顯現為身體。既然形成了根身,也就是這個色陰,攝取六塵,形成四種名蘊。內在搖動,向外奔逸。所謂的昏昧擾動,就是滋養無明。一旦迷惑,就誤認為這是心,那麼必定會迷惑地認為心就在身體之內。大地上所有的眾生,都是從這種顛倒執著開始,最終一同迷失了。",
    
    "『不知色身外洎山河虛空大地。咸是妙明真心中物。譬如澄清百千大海棄之。惟認一浮漚體。目為全潮窮盡瀛渤。汝等即是迷中倍人。如我垂手等無差別。如來說為可憐愍者。』",
    
    "不知道色身之外,包括山河、虛空、大地,都是妙明真心中的事物。譬如把澄清的成百上千的大海拋棄,只認一個水泡,就認為它是全部的潮水,窮盡了整個大海。你們這些人就是迷惑中的加倍迷惑的人。就像我垂下手,你們所見的倒正並沒有什麼差別。如來說這是可憐憫的人。",
    
    "『色身即根身。虛空大地即器界。根身器界。皆為內識變似。本無自性。唯是一心。故曰咸是妙明真心中物也。百千大海即喻妙明真心。一浮漚體喻惑為身內之心。即前所云汝身汝心也。棄即遺失也。倍人即一倍瞻視之人。猶云此一倍迷人。如我垂手。各見倒正。更無差別。』",
    
    "色身就是根身,虛空大地就是器界。根身和器界,都是內在的意識所變現的,本來沒有自性,唯一是真心。所以說都是妙明真心中的事物。成百上千的大海比喻妙明真心,一個水泡比喻迷惑地認為是身內的心,也就是前面所說的你的身體和你的心。拋棄就是遺失。加倍的人就是加倍瞻視的人,也就是加倍迷惑的人。就像我垂下手,你們各自看到的倒正並沒有什麼差別。",
    
    "『夫人迷於前塵。良由境見不分。故境在見生。境沈見滅。雖生非真生。滅非真滅。然迷中之心性。待因緣而後有。則目前之對現。逐境物以成無。此能推之心。所為離前塵無分別性也。自客塵不住。主空寂然。身限歲時。見無童耄。亦可以悟見聞之必無生滅矣。然乍回之心。雖能脫身世之緣。而離塵之見未易融分別之慮。自以為真性究竟無他。夫安知顛倒誠難自覺。法界元無彼我。渤海不住浮漚。乃以身內為心。詎信色前匪物。自心』",
    
    "人們之所以迷惑於過去的塵境,是因為境和見沒有區分開來。所以境存在,見就產生;境消失,見就滅亡。雖然產生不是真正的產生,滅亡也不是真正的滅亡。然而迷惑中的心性,要等待因緣才能產生。那麼眼前的對境顯現,隨著外境而消失。這種能推論的心,之所以能夠離開過去的塵境,是因為它沒有分別性。當客塵不住留,主觀變得空寂,身體受到歲月的限制,見卻沒有童年和衰老。也可以由此領悟到見聞一定沒有生滅。然而剛剛回頭的心,雖然能夠脫離身世的因緣,但是離開塵境的見解不容易融化分別的思慮。自認為這就是真正的自性,除此之外再沒有其他的了。哪裡知道顛倒確實難以自覺。法界原本沒有彼此,大海不會停留在水泡上,卻認為心在身體之內,怎麼會相信在色之前沒有東西呢?自心"
  ],
  "english_translations": [
    "English version",
    "'In darkness. Knots of darkness become *. *Mixed with deluded thoughts. Thoughts manifest as the body. Aggregating causes internally stir, pursuing external escapes. Confused and disturbed appearances are taken as the nature of mind. One delusion becomes the mind, decisively mistaking it for being within the physical body.'",
    
    "In the midst of darkness, mutual binding forms dark entities. These dark entities then mix with deluded thoughts, which in turn manifest as the form of the body. Various causes and conditions gather, internal thoughts stir, chasing after external escapes. The state of confusion and disturbance is mistaken for the nature of mind. Once deluded, one mistakenly believes this to be the mind, and firmly believes that the mind resides within this physical body.",
    
    "'Obscurity is the fundamental ignorance (avidyā, a Buddhist term referring to delusion and ignorance of the true nature of things). With ignorance obscuring, the original nature vanishes. This is what is meant by delusion creating emptiness. In emptiness, darkness knots. This is the ignorance that can transform. Relying on emptiness, views arise. This is what is meant by thoughts clarifying to form lands. Furthermore, using the transformed form to reflect the formed ability, hence it is said that form mixes with deluded thoughts. Thoughts manifest as the body. Once the root body is formed, it is this form skandha that grasps the six sense objects, forming the four name skandhas. Internal stirring and external escape, the so-called confusion and disturbance, is the nourishing of ignorance. Once deluded as the mind, one will surely be confused that it is within the body. All beings on earth, from this inverted clinging, together become lost.'",
    
    "The 'obscurity' here is the fundamental ignorance. Ignorance obscures, causing the original nature to disappear. This is what is meant by delusion creating emptiness. In emptiness, darkness knots, which is the ignorance that can transform. Relying on emptiness, views arise, which is what is meant by thoughts clarifying to form lands. Furthermore, using the transformed form to reflect the formed ability, hence it is said that form mixes with deluded thoughts. Thoughts manifest as the body. Once the root body is formed, it is this form skandha that grasps the six sense objects, forming the four name skandhas. Internal stirring and external escape, the so-called confusion and disturbance, is the nourishing of ignorance. Once deluded as the mind, one will surely be confused that it is within the body. All beings on earth begin from this inverted clinging, and ultimately become lost together.",
    
    "'Not knowing that beyond the physical body, including mountains, rivers, empty space, and the great earth, all are things within the wonderfully bright true mind. It is like discarding a hundred thousand clear oceans, only recognizing a single floating bubble, mistaking it for the entire tide, exhausting the whole ocean. You are doubly deluded among the deluded. Like my lowered hand, there is no difference in what you see as inverted or upright. The Tathagata says you are pitiable.'",
    
    "Not knowing that beyond the physical body, including mountains, rivers, empty space, and the great earth, are all things within the wonderfully bright true mind. It is like discarding a hundred thousand clear oceans, only recognizing a single floating bubble, mistaking it for the entire tide, exhausting the whole ocean. You are doubly deluded among the deluded. Like my lowered hand, there is no difference in what you see as inverted or upright. The Tathagata says these are pitiable.",
    
    "'The physical body is the root body. Empty space and the great earth are the container world. The root body and the container world are all transformations of the inner consciousness. They originally have no self-nature, only the one mind. Therefore, it is said that all are things within the wonderfully bright true mind. The hundred thousand oceans are a metaphor for the wonderfully bright true mind. The single floating bubble is a metaphor for mistaking the mind as being within the body, which is what was previously said as your body and your mind. Discarding means losing. Doubly deluded means doubly observing, which is like saying doubly deluded. Like my lowered hand, each sees inversion or uprightness without any difference.'",
    
    "The physical body is the root body, and empty space and the great earth are the container world. The root body and the container world are all transformations of the inner consciousness. They originally have no self-nature, only the one mind. Therefore, it is said that all are things within the wonderfully bright true mind. The hundred thousand oceans are a metaphor for the wonderfully bright true mind. The single floating bubble is a metaphor for mistaking the mind as being within the body, which is what was previously said as your body and your mind. Discarding means losing. Doubly deluded means doubly observing, which is like saying doubly deluded. Like my lowered hand, each sees inversion or uprightness without any difference.",
    
    "'People are deluded by past dusts. This is because the object and the seeing are not distinguished. Therefore, when the object exists, seeing arises; when the object ceases, seeing ceases. Although arising is not truly arising, and ceasing is not truly ceasing. However, the nature of mind in delusion arises depending on conditions. Then, the present appearance before the eyes vanishes with the external object. This mind that can infer is able to leave past dusts because it has no discriminating nature. When the guest dust does not abide, the host becomes empty and still. The body is limited by time, but seeing has no childhood or old age. One can also realize that seeing and hearing must have no arising or ceasing. However, the mind that has just turned back, although able to escape the conditions of the world, the view that is separate from dust is not easy to melt away discriminating thoughts. One thinks that this is the true nature, and there is nothing else. How can one know that inversion is truly difficult to self-realize? The Dharma realm originally has no self or other. The Bohai Sea does not dwell on floating bubbles, yet one takes the inside of the body as the mind. How can one believe that there is nothing before form? The self-mind'",
    
    "People are deluded by past dusts because the object and the seeing are not distinguished. Therefore, when the object exists, seeing arises; when the object ceases, seeing ceases. Although arising is not truly arising, and ceasing is not truly ceasing. However, the nature of mind in delusion arises depending on conditions. Then, the present appearance before the eyes vanishes with the external object. This mind that can infer is able to leave past dusts because it has no discriminating nature. When the guest dust does not abide, the host becomes empty and still. The body is limited by time, but seeing has no childhood or old age. One can also realize that seeing and hearing must have no arising or ceasing. However, the mind that has just turned back, although able to escape the conditions of the world, the view that is separate from dust is not easy to melt away discriminating thoughts. One thinks that this is the true nature, and there is nothing else. How can one know that inversion is truly difficult to self-realize? The Dharma realm originally has no self or other. The Bohai Sea does not dwell on floating bubbles, yet one takes the inside of the body as the mind. How can one believe that there is nothing before form? The self-mind"
  ]
}

所現。性海本具波瀾。所現唯心。水月全歸霄漢。萬象體玄。鑒光自滿。而顧妄作親疏。終成同異。則豈非遺失真性。顛倒行事哉。慶喜但謂見聞本無生滅。須知迷悟尚隔偏圓。悟則全悟。會萬物而為自己。鏡中豈有二三。迷則終迷。守所得而絕前塵。空里難忘一一。迷中倍人。當不但昔賢耳。

  上九指顛倒所在竟。

  △十揀緣心以示見性無還。分三。初陳所悟不敢自認。

  阿難承佛悲救深誨。垂泣叉手。而白佛言。我雖承佛如是妙音。悟妙明心元所圓滿常住心地。而我悟佛現說法音。現以緣心允所瞻仰。徒獲此心。未敢認為本元心地。愿佛哀愍。宣示圓音。拔我疑根。歸無上道。

  此言所悟之心。本自妙明。圓滿常住。而能悟之心。現領法音。從緣而起。反觀所悟。未見真切。故曰徒獲而不敢認也。圓音謂一切音即一音。一音即一切音。又一語演盡。又各同一切也。